Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-TOWN WINS

[Jace22]

Also, I know this was mentioned before as well. I don't see how uncle is a cpr doc

fastposted, not only that, but uncle has no medical training

[Jace22]

I would also vote for sully, however he is at L-1, so my vote won't count. Can someone unvote real quick?

[Commander9]

I would also vote for sully, however he is at L-1, so my vote won't count. Can someone unvote real quick?

Unvote.

Any last words, Sully? I'll wait for more post of his before I hammer.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

I don't think CPR doc literally means he's using cpr, Commander. It makes some sense because of his alcoholism and general incompetence. And I'm not sure you would misconstrue that.

-Tails

[Victor Sullivan]

However, the part where you've pointed out that CPR doctor shouldn't have been around back then is a very good point. Victor, any responses to this?

Commander, I already did:

My character's name is just "Uncle", I guess. I didn't really get a name... Never played Red Dead before, so I'm not familiar with the characters.

Basically, I think my guy is clumsy or incapable or something, because he basically said that "if someone's in need of your small knowledge of medicine, you can help them, but if they were okay in the first place, you'll probably screw up and kill them". Obviously those aren't the exact words from the PM (as that would be cheating), but I think my paraphrase covered it.

-Uncle Sully

My character, "Uncle", doesn't literally have those CPR paddles or whatever you want to call them. He's just a clumsy oaf, from what I can tell.

-Professor Oaf

A big LOL

[Commander9]

I don't think CPR doc literally means he's using cpr, Commander. It makes some sense because of his alcoholism and general incompetence. And I'm not sure you would misconstrue that.

-Tails

But then his role would say something else and he'd just give him abilities matching CPR doctor's. This is the reason I asked for the exact name of his role, but he didn't give that.

Fastposted: Yet again, no specific name.

[Victor Sullivan]

I don't think CPR doc literally means he's using cpr, Commander. It makes some sense because of his alcoholism and general incompetence. And I'm not sure you would misconstrue that.

-Tails

But then his role would say something else and he'd just give him abilities matching CPR doctor's. This is the reason I asked for the exact name of his role, but he didn't give that.

Fastposted: Yet again, no specific name.

Oh, I think I know what you mean now. He called the role Rookie Doc, I believe. Id have to check my role PM again to make sure, though. Gimme a minute.

[Commander9]

Oh, I think I know what you mean now. He called the role Rookie Doc, I believe. Id have to check my role PM again to make sure, though. Gimme a minute.

Let me guess - you lost your PM?

I've looked again and there was absolutely nothing with medicine and uncle. Not buying it, mate.

[Commander9]

And he went offline. Okay, I will hammer.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

unvote

Uncle continues to live with the Marston family for some time after John's return. Working at the ranch, Uncle can be seen assisting with blacksmithing and animal tending duties.

Animal husbandry often requires at least some knowledge of medicine, e.g. stitching up wounds, cleaning, etc etc, which really can be used on humans as well. I think Sully's claim is plausible.

Giving the role as CPR doc is just a role, and I don't think every mod would customize the name of the role to fit the period, otherwise there might be confusion. That's why it's known as a cpr doc in the first place. Kinda like how we have common names for animals and plants, but they all have scientific names.

Frankly I think you're pursuing this rather doggedly for such a minor detail.

vote Commander

-Tails

[Victor Sullivan]

Amateur Doctor was the name, sorry.

P.S. Elect Victor for mayor!
P.S.S. Not sure if I have a vote on someone, but unvote.

[Commander9]

So you will discard his dodgy behaviour, dodgy role and scummaring (especially when he already said that his role's name wasn't CPR Doc and he went to look for it and disappeared) and will vote me. Brilliant

[Victor Sullivan]

So you will discard his dodgy behaviour, dodgy role and scummaring (especially when he already said that his role's name wasn't CPR Doc and he went to look for it and disappeared) and will vote me. Brilliant

I never went offline... Just got sidetracked by the Foundry.

[Commander9]

Nevermind, now that I looked back to TG's posts, I think it all makes perfect sense for him to vote me.

I think that makes me L-2, right? With Commander that's a hammer if he votes, so...

I'm Nigel West Dickens, Town Politician. It is probably vital that I stay alive. If Commander is scum, then I can negate his double vote.

It's not like you try. You just complain over the deadness of the thread and that's it.

Sorry, I can't spin straw into gold. I'm just not that good. Would if I could.

-Tails

Just like back then your claim didn't make sense compared to your character's role, but I backed down because I was the only one.

Oh and I didn't steal anybody's vote last night. I figured that would be the best way to judge from people's posts who was scum.

-Tails

If you would have been truly-pro town, you would have taken that vote from someone, because you would have had more control. It's better to have the control yourself than in the hands off someone unconfirmed.

Unvote.

Now I'm strongly leaning towards voting TG after all.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

So you will discard his dodgy behaviour, dodgy role and scummaring (especially when he already said that his role's name wasn't CPR Doc and he went to look for it and disappeared) and will vote me. Brilliant

Well VS tends to act dodgy and scummarine in just about every game I've played with him. Hell he even told us in Briarsburg that there were two mafias. I think it's easy to paint him as scummy. You, on the other hand, are a different story.

-Tails

[Commander9]

Well VS tends to act dodgy and scummarine in just about every game I've played with him. Hell he even told us in Briarsburg that there were two mafias. I think it's easy to paint him as scummy. You, on the other hand, are a different story.

-Tails

How so? Care to explain?

[TA1LGUNN3R]

See this is what I'm talking about. Politician makes perfect sense. My character is a salesman, a con artist. The fact that of the claims presented thus far, yours is the only "saint" and perfect person leads me to believe you picked the best-looking one for a claim. The only reason I didn't vote for you earlier was because you claimed to have been masoned with edocsil, which made sense for with your reaction, but really that can be pulled off by any scum feigning concern for the town.

-Tails

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Well VS tends to act dodgy and scummarine in just about every game I've played with him. Hell he even told us in Briarsburg that there were two mafias. I think it's easy to paint him as scummy. You, on the other hand, are a different story.

-Tails

How so? Care to explain?

Well generally I think you're much more careful, and you bring better evidence to the table then "oh his role doesn't make sense because they didn't have cpr at the time."

-Tails

[Victor Sullivan]

I see the tables have turned, and with good reason. Tailgunner makes some good points, Commander, and your behavior isnt exactly normal, either. vote Commander (Sorry to interrupt your heated argument )

[Commander9]

See this is what I'm talking about. Politician makes perfect sense. My character is a salesman, a con artist. The fact that of the claims presented thus far, yours is the only "saint" and perfect person leads me to believe you picked the best-looking one for a claim. The only reason I didn't vote for you earlier was because you claimed to have been masoned with edocsil, which made sense for with your reaction, but really that can be pulled off by any scum feigning concern for the town.

-Tails

How is con artist and salesman connected to politician? (I've google 2 times now the word con-artist and nothing came up connected to politics).

Well, out of all characters that are still here, mine is the only major one - it would make no sense if Landon Ricketts wouldn't have been in the game. If I would have been scum, I would not have picked a major character - way too many chances for it to be ousted. It makes much more sense to pick a minor character, just like you did.

Well generally I think you're much more careful, and you bring better evidence to the table then "oh his role doesn't make sense because they didn't have cpr at the time."

-Tails

When it's LiLo day and there are no cops left with credible evidence, you have to go with you know. I've used enough of credible evidence and while both of you seem scummy, I see what you' have done here.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

A politician "buys" votes, or scams them from the people. It's a misanthropic view of what a politician is.

I've used enough of credible evidence and while both of you seem scummy, I see what you' have done here.

What? Do you think I'm scum, or Victor? There can be only one. (hehe repressing urge to post pic of the Highlander)

-Tails

[Victor Sullivan]

We cant both be scum, hotshot, OR CAN WE??? Lol...

[TA1LGUNN3R]

If you would have been truly-pro town, you would have taken that vote from someone, because you would have had more control. It's better to have the control yourself than in the hands off someone unconfirmed.

It's just as easy to validate what I did. I had no idea who is scum, and therefore am suspect of being swayed by any convincing argument. Then I would be an overpowered hammer who could've eliminated town unknowingly, while anyone with other perspectives would be powerless to prevent anything.

-Tails

[TA1LGUNN3R]

So when has that been? Edoc hasn't survived a single day.

Hmm, apparently you are right. I was almost completely sure that I've sent PM about that. Anyways, any comments about your own rule then?

Also I almost forgot about this. Could you elaborate more? You claimed to have protected edoc, but he didn't survive the first day, so who did you protect?

-Tails

[Commander9]

A politician "buys" votes, or scams them from the people. It's a misanthropic view of what a politician is.

What? Do you think I'm scum, or Victor? There can be only one. (hehe repressing urge to post pic of the Highlander)

-Tails

Hmm, I guess that does make sense, because politicians in reality do pretty much buy votes.

I don't know, both of you seem scummy - the only one I seem fairly certain about is Jace. I am leaning towards Victor, but you also had a fair share.

I thought that the main reason for your vote switch was that you considered myself a tougher opponent and that you knew I'd go for you tomorrow if we lynched Victor today. However, then I realized that if one of us dies and he isn't scum, night comes and another NK happens. There would only be 2 left and mafia automatically would win. With that in mind, now I think you went for me for the good of the town, because if you were scum and Victor wasn't, it would make no sense for you to switch when Victor was about to be lynched.

Thus, between you both, I still want to vote Victor.