[Complete] Society of Cooks Standard Invitational Tournament

[sziv]

5 man games

[emelar]

Hmmm? One other consideration: Perhaps one of the 5 man games could be by Shoop, moop, Krissan, Phil, and Patrickaa317 since they were all the winners of their game # 7778950 Just a thought

[oldrisky44]

LOL,

Two 5 man games

thx

[derivative133]

Removed.

[oldrisky44]

Thanks for the encouragement derivative, I expected to hear from you on this.

I will allow voting until 5am EST tomorrow then set the games in motion.

I want to be as fair as possible to all you guys.

[nesterdude]

two 5 man games

[oldrisky44]

Sent: Sat Nov 13, 2010 9:01 am
by caymanmew
2

[andyr601]

I vote for 2 5 man games
Thanks

[Industrial Helix]

5 man game.

[oldrisky44]

Sent: Sat Nov 13, 2010 11:06 am
From: el simondo
To: oldrisky44
still going with option 2
lol

[mpjh]

I vote option 2

[scoobyzx10r]

pick from the losers of round 1.

[kiwi3]

i guess two five man games.

[General Roy]

I go with 2 5 man games.

[Mad777]

I vote for option 2 (2 five players games)

[cy22]

I'll vote for random draw

[9trumpet9]

5 player games for me.

[moshu]

option 2: random from losers of round 1

[oldrisky44]

Sent: Sat Nov 13, 2010 12:58 pm
From: Preditor
To: oldrisky44
I'm assuming your drawing from the losers of the games involved? I wouldn't make it more complicated then it is. It's a 6 man game and should remain such.

Sergeant 1st Class Preditor

Posts: 32
Joined: Sat Feb 06, 2010 11:07 pm
Location: USA

* Private message

[longboreder]

5 man games

The tournament rules state:
"The winner of each game will advance to the next round, and the losers go home."

Losers go home seems straightforward. If a game winner drops out, why should the rest of the winners be at risk to lose the tournament to a player who lost the first round?

[oldrisky44]

Vote Tally

1. Two 5 man games = 11
2. Random draw = 7

[skeeta]

2 x 5's

[shis]

I vote for the 5-man games.

[Preditor]

5 man games

The tournament rules state:
"The winner of each game will advance to the next round, and the losers go home."

Losers go home seems straightforward. If a game winner drops out, why should the rest of the winners be at risk to lose the tournament to a player who lost the first round?

very good point!

[scoobyzx10r]

5 man games

The tournament rules state:
"The winner of each game will advance to the next round, and the losers go home."

Losers go home seems straightforward. If a game winner drops out, why should the rest of the winners be at risk to lose the tournament to a player who lost the first round?

very good point!

on the other hand,not knowing the reasons why the 2 players dropped out,why should a "6" player game be reduced to 5,it's not fair on the other players in the tournament.


i do like playiing devils advocate