Quentin Tarantino Mafia Night 3 (Mafia Win!)

[pmchugh]

nag(1)-mandy, pmchugh

Is this deliberately only one vote?

Also, Nag, why not just say you're not scum...?
unvote vote nag

Because I am under no pressure to make such a statement at this stage in the game Let's flip this over shall we, aage, how about you tell me if you are scum or not...

Anyway, if you insist - I am in fact a townsperson,I just wouldn't say I was town as I wanted to see who was out there hunting a bandwagon. Scum usually try and slip a third vote on or so on day one, in order to try and build a case against someone who might as well be an easy lynch. A lot of you have never played with me so you have no idea about my mafia capabilities but I will tell you 'this.' Nice try on the bandwagon scumster. Very subtle, I like.

unvote vote aage

Well la-di-da nick, aren't you such a great player!

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

nag(2)-pmchugh, aage
mandy(2)-fir
tailgunner(2)-spurgistan, flores
Violet(1)-lalaland,
fircoal(1)-edocsil
spurgistan(1)-colton
MeDeFe(2)-AoG, aage
lalaland(1)-VioIet
aage(3)-tailgunner, nag, mandy

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.

[nagerous]

Oh, forgot something.
Nope, not scum.

There there, darling, nobody was asking if you were scum. And yet you felt such need to deny it, that you wrote an additional post just for that.

Unvote vote aage for overdefending himself.

Actually, nag did kind of ask:

Let's flip this over shall we, aage, how about you tell me if you are scum or not...

Also, i go away for the weekend and you guys give me 5 pages to read, geez ...

5 pages are you kidding me? I hope that is sarcasm, back in the day a good argument involving wicked, mandy, nark, lsu etc. could produce a 75 day page one

And as to the point about aage over defending himself, that just justifies the whole futility of the said exercise, if we began a game with everyone stating that they are not scum, it would be a waste of time because of course anyone with half a brain cell would obviously unequivocally state that they are not of scum background.

[aage]

Then please tell me what the point is of voting for someone because they haven't said they're scum yet?

Exactly, there is no. Must've been a joke. Remember this is still day 1.

[Army of GOD]

Then please tell me what the point is of voting for someone because they haven't said they're scum yet?

Exactly, there is no. Must've been a joke. Remember this is still day 1.

I've learned that people in mafia games will vote you out if you look at them the wrong way.

[mandalorian2298]

I have a sudden need to role-claim because I kind of feel a deja vu to Sherwood and I think I know who one scum is. I also think that, maybe as soon as Day 2 I may be forced to protect, bodyguard or (ye gods!) be his chump Lover. What do you guys think?

P.S. I plan to claim just the name, not the role itself.

[karelpietertje]

Vote Count

nag(2)-pmchugh, aage
mandy(2)-fir
tailgunner(2)-spurgistan, flores
Violet(1)-lalaland,
fircoal(1)-edocsil
spurgistan(1)-colton
MeDeFe(2)-AoG, aage
lalaland(1)-VioIet
aage(3)-tailgunner, nag, mandy

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.

Wait what?


the game maker is acting suspicious. using his own maths for the votings.
I believe a FOS is in order.

[edocsil]

I have a sudden need to role-claim because I kind of feel a deja vu to Sherwood and I think I know who one scum is. I also think that, maybe as soon as Day 2 I may be forced to protect, bodyguard or (ye gods!) be his chump Lover. What do you guys think?

P.S. I plan to claim just the name, not the role itself.

I am interested. Perhaps a lynch before anything happens to you? Of course if you're wrong and said player is not scum, you might be in a bit of trouble.

[Army of GOD]

I have a sudden need to role-claim because I kind of feel a deja vu to Sherwood and I think I know who one scum is. I also think that, maybe as soon as Day 2 I may be forced to protect, bodyguard or (ye gods!) be his chump Lover. What do you guys think?

P.S. I plan to claim just the name, not the role itself.

Wait, what? I'm confuzzled.

We didn't have a night yet, so is your role like a "during day" one?

[mandalorian2298]

Ok, two minutes are up and so my pretending to give a rat's ass about what you guys thinking has just timed out. (wow, someone actually managed to fastpost me. Thanks for the vote of support Edocsil. )

I'm Mr. White. Given how insanely supportive pmchugh has been towards me, I must conclude that he is Mr. Orange and that we are going to mason up in the near future, but he has been briefed about it in advance. Also, given that Mr. Orange was a mole, I think that it is a fairly logical to assume that his role in this game is Mafia Spy. In fact, I have played Mafia Spy once (in the Braveheart game) and I played the Day 1 much the same as pmchugh is playing now.

unvote vote pmchugh

[Army of GOD]

I'm so confused now...what the hell is a mafia spy?

[mandalorian2298]

I have a sudden need to role-claim because I kind of feel a deja vu to Sherwood and I think I know who one scum is. I also think that, maybe as soon as Day 2 I may be forced to protect, bodyguard or (ye gods!) be his chump Lover. What do you guys think?

P.S. I plan to claim just the name, not the role itself.

Wait, what? I'm confuzzled.

We didn't have a night yet, so is your role like a "during day" one?

I think it may be event-triggered (like Maid Marion was supposed to be in Sherwood and like the Mykrr mission triggered some of the Jedi in NJO Mafia). Since I don't know when the event is supposed to happen, I think it's better to role the dice now then is to wait for Safari to role it for me.

P.S. Google it AoG, you big n00b.

[edocsil]

I am familiar with the role so I see why you claimed. Do you mind telling me what movie the characters are from, I haven't seen the one the characters are in. You logic however for identifying Mr. Orange I find lacking. It is enough for me to want a claim from pmc, but for a lynch? I don't know.

[aage]

I'm so confused now...what the hell is a mafia spy?

I know exactly how you feel... Well, probably not atm, but what you felt like when you wrote that post.

Mandalorian, if you want me to trust you I suggest you explain some more, before we get into this theory of yours.

[nagerous]

Ok, two minutes are up and so my pretending to give a rat's ass about what you guys thinking has just timed out. (wow, someone actually managed to fastpost me. Thanks for the vote of support Edocsil. )

I'm Mr. White. Given how insanely supportive pmchugh has been towards me, I must conclude that he is Mr. Orange and that we are going to mason up in the near future, but he has been briefed about it in advance. Also, given that Mr. Orange was a mole, I think that it is a fairly logical to assume that his role in this game is Mafia Spy. In fact, I have played Mafia Spy once (in the Braveheart game) and I played the Day 1 much the same as pmchugh is playing now.

unvote vote pmchugh

Wait a second? You're basing his 'insane supportiveness' on the fact that he voted me after you amirite?

[aage]

I guess it'll be some cop food for tonight... Atm I don't feel like lynching someone because they voted for Nag.

[nagerous]

I am familiar with the role so I see why you claimed. Do you mind telling me what movie the characters are from, I haven't seen the one the characters are in. You logic however for identifying Mr. Orange I find lacking. It is enough for me to want a claim from pmc, but for a lynch? I don't know.

You actually want a claim from pmc for that? Seems a bit forced. Also, as for your claim of Mr. White, isn't y'know Mr. White a bit of the old scummy mcscummer scum and Mr. Orange y'know a cop?

Just saying.

[Army of GOD]

I am familiar with the role so I see why you claimed. Do you mind telling me what movie the characters are from, I haven't seen the one the characters are in. You logic however for identifying Mr. Orange I find lacking. It is enough for me to want a claim from pmc, but for a lynch? I don't know.

Mr. [insert color here]s are from Reservoir Dogs.

[Army of GOD]

Ok, two minutes are up and so my pretending to give a rat's ass about what you guys thinking has just timed out. (wow, someone actually managed to fastpost me. Thanks for the vote of support Edocsil. )

I'm Mr. White. Given how insanely supportive pmchugh has been towards me, I must conclude that he is Mr. Orange and that we are going to mason up in the near future, but he has been briefed about it in advance. Also, given that Mr. Orange was a mole, I think that it is a fairly logical to assume that his role in this game is Mafia Spy. In fact, I have played Mafia Spy once (in the Braveheart game) and I played the Day 1 much the same as pmchugh is playing now.

unvote vote pmchugh

Ok, so I googled it and found this:

Spy: Mafia player who is, at first, innocent. He knows the other mafia members, but they do not know him. He tries to keep the town from lynching the mafia members. At any point in the game, the mafia can call the Spy into their ranks. From that point on, he is then considered to be a normal Mafioso, and guilty when investigated.

Is this true for this game? Just making sure.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Ok, two minutes are up and so my pretending to give a rat's ass about what you guys thinking has just timed out. (wow, someone actually managed to fastpost me. Thanks for the vote of support Edocsil. )

I'm Mr. White. Given how insanely supportive pmchugh has been towards me, I must conclude that he is Mr. Orange and that we are going to mason up in the near future, but he has been briefed about it in advance. Also, given that Mr. Orange was a mole, I think that it is a fairly logical to assume that his role in this game is Mafia Spy. In fact, I have played Mafia Spy once (in the Braveheart game) and I played the Day 1 much the same as pmchugh is playing now.

unvote vote pmchugh

hm. I see what you're saying, but I can't tell if you're genuine or not. Edocsil has investigative abilities, but only if Mafs don't know who he is, right?

I am familiar with the role so I see why you claimed. Do you mind telling me what movie the characters are from, I haven't seen the one the characters are in. You logic however for identifying Mr. Orange I find lacking. It is enough for me to want a claim from pmc, but for a lynch? I don't know.

You actually want a claim from pmc for that? Seems a bit forced. Also, as for your claim of Mr. White, isn't y'know Mr. White a bit of the old scummy mcscummer scum and Mr. Orange y'know a cop?

Just saying

I have to agree with nagerous. Doesn't a Mafia Spy win if mafia wins?
Definition of Mafia Spy
Mr. Orange (from Resevoir Dogs edocsil) is an undercover cop, so he would be a townie, and we know he's a good guy who wouldn't flip (in the movie he felt bad when he killed the woman and he protected the cop from Mr. Blonde during the torture scene).

However mandy just admitted to being scum. However I'm wondering if safariguy threw a twist in there, because I believe it was Mr. White who shot Joe Cabot, who I believe could be a possible mob boss.

-TG

[Army of GOD]

Wait, I'm really confused now.

Like TG said, Mr. Orange is actually a "town spy" (if such a role exists) in the movie and Mr. White is mafia.

Why would mandy admit he's scum on day 1 though? THINGS JUST DONT ADD UP

[nagerous]

That's what I was thinking about Mr. White, he wasn't the baddest bad ass in the history of Tarrantino films, Mr. Blonde in comparison was an evil son of a bitch and the mafia would have to be huge to accommodate all the Tarrantino criminals, like Ving Rhames (Marcellus 'does he look like a bitch' Wallace) from Pulp Fiction, Bill from Kill Bill etc. so there is every possibility that Mr. White could be a town role. That being said I still can't get the logic from where Mandy is going with his very odd and sudden role claim.

[edocsil]

hm. I see what you're saying, but I can't tell if you're genuine or not. Edocsil has investigative abilities, but only if Mafs don't know who he is, right?
-TG

Are you sure you meant to refer to me here?

[TA1LGUNN3R]

hm. I see what you're saying, but I can't tell if you're genuine or not. Edocsil has investigative abilities, but only if Mafs don't know who he is, right?
-TG

Are you sure you meant to refer to me here?

No I didn't. Sorry for the confusion. Yeah I meant pmc as being Mr. Orange (according to mandy), but I typed your name on accident.

-TG

[Army of GOD]

That's what I was thinking about Mr. White, he wasn't the baddest bad ass in the history of Tarrantino films, Mr. Blonde in comparison was an evil son of a bitch and the mafia would have to be huge to accommodate all the Tarrantino criminals, like Ving Rhames (Marcellus 'does he look like a bitch' Wallace) from Pulp Fiction, Bill from Kill Bill etc. so there is every possibility that Mr. White could be a town role. That being said I still can't get the logic from where Mandy is going with his very odd and sudden role claim.

But I'm wondering if it's in general moral "who's good in the movie and who isn't" or "protagonists of the movie are town and antagonists are mafia".

Like, in Pulp Fiction, Jules Winnfield is a protagonist, but he's essentially "evil" if we were to think about what his job actually is.

Mr. White was a protagonist in Reservoir Dogs, but he was also "evil" in a sense (while Mr. Orange was "good" [undercover cop]).

And there are so many ultimate antagonists from all of the Tarintino flicks (Bill, Wallace, Hans Landa from Inglorious Basterds, Joe Cabot, etc.) that Mr. White just doesn't seem right for a mafia role.