Nashville Mafia Wars Mafia Night 3_Terror Subsides

[spiesr]

I'm Bob Hall's brother, Tim Hall. I witnessed the whole intro charade, so I can figure out if someone's guilty or innocent, but I've no clue which mafia the guilty person belongs to.

So are you saying that in a game where a police force is purported to exist, that the role the sounds most similar to a cop is not a affiliated with it?

[oldrisky44]

Just trying to put all the pieces together...

2 mafia factions
?? Police
?? Witnesses who have hard evidence?
At least 1 Non-voter

Mafia factions are rivals and therefore want to kill each other
Witnesses by claiming are setting themselves up for hit by mafia?
Non-voter is benign? or is he dangerous?

That accounts for at least 5. Am I missing any clues?

[edocsil]

I'm Bob Hall's brother, Tim Hall. I witnessed the whole intro charade, so I can figure out if someone's guilty or innocent, but I've no clue which mafia the guilty person belongs to.

So are you saying that in a game where a police force is purported to exist, that the role the sounds most similar to a cop is not a affiliated with it?

One cop was killed pre game, and 2 cops in a 12 man game wouldn't be that odd. Especially considering that the game was originally built for 18 I think the role is reasonable.

[aage]

Just trying to put all the pieces together...

2 mafia factions
?? Police
?? Witnesses who have hard evidence?
At least 1 Non-voter

Mafia factions are rivals and therefore want to kill each other
Witnesses by claiming are setting themselves up for hit by mafia?
Non-voter is benign? or is he dangerous?

That accounts for at least 5. Am I missing any clues?

I think you're missing what the "???" stands for. I guess it means someone can vote by PM. Can't figure another explanation.

Also, the cop killed pre-game was an NPC so I don't think we need to take that one too serious. I'm guessing on 2 bodyguards/protectors and 2 cops.

[duday53]

This is an interesting game because even mafia players may be looking for scum tells lol.

I'm in too many of these goddamn mafias

QFT

As for Victor's claim.. its believable. He may have doomed himself tonight if there are no bodyguards or doctors. But there must be if there are going to be at least two nightkills every night..

[oldrisky44]

Clarification of ??

I should have used #

meaning an unknown number of

[oldrisky44]

Still putting pieces together.

Of those not voting, Fircoal and duday have said very little.

Fircoal posted an excuse for not posting and duday posted that he does not know what to post?

Suspicious???

[Victor Sullivan]

I'm in too many of these goddamn mafias

QFT

What does QFT mean?

[aage]

@Victor: quoted for truth, means he agrees.

@oldrisky44: Yes. Suspicious. But I don't understand the post you made before that.

[spiesr]

So where do we go from here???

[oldrisky44]

Just trying to put all the pieces together...

2 mafia factions
?? Police
?? Witnesses who have hard evidence?
At least 1 Non-voter

Mafia factions are rivals and therefore want to kill each other
Witnesses by claiming are setting themselves up for hit by mafia?
Non-voter is benign? or is he dangerous?

That accounts for at least 5. Am I missing any clues?

Further clarification...

The "question marks" above (i.e. ?? Police) are meant to represent "an unknown number of". Thus my clarifying post where I said "I should have used the # sign"

SO to reiterate...

This is what we "know" to be true so far...

This game contains at least;
2 Mafia factions
# Police? (there may be an unknown number of police)
At least 1 witness who claims to have seen the murder
At least 1 non-voter
2 players are suspiciously quiet


"Now what do we do?"

[colton24]

Vote Count
lalaland(1)-AceArtemis
Victor Sullivan(5)L-2-spiesr, cena-rules, sensfan, oldrisky44, freezie
freezie(2)-Victor Sullivan, ???
Fircoal(1)-aage
edocsil(1)-lalaland

Not voting: Fircoal, duday53, edocsil

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch

[oldrisky44]

UNVOTE Vote Fircoal

Reasoning as per my previous posts.

[Victor Sullivan]

What happened to A_D? Or am I getting my mafias mixed up again?

[freezie]

Oh, I just ignored all that crap cuz it would require me reading more than I prefer.

Vote Victor Sullivan

That's taking Skimming to a whole new level

Oh, I just ignored all that crap cuz it would require me reading more than I prefer.

Vote Victor Sullivan

Fine, fine, I read it. I think the case against lala is a bit absurd (despite him FoSing me grrr...). Though a role claim might help. unvote, vote lalaland

Are you freaking kidding me?! Calling out for a claim with barely half the players posting? Especially when everyone is going into a bandwaggon over a confirm in the wrong thread...

Boy...

Vote: Victor Sullivan

FoS: Acee and Aceartemis

Fine, if you don't want lalaland to have my vote, you can have it! unvote, vote freezie

this is the last time I vote for victor..I wanted you to explain why you mindlessly went against lala to start off, for no actual reason other than she mis-confirmed. Remember the bandwagon you continued?

Then you go OMGUS me when I call you out. that's what I wanted you to explain...but whatever......

Unvote

[freezie]

6. Lynching requires a majority of the town vote, once the majority has been reached any unvotes will not be counted. The majority is half the player's alive +1.

Rule 6 seems to indicate 7 for this game...

Vote spiesr Idk... This post just pissed me off for some reason.

That, too, I still want an explanation.

[freezie]

right now..I see Duday AND fircoal submarinning like hell.

fircoal came back only to say he was to a Concert..and vanishes after. So.......

Vote: Fircoal

FoS: Duday

[oldrisky44]

About suspicious behavior...

Why would two who have not yet voted not jump on the bandwagon to vote for Victor and get a quick lynch?

FOS duday

[spiesr]

Why would two who have not yet voted not jump on the bandwagon to vote for Victor and get a quick lynch?

Why would they? What reason would they have to want a quick lynch of Victor? Doing so would too quickly would also cause suspicion towards them...

[Fircoal]

Ok this time I'm just being lazy and I know it. Idk I don't really look at this thread like I do the others. I don't know why. Because everyone's being so lazy I should go and look through for scummy things. YAY

[Fircoal]

vote Victor Sullivan lala seems to have made valid points. Endo's role seems to be beneficial. Victor seems shady to me.

wait, what? I have no idea what you'er referencing at all, and out of context it's somewhat scummy...

[Fircoal]

So where do we go from here???

sadly I have no idea and am not finding any yet. ffffffffffffffffff

[lalaland]

About suspicious behavior...

Why would two who have not yet voted not jump on the bandwagon to vote for Victor and get a quick lynch?

FOS duday

This makes me suspicious of you... I see no reason why we need a "quick lynch"... although this thread has not been uber active, we are finding stuff out and I'd say we're having (at least were having) a fairly productive Day 1. And it's only been 9 pages or so. FOS oldrisky Personally, I don't see overwhelming evidence against victor, and I think we should at least have somebody check out his claim tonight before we do anything rash.

Although I'm not a fan on principle, what do people think about a no-lynch?

[spiesr]

Although I'm not a fan on principle, what do people think about a no-lynch?

I'm not a fan on principle

[freezie]

.
what do people think about a no-lynch?

Definitly not. We got 2 submariners and someone who wanted a quick lynch on Victor.

No need for a no lynch.