Moderator: Community Team
) --- it's got SHIELDS!everywhere116 wrote:You da man! Well, not really, because we're colorful ponies, but you get the idea.
No, it's definitely a valid point as he's been minimally active and hasn't posted much of substance. I agree that a no lynch is bad, but wagonning a submariner so close to deadline is a double edged sword as he might not get in here to post or claim before deadline anyways. But edoc and Yoshi claiming roleblocker and jailkeeper is useful information as scum fakeclaims tend to unravel over time.shieldgenerator7 wrote:Yeah, maybe MeDeFe isn't the least inactive, but when I thought "inactivity" he came to mind, so I just posted his name. I'll be waiting for your case while I sit here looking scummy cause I'm too lazy to do it myself. (no I'll do one too when I find the time)
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
And if we have any investigative roles, they have a good idea of who to investigate.edocsil wrote:That's what it looked like. Bit of a waste, but at least we can start guns blazing tomorrow.
John Smith remains awesome.evilchaos wrote:John Smith deserves your ultimate respect. He is greater than any of us can ever hope to be.
I don't think MeDeFe is submarining any more than all of us. This game seems to be generally inactive, with not much real discussion. I'm going to make cases on everyone after this weekend, but I'm a bit busy now so it definitely won't be before the day is over.
) --- it's got SHIELDS!everywhere116 wrote:You da man! Well, not really, because we're colorful ponies, but you get the idea.
I'd pressure MeDeFe before Com9, I think Com9 has been active, but MeDeFe tends to be pretty sporadic in posting.shieldgenerator7 wrote:I just finished re-reading the thread, and I have some thoughts (actually I'm just going to post thoughts and no quotes)
snowvillage posted in purple even before the game started, so I doubt the color is part of his PR. And this is his first game, so I wonder whether his hippie attitude is really him or his PR. Either way, he is a great addition to the game.
It seems some roles have been exposed this game, and some speculation has occured, which led me to this setup guess:
1. mafia - MeDeFe? (???)
2. mafia - Com9? (???)
3. busdriver - snow (switched yoshi and edoc)
4. busdriver - saf (switched himself & MeDeFe)
5. busdriver - VS (lynched)
6. Mason - evilchaos (attempted recruit of yoshi, but instead got edoc)
7. roleblocker - edoc (blocked saf)
8. jailkeeper - yoshi (???)
9. ??? - shield (???)
So the only ones who haven't claimed are MeDeFe, Com9, and me.
So that leads me to believe that MeDeFe and Com9 are scum, based on this chart, and assuming that everyone has been truthful in their claims (and assuming yoshi is jailkeeper). Going back throught the thread, Com9 has been shamelessly bandwagoning and not posting much substance. Of course, he recently had exams, so that might be a good reason for it, but it seems they have since passed and he still has not posted much substance. So I will
Vote Com9
Also, edoc and evilchaos, if you can PM yoshi ask him what he did last night so we can have a bigger picture.
Now, I have some suspicions of saf. It does seem he is genuinely busdriver, but if he is mafia, and got roleblocked, it'd make sense that he didn't make a kill last night.
Also, the 9th one is me, and I am not ready to reveal my role or my night action, because it doesn't make sense so far with what we "know" (or think we know).
@MeDeFe & Com9, I think you two should claim. Both of you have been submarining and not posting much of any substance. And do you have PRs? If not, then it would make sense that you haven't been punished for not using them, and if you do, then it would make sense there was no kill last night if the punishment for forgetting your PR was loss of night action. That is, of course, assuming you're mafia.
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
unvote vote MeDeFesafariguy5 wrote:I'm willing to do it today, mainly because I sort of doubt we're going to get lucky and not have a NK again.
unvote vote MeDeFe
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
) --- it's got SHIELDS!everywhere116 wrote:You da man! Well, not really, because we're colorful ponies, but you get the idea.
True, although it does sort of depend on priority of night actions. It's the best logic we can come up with right now though, so worth a shot, especially considering shield's list.edocsil wrote:unvote vote MeDeFesafariguy5 wrote:I'm willing to do it today, mainly because I sort of doubt we're going to get lucky and not have a NK again.
unvote vote MeDeFe
If you swapped yourself with him and I blocked you there is a chance I blocked the nk.
I would laugh if this wouldn't be so sad: you are blaming others for posting lack of substance - have you looked at the mirror? You posted next to NOTHING of substance during the whole game and mostly just posted your jokes. I will not claim before you WHATEVER happens - that's my word. If you trying to manipulate other people, you should really look into how to do it rather than trying this BS. Your PR speculation is the biggest BS I've seen in a long time - why don't you trying rereading what others are posting for once and then spewing such posts? Perhaps you would care to remember that it was me who at the started of the day pointed out that while almost everyone had PR's, Safari didn't - but of course, you're too much of a pro-town hero to remember thatshieldgenerator7 wrote:I just finished re-reading the thread, and I have some thoughts (actually I'm just going to post thoughts and no quotes)
snowvillage posted in purple even before the game started, so I doubt the color is part of his PR. And this is his first game, so I wonder whether his hippie attitude is really him or his PR. Either way, he is a great addition to the game.
It seems some roles have been exposed this game, and some speculation has occured, which led me to this setup guess:
1. mafia - MeDeFe? (???)
2. mafia - Com9? (???)
3. busdriver - snow (switched yoshi and edoc)
4. busdriver - saf (switched himself & MeDeFe)
5. busdriver - VS (lynched)
6. Mason - evilchaos (attempted recruit of yoshi, but instead got edoc)
7. roleblocker - edoc (blocked saf)
8. jailkeeper - yoshi (???)
9. ??? - shield (???)
So the only ones who haven't claimed are MeDeFe, Com9, and me.
So that leads me to believe that MeDeFe and Com9 are scum, based on this chart, and assuming that everyone has been truthful in their claims (and assuming yoshi is jailkeeper). Going back throught the thread, Com9 has been shamelessly bandwagoning and not posting much substance. Of course, he recently had exams, so that might be a good reason for it, but it seems they have since passed and he still has not posted much substance. So I will
Vote Com9
Also, edoc and evilchaos, if you can PM yoshi ask him what he did last night so we can have a bigger picture.
Now, I have some suspicions of saf. It does seem he is genuinely busdriver, but if he is mafia, and got roleblocked, it'd make sense that he didn't make a kill last night.
Also, the 9th one is me, and I am not ready to reveal my role or my night action, because it doesn't make sense so far with what we "know" (or think we know).
@MeDeFe & Com9, I think you two should claim. Both of you have been submarining and not posting much of any substance. And do you have PRs? If not, then it would make sense that you haven't been punished for not using them, and if you do, then it would make sense there was no kill last night if the punishment for forgetting your PR was loss of night action. That is, of course, assuming you're mafia.
This would definitely make sense - and it's as good idea as any to test. Unvote. Vote MeDeFe. (That's L-1)safariguy5 wrote:True, although it does sort of depend on priority of night actions. It's the best logic we can come up with right now though, so worth a shot, especially considering shield's list.edocsil wrote:unvote vote MeDeFe
If you swapped yourself with him and I blocked you there is a chance I blocked the nk.
) --- it's got SHIELDS!everywhere116 wrote:You da man! Well, not really, because we're colorful ponies, but you get the idea.
No, that's pretty much his play style.shieldgenerator7 wrote:Nice defense, Com9. I assume the built-in emotion was due to a PR and not your actual play style. BTW, I did more than PR speculation. Nice to see trying to contribute.
Ok, MeDeFe, your time to claim. Tell us who you are, or we'll lynch you. (although we might just do it anyway)
Oh, ok. Sorry, Com9. I was just watching Chris Nolan Mafia and you said there you try to take things objectively, so I guessed you weren't trying to put any emotion in that post I quoted, but it seemed like you did to me.safariguy5 wrote:No, that's pretty much his play style.shieldgenerator7 wrote:Nice defense, Com9. I assume the built-in emotion was due to a PR and not your actual play style. BTW, I did more than PR speculation. Nice to see trying to contribute.
Ok, MeDeFe, your time to claim. Tell us who you are, or we'll lynch you. (although we might just do it anyway)
) --- it's got SHIELDS!everywhere116 wrote:You da man! Well, not really, because we're colorful ponies, but you get the idea.
saxitoxin wrote:Your position is more complex than the federal tax code. As soon as I think I understand it, I find another index of cross-references, exceptions and amendments I have to apply.
Timminz wrote:Yo mama is so classless, she could be a Marxist utopia.
Well, the only way my case is "mindless fluff" is if someone lied when claiming their role, such as saf or snow with busdriver or with evil, edoc, and yoshi. I do have my suspicions about the truthfulness of some of these claims, but if they're all truthful then it points to you and Com9 as being Mafia. And you didn't put up much of a defense, though it was a good try. And you didn't claim either, and yet you're at L-1 (that is if you haven't already been lynched). So what's up with that MeDeFe? I think it's because you're Mafia. And pushing for the deadline to get here is even more scummy.MeDeFe wrote:This is such bullshit. I can understand bandwagoning me for not posting, but shieldgen, your "case" against me and commander... you deserve to be lynched for trying to drown everyone in mindless fluff.
And how come noone's pressured the GM? I thought there was some kind of deadline, what happened to that? I figured the day could end any time during the weekend, "Saturday the 3rd" or was it "Friday the 4th" so what use was posting with a deadline of potentially less than 24 hours? Can I have a votecount?
) --- it's got SHIELDS!everywhere116 wrote:You da man! Well, not really, because we're colorful ponies, but you get the idea.
