Nashville Mafia Wars Mafia Night 3_Terror Subsides

[spiesr]

Well, if the role-blocker person wants to reveal themselves they could prove oldrisky's claim of bus-driver. Conversely they could also disprove it if they targeted victor last night.

[oldrisky44]

But if the role blocker is scum he may want to sit back and watch me hang.

[oldrisky44]

BTW on an unrelated and completely random note, I like the way victor's avatar changes every day or two.

[Fircoal]

If there is a town roleblocker who blocked Cena, then that puts the roleblocker and Oldrisky in the clear. However if there is no such role that means that either there is a scum roleblocker and they blocked Victor (because a scum roleblocker blocking someone they don't know instead of a cop makes no sense) and oldrisky is scum, or that Victor lied about being blocked and is scum.

We should wait and see if anyone claims. If not we should lynch oldrisky. If he's town then we should lynch Victor.

[oldrisky44]

I think I have to agree with fircoal's reasoning on this, except the way he phrased the proposition, I am only safe if there is a town role-blocker who helps me out. But if victor is a liar or the role blocker is scum I still hang and the only way you will be convinced of my innocence is when you read my obituary, and it will be too late.

[freezie]

I kinda agree with oldrisky there: if victor is scum and lied, that doesnt necessarly mean oldrisky is scum. he could havge busdriven absolutly nothing last night aswell.

[Fircoal]

I kinda agree with oldrisky there: if victor is scum and lied, that doesnt necessarly mean oldrisky is scum. he could havge busdriven absolutly nothing last night aswell.

NO! you don't get it!

If Victor is scum then Oldrisky is town.

If Oldrisky is scum then Victor is town.

Out of the two I'd prefer to lynch the one that seems scummier and isn't a cop.

However none of this applies if a town roleblocker comes forward.

[duday53]

I kinda agree with oldrisky there: if victor is scum and lied, that doesnt necessarly mean oldrisky is scum. he could havge busdriven absolutly nothing last night aswell.

NO! you don't get it!

If Victor is scum then Oldrisky is town.

If Oldrisky is scum then Victor is town.

Out of the two I'd prefer to lynch the one that seems scummier and isn't a cop.

However none of this applies if a town roleblocker comes forward.

OH

Now I understand. Sadly, I can't help our situation at all

[colton24]

Vote Count
oldrisky44(2)L-3-Victor Sullivan, aage
AceArtemis(1)-???
duday53(1)-oldrisky44
Victor Sullivan(1)-AceArtemis

Not Voting: cena-rules, spiesr, freezie, duday53, Fircoal

With 9 alive it take 5 to lynch

[Victor Sullivan]

I kinda agree with oldrisky there: if victor is scum and lied, that doesnt necessarly mean oldrisky is scum. he could havge busdriven absolutly nothing last night aswell.

NO! you don't get it!

If Victor is scum then Oldrisky is town.

If Oldrisky is scum then Victor is town.

Out of the two I'd prefer to lynch the one that seems scummier and isn't a cop.

However none of this applies if a town roleblocker comes forward.

I don't understand. Couldn't we potentially both be town?

[Fircoal]

I kinda agree with oldrisky there: if victor is scum and lied, that doesnt necessarly mean oldrisky is scum. he could havge busdriven absolutly nothing last night aswell.

NO! you don't get it!

If Victor is scum then Oldrisky is town.

If Oldrisky is scum then Victor is town.

Out of the two I'd prefer to lynch the one that seems scummier and isn't a cop.

However none of this applies if a town roleblocker comes forward.

I don't understand. Couldn't we potentially both be town?

Only if there is a town roleblocker.

[aage]

Fircoal is completely right.

If there is a town roleblocker he may have targeted Cena and was busdriven to Victor.

If there is a scum roleblocker he UNDOUBTEDLY targeted Victor (since vic claimed cop) and should have been busdriven to Cena... but that didn't happen. So in that case Oldrisky would be lying about being a busdriver. We should lynch Oldrisky.

If there is no roleblocker at all, Victor is lying about being blocked.


In either case, roleblocker, please step up.
No, it's not me.

[oldrisky44]

Thanks aage, that makes me feel good. If nobody steps up and I am revealed to have been telling the truth then the town will be better off knowing victor has to be lying. That would make me a martyr for the cause of truth. I can live(or die) with that.

[aage]

Thanks aage, that makes me feel good. If nobody steps up and I am revealed to have been telling the truth then the town will be better off knowing victor has to be lying. That would make me a martyr for the cause of truth. I can live(or die) with that.

In this case I'd tell one of my scum buddies to come out and claim roleblocker

[oldrisky44]

You just hate me don't you.

[aage]

No. It's just logics. Either you or victor is lying, or there's a roleblocker. If the roleblocker cares about the lives of you and Victor, and I'm sure he will, he'll claim. If not, either you or Victor is scum, and it's best to not kill the guy that claimed cop first, in case we're wrong and he actually is the cop.

[oldrisky44]

ok, once again, I have to agree with your logic. A few questions...

1. Is there any other (not previously mentioned) way to verify victor?
2. Since I can't quote coltons PM with my assignment, can I quote my PM to him?
3. What if I provided my password and you could check my outbox? Is that legal?

[oldrisky44]

One more question...

Why isn't anybody FOSing ace for his vote on victor?

[oldrisky44]

Vote Count
oldrisky44(2)L-3-Victor Sullivan, aage
AceArtemis(1)-???
duday53(1)-oldrisky44
Victor Sullivan(1)-AceArtemis

Not Voting: cena-rules, spiesr, freezie, duday53, Fircoal

With 9 alive it take 5 to lynch

This should have went with my previous post.

[colton24]

ok, once again, I have to agree with your logic. A few questions...

1. Is there any other (not previously mentioned) way to verify victor?Not really
2. Since I can't quote coltons PM with my assignment, can I quote my PM to him?Absolutly not unless you're looking to be blacklisted
3. What if I provided my password and you could check my outbox? Is that legal?No. Not only would that be total violation of all rules in mafia, but you'd be busted for account sharing

Vote Count
oldrisky44(3)L-2-Victor Sullivan, aage, ???
duday53(1)-oldrisky44
Victor Sullivan(1)-AceArtemis

Not Voting: cena-rules, spiesr, freezie, duday53, Fircoal

With 9 alive it take 5 to lynch

oldrisky44 is at L-2

[AceArtemis]

I agree with the logic that we should lynch oldrisky. If there is no claimed roleblocker, the only way Vic and oldrisky can both be town is to have a mafia roleblocker that blocked cena last night.

Unvote, Vote: oldrisky

[oldrisky44]

Nice dodge ace. My offer still stands.

[oldrisky44]

Never mind I just notice colton shot my offer down in flames.

Well if I have no tangible way to prove my claim and apparently the blocker is scum, lynch me and see. Then vic will be next.

[spiesr]

Is there anyone who hasn't posted since the call for the roleblocker to reveal himself went out?

[Victor Sullivan]

unvote for now. I don't want anyone to get trigger happy before we get all the info we can. I don't see why it'd be so hard to believe that a scum roleblocker would target cena. How is it that I'd be the liar if oldrisky is what he says? Fircoal or whoever came up with the argument could just as easily be lying. oldrisky could be lying about who he busdrove, even if he is a town busdriver. I don't see how one can trump another. It'd be foolish to lynch a witness with scum still on the loose.