Lord of the Rings mafia [Town wins]

[Stroop]

I totally forgot to do this yesterday... expect Day 3 to start soon

[spiesr]

So much for doing it soon...

[Stroop]

So much for doing it soon...

Soon is a relative term. You are just impatient.

Going to start Day 3 within the hour

[Stroop]

The following day, Frodo had to make his decision. What would be their path to Mount Doom? He walks away from the camp, so that he can think about the future of the fellowship in peace. Soon after he leaves, the fellowship sees Boromir leave the camp as well…

Boromir finds and Frodo and tries to convince him to bring the Ring to Gondor. When this fails Boromir attacks Frodo, driven to this horrible action by the Ring and his will to save his homeland. Frodo escapes by putting the Ring on and running away, to the summit of Amon Hen. Aragorn finds Frodo there, but soon they hear the sounds of a horn.



A company of Uruk-hai and Orcs has found the fellowship.

The fellowship is under attack; the mafia gets a daykill to use during Day 3

Day 3 starts now!

Day 3 will end 312 hours from now

[Stroop]

Thezzaruz has asked to be replaced, because he can't get to a PC often enough for this game anymore. I tried to do it during the night but that failed.

[Iliad]

Good thing that no death happened, but bad thing that mafia now gets a daykill.

[pmchugh]

Thez is almost certainly sauron, with the failed lynch yesterday however I don't know if there is any point in pursuing him if we can't kill him. Only other options are the ring, the nazgul who can't be killed by man or frodo. If he is sauron chances are we need to survive till a certain time or actionthat frodo does to throw the ring into mount doom. If he is the ring ditto, if he is the witch king of angmar it would mean that eowen is in this game with a one-shot kill or similar. If this is the case then I suggest you target thez tonight. Anyway I think his replacement should claim ASAP.

[Mr. Squirrel]

Anyway I think his replacement should claim ASAP.

I'm not sure about the rest of what you said pmc, but I agree with this. Teh fact that he is alive is very strange. I had never heard of a role that could stop a lynch, only ones that survive night kills.

[pmchugh]

Anyway I think his replacement should claim ASAP.

I'm not sure about the rest of what you said pmc, but I agree with this. Teh fact that he is alive is very strange. I had never heard of a role that could stop a lynch, only ones that survive night kills.

Governer's can stop lynches, but this doesn't sound like a governer to me. Last time I see something like this it was the joker in batman mafia.

[william18]

Anyway I think his replacement should claim ASAP.

I'm not sure about the rest of what you said pmc, but I agree with this. Teh fact that he is alive is very strange. I had never heard of a role that could stop a lynch, only ones that survive night kills.

Governer's can stop lynches, but this doesn't sound like a governer to me. Last time I see something like this it was the joker in batman mafia.

Lol, you mean like a bullet-proof vest that works or either night or day? Possibly.

[william18]

Thez is almost certainly sauron, with the failed lynch yesterday however I don't know if there is any point in pursuing him if we can't kill him. Only other options are the ring, the nazgul who can't be killed by man or frodo. If he is sauron chances are we need to survive till a certain time or actionthat frodo does to throw the ring into mount doom. If he is the ring ditto, if he is the witch king of angmar it would mean that eowen is in this game with a one-shot kill or similar. If this is the case then I suggest you target thez tonight. Anyway I think his replacement should claim ASAP.

technacally anyone can kill a nazgul, all you have to do is detach the ring from their body, since that ring is what is keeping them alive from events that would kill even the greatest soldier instantly. I read somewhere that the ring connects the riders to Sauron, thus making them live thousands of years.

[spiesr]

So, thezzz survived the lynch and we think it could be because he is sauron. Now do we try to lynch him again or assume that he is unlynchable?

[spiesr]

So Suspect, got any more whisperings or what not?

[Suspect101]

So Suspect, got any more whisperings or what not?

I did. I was told that Mr.Squirrel is not working for the dark lord.

[Mr. Squirrel]

Anyway I think his replacement should claim ASAP.

I'm not sure about the rest of what you said pmc, but I agree with this. Teh fact that he is alive is very strange. I had never heard of a role that could stop a lynch, only ones that survive night kills.

Governer's can stop lynches, but this doesn't sound like a governer to me. Last time I see something like this it was the joker in batman mafia.

Lol, you mean like a bullet-proof vest that works or either night or day? Possibly.

Well, how did you kill the joker then? If he can't be lynched and night kills don't work, what other way is there to kill him?

So Suspect, got any more whisperings or what not?

I did. I was told that Mr.Squirrel is not working for the dark lord.

I'm not liking these whisperings. Although this one speaks the truth (I should know), it casts just as much suspicion on their target as it does protection. Yesterday we debated whether or not the whisperings were true about PMC and even a few votes were exchanged because of it. These do not provide us with solid evidence and I would rather not rely on them for my information.

Although, the first prediction is looking more truthful to me now that i know this one is.

[pmchugh]

I see absolutely no reason to deny these wisperings as I know I am town, as I said I am convinced Mr squirrel is and I also believe karel to be town. And for anyone thinking well they could all be scum together then think more carefully if one of us were found out so would the rest of us.


The below is what I think of people:

1. pmchugh TOWN
2. Suspect101 TOWN
3. william18 SCUMMY
4. karelpietertje TOWN
5. Mr. Squirrel TOWN
6. Simon Viavant (replaced Hologram Night 1) SCUMMY
7. AceArtemis TOWN
9. sam_levi_11 ????
10. Iliad SCUMMY
12. Thezzaruz VERY VERY SCUMMY
13. Clive LEGOLAS
14. Falkomagno PROBs TOWN
15. spiesr ????

Just telling you all before I get day killed, either me or suspect will I garuntee it.

[Falkomagno]

I think that Thezz is one of the bad guys. He was almost lynched at day 1 instead of Gandalf, and in day 2, when we finally achieve that, he is still alive. I don't know if he is unlynchable once or all the game. But If he is scum, as I actually think, how can win the fellowship if we can not lynch him? so, it's probable that he was just saved once. Another fact to consider, is the mod urgency in trying to replace thez at night stage. That leads us to think that thez is a real important role in the game. But with his level of activity, it's hard to be 100% sure of anything.

[pmchugh]

I think that Thezz is one of the bad guys. He was almost lynched at day 1 instead of Gandalf, and in day 2, when we finally achieve that, he is still alive. I don't know if he is unlynchable once or all the game. But If he is scum, as I actually think, how can win the fellowship if we can not lynch him? so, it's probable that he was just saved once. Another fact to consider, is the mod urgency in trying to replace thez at night stage. That leads us to think that thez is a real important role in the game. But with his level of activity, it's hard to be 100% sure of anything.

It could have been a one shot thing thats what it was with the joker in batman mentioned earlier. But the biggest fear is that we do it again and he is still unlynchable.

[Mr. Squirrel]

Hey suspect, can you give us your character name? I am asking because it might help us determine the validity of your whisperings. For example, if you are pippin and your whisperings come from the orb of sauron, there is a good chance we can't trust them. But, if you are Galadriel and your whisperings come from her mind reading powers, there is a much higher chance that they are true.

I don't want you to reveal your role, just your name.

[spiesr]

I think that Thezz is one of the bad guys. He was almost lynched at day 1 instead of Gandalf, and in day 2, when we finally achieve that, he is still alive. I don't know if he is unlynchable once or all the game. But If he is scum, as I actually think, how can win the fellowship if we can not lynch him? so, it's probable that he was just saved once. Another fact to consider, is the mod urgency in trying to replace thez at night stage. That leads us to think that thez is a real important role in the game. But with his level of activity, it's hard to be 100% sure of anything.

Well if he is Sauron then I think there are two real possibilities.
1. It was a one shot save.
2. He can't be killed until the ring is destroyed.

[Suspect101]

Hey suspect, can you give us your character name? I am asking because it might help us determine the validity of your whisperings. For example, if you are pippin and your whisperings come from the orb of sauron, there is a good chance we can't trust them. But, if you are Galadriel and your whisperings come from her mind reading powers, there is a much higher chance that they are true.

I don't want you to reveal your role, just your name.

I am Sam and I have no known powers. I am pretty sure the whisperings are not sauron but a good aligned player in the game. I am guessing Frodo but I could be wrong.

I know for a fact these players are not working for the dark lord: Mr.S, Pmc, karl, and myself.

[pmchugh]

Hey suspect, can you give us your character name? I am asking because it might help us determine the validity of your whisperings. For example, if you are pippin and your whisperings come from the orb of sauron, there is a good chance we can't trust them. But, if you are Galadriel and your whisperings come from her mind reading powers, there is a much higher chance that they are true.

I don't want you to reveal your role, just your name.

I am Sam and I have no known powers. I am pretty sure the whisperings are not sauron but a good aligned player in the game. I am guessing Frodo but I could be wrong.

I know for a fact these players are not working for the dark lord: Mr.S, Pmc, karl, and myself.

Don't forget that aceartemis and clive already have secure claims. Leaving:

1. iliad
2. thez
3. will
4. simon
5.sam
6. speisr

With 3 scum+ 1 3rd party most likely.

[Iliad]

I see absolutely no reason to deny these wisperings as I know I am town, as I said I am convinced Mr squirrel is and I also believe karel to be town. And for anyone thinking well they could all be scum together then think more carefully if one of us were found out so would the rest of us.


The below is what I think of people:

1. pmchugh TOWN
2. Suspect101 TOWN
3. william18 SCUMMY
4. karelpietertje TOWN
5. Mr. Squirrel TOWN
6. Simon Viavant (replaced Hologram Night 1) SCUMMY
7. AceArtemis TOWN
9. sam_levi_11 ????
10. Iliad SCUMMY
12. Thezzaruz VERY VERY SCUMMY
13. Clive LEGOLAS
14. Falkomagno PROBs TOWN
15. spiesr ????

Just telling you all before I get day killed, either me or suspect will I garuntee it.

It's a good thing that your scum sensor is so great. Oh wait. You outted Gandalf, probably our best power role and then Legolas had to claim.

The only thing you've tried to raise against me was that I disagreed you against the whisperings. Obviously as Minister Masket found out, disagreeing with you is a definite scumtell. I personally don't remember any kind of whisperings role, except the telegraph function in Deadwood mafia. But that wasn't a role. Considering this could easily be the Ring or some other corrupting force, I'm still a bit wary of the whispering. Mainly because it conveniently can't be traced, and there is no way to prove or disprove it.

Pmchugh, you've been awfully agressive and have been trying to lead town all game.

[spiesr]

Don't forget that aceartemis and clive already have secure claims. Leaving:

1. iliad
2. thez
3. will
4. simon
5.sam
6. speisr

With 3 scum+ 1 3rd party most likely.

So then, let's either look at relynching thezz or probing Iliad, will, or simon as you found them the most scummy.

[pmchugh]

There is a way to prove it someone is sending these whisperings and i say they tell us now and claim their role, as soon as scum use their day kill. With doctors at night we would be virtually unbeatble if the claim came up as true.

And I have more than that agianst you illy, I think I will go back and find some legit reasons to put on paper.

And whats with all the personal diggs at my scumdar, I ain't perfect and don't claim to be. Sure I may go OTT when I get it right but who isn't happy when they do?

@ speisr who do you think is most scummy on that list?