Dark Knight Mafia! The End! Town Win!

[SEAsportsfan]

Ok, I will reread, I was pretty busy recently....but skimming over things, this is getting rather confusing...

[spiesr]

So, what should we do about mystery no lynch boy?

[Thezzaruz]

So, what should we do about mystery no lynch boy?

No idea, we tried lynching him but that didn't stick... Do most people still think he is the joker???

[pmchugh]

i still think ga7 may be innocent but I have to admit the scene seems suspicious. The two reasons I think ga7 is actually Alfred are:

1. The butler is surely in this game and Batman enabler makes sense. as a role for him.
2. If the joker was unlynchable it would be impossible to win.

[Thezzaruz]

2. If the joker was unlynchable it would be impossible to win.

Dent or a Vig or a green scum NK???

[spiesr]

I think he is joker, but am not sure what to do about it. Another attempt at a lynch may just fail again. Nate, does your joat have a kill ability we could use?

Pmc, if he is not joker how do you explain the failed lynch? There is no mayor role.

[Natewolfman]

I think he is joker, but am not sure what to do about it. Another attempt at a lynch may just fail again. Nate, does your joat have a kill ability we could use?

Pmc, if he is not joker how do you explain the failed lynch? There is no mayor role.

i do, yes, but im not convinced either... i would rather investigate first to be certain

[ga7]

Why do you guys always talk about me when I'm not here
I'm still not caught up and might not be until tuesday due to lack of time but let me at least say this: I had no idea my lynch wasn't going to go through, and the Joker being unlynchable would be quite silly so I don't really get the point of this argument

[spiesr]

I had no idea my lynch wasn't going to go through

Care to elaborate on this?

[pmchugh]

I think he is joker, but am not sure what to do about it. Another attempt at a lynch may just fail again. Nate, does your joat have a kill ability we could use?

Pmc, if he is not joker how do you explain the failed lynch? There is no mayor role.

How do you know their is no mayor role? There is no way of telling unless everyone claims, will could have invented some other role with similar consequences.

I had no idea my lynch wasn't going to go through

Care to elaborate on this?

Sheesh how is he supposed to elaborate, its pretty clear he is saying that he had no idea and thats all their is to it.

The only way ga7 can be joker is if Will didn't include the butler in the game, told the joker this as a claim to use and then gave him a one lynch protection. Or he isn't and their is a mayor/politician. Which seems more likely to you?

[Thezzaruz]

How do you know their is no mayor role? There is no way of telling unless everyone claims, will could have invented some other role with similar consequences.

ofc we don't know. But seeing as the mayor guy was a politician by role (and that is not a lynch stopping role) there really aren't anyone else that fits for a mayor/governor role IMO. And also the scene was as far away from a "someone else stopped the lynch" scene as it could be (though that isn't very conclusive).

The only way ga7 can be joker is if Will didn't include the butler in the game, told the joker this as a claim to use and then gave him a one lynch protection. Or he isn't and their is a mayor/politician. Which seems more likely to you?

Him being the Joker tbh.

[Thezzaruz]

i would rather investigate first to be certain

Would have expect you do have done that already when the lynch failed, hard to see a better investigation than that tbh.

[spiesr]

Replies in this color.

I think he is joker, but am not sure what to do about it. Another attempt at a lynch may just fail again. Nate, does your joat have a kill ability we could use?

Pmc, if he is not joker how do you explain the failed lynch? There is no mayor role.

How do you know their is no mayor role? There is no way of telling unless everyone claims, will could have invented some other role with similar consequences.
Well the real mayor was a politician but I guess he could have used the commissioner as with that power.

I had no idea my lynch wasn't going to go through

Care to elaborate on this?

Sheesh how is he supposed to elaborate, its pretty clear he is saying that he had no idea and that's all their is to it.
Whoops, I thought he said that he knew the not lynched was coming.

The only way ga7 can be joker is if Will didn't include the butler in the game, told the joker this as a claim to use and then gave him a one lynch protection. Or he isn't and their is a mayor/politician. Which seems more likely to you?

[pmchugh]

How do you know their is no mayor role? There is no way of telling unless everyone claims, will could have invented some other role with similar consequences.

ofc we don't know. But seeing as the mayor guy was a politician by role (and that is not a lynch stopping role) there really aren't anyone else that fits for a mayor/governor role IMO. And also the scene was as far away from a "someone else stopped the lynch" scene as it could be (though that isn't very conclusive).

Still doesn't conlude their is no mayor/governer although I agree about the scene.

The only way ga7 can be joker is if Will didn't include the butler in the game, told the joker this as a claim to use and then gave him a one lynch protection. Or he isn't and their is a mayor/politician. Which seems more likely to you?

Him being the Joker tbh.

Im still not convinced, although I will be willing to lynch him tommorow seeing as nate will have ran out of abilities (i think) as a JOAT and we lose no powers if we are wrong. Plus this gives us another chance to find the joker (with a lynch and investigation) if ga7 is town.

[spiesr]

Who do you suggest we go after then?

[SEAsportsfan]

well, let's just see what happens after that...investigations will be a big help, hopefully.

[spiesr]

well, let's just see what happens after that...investigations will be a big help, hopefully.

After what?

[SEAsportsfan]

well, let's just see what happens after that...investigations will be a big help, hopefully.

After what?

oh, nevermind, i read your post way wrong....

[ga7]

Lol obviously Nate is an unlimited JOAT. Why on earth would there be an enabler for a limited one

[Natewolfman]

Lol obviously Nate is an unlimited JOAT. Why on earth would there be an enabler for a limited one

yes im unlimited, ive only used investigation thus far

[spiesr]

Now what again were the results of all of these investigations?

[Thezzaruz]

He has said that pmc, nag and illy are all "innocent".

[Natewolfman]

He has said that pmc, nag and illy are all "innocent".

well, pmc and nag were found innocent, illy died before i got a verdict

[spiesr]

Well the theory of investigate first and kill later may not fully work in this case if he really is the joker he may just finally kill you to keep you from outing him or killing him the next day. If he is not, you may be killed any for "framing" purposes. Also, why haven't they killed you yet?

[pmchugh]

If nate an unlimited JOAT then it fully explains the enabler, I'm sorry but I'm inclined to believe ga7.

I think the only reason you (thez) are pushing for ga7 is OMGUS and to try and save your self. Either that or you want rid of a townie and the batman's powers, either way I'm happy to lynch you.

unvote vote thez