Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-TOWN WINS

[TA1LGUNN3R]

However, then I realized that if one of us dies and he isn't scum, night comes and another NK happens.

Presuming in this scenario you're town, there's still one more lynch. It's lights out.

-Tails

[Commander9]

We cant both be scum, hotshot, OR CAN WE??? Lol...

I think in the end it turns out that there's only one scum.

It's just as easy to validate what I did. I had no idea who is scum, and therefore am suspect of being swayed by any convincing argument. Then I would be an overpowered hammer who could've eliminated town unknowingly, while anyone with other perspectives would be powerless to prevent anything.

-Tails

Again, that kind of makes sense, but if I had such an ability, I definitely would have used it.

Also I almost forgot about this. Could you elaborate more? You claimed to have protected edoc, but he didn't survive the first day, so who did you protect?

-Tails

Since Edoc died @ Day 1, I think I probably mixed protecting him in another game.

As far as Night 1? No one. I didn't trust anyone and I didn't protect anyone.

[Commander9]

Presuming in this scenario you're town, there's still one more lynch. It's lights out.

-Tails

Then it goes against you, as now it would again make sense for you vote me out, as you know that if Victor would turn out to be town, I'd vote for you and not Jace. Thanks for reminding me about this.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Presuming in this scenario you're town, there's still one more lynch. It's lights out.

-Tails

Then it goes against you, as now it would again make sense for you vote me out, as you know that if Victor would turn out to be town, I'd vote for you and not Jace. Thanks for reminding me about this.

Same could be said for me. If you're lynched and town, then I know to go after Victor. I'm playing all the angles here.

Victor, if you want Commander lynched, you're gonna have to unvote him, and wait for Jace to vote for him. Jace can't cast the hammer. (Summing up for you because I know you've skimmed )

I look forward to seeing what happens after I get off work. Sorry but I have to leave for now.

@Jace-- You're the key here. Choose wisely.

-Tails

[Commander9]

Same could be said for me. If you're lynched and town, then I know to go after Victor. I'm playing all the angles here.

Victor, if you want Commander lynched, you're gonna have to unvote him, and wait for Jace to vote for him. Jace can't cast the hammer. (Summing up for you because I know you've skimmed )

I look forward to seeing what happens after I get off work. Sorry but I have to leave for now.

@Jace-- You're the key here. Choose wisely.

-Tails

Or then, if you are indeed scum or not pro-town, you could team up with Victor to bring down the only known townie, Jace. I am doing exactly the same thing and that's why I said that you're both scummy to me. It's just that Victor seems scummier, if you combine everything he had done through-out the game.

[Commander9]

Or then, if you are indeed scum or not pro-town, you could team up with Victor to bring down the only known townie, Jace. I am doing exactly the same thing and that's why I said that you're both scummy to me. It's just that Victor seems scummier, if you combine everything he had done through-out the game.

Actually, stupid me. If you're not pro-town and I'm out, of course you will oust Victor... and you will win because it's only you and a townie left.

[naxus]

Vote count 1-Aage
Vote Count 2
Com9(2)-Tails, victor

Vote count-Mayor
Victor(1)-Victor

4 alive 3 to lynch

[Commander9]

Vote count 1-Aage
Vote Count 2
Com9(2)-Tails, victor

Vote count-Mayor
Victor(1)-Victor

4 alive 3 to lynch

Naxus, if say, we lynched the scum, would the day end?

[naxus]

Vote count 1-Aage
Vote Count 2
Com9(2)-Tails, victor

Vote count-Mayor
Victor(1)-Victor

4 alive 3 to lynch

Naxus, if say, we lynched the scum, would the day end?

Com9, if say, you lynched scum, yes it would

[Commander9]

Vote Sully.

For the afro-mentioned reasons that have been discussed.

[Victor Sullivan]

unvote so Jace can vote him

I wont try to argue further, just dont see how I can change Commanders mind...

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Damnit we had some nice action going, and now we're stuck waiting on Jace. :X

-Tails

[Victor Sullivan]

Jace was online, too! Dammit...

[Jace22]

yeah, sorry, I've been analyzing the past couple of days, comparing all the roles we know of and that have been claimed and trying to figure out who is scum. I kinda have it narrowed down to either commander and sully. commander for a weak reason, his role fits the character too well. Everyone else's role took a fair bit of connect the dots to make sense, but commander's I could see right away. Sully on the other hand has been acting scummy and not really contributing much, but that is how he normally plays. If I had to choose, I'll vote sully for the fact that like I said, my reason for commander is a really weak one.

[naxus]

Vote count mayor
Sully(1)-Sully

Vote Count 1-Aage
Vote Count 2
Com9(1)-Tails
Victor(2)-Com9, jace

With 4 alive, three to lynch

Deadline set for Friday midnight(Mountain time)

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Fine f*ck it. vote Victor

Hopefully you don't have a trick up your sleeve, Commander.

-Tails

[Jace22]

well commander, just waiting for you to hammer now (just posting this so it is known that my prod was received)

[TA1LGUNN3R]

No he's lynched, just waiting for the scene.

-Tails

[Jace22]

oops , can't believe I skimmed

[Victor Sullivan]

Way to go, Jace. Way to f*cking go...to Walmart to get that T-shirt. WHAT THE F*CK WERE YOU THINKING??? Sure, you may save a few bucks by buying it at Walmart, but the quality sucks, look it's almost threadbare. Should've gone to Kohl's, Jace, should've gone to Kohl's...

[naxus]

With much rigamarole and Razzmatazz, the final five argued the day away. Aage put up a valiant defense but was overruled by his own family and sent to rot in a cell.

With Vengeance rich in his heart, Victor tried to turn the tables on the so called judges and get one of them thrown to the dogs. His tale was great but stubbornness prevailed as Victor was sentenced instead.

Prisoners led outside. Two short drops and sudden stops, it was found that

Aage(MAfia Godfather)-Dutch Van Der Linde
Victor Sullivan(Mafia PGO)-Bill Williamson had been lynched.

Town Wins.

[Commander9]

I knew it!

Nicely done Jace and TG - I'm glad you made the right choice of trusting me. I honestly have no idea why you, TG, said that I was scummy

[naxus]

Aage(Mafia GF)-Dutch-Lynched day 2
Victor(Mafia PGO)-Bill Williamson-Lynched day 2


Violet Replaced by Safariguy(Irish)-Third Party Bomb-Sacrificed self to kill Edoc Day 1

Edocsil(Town cop)-John Marston-Killed by Safari day 1
Stefunny85 replaced by Jace22(Town Priest)-Bonnie Mcfarlane
Commader9(Town bodygaurd)-Landon Ricketts
Haggis_Mcmutton(Hated Townie)-Edgar Ross-Mafia Kill Night 1
Ta1lgunn3r(Politician)-Nigel West Dickens

Day 1 Actions
Safari kills edoc

This was really supposed to be a vote heavy game. Tails if youd been elected mayor you could of had three votes and open kills the following day

Night one
Mafia Kill Haggis

[safariguy5]

So the reason I killed edoc was partly because I was pissed nobody believed me and partly due to the fact that I was 3rd party. If I was third party, didn't really matter which side won. I just felt I had to follow through on the threats and harm the hostage.

I guess you can't trust me with explosives...

[Commander9]

So the reason I killed edoc was partly because I was pissed nobody believed me and partly due to the fact that I was 3rd party. If I was third party, didn't really matter which side won. I just felt I had to follow through on the threats and harm the hostage.

I guess you can't trust me with explosives...

You have no idea how much that action annoyed me... For a short moment I wanted to do something really rash