Quentin Tarantino Mafia Night 3 (Mafia Win!)

[TA1LGUNN3R]

unvote vote mandy

-TG

[karelpietertje]

Vote count?

[edocsil]

I think it is about 4 for mandy, but the mod has to look over the last ~ 8 pages might take a bit

[lalaland]

and how many to lynch?

[aage]

13 alive... i'd say 7 to lynch.

[ga7]

Despite repeated advice you guys want to go for the lynch of a guy that just happens to always have more illogical gameplay and that claimed, well at this point I say go ahead and do your noob thing, I'm pretty sure it will prove you wrong, I seriously hope there's some scum on this wagon as else it will mean we got a piss poor town. Wake me up at day 2...

[karelpietertje]

mandy, claim please.

[nagerous]

Despite repeated advice you guys want to go for the lynch of a guy that just happens to always have more illogical gameplay and that claimed, well at this point I say go ahead and do your noob thing, I'm pretty sure it will prove you wrong, I seriously hope there's some scum on this wagon as else it will mean we got a piss poor town. Wake me up at day 2...

Hear hear.

Safariguy5, can we have a vote count please.

[spurgistan]

mandy, claim please.

... lol.

[Fircoal]

Despite repeated advice you guys want to go for the lynch of a guy that just happens to always have more illogical gameplay and that claimed, well at this point I say go ahead and do your noob thing, I'm pretty sure it will prove you wrong, I seriously hope there's some scum on this wagon as else it will mean we got a piss poor town. Wake me up at day 2...

Hear hear.

QFT

[mandalorian2298]

Vote Mandy.

A few reasons.
1.He is try to lynch many different people, mainly for illogical reasons.
2. Mr. White sounds like no friend of the town
3. His reasoning for claiming was poor, I suspect it is either A: Lies. B: Half-Truth

This game has to get moving. If the others who are not posting don't get involved this game will slowly die.

So you suspect that I:

1. Am playing Mafia.
2. Have a role based on a character from a Tarantino movie and
3. Am either saying truth or lies. (You are wrong about that, btw. My role says that I'm Mr. White only while I'm falsly claiming to be Mr. White ).

Edocsil for your post to be any more general, you would have to be a gipsy women claiming that she is channeling the spirit of my dead grandmother and offering to predict that in the near future "Luck will stay to my house". On the other hand, for your post to be more absurd it would have to sound like this:

Or it could just be a fakeclaim?

Yes AoG, I fake-claimed a criminal to hide the fact that my character is some other criminal. But I guess fooling you is a task that only you can achieve.

Anyhow, I don't really care about surviving, so just be so kind as to lynch Aage and PMC after you have lynched me and the chances of you finding the last scumster before he kills you all are pretty good.

[karelpietertje]

vote mandy

[Fircoal]

vote mandy

Do you have a reason for that stupidity? Or are you really trying to be as scummy/stupid as possible?

[karelpietertje]

vote mandy

Do you have a reason for that stupidity? Or are you really trying to be as scummy/stupid as possible?

Keep up Fircoal.
I told him to claim, and he won't.

Don't tell me his last post actually convinced you

[Fircoal]

vote mandy

Do you have a reason for that stupidity? Or are you really trying to be as scummy/stupid as possible?

Keep up Fircoal.
I told him to claim, and he won't.

Don't tell me his last post actually convinced you

why do you want him to claim?

And I'll tell you this, I don't believe that Mandy is scum and I've never believed that, and I've said that, so YOU keep up.

[aage]

Vote Mandy.

A few reasons.
1.He is try to lynch many different people, mainly for illogical reasons.
2. Mr. White sounds like no friend of the town
3. His reasoning for claiming was poor, I suspect it is either A: Lies. B: Half-Truth

This game has to get moving. If the others who are not posting don't get involved this game will slowly die.

So you suspect that I:

1. Am playing Mafia.
2. Have a role based on a character from a Tarantino movie and
3. Am either saying truth or lies. (You are wrong about that, btw. My role says that I'm Mr. White only while I'm falsly claiming to be Mr. White ).

When, if ever, will you read what people write instead of what you would like to read?

Seriously, if this were any other player than Mandy, he'd be dead by now, right?

[edocsil]

vote mandy

Do you have a reason for that stupidity? Or are you really trying to be as scummy/stupid as possible?

Fircoal, he has got to be worse then sens when it comes to his posts being devoid of all rational logic. I understand he always acts like this, but he cannot be allowed to live with a scum claim and random lynching patterns like this.

[nagerous]

vote mandy

That's why my vote remains on you sir.

[mandalorian2298]

Vote Mandy.

A few reasons.
1.He is try to lynch many different people, mainly for illogical reasons.
2. Mr. White sounds like no friend of the town
3. His reasoning for claiming was poor, I suspect it is either A: Lies. B: Half-Truth

This game has to get moving. If the others who are not posting don't get involved this game will slowly die.

So you suspect that I:

1. Am playing Mafia.
2. Have a role based on a character from a Tarantino movie and
3. Am either saying truth or lies. (You are wrong about that, btw. My role says that I'm Mr. White only while I'm falsly claiming to be Mr. White ).

When, if ever, will you read what people write instead of what you would like to read?

Seriously, if this were any other player than Mandy, he'd be dead by now, right?

Actually, I'm reading what people write, but through my patented Bullshit CensorTM. In other words: click here.

[mandalorian2298]

vote mandy

Do you have a reason for that stupidity? Or are you really trying to be as scummy/stupid as possible?

Keep up Fircoal.
I told him to claim, and he won't.

Don't tell me his last post actually convinced you

If ignoring you makes a person scum, then all the townies would have to be pretty dumb and/or tolerant.

[edocsil]

Vote Mandy.

A few reasons.
1.He is try to lynch many different people, mainly for illogical reasons.
2. Mr. White sounds like no friend of the town
3. His reasoning for claiming was poor, I suspect it is either A: Lies. B: Half-Truth

This game has to get moving. If the others who are not posting don't get involved this game will slowly die.

So you suspect that I:

1. Am playing Mafia.
2. Have a role based on a character from a Tarantino movie and
3. Am either saying truth or lies. (You are wrong about that, btw. My role says that I'm Mr. White only while I'm falsly claiming to be Mr. White ).

When, if ever, will you read what people write instead of what you would like to read?

Seriously, if this were any other player than Mandy, he'd be dead by now, right?

Actually, I'm reading what people write, but through my patented Bullshit CensorTM. In other words: click here.

No you are twisting what I write and using strawman arguments to avoid my accusations. That is self evident if you compare my reasoning with your counter.

[mandalorian2298]

Vote Mandy.

A few reasons.
1.He is try to lynch many different people, mainly for illogical reasons.
2. Mr. White sounds like no friend of the town
3. His reasoning for claiming was poor, I suspect it is either A: Lies. B: Half-Truth

This game has to get moving. If the others who are not posting don't get involved this game will slowly die.

So you suspect that I:

1. Am playing Mafia.
2. Have a role based on a character from a Tarantino movie and
3. Am either saying truth or lies. (You are wrong about that, btw. My role says that I'm Mr. White only while I'm falsly claiming to be Mr. White ).

When, if ever, will you read what people write instead of what you would like to read?

Seriously, if this were any other player than Mandy, he'd be dead by now, right?

Actually, I'm reading what people write, but through my patented Bullshit CensorTM. In other words: click here.

No you are twisting what I write and using strawman arguments to avoid my accusations. That is self evident if you compare my reasoning with your counter.

Ok, Buttercup, I'll elaborate.

1.1.He is try to lynch many different people, mainly for illogical reasons. Have I tried to lynch "many different people"? Well, I tried to lynch pmc and Aage, plus I have been aboard for Violet bandwagon. My reasons: Violet voted No Lynch on Day 1. PMC seemed very overly supportive, from which I concluded that he might be Mr Orange, and since Mr Orange was an undercover cop, it seems to me that in this game he might be Mafia Spy. Are my evidence conclusive, no! Are they logical, yes. As for Aage, his general demeanor has been scummy and he posted many suspicious sounding things, which I quoted in my previous posts along with an explanation why I find them to be suspicious.

To conclude, the only one who could try to lynch somebody based on deductive logic is Safari. The rest of us must rely on induction and intution, because, with the exception of Mafia, we have no solid knowledge of who got Mafia roles. Thus, your first accusation roughly translates: He is playing a game of Mafia.

2. Mr. White sounds like no friend of the town. As I said before, only someone who hasn't seen any Tarantino movie would expect the Town in this game to comprise morally impecable Mormon-like saints. Given the average character in a Tarantino flick, I definitly see Mr White as one of the good(better) guys, since he has some sort of a moral compass and doesn't kill people for the fun of it.

3. His reasoning for claiming was poor, I suspect it is either A: Lies. B: Half-Truth. This senetance, especially considering that the accusation 2) implies that you beleive me to be Mr White, so completely stupid, that it would be impossible to respond to it without resorting to insults and I would never do that to you .

[aage]

Wait. You're saying it's stupid to believe you are Mr. White, which means you're not Mr. White, and that your reason to say Pmc is Mr. Orange is devoid of reason. Give us another reason not to lynch you now. You're talking crap, wtf?

[edocsil]

So you suspect that I:

1. Am playing Mafia.
2. Have a role based on a character from a Tarantino movie and
3. Am either saying truth or lies. (You are wrong about that, btw. My role says that I'm Mr. White only while I'm falsly claiming to be Mr. White ).

When, if ever, will you read what people write instead of what you would like to read?

Seriously, if this were any other player than Mandy, he'd be dead by now, right?

Actually, I'm reading what people write, but through my patented Bullshit CensorTM. In other words: click here.

No you are twisting what I write and using strawman arguments to avoid my accusations. That is self evident if you compare my reasoning with your counter.

Ok, Buttercup, I'll elaborate.

1.1.He is try to lynch many different people, mainly for illogical reasons. Have I tried to lynch "many different people"? Well, I tried to lynch pmc and Aage, plus I have been aboard for Violet bandwagon. My reasons: Violet voted No Lynch on Day 1. PMC seemed very overly supportive, from which I concluded that he might be Mr Orange, and since Mr Orange was an undercover cop, it seems to me that in this game he might be Mafia Spy. Are my evidence conclusive, no! Are they logical, yes. As for Aage, his general demeanor has been scummy and he posted many suspicious sounding things, which I quoted in my previous posts along with an explanation why I find them to be suspicious.

To conclude, the only one who could try to lynch somebody based on deductive logic is Safari. The rest of us must rely on induction and intuition, because, with the exception of Mafia, we have no solid knowledge of who got Mafia roles. Thus, your first accusation roughly translates: He is playing a game of Mafia.

2. Mr. White sounds like no friend of the town. As I said before, only someone who hasn't seen any Tarantino movie would expect the Town in this game to comprise morally impeccable Mormon-like saints. Given the average character in a Tarantino flick, I definitely see Mr White as one of the good(better) guys, since he has some sort of a moral compass and doesn't kill people for the fun of it.

3. His reasoning for claiming was poor, I suspect it is either A: Lies. B: Half-Truth. This senetance, especially considering that the accusation 2) implies that you beleive me to be Mr White, so completely stupid, that it would be impossible to respond to it without resorting to insults and I would never do that to you .

A logical, well thought out post. This is something where I can easily follow and comprehend your train of thought.
While I dislike your reasoning for my third point, I doubt I will get a better answer out of you.

Unvote

[ga7]

Well, at least we got some good info out of that Mandy wagon, it's hard to figure who's the scummiest on this, Karel trying to push for a claim when Mandy is answering the accusation, Aage obviously trying to confuse the town after Mandy's defense with a post that makes no sense, or Tail that just wagonned and laid low? Edoc is the only one that provided reason with his accusation, seriously...