Dexter mafia Game Over: Tailgunn3r wins.

[Anarkistsdream]

Anyone wanna jump in here and post?

[Commander9]

If anyone of you could assure me that according to the previous scenes none of the kills were done by Dexter until tonight, I think I would know who Dexter is.

[Anarkistsdream]

If anyone of you could assure me that according to the previous scenes none of the kills were done by Dexter until tonight, I think I would know who Dexter is.

Sorry, there was the one against the fat woman on Day 2 or 3.... It also used a needle.

Also, the sad part is, Dexter is pretty much a good guy.

[edocsil]

If anyone of you could assure me that according to the previous scenes none of the kills were done by Dexter until tonight, I think I would know who Dexter is.

Sorry, there was the one against the fat woman on Day 2 or 3.... It also used a needle.

Also, the sad part is, Dexter is pretty much a good guy.

D3, No needle. Dexter could have killed the one who just disappeared, but it is a lead worth perusing IMO.

[Commander9]

However, if I'd want to reveal that, I'd have to reveal my role, which would be a bad idea, unless I'd be sure. The only way this would work if Dexter indeed did not kill on Night 2 and Night 3.

[Anarkistsdream]

Seriously... We are just gonna have to bandwagon on someone or try to have the mod replace... Nobody is posting.

[Commander9]

Seriously... We are just gonna have to bandwagon on someone or try to have the mod replace... Nobody is posting.

Huh? What are you talking about?

[edocsil]

However, if I'd want to reveal that, I'd have to reveal my role, which would be a bad idea, unless I'd be sure. The only way this would work if Dexter indeed did not kill on Night 2 and Night 3.

If you are only a role blocker you may as well just say who you think it is. If there is any question as to if the person is actually a SK or not, you can always block them tonight, as there are no claimed roles alive the doc will likely protect you. If my assumption as to your role is wrong, well it is for you to decide what to to, but I think we need something to spark the conversation here.

[Anarkistsdream]

However, if I'd want to reveal that, I'd have to reveal my role, which would be a bad idea, unless I'd be sure. The only way this would work if Dexter indeed did not kill on Night 2 and Night 3.

If you are only a role blocker you may as well just say who you think it is. If there is any question as to if the person is actually a SK or not, you can always block them tonight, as there are no claimed roles alive the doc will likely protect you. If my assumption as to your role is wrong, well it is for you to decide what to to, but I think we need something to spark the conversation here.

Well said.

[Commander9]

Okay, I'll think about it. I also would like to hope that there will be more than just 3 SKs players participating in discussion.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Looks like Dexter has to kill, and a doc did things right. Waiting to hear the news with the Streaker thing.

Um the cop died? Also I'm not so sure Dex is gonna be town. You've said a couple of times that you think he's the one behind the disappearance (Drabod or ga7), so either:

A) Dex is a noob player who targeted blindly, which isn't likely with the roster of players left (except Streaker who has claimed gunsmith) or

B) He's a SK, regular style or some weird flavor.

@Streaker--

Are you a day investigator?

-Tails

[Streaker]

TG, I just WikiMafia'd Gunsmith. The most accurate description would be 'Flavour Cop'.
It is a Daypower, yes. I already stated what exactly I can do (I think?).

I'm trying to work out what to do with my role though

[strike wolf]

Seriously... We are just gonna have to bandwagon on someone or try to have the mod replace... Nobody is posting.

I'm looking for who's posted when and preparing to send out prods now.

[aage]

If anyone of you could assure me that according to the previous scenes none of the kills were done by Dexter until tonight, I think I would know who Dexter is.

Sorry, there was the one against the fat woman on Day 2 or 3.... It also used a needle.

Also, the sad part is, Dexter is pretty much a good guy.

This makes me think you're dexter covering yourself up.


I'd be interested in Commander's story too but I'll have to check how many grains of salt I'll need with it. I might have scewed up his attempts.

[Anarkistsdream]

If anyone of you could assure me that according to the previous scenes none of the kills were done by Dexter until tonight, I think I would know who Dexter is.

Sorry, there was the one against the fat woman on Day 2 or 3.... It also used a needle.

Also, the sad part is, Dexter is pretty much a good guy.

This makes me think you're dexter covering yourself up.


I'd be interested in Commander's story too but I'll have to check how many grains of salt I'll need with it. I might have scewed up his attempts.

I am Dexter... *shrug* And I'm town. So, if we want to get this party going, we should kill all scum.

[edocsil]

If anyone of you could assure me that according to the previous scenes none of the kills were done by Dexter until tonight, I think I would know who Dexter is.

Sorry, there was the one against the fat woman on Day 2 or 3.... It also used a needle.

Also, the sad part is, Dexter is pretty much a good guy.

This makes me think you're dexter covering yourself up.


I'd be interested in Commander's story too but I'll have to check how many grains of salt I'll need with it. I might have scewed up his attempts.

I am Dexter... *shrug* And I'm town. So, if we want to get this party going, we should kill all scum.

IMO I am inclined to believe you, it is kinda the whole point of the series that he is the good guy. I would however expect you to tell us your night actions.

[Anarkistsdream]

If anyone of you could assure me that according to the previous scenes none of the kills were done by Dexter until tonight, I think I would know who Dexter is.

Sorry, there was the one against the fat woman on Day 2 or 3.... It also used a needle.

Also, the sad part is, Dexter is pretty much a good guy.

This makes me think you're dexter covering yourself up.


I'd be interested in Commander's story too but I'll have to check how many grains of salt I'll need with it. I might have scewed up his attempts.

I am Dexter... *shrug* And I'm town. So, if we want to get this party going, we should kill all scum.

IMO I am inclined to believe you, it is kinda the whole point of the series that he is the good guy. I would however expect you to tell us your night actions.

Night 1 Edoc
2 Drabod
3 Targetman

So, my question for YOU, Mr. Edoc... Is how come you aren't dead?

[edocsil]

Interesting. I have a few ideas why it was blocked. When it failed were you given any hints as to why? Also why kill Target? Your actions do not seem to target those who were scum.

[Anarkistsdream]

Interesting. I have a few ideas why it was blocked. When it failed were you given any hints as to why? Also why kill Target? Your actions do not seem to target those who were scum.

Well, it is kind of a crap shoot, if you haven't noticed. Target had seemed scummy to me for several reasons, most of which, due to these long, drawn-out games, I can't remember...

Much easier to be a serial killer than a vigilante, which is technically what I am.

As for your question, no, I receive no indication of whether it worked or not or why until I see the Day scene like everyone else.

Like Mandy in Buffy, though, I have no problem with working with a few townies to figure out who should be put to the drill at night.

As for a few ideas as to why it was blocked on night 1, I'd love to hear them.

[edocsil]

Interesting. I have a few ideas why it was blocked. When it failed were you given any hints as to why? Also why kill Target? Your actions do not seem to target those who were scum.

Well, it is kind of a crap shoot, if you haven't noticed. Target had seemed scummy to me for several reasons, most of which, due to these long, drawn-out games, I can't remember...

Much easier to be a serial killer than a vigilante, which is technically what I am.

As for your question, no, I receive no indication of whether it worked or not or why until I see the Day scene like everyone else.

Like Mandy in Buffy, though, I have no problem with working with a few townies to figure out who should be put to the drill at night.

As for a few ideas as to why it was blocked on night 1, I'd love to hear them.

If you received no flavor info, I can only assume we had a lucky roleblock/doc.

IMO we have two psudo claimed roleblockers, Com9 and Aage. This on top of the roleblocker who died early on leaves me with a bad taste in my mouth. Com is less scummy then Aage IMO so I will Vote Aage. majority of the lynches and wagons have been fairly textbook lynches and there are few leads to be gained at all. Anark, when night comes I think you should kill Icedagger for inactivity.

[Anarkistsdream]

Sounds good.

[/]

I was just theorizing ice was a plausible last killer, after all we haven't seen any evidence of another killer, an inactive would be more probable than an extremely unlucky 3 day in a row scummy.
And the case is aage claims a cop busdriver? I suppose it would be good to get a name-claim to test the plausibility of this.
Especially seeing as on p17 how evasively he avoided a name claim despite role-claiming out of completely nowhere.
Vote aage
that's l-3 I believe

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Streaker I was curios about your role because I thought it odd that you happened to investigate the scene of target's death at night, but since you can investigate during the day that makes sense. I meant gunsmith as merely a role which has weapon-related info. They can tell what weapon was used, and if the item is found on someone, it's a good lead.

So Anark, you ARE a SK, who HAS to kill, correct? Target was the claimed cop. When I was SK in the Tarantino game, I had to send in a kill, even though I was drawing suspicion on myself.

I can only assume that while you may win with town, you still have to kill. This would fit with what little I've seen of Dexter. Otherwise why would you be targeting all these town roles? Maybe if you state who you're going to target tonight, the doc can protect them (if there is one, I have no idea).

I'm curious about edoc, too. But him having NK immune abilities may be rather important to town. In a game with SKs, I can see the mod adding a vital town role with some protection.

-Tails

[TA1LGUNN3R]

hm plus there was that kicker that aage mentioned. Almost forgot about that.

-Tails

[Commander9]

Just to clarify - I am not a roleblocker.