http://www.conquerclub.com/public.php?m ... tructions5
Instructions on ratings can be found under the above link.
A few experiance rules. The tag deadbeat is only appropriate for someone who actually misses 3 turns in a row.
The instructions state that a 3 star is average. many players will however take offense to a 3 star rating. After all we all find ourselves to be extraordinary players, so 3 stars is not going to cut it...
I suggest you rate them according to your own conciense, and remember. you can always withdraw a rating. Once a rating is withdrawn, you can only leave a rating if you have played that player again, and the game has not been archived yet.
I think that covers most of it, anything else?