Watchmen Mafia_Godfather found! Town Wins!

[pmchugh]

the confusing part about all this is that everyone knows two of the six players roles. there own and pmc who is town. so this leaves four unknowns in the equation and if pmc is right two of them are mafia.
pmc your role said you are a naive cop what does that do and what have you found out at night

It effectively does nothing. i investigated ga7 and got town, but "naive" means that no matter who i investigate i will get town so i am useless really.

i would like to hear mad pine's response to squirrel.

[pmchugh]

By squirrel i mean ace.

[AceArtemis]

I just noticed that nobody was revived last night. Any reason why?

Probably a 1-shot deal, or else it would be extremely overpowered, unless the revived have a chance to come back as mafia.

[Mr. Squirrel]

Vote Count:

MP - 1 Ace

With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

[Crazyirishman]

the confusing part about all this is that everyone knows two of the six players roles. there own and pmc who is town. so this leaves four unknowns in the equation and if pmc is right two of them are mafia.
pmc your role said you are a naive cop what does that do and what have you found out at night

It effectively does nothing. i investigated ga7 and got town, but "naive" means that no matter who i investigate i will get town so i am useless really.

i would like to hear mad pine's response to squirrel.

I investigated Ga7 and got scum, but he hasn't done anything scummy yet so I'm going to hold my vote sinse that could be misleading like PMC's role

[pmchugh]

the confusing part about all this is that everyone knows two of the six players roles. there own and pmc who is town. so this leaves four unknowns in the equation and if pmc is right two of them are mafia.
pmc your role said you are a naive cop what does that do and what have you found out at night

It effectively does nothing. i investigated ga7 and got town, but "naive" means that no matter who i investigate i will get town so i am useless really.

i would like to hear mad pine's response to squirrel.

I investigated Ga7 and got scum, but he hasn't done anything scummy yet so I'm going to hold my vote sinse that could be misleading like PMC's role

Have you investigated anyone else?

[Crazyirishman]

No, The first night I killed colton because I thought he was scum, but he was just stupid for not paying attention to the fact that PMC was at L-1, which was an irrational decision on my part. I am a jack of all trades, and if you look at what the scene said for what happened to colton it corresponds to my claim.

[pmchugh]

No, The first night I killed colton because I thought he was scum, but he was just stupid for not paying attention to the fact that PMC was at L-1, which was an irrational decision on my part. I am a jack of all trades, and if you look at what the scene said for what happened to colton it corresponds to my claim.

Ok I seriously doubt squirrel gave you JOAT with an insane investigation but a normal kill. Therefore unvote vote ga7, I investigated him for a reason and I think this pretty much garuntees he is scum or squirrel is very inventive with his roles.

[gregwolf121]

well looking over things i think that MP is lurking, ga7 also hasn't posted in a while, we all know pmc is town, i'm not sure what ace or crazyirishman are, but it seems to me that the best case so far is against ga7 not that any of the cases are very good so vote ga7

[AceArtemis]

I won't place my vote on Ga7 because I don't want the mafia quickhammering, but Ga7 definitely needs to claim because of the evidence against him.

[ga7]

Gah I'm so out of it. I barely skimmed over today but I was Rorscharch's lyncher so I guess I'm vanilla now. I didn't even know whose player was Rorscharch so it was quite a sucky role too -_- Especially since we can't give our character names while claiming apparently. Anyway I'll have to check with Squirrel if I can even win with the town since that wasn't detailed, but either way I don't think we're at LYLO since I was anti town to start with; so up to you just decide now so I know if I bother or not rereading

[pmchugh]

Gah I'm so out of i-

Yo ga7, i'm really happy for you and I'm gonna let you finish but your claim in dark knight was one of the best fake claims of all time.

[Crazyirishman]

Ok I seriously doubt squirrel gave you JOAT with an insane investigation but a normal kill. Therefore unvote vote ga7, I investigated him for a reason and I think this pretty much garuntees he is scum or squirrel is very inventive with his roles.

My investigation was pretty much dumb luck which is why I'm withholding my vote. All it consisted of was I looked at who posted last at the time my night action was sent in, and I investigated them sinse I hadn't drawn any conclusions.

[pmchugh]

Ok I seriously doubt squirrel gave you JOAT with an insane investigation but a normal kill. Therefore unvote vote ga7, I investigated him for a reason and I think this pretty much garuntees he is scum or squirrel is very inventive with his roles.

My investigation was pretty much dumb luck which is why I'm withholding my vote. All it consisted of was I looked at who posted last at the time my night action was sent in, and I investigated them sinse I hadn't drawn any conclusions.

Nevertheless it turned up scum. It would have said third party if he was a lyncher like he claimed. He is using the excuses of it being at LYLO and him not being able to character claim in order to try and get us to avoid lynchnig him As far as i see it it is far more likely he is scum pretending to be a lyncher than any other individual is scum. And i did suspect him before hand, I can create a case against him if need be but with his poor claim I don't think their is any need to.

[Mr. Squirrel]

Vote Count

Mad Pineapples- 1 ace
Ga7- 2 greg, pmc

with 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch

Pineapples is being prodded.

[ga7]

See if I tell the truth since you can't seem to read properly.
Vote ga7

[gregwolf121]

okay if i remember right in the movie the person who killed rorscharch was Dr. manhatten, the blue guy. now if this setup mirrors the movie then dr manhatten would be the lyncher and rorscharch would be the lynchee, and ga7 would then be claiming to be dr. manhatten
but

No, The first night I killed colton because I thought he was scum, but he was just stupid for not paying attention to the fact that PMC was at L-1, which was an irrational decision on my part. I am a jack of all trades, and if you look at what the scene said for what happened to colton it corresponds to my claim.

Dr. Malcom Long sat in his office at the county jail, performing his daily paperwork. He had been busy lately, with the rough times and crime on the rise more and more patients were passing through his office on a daily basis. He looked at the clock, it was late. He grabbed his sweater and decided to head home. His wife would be unhappy with him for staying late. As he entered his car, a flash of blue light blinded him. When he regained his bearings, he saw the famous glowing blue man who had come to symbolize American power standing in front of his car. Without any sort of explanation, Dr. Manhattan raised his hand and pointed at the overweight man in the car. In a fraction of a milisecond, the interior of the car went from being pristine to covered in blood and entrails.

Colton (Dr. Malcom Long – Town Prison Doctor) has been killed!

so if im right we got two people claiming to be dr manhatten

[pmchugh]

I agree, lynch him, he is almost certainly scum.

[ga7]

I love when people try to play the setting in a game set up so that they can't. Hurry up, this is silly.

[pmchugh]

I love when people try to play the setting in a game set up so that they can't. Hurry up, this is silly.

[Crazyirishman]

Is Ga7 allowed to vote himself?

[gregwolf121]

i don't see why not

[Mr. Squirrel]

...now if this setup mirrors the movie...

This set up is based on the novel, (proof is that Thez's character, Derf, was never seen in the movie) but it does vary slightly depending on what you guys do in-game. For example, in the book Nite Owl and Silk Spectre never died, but here in the mafia game I had to do it.

Basically, don't expect this game to end up exactly the same way the movie/book did.

[AceArtemis]

Unvote, Vote: Ga7

[Mr. Squirrel]

Vote count:

Ga7- 4 Ace, pmc, greg, ga7

That's a lynch. Scene coming shortly.