COP MAFIA Day 3. Victor stabbed

[aage]

Heh, I just realized there's nothing you can gain from the night results...

Scenario 1:
Tails is scum and everything he said about investigating so far is fake.
I'm the paranoid cop, everyone I investigated is guilty.
Haggis is the naive cop, everyone he investigated is innocent.
Victor is the sane cop, he got Haggis innocent.
Lalaland is the insane cop, she got Haggis guilty.

Scenario 2
I'm scum and have been lying all game.
Tails is the insane cop and got everyone but me as guilty.
Haggis is the naive cop.
Lalaland is the paranoid cop.
Victor is the sane cop.

Damn, lol. It does come down to you indeed

[TA1LGUNN3R]

I must applaud for Tails that he managed to kill precisely the two guys that could have busted him though.

Damn, lol. It does come down to you indeed

That's funny that's what I would say if I was scum.

You're a sneaky one aage.

I know your tricks, Dewey.

-Tails

[Haggis_McMutton]

f*ck it, I'm just going with gut instinct.

vote aage

[aage]

Good choice. Damn it. Good job, both. Suppose it's hard to win twice in a row as mafia

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Yay!! Thank you Haggis I am supremely thankful.

But really I wasn't so sure. I thought Haggis might side with the more experienced player, someone he knew more.

-Tails

[aage]

More experienced? Thanks for the compliment, but I really haven't played that much more games around here than you have, Tailgunner

[Haggis_McMutton]

Yay!! Thank you Haggis I am supremely thankful.

But really I wasn't so sure. I thought Haggis might side with the more experienced player, someone he knew more.

-Tails

The experience is actually why i didn't side with him.

I tried to have a half-trick in my explanation post. Hinted that i thought I'd die etc, when the obvious correct choice for scum was to kill Victor. If Victor lived, no matter what he got, we would have known who is scum.

I was hoping that if you're scum you might screw up. The fact that victor was killed was kind of weak circumstantial evidence of your innocence. That plus your post just before my explanation post made me suspect aage more. Eh, guess it worked out this time.

Fastposted: dunno about number of games, but from play style you do seem more experienced to me. Maybe it's just confidence or something

[aage]

I had all roles figured out last night, but it didn't help a thing. I was just praying to the supreme overbeing of the universe that Lalaland was the insane cop and not Tailgunner, and all for naught as it turns out lol.

Although, I have to ask, Tailgunner, if you were the paranoid cop and you would've gotten me guilty as well, what would you have said?
(personally I'd have lied like hell and said I were the insane cop just to be sure to have a lynch, but it's all wifom and everyone does different stuff...)


[edit]
Now that I come to think of it, Haggis, if the two of us hadn't posted before you would you also have said you were the naive cop? It must be interesting to watch what would happen if you'd also lie, but not vote, about Tails' alignment. It certainly would mess up everyone's senses

[Haggis_McMutton]

I had all roles figured out last night, but it didn't help a thing. I was just praying to the supreme overbeing of the universe that Lalaland was the insane cop and not Tailgunner, and all for naught as it turns out lol.

Although, I have to ask, Tailgunner, if you were the paranoid cop and you would've gotten me guilty as well, what would you have said?
(personally I'd have lied like hell and said I were the insane cop just to be sure to have a lynch, but it's all wifom and everyone does different stuff...)

Yeah, I didn't really put any weight on what any of you guys claimed today, pretty irrelevant.

I was toying with the idea of claiming to be sane and having got tails guilty but "forgetting" to actually vote him, just so i could gauge reactions, but decided that'd probably be useless too. Might have been funny though

[Haggis_McMutton]

Haha, wow. I only saw your edit after submitting

[aage]

I saw your comment after returning to the threadlist. lol

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Fastposted: dunno about number of games, but from play style you do seem more experienced to me. Maybe it's just confidence or something

This is a pretty apt description of me.

Although, I have to ask, Tailgunner, if you were the paranoid cop and you would've gotten me guilty as well, what would you have said?
(personally I'd have lied like hell and said I were the insane cop just to be sure to have a lynch, but it's all wifom and everyone does different stuff...)

I would've either done that, or I guess make a weak attempt at pointing out the fact that you jumped straight to my vote.

I was toying with the idea of claiming to be sane and having got tails guilty but "forgetting" to actually vote him, just so i could gauge reactions, but decided that'd probably be useless too. Might have been funny though

You're a devious kinda guy. I like it.

-Tails

[Victor Sullivan]

Yay, town! BUT I'M STILL DEAD

[Haggis_McMutton]

Yay, town! BUT I'M STILL DEAD

Hey, I know, lets maim Victor's corpse.
That's what he gets for for... wait, wrong game?

[Victor Sullivan]

Yay, town! BUT I'M STILL DEAD

Hey, I know, lets maim Victor's corpse.
That's what he gets for for... wait, wrong game?

[sensfan]

aage is mafia.
Congrats town!
Points will be awarded this weekend

Haggis - naive -- MVP!
Vic - Cop -- Killed N2
Tails - insane
Lala - paranoid -- killed N1
aage - mafia -- Lynched D3
.