M:tG Planeswalker mafia - Town wins!

[edocsil]

Iron has to be mod killed. That is not allowed.

[Iron Butterfly]

yup my bad...was to tired.

goof riddance actually

[sheepofdumb]

I claimed to counter claim Sully. Sorry I dragged you into this Iron. I'll admit I didn't think this one all the way through. Now, thanks in part to me, we've lost another townie. But not all is lost. My role will be confirmed where Sully has no proof.

[slowreactor]

Due to the nature of the action, I won't be able to post a proper scene, so:

Karn (Iron Butterfly, town bus driver) has been modkilled!

The day will continue.

[slowreactor]

Vote Count:

Victor Sullivan (2) - Iliad, sheepofdumb
Iliad (1) - wildwilliam
sheepofdumb (3) - pancakemix, shieldgenerator7, wildwilliam

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

[Victor Sullivan]

I think town is at a severe disadvantage now...

-Sully

[freezie]

Iron has to be mod killed. That is not allowed.

First of all:

Cast Reanimate Dead on: Sarkhan Vol


He doesn't read posts fully, doesn't read the rules fully...

Or am I wrong? Anyway, just a bad guy's oppinion here....

Alright alright, I get it:

I cast Disenchant at my own animate dead.

Now, back to the grave. Keep going.

[Victor Sullivan]

Iron has to be mod killed. That is not allowed.

First of all:

Cast Reanimate Dead on: Sarkhan Vol


He doesn't read posts fully, doesn't read the rules fully...

Or am I wrong? Anyway, just a bad guy's oppinion here....

Alright alright, I get it:

I cast Disenchant at my own animate dead.

Now, back to the grave. Keep going.

I hope you don't expect me to pay the mana for that...

-Sully

[pancakemix]

Iron has to be mod killed. That is not allowed.

First of all:

Cast Reanimate Dead on: Sarkhan Vol


He doesn't read posts fully, doesn't read the rules fully...

Or am I wrong? Anyway, just a bad guy's oppinion here....

Alright alright, I get it:

I cast Disenchant at my own animate dead.

Now, back to the grave. Keep going.

Counterspell. Now get out.

[freezie]

Iron has to be mod killed. That is not allowed.

First of all:

Cast Reanimate Dead on: Sarkhan Vol


He doesn't read posts fully, doesn't read the rules fully...

Or am I wrong? Anyway, just a bad guy's oppinion here....

Alright alright, I get it:

I cast Disenchant at my own animate dead.

Now, back to the grave. Keep going.

Counterspell. Now get out.

Flusterstorm.

I'd like to see your mana pool sir..

[slowreactor]

Iron has to be mod killed. That is not allowed.

First of all:

Cast Reanimate Dead on: Sarkhan Vol

/rant

I stopped reading after this line...

1) I'm a reanimator player so I'm gonna get picky on this. THAT IS NOT A CARD. It's either reanimate or animate dead.
2) Reanimating a planeswalker?

/endrant

[freezie]

Iron has to be mod killed. That is not allowed.

First of all:

Cast Reanimate Dead on: Sarkhan Vol

/rant

I stopped reading after this line...

1) I'm a reanimator player so I'm gonna get picky on this. THAT IS NOT A CARD. It's either reanimate or animate dead.
2) Reanimating a planeswalker?

/endrant

Animate dead..knew I had something wrong. Eh, I am a reanimator player too..Except I use corpse dance

[slowreactor]

Anyhow, just to make sure, you guys know the day is still on right?

[pancakemix]

Anyhow, just to make sure, you guys know the day is still on right?

Yes, yes, back on topic.

Can I point out that Tezzeret was in direct conflict with Karn (now proven town)?

[edocsil]

Anyhow, just to make sure, you guys know the day is still on right?

Yes, yes, back on topic.

Can I point out that Tezzeret was in direct conflict with Karn (now proven town)?

Very honestly, flavor analysis could be the only way to break a counterclaim like this.

[slowreactor]

Let's get this moving again guys.

[edocsil]

Alright lets take a look at this. This is a warning, my entire post is about to be metagaming.

I am Garruk Wildspeaker - Town Tracker and I am of the green mana type.

This reeks of fake claim. Here is why. My role PM does not discuss mana orientation, his does, and that is odd.

then there is this

Garruk Wildspeaker

A Human Planeswalker who uses Green Mana. (card: Garruk Wildspeaker)

Green mana is listed in the beginning of the description, if just a name was given as a fake, I could see this as a careless mistake.

Now all this being said Tezzeret is not a nice guy, go read up on him if you like. However flavor does put him into direct opposition of the Infinite Consortium, the bad guys here. I am going to go with Vote Victor, due to being (almost) counterclaimed, a suspicious claim and a bit of meta.

[Victor Sullivan]

Alright lets take a look at this. This is a warning, my entire post is about to be metagaming.

I am Garruk Wildspeaker - Town Tracker and I am of the green mana type.

This reeks of fake claim. Here is why. My role PM does not discuss mana orientation, his does, and that is odd.

then there is this

Garruk Wildspeaker

A Human Planeswalker who uses Green Mana. (card: Garruk Wildspeaker)

Green mana is listed in the beginning of the description, if just a name was given as a fake, I could see this as a careless mistake.

Now all this being said Tezzeret is not a nice guy, go read up on him if you like. However flavor does put him into direct opposition of the Infinite Consortium, the bad guys here. I am going to go with Vote Victor, due to being (almost) counterclaimed, a suspicious claim and a bit of meta.

Firstly, who's to say our mod didn't get that info from the same place? Secondly, the brief sentence or two in my role PM talks exclusively about how I'm a 'nature guy', so it would be ignoring the elephant in the room to not say I'm green mana-oriented. And if there's no mention of your mana color, perhaps your a white mana planeswalker?

-Sully

[jgordon1111]

took your advice edoc,read up on tezzeret he is in kind of a gray area,but is at odds with the consortium,Did anyone else's role description say what mana they used? you dont have to reply with what kind just yes or no on the description please

[pancakemix]

I am Garruk Wildspeaker - Town Tracker and I am of the green mana type.

This reeks of fake claim. Here is why. My role PM does not discuss mana orientation, his does, and that is odd.

Mine does discuss mana color.

[edocsil]

I am Garruk Wildspeaker - Town Tracker and I am of the green mana type.

This reeks of fake claim. Here is why. My role PM does not discuss mana orientation, his does, and that is odd.

Mine does discuss mana color.

Humh, discrepancies. Well that blows part of my case out of the water. Had to look it up just now to know I am Black.

[sheepofdumb]

I am Garruk Wildspeaker - Town Tracker and I am of the green mana type.

This reeks of fake claim. Here is why. My role PM does not discuss mana orientation, his does, and that is odd.

Mine does discuss mana color.

Humh, discrepancies. Well that blows part of my case out of the water. Had to look it up just now to know I am Black.

It says I'm blue.

[jgordon1111]

I thought you had something there myself edoc,back to square one,so we have 2 claims one possibly(most likely fake).so we come to who's role would be most legitimate and why.and which player so far has given out scum tells that actually point to them

[slowreactor]

Vote Count:

Victor Sullivan (3) - Iliad, sheepofdumb, edocsil
Iliad (1) - wildwilliam
sheepofdumb (3) - pancakemix, shieldgenerator7, wildwilliam

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Due to the lack of activity here, I will set the deadline for next Wednesday, Dec. 21 at 12:00AM EST (Midnight between Tuesday & Wednesday in US East). There will be no lynch if no one has reached the required number of votes.

[jgordon1111]

Thank reactor I thought everyone died and left me alone in the universe in this game