UnMafia 3 (1/19) *OVAR* GO GO GO!!!

[nagerous]

Seems like the evidence against tails is piling up. We are in a lynch or lose situation here considering the amount of townies we've lost in total I would say there are 2 mafia here and 3 town, which surprises me that you've suggested there is only 1 scum remaining according to your town sensing (well I know I'm town..). I think it is pretty much an everyone should claim type situation, I don't like the idea of both edoc and strike attacking tails like they are right now it looks like they are trying to pin the lynch on him right now and have planned this and maybe their claims in the night phase.

[nagerous]

Ah wait, 3 scum and an SK have died. There probably is only the 1 scum left then.. I believe edoc's claim but it would be nice to see what everyone else can produce as defences.

[Skoffin]

Sorry for not being around lately, I'm not going to waste your time with my reasons.

I am also of the belief that there would only be 1 mafia left. I also think it might be worth having more claims out, but I'd like to know what others think of that idea. There are five of us left I think, two have claimed. Most of the suspicions seem to be on us three who have not claimed, at this stage of the game I don't see a disadvantage in getting that info out.

I would like to take a different approach in regards to casting suspicions, instead of focusing on one person I would like to came at it as if I am accusing each of you of being scum. I'll go back through the game and find any evidence I can on each of you and make a case, see what I turn up and how strong each one might be. Then based on which I find to be the best lead, then carry on with that one later on.
I'll get to doing that after dinner.

[strike wolf]

I'm usually not a big fan of mass claims but it is true that we are probably at that point in the game...I would agree this is possibly the last scum and there is some kind of day killer out there whether they are one and the same is another question...

[edocsil]

Claim time from all then!

[Skoffin]

Me first? Me first!

I am Skoffin the magical princess pony (Not a BP, just my role name), the happiest ray of sunshine in all the land. I will do anything to protect the good of the world. I even had the ability to stomp out evil with my hooves, however I have since lost those abilities.
*prances*
I haven't gotten around to re-reading yet, unfortunately. I'll get on that as soon as I can.

[Victor Sullivan]

Oh hey, I died. Tears and sadness...

[TA1LGUNN3R]

okely-dokely I suppose a mass claim is in order. Here goes:

I'm a "level 70 silleh pokemon", and as such, apparently don't always cooperate with just anybody. I'm not really sure what that means, maybe if I'm investigated or something? Also I guess I'm prone to "escaping" and becoming mafia if they are stronger and have the right badge or some such. I wanted to delay claiming as long as possible because I didn't want to become a target for recruiting, but if there's only one left, then I suppose it can't hurt now.

I am Skoffin the magical princess pony (Not a BP, just my role name), the happiest ray of sunshine in all the land. I will do anything to protect the good of the world. I even had the ability to stomp out evil with my hooves, however I have since lost those abilities.
*prances*

Are you the day-killer?

-Tails

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Oh hey, I died. Tears and sadness...

Oh and Victor you bastard, instead of making a new mafia, try finishing your "No Vanilla" game.

-Tails

[aage]

Oh hey, I died. Tears and sadness...

Oh and Victor you bastard, instead of making a new mafia, try finishing your "No Vanilla" game.

-Tails

+1

[edocsil]

okely-dokely I suppose a mass claim is in order. Here goes:

I'm a "level 70 silleh pokemon", and as such, apparently don't always cooperate with just anybody. I'm not really sure what that means, maybe if I'm investigated or something? Also I guess I'm prone to "escaping" and becoming mafia if they are stronger and have the right badge or some such. I wanted to delay claiming as long as possible because I didn't want to become a target for recruiting, but if there's only one left, then I suppose it can't hurt now.

I am Skoffin the magical princess pony (Not a BP, just my role name), the happiest ray of sunshine in all the land. I will do anything to protect the good of the world. I even had the ability to stomp out evil with my hooves, however I have since lost those abilities.
*prances*

Are you the day-killer?

-Tails

Yes, an answer to this and a claim from strike and we are good to go pick apart some claims

[Skoffin]

I am not a day killer, my powers only worked at night time.

I've skimmed part of the game, I'll admit that my abilities and findings at this juncture are unremarkable. Tails seemed to make a lot of fluff posts - which tend to be common amongst scum, edoc seemed non-committal on some issues while coming out to argue on other cases that had been brought up - potentially suspect as scum would want to lay low, but also need to look like they are working towards catching things, strike has been aggressively acting pro-town - could be town, could be another tricksy ga7 in the making.. argh, while I've simply not had much read on Naggy. He seemed to have disappeared for a bit and not much else about him came up. I did feel a scummy vibe from him, however I am having trouble finding the post I am thinking of - This could just be my memory fail though, I'll bring it back up if I do find it.
I'd like to see the final role claim before I try to establish a case.

[strike wolf]

sorry for the delay. I was on yesterday for a short while but didn't get a chance to post. Anyways, I am a pokemon researcher aka an inventor. I was given two potions (red and green] and two pokemon (pichu and mew) but I didn't know what they did. Night one I used pichu on edoc and got an investigation saying he was innocent. Night 2 I apparently roleblocked karel, I killed two night 3 and protected skoffin night 4.

[edocsil]

sorry for the delay. I was on yesterday for a short while but didn't get a chance to post. Anyways, I am a pokemon researcher aka an inventor. I was given two potions (red and green] and two pokemon (pichu and mew) but I didn't know what they did. Night one I used pichu on edoc and got an investigation saying he was innocent. Night 2 I apparently roleblocked karel, I killed two night 3 and protected skoffin night 4.

So you have nothing you can do now?

[strike wolf]

What are you talking about? A pokemon researcher always has an ace in the hole. Go magikarp. Yeah now use splash attack magikarp.

[Victor Sullivan]

What are you talking about? A pokemon researcher always has an ace in the hole. Go magikarp. Yeah now use splash attack magikarp.

Critical hit! Its super effective! edocsil fainted! Magikarp receives 1 EXP! Magikarp grew to level 2!

[edocsil]

What are you talking about? A pokemon researcher always has an ace in the hole. Go magikarp. Yeah now use splash attack magikarp.

WTF?

Sorry I don't get it, do you have a remain action or not?

[strike wolf]

Basically what I said is that I do not. I used them. Originally I was going to hold onto the last one for when I knew more about what was going on but when it was announced that we were also skipping day 4 I decided to go ahead and use it since I couldn't guarrantee I would survive the night.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

What are you talking about? A pokemon researcher always has an ace in the hole. Go magikarp. Yeah now use splash attack magikarp.

WTF?

Sorry I don't get it, do you have a remain action or not?

Did you never play pokemon edocsil?

-TG

[Fircoal]

Deadline at end of weekend.

[Skoffin]

Well this is going rather slower than I expected. I may as well come out with my actions thus far then.

Night one - No action (I was away at the time of the night phase, however I would not have done anything then anyway)
Night two - flores (oops)
night three - karel (not oops) and lost powers
night four - nothing

Note: There is a problem with BT's internet connections in my area, so there is limited time I can get here until it is resolved. It was supposed to be fixed 24 hours ago so I have no idea when it actually will be done. >_>

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Wait nagerous I'm kinda confused about your role. Ga7 said you kick (NK?) others who have an extra life, while others are unharmed. I'm not quite clear what that means. Also how it relates to why edoc and skoffin were unaffected.

Sorry I've haven't heard of this role before.

-Tails

[nagerous]

Wait nagerous I'm kinda confused about your role. Ga7 said you kick (NK?) others who have an extra life, while others are unharmed. I'm not quite clear what that means. Also how it relates to why edoc and skoffin were unaffected.

Sorry I've haven't heard of this role before.

-Tails

Anyone who has an extra life as in a super SK apparently. I was not aware/remembered this role before I got it but a simple forum search of kicker will give you all your answers.

[nagerous]

okely-dokely I suppose a mass claim is in order. Here goes:

I'm a "level 70 silleh pokemon", and as such, apparently don't always cooperate with just anybody. I'm not really sure what that means, maybe if I'm investigated or something? Also I guess I'm prone to "escaping" and becoming mafia if they are stronger and have the right badge or some such. I wanted to delay claiming as long as possible because I didn't want to become a target for recruiting, but if there's only one left, then I suppose it can't hurt now.

I am Skoffin the magical princess pony (Not a BP, just my role name), the happiest ray of sunshine in all the land. I will do anything to protect the good of the world. I even had the ability to stomp out evil with my hooves, however I have since lost those abilities.
*prances*

Are you the day-killer?

-Tails

Is it just me or does this claim seem contrived?

[strike wolf]

Well I was hoping to more thoroughly reread when I had the chance but with the impending deadline I'm speeding it up a bit:

Hmm, why the sudden jump on Flores. I don't see anything suspicious in her actions. It was a joke vote. Both me and sax seem to want that car.

Gosh, I can't believe i'm actually defending Flores for once

vote violet the scum. You're obviously trying to backtrack here.

-Tails

This happened in the middle of the could flores be feigning jester debate. No comment about anything relating to any opinions just a quick silly vote. Possible fluff for a scum trying to appear active?

I am SHOCKED and OUTRAGED that anyone could accuse me of being a jester, how could I ever be such a thing!

No no, the trooth is that I've not played in quite some time and thus am quite rusty, plus it is a Fircoal game and as such figured it'd be alright to act goofy for a short time near the start and to also hide just how rusty I've become. I'll save showing my true ineptitude for tomorrow.
(It also doesn't help that Fir has practically punished me with my role)

*Trots back to the corner*

A fairly big fluff post in the middle of a debate?

We'll have a girl's night out and discuss all our mafia woes.

Tsk tsk discussing mafia games outside of the game thread. You're getting scummier by the minute.

-Tails

Another fluff post from tails?

Huh, after what post? Tailgunner being silly just like half the players in here? Yeah ...

Even if that were the case, the case was getting serious enough to stop the sillehness.

Don't be ridiculous.

-Tails

And another...

Intersting theory against Iliad definitely worth an fos.

I'm not yielding on victor. Town don't risk hammering people if they don't believe the person to be scum and nothing about his vote showed he thought that. Being a fruit shouldn't continue through risking a lynch. Victor's been in enough mafia games that he should know it was risky voting that person was, so why risk it? I initially thought he was a jester trying to get himself lynched. That no longer seems to be the case.

Moreso he really didn't say much during the major discussions and bandwagons. He posted ocasionally but he never said much. So basically he was active but not saying much. Possibly trying to seem active without showing himself to be on anyone's side or ruffle too many feathers.

Copier itself..mevery role claim has been fairly convincing but it wouldn't be a huge surprise if there was a mafia copier in this game.

I agree with this. I know he's trying to just have some fun, but if it was any other mod, I think he would've hammered violet. So vote victor.

-Tails

This post itself wouldn't be that suspicious except for the timing. It came only a few posts after ga7 accused him of not contributing.

Well that makes things less confusing in the future...

-Tails

I guess I can't complain too much about fluff I did need to get my pillow restuffed.

So are we believing victor? It seems convenient to say "oh I was roleblocked" after his claim.

-Tails

Sounds a bit like a non-commital way of saying "hey I don't think we should trust this excuse maybe we should lynch him."

So are we believing victor? It seems convenient to say "oh I was roleblocked" after his claim.

-Tails

Convenient yes, but if you were a scum roleblocker who would you block? IDK what to do with him.

Hm point taken.

-Tails

Just continues to be non-commital.

I don't have time right now to finsih my reread so the rest I will summarize my opinion on later and hopefully I 'll find time for the rest before the deadline:

1. Skoffin: may be a bit non-commital at times but behavior seems more consistant with an assertive but cautious townie than scum and low amount of fluff.
2. Edoc: seemed flip floppy and noncommital at times but mostly appears town and investigation supports that (though possibly busdriven.
3. Nag: aggressive day 1 less noticeable day 2. Leaning towards him being town and has a likely role claim.
4. Tails often non-commital and a lot of fluff. Possible connection with mafia and a confusing possibly contrived role claim.

With the deadline coming up I'm going to go ahead and vote tails. Most suspicious and least believable role claim.