It's obvious either Tristan or Roger Dodger (or both) are lying about being a doctor.
And now that I think about it some more, lynching Roger Dodger does seem like a good idea.
And concerning the second kill, this is my opinion on the subject (Meant to post this earlier). Unless the vigilante is a newb/noob, I'm going to believe that the 2nd kill was a 2nd mafia or a serial killer.
Also, depending on how the death scene for day 3 works, we can conclude one of several things. If the killer is an SK, he can kill every other night. If it's a mafia, the same thing may apply or the doctor got lucky. However, Day 3 should clear things up a bit for us.
supercram wrote:go after someone who didn't vote for RD. if she is mafia. or else just hang out and wait a bit for more info.
if we're wrong on this, just lynch me because i obviously suck at mafia.
The problem is that most of the people that didn't vote for RD haven't been around much, or their schedules didn't permit them to be around for the last few hours (which is what happened to me in day 1)
I'd love to come up with something more substantial. Because the vig isn't looking for someone to investigate, and we can't lose too many more townies. (esp. if we fucked up the RD thing)
And I'm right there with ya on the hoping we're right thing. If we inadvertently lynched another doctor... yikes.
Also, for a day 3 lynch, I was thinking about the following things. Whoever dies on Day 3, it may be a good idea to see who voted for them in the previous rounds. We can do the same thing for Wicked as well.
It's possible that the mafia may have wanted them dead one way or the other, and killed them with their nightkill attempt.
10 Nyvek (Master Bush, Wisse, Kokunai, trestain, Roger Dodger, for dummies, P Gizzle, reverend_kyle, supercram, wicked)
1 reverend kyle (Nyvek)
2 No Lynch (Senfive, XenHu)
5 Not Voting (Fircoal, Incandenza, vgmmaster, HoussamTheGreat, onbekende)
There are the day one results. Obvious they fluctuated during the day... but there's not a lot to go on there. The only person that I recall voting for wicked was RD.
And just looking at that, is it me or did houssam not post at all today?
Incandenza wrote:
I'd love to come up with something more substantial. Because the vig isn't looking for someone to investigate, and we can't lose too many more townies. (esp. if we fucked up the RD thing)
ok so i dunno when we stopped assuming that we had a serial killer. someone point me to that post please?
but if i were the vig, i might just NOT SHOOT ANYBODY because we are not sure.
if RD turns out to be mafia, SenFive looks shady (voting for P Gizzle in the face of a blatant roger dodger/trestain controversy).
Incandenza wrote:
I'd love to come up with something more substantial. Because the vig isn't looking for someone to investigate, and we can't lose too many more townies. (esp. if we fucked up the RD thing)
ok so i dunno when we stopped assuming that we had a serial killer. someone point me to that post please?
but if i were the vig, i might just NOT SHOOT ANYBODY because we are not sure.
if RD turns out to be mafia, SenFive looks shady (voting for P Gizzle in the face of a blatant roger dodger/trestain controversy).
we didn't stop assuming that. It just makes more sense to me that wicked was killed by the mafia and onbekende by someone else. Since onbekende looked kinda weird during day 1 (and garnered a couple of votes that were later changed to nyvek, if I recall correctly), I postulate that he/she was killed by a vig, not an SK.
I could be wrong. It's just a theory.
But either way, we can't (and don't) want to help a SK pick a target. However, we maybe can give a vig a good target. But if we can't find a target, and there is indeed a vig, I'm with you in hoping they don't pick someone at random.
And just looking at that, is it me or did houssam not post at all today?
That is correct. Have had a bunch of things going on and very little access. Having said that, reading this, I don't think I missed much. I think we are going or more accurately being slapped in all sorts of directions by an experienced mafia. I have no idea really why we are voting RD. I have no idea what the plan is if she is found to be mafia. To be townie? And for petes sake, if the second kill was indeed vigilante, which I doubt, he should really shut the hell up tonight and keep it in his pants!
Master Bush wrote:Player who have yet to give a single vote in 2 (game) days:
Fircoal, Incandenza, vgmmaster, HoussamTheGreat
I would like to know why you 4 have yet to vote anyone?
I did, but I unvoted it. And I like to have proof, before I vote, so I don't lynch someone not on that much proof. Also, I thought Nyvek was a townie, so I wasn't in favor of that bangwagon.
I would vote RD, but it doesn't matter know that she is lynched. Vote: RD
Vote: Mandy
Eddie35: hi everyone
Serbia: YOU IDIOT! What is THAT supposed to be? Are you even TRYING to play this game?! Kill the idiot NOW please!
Skoffin wrote: So um.. er... I'll be honest, I don't know what the f*ck to do from here. Goddamnit chu.
And just looking at that, is it me or did houssam not post at all today?
That is correct. Have had a bunch of things going on and very little access. Having said that, reading this, I don't think I missed much. I think we are going or more accurately being slapped in all sorts of directions by an experienced mafia. I have no idea really why we are voting RD. I have no idea what the plan is if she is found to be mafia. To be townie? And for petes sake, if the second kill was indeed vigilante, which I doubt, he should really shut the hell up tonight and keep it in his pants!
Houssam, RD role claimed. then Trestain role claimed. both claimed doctor. RD seemed shadier to a lot of people. then she threw our a weird vote to Master Bush and said there might be 3 doctors. it was all weird.
Incandenza wrote:
Perhaps, but there hasn't been much heat at all on senfive this round, and if he's really going to go off so full-throttle against PG and fircoal, either he's the noobiest mafia of all time (his less-than-sterling performance in the last game would potentially bear this out), or he's just dead convinced of his reasoning.
Or he's mafia and both RD and trestain are as well, and he's trying to draw the heat off them both. That's barely remotely possible, and probably not worth following up.
I understand people FOSing him, though.
Senfive, is a noob, I don't know why he's so against me, and he probably is trying to get the heat off of RD, and tre, or he really thinks Me and PG, are mafia. He doesn't even listen to my explaintion that I posted before. I said them, because they had the least amount of proof on the lynch, and they barely post too. MAybe the 6th and 7th vote should be there too.
Vote: Mandy
Eddie35: hi everyone
Serbia: YOU IDIOT! What is THAT supposed to be? Are you even TRYING to play this game?! Kill the idiot NOW please!
Skoffin wrote: So um.. er... I'll be honest, I don't know what the f*ck to do from here. Goddamnit chu.
Incandenza wrote:
The question now is: if there is a vigilante (not speculating who, of course), who should they go after?
go after someone who didn't vote for RD.
then came this from vgmmaster...
vgmmaster wrote:
VOTE: Roger Dodger
hmmm... conicidence?
According to the times, my post did come after yours. However, I would like to mention the fact that I clicked add reply before your post appeared. So, I was not aware of the fact that you posted beforehand.
Fircoal wrote:Senfive, is a noob, I don't know why he's so against me, and he probably is trying to get the heat off of RD, and tre, or he really thinks Me and PG, are mafia. He doesn't even listen to my explaintion that I posted before. I said them, because they had the least amount of proof on the lynch, and they barely post too. MAybe the 6th and 7th vote should be there too.
A noob, certainly. But mafia? I'm not so sure. If he was trying to deflect attention away from RD or trestain, he did a terrible, unsubtle job. He does seem awful zealous, but that might be noobery rather than mafia. Hard to say, but worth keeping a loose eye on.
When you say the 6th and 7th votes should be added too, I assume you mean added to the EOS pile you created, but do you mean the nyvek vote or the RD vote?
Fircoal wrote:Senfive, is a noob, I don't know why he's so against me, and he probably is trying to get the heat off of RD, and tre, or he really thinks Me and PG, are mafia. He doesn't even listen to my explaintion that I posted before. I said them, because they had the least amount of proof on the lynch, and they barely post too. MAybe the 6th and 7th vote should be there too.
A noob, certainly. But mafia? I'm not so sure. If he was trying to deflect attention away from RD or trestain, he did a terrible, unsubtle job. He does seem awful zealous, but that might be noobery rather than mafia. Hard to say, but worth keeping a loose eye on.
When you say the 6th and 7th votes should be added too, I assume you mean added to the EOS pile you created, but do you mean the nyvek vote or the RD vote?
MAybe sen is mafa, that I'm not sure about.
The Nvyek BAngwagon, the RD votes, had more proof to it, then the NYvek one.
Vote: Mandy
Eddie35: hi everyone
Serbia: YOU IDIOT! What is THAT supposed to be? Are you even TRYING to play this game?! Kill the idiot NOW please!
Skoffin wrote: So um.. er... I'll be honest, I don't know what the f*ck to do from here. Goddamnit chu.
Fircoal wrote:Senfive, is a noob, I don't know why he's so against me, and he probably is trying to get the heat off of RD, and tre, or he really thinks Me and PG, are mafia. He doesn't even listen to my explaintion that I posted before. I said them, because they had the least amount of proof on the lynch, and they barely post too. MAybe the 6th and 7th vote should be there too.
A noob, certainly. But mafia? I'm not so sure. If he was trying to deflect attention away from RD or trestain, he did a terrible, unsubtle job. He does seem awful zealous, but that might be noobery rather than mafia. Hard to say, but worth keeping a loose eye on.
When you say the 6th and 7th votes should be added too, I assume you mean added to the EOS pile you created, but do you mean the nyvek vote or the RD vote?
MAybe sen is mafa, that I'm not sure about.
The Nvyek BAngwagon, the RD votes, had more proof to it, then the NYvek one.
vgmmaster wrote:
According to the times, my post did come after yours. However, I would like to mention the fact that I clicked add reply before your post appeared. So, I was not aware of the fact that you posted beforehand.
fircoal wrote:MAybe sen is mafa, that I'm not sure about.
The Nvyek BAngwagon, the RD votes, had more proof to it, then the NYvek one.
i think Sen is
Could be... but I'd have to see more, and I definitely wouldn't advise our hypothetical vig to kill him at this point. But if you guys really believe he's mafia, give him some jack bauer style interrogation on day 3....
