Moderator: Community Team
I disagree, mass claims are boring when the setup is known or the theme is known. They take the fun out of a game. I think there should be a rule agianst them in themed games.captainwalrus wrote:ya, or the scum could be smart enought no not agree to a mass claim. Although that would be scummy.
Kewl. Bulletproof is back on the table.Mr. Squirrel wrote:My idea was if there was a massclaim, then the scum would be forced to make up a town role. We would know they were scum, because no one would have submitted that role. However, this backfires on the townie who recieves the role that the scum submitted. The scum would obviously not claim to have submitted that role and the townie would be lynched. See what I mean?

Talapus wrote: I'm far more pissed that mandy and his thought process were right from the get go....damn you mandy.

Talapus wrote: I'm far more pissed that mandy and his thought process were right from the get go....damn you mandy.
Awww, but I want to be awesome!mandalorian2298 wrote:Ok, I finished smoking, grabed supplies and changed the lemming's water (but not the food because he still has some left in bowl and he is fat anyway. Like a miniature furry piglet. Reminds me of Fircoal back when he was younger. Except for the fact that the lemming isn't yellow with red cheeks. And Fircoal doesn't run around a wheel all day long. At least I don't think that he does. Who can know for sure.)
Kewl. Bulletproof is back on the table.Mr. Squirrel wrote:My idea was if there was a massclaim, then the scum would be forced to make up a town role. We would know they were scum, because no one would have submitted that role. However, this backfires on the townie who recieves the role that the scum submitted. The scum would obviously not claim to have submitted that role and the townie would be lynched. See what I mean?
BTW, normal roles only. No all-knowing-indestructible-killing machines, ok PMC?
Zigacly! That has been my plan all along.Simon Viavant wrote:You should name a faction in the pm and have people give a role, so that way they won't necessarily be part of that faction, which will keep balance, and then randomly mix up the roles later.

Talapus wrote: I'm far more pissed that mandy and his thought process were right from the get go....damn you mandy.
But of course then you would have to make sure roles aren't overpowerred, see above ^^^^mandalorian2298 wrote:Zigacly! That has been my plan all along.Simon Viavant wrote:You should name a faction in the pm and have people give a role, so that way they won't necessarily be part of that faction, which will keep balance, and then randomly mix up the roles later.
"Peace plans for the Middle East"![]()
I found some paper!
Aye, they be a strange bunch.Simon Viavant wrote:That's what I thought at first but everyone was talking about not doing this or that role because it'd be overpowered, so I thought it was something else.

Talapus wrote: I'm far more pissed that mandy and his thought process were right from the get go....damn you mandy.
Is Illiad comming? He hasn't responded to my PM yet.pmchugh wrote:Some intrestingly overpowered roels could come out of this
OK I am gonig to play a speed game anyway, I seen illy about so maybe we could rope him in on it.

Talapus wrote: I'm far more pissed that mandy and his thought process were right from the get go....damn you mandy.
Idkmandalorian2298 wrote:Is Illiad comming? He hasn't responded to my PM yet.pmchugh wrote:Some intrestingly overpowered roels could come out of this
OK I am gonig to play a speed game anyway, I seen illy about so maybe we could rope him in on it.
Probably not. I'll have to leave in a while, and do stuff until then.mandalorian2298 wrote:Is Illiad comming? He hasn't responded to my PM yet.pmchugh wrote:Some intrestingly overpowered roels could come out of this
OK I am gonig to play a speed game anyway, I seen illy about so maybe we could rope him in on it.
Er, it's actually 4 now. Exile had to bail.pmchugh wrote:I say just try it with 5, before others start to disappear.

Talapus wrote: I'm far more pissed that mandy and his thought process were right from the get go....damn you mandy.
wait for 1 more then?mandalorian2298 wrote:Er, it's actually 4 now. Exile had to bail.pmchugh wrote:I say just try it with 5, before others start to disappear.
Maybe it would be best if we tried this again tomorrow night then. I really like this idea of pick-your-own-roles, but I don't think it will reach its full potential in a 4 person game.mandalorian2298 wrote:Er, it's actually 4 now. Exile had to bail.pmchugh wrote:I say just try it with 5, before others start to disappear.
yes but all of us yanks will be at 4th of july parties tomorrow so there might be even less turnout.Mr. Squirrel wrote:Maybe it would be best if we tried this again tomorrow night then. I really like this idea of pick-your-own-roles, but I don't think it will reach its full potential in a 4 person game.mandalorian2298 wrote:Er, it's actually 4 now. Exile had to bail.pmchugh wrote:I say just try it with 5, before others start to disappear.
That's true. I forgot it was the 4th tomorrow.Simon Viavant wrote:yes but all of us yanks will be at 4th of july parties tomorrow so there might be even less turnout.Mr. Squirrel wrote:Maybe it would be best if we tried this again tomorrow night then. I really like this idea of pick-your-own-roles, but I don't think it will reach its full potential in a 4 person game.mandalorian2298 wrote:Er, it's actually 4 now. Exile had to bail.pmchugh wrote:I say just try it with 5, before others start to disappear.
Or mroe drunken turn outSimon Viavant wrote:yes but all of us yanks will be at 4th of july parties tomorrow so there might be even less turnout.Mr. Squirrel wrote:Maybe it would be best if we tried this again tomorrow night then. I really like this idea of pick-your-own-roles, but I don't think it will reach its full potential in a 4 person game.mandalorian2298 wrote:Er, it's actually 4 now. Exile had to bail.pmchugh wrote:I say just try it with 5, before others start to disappear.