Re: Merlin C9 Game Over Mafia Win

[Conzocool]

Oh, bringeth it on!

[edocsil]

Vote Victor, Speedwagon gogogo!!

[wildwilliam]

Vote Victor, Speedwagon gogogo!!

didn't you already vote him on the previous page?

unvote vote edocsil

[DoomYoshi]

Hmmm.... Unvote vote Usair for lurking.

[usAir]

Hmmm.... Unvote vote Usair for lurking.

still here, just don't have much to go on.

FOS DoomYoshi

[wildwilliam]

Hmmm.... Unvote vote Usair for lurking.

still here, just don't have much to go on.

FOS DoomYoshi

FOS'ing someone because they called you out for lack of participation?

unvote vote usAir

[chapcrap]

Put me down as a reserve.

[usAir]

methinks that we've just left the jokevote stage.

Unvote Vote wildwilliam for changing his vote twice in the past 4 posts.

[Victor Sullivan]

Havest we?

-Sully

[Conzocool]

I dost agree. Wildwilliam dost not soundeth quite jokey... -eth?

I'll hold off for now, but I'm wondering about his tone.

[Victor Sullivan]

May the gods declare,
The scum is usAir!

Unvote vote usAir

-Sully

[DoomYoshi]

Hmmm.... Unvote vote Usair for lurking.

still here, just don't have much to go on.

FOS DoomYoshi

FOS'ing someone because they called you out for lack of participation?

unvote vote usAir

It's not like he had terrible participation, but at least he didn't vote me.

Sully, what is the basis if your vote?

[Victor Sullivan]

The young chap seemeth eager to lyncheth! Methinks scum, good sah!

-Sully

[usAir]

The young chap seemeth eager to lyncheth! Methinks scum, good sah!

-Sully

Twas but in good fun!

I also do believe I voted to hang you about a week before anyone got their role PM's.

[wildwilliam]

Hmmm.... Unvote vote Usair for lurking.

still here, just don't have much to go on.

FOS DoomYoshi

FOS'ing someone because they called you out for lack of participation?

unvote vote usAir

It's not like he had terrible participation, but at least he didn't vote me.

Sully, what is the basis if your vote?

My vote from evening past and statement tired and true was yet meant to try a ruffle some scum feathers and gauge reaction. Hence, I was nay surprised when the thwart of an OMGUS vote came billowing down. So until further inspection or change of discourse, my vote shall sit.

[jonty125]

Vote Count

edocsil (0) -
Conzocool (0) -
usAir (3) - DoomYoshi, wildwilliam, Victor Sullivan
DoomYoshi (1) - shieldgenerator7
shieldgenerator7 (0) -
wildwilliam (1)- usAir
Victor Sullivan (2)- Conzocool, edocsil

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch

No deadline.

[Conzocool]

Vote Count

edocsil (0) -
Conzocool (0) -
usAir (3) - DoomYoshi, wildwilliam, Victor Sullivan
DoomYoshi (1) - shieldgenerator7
shieldgenerator7 (0) -
wildwilliam (1)- usAir
Victor Sullivan (2)- Conzocool, edocsil

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch

No deadline.

Whoa, L-1. Do you think this calls for a claim from usair?

[usAir]

If necessary, I will, however, I would prefer not to this early in the game. If you'd like me to, at least give me a chance to respond before lynching. I should be back on later today.

[Victor Sullivan]

If necessary, I will, however, I would prefer not to this early in the game. If you'd like me to, at least give me a chance to respond before lynching. I should be back on later today.

You've already soft-claimed. Might as well spill the beans. We now know you're either a doctor or a cop (as well as the mafia!), unless you're lying.

-Sully

[DoomYoshi]

No. We don't have a deadline. My vote was mostly in jest. unvote vote Victor. I sigh, because I know that C9 games are skewed towards more power roles. I vote you, because I fear that you may have given away valuable information to players who might not have otherwise caught it.

I mean specifically, that if the mafia are skimming (which is allegedly a scumtell) than they might not have caught the softclaim. By drawing attention it, you may have helped them.

[DoomYoshi]

I just realized that puts you at L-1. unvote.

[Conzocool]

Since my Sully vote was joking, unvote.

[jonty125]

Vote Count

edocsil (0) -
Conzocool (0) -
usAir (2) - wildwilliam, Victor Sullivan
DoomYoshi (1) - shieldgenerator7
shieldgenerator7 (0) -
wildwilliam (1)- usAir
Victor Sullivan (1)- edocsil

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch

Deadline 5th December

[wildwilliam]

No. We don't have a deadline. My vote was mostly in jest. unvote vote Victor. I sigh, because I know that C9 games are skewed towards more power roles. I vote you, because I fear that you may have given away valuable information to players who might not have otherwise caught it.

I mean specifically, that if the mafia are skimming (which is allegedly a scumtell) than they might not have caught the softclaim. By drawing attention it, you may have helped them.

There is so much wrong with this I do not know where to start.

How do you are already know that US is a power role? because he soft claimed? What if he is lying.......???? You are voting Victor based on an assumption, and a poor assumption at that. A vote on someone because they voted for you is wayyyyyyyyy more scummy than someone wanting someone who has acted scummy, and at L-1, to fully claim. Victor is right to demand a full claim, especially after someone who does something scummy soft claims. A full claim he can not hide if he is scum, he has to get lucky and hope that there is no counterclaim. A soft claim he can say "don't lynch me I am a pro town power role". This does nothing but give scum something to hide behind. Also if he claims and someone tries to speed lynch him, you have scum target right there.

then you vote victor, but take you vote off because it puts him at L-1? If you think he is scum, then put pressure on him, don;t try to start something then take pressure off. That to me is a scum move. Try to start a movement, but would rather hide in the crowd and not take the lead, those who have nothing to hide should not be ashamed to voice their opinion, and you seem to not want to do that.

unvote vote doomyoshi

the only reason I am going to remove my vote from US is the possibility he might be pro town, but if you come up scum, I guarantee he will as well.

[DoomYoshi]

No. We don't have a deadline. My vote was mostly in jest. unvote vote Victor. I sigh, because I know that C9 games are skewed towards more power roles. I vote you, because I fear that you may have given away valuable information to players who might not have otherwise caught it.

I mean specifically, that if the mafia are skimming (which is allegedly a scumtell) than they might not have caught the softclaim. By drawing attention it, you may have helped them.

There is so much wrong with this I do not know where to start.

How do you are already know that US is a power role?

Nobody does, it was just a guess/conclusion that both Victor and I jumped to.

because he soft claimed? What if he is lying.......???? You are voting Victor based on an assumption, and a poor assumption at that.

I was voting Victor to keep the game moving. It wasn't the greatest reason, a FOS would have sufficed. However, I don't usually use FOSs.

A vote on someone because they voted for you is wayyyyyyyyy more scummy than someone wanting someone who has acted scummy, and at L-1, to fully claim. Victor is right to demand a full claim, especially after someone who does something scummy soft claims. A full claim he can not hide if he is scum, he has to get lucky and hope that there is no counterclaim. A soft claim he can say "don't lynch me I am a pro town power role". This does nothing but give scum something to hide behind. Also if he claims and someone tries to speed lynch him, you have scum target right there.

I figured it was too early in the game to start talking about claiming. This game is moving a lot faster than I am used to. Part of that is probably because this is the smallest game I have ever played in.

then you vote victor, but take you vote off because it puts him at L-1? If you think he is scum, then put pressure on him, don;t try to start something then take pressure off. That to me is a scum move. Try to start a movement, but would rather hide in the crowd and not take the lead, those who have nothing to hide should not be ashamed to voice their opinion, and you seem to not want to do that.

unvote vote doomyoshi

the only reason I am going to remove my vote from US is the possibility he might be pro town, but if you come up scum, I guarantee he will as well.

In any case, we have some fresh evidence. Last night while I was waffling around voting Victor. I saw USair on the mafia forum. However, he did not claim even though he was asked to. This makes me think he has something to hide.

vote USair