Soundman's First Mafia [End] Arsonist Wins!!

[codierose]

on page 9 shield said

Rodion's at L-1? Let's lynch him! VOTE RODION he's always scum anyways

but i cant see a record of this vote anyware

[soundman]

Vote Count:

Rodion -
Zimmah -
Mob Deadly -
Mr. Squirrel -
Codierose -
Chapcrap -
Crazymilkshake5 -
usAir - codierose, Mob - (L4)
thehippo8 -
TheGeneral2112 -

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline: Monday, Jan. 9th

If activity really picks up then I'm willing to extend the deadline.

[TheGeneral2112]

for the sake of sparking this game unvote vote usair

This.

Vote usair

[zimmah]

for the sake of sparking this game unvote vote usair

This.

Vote usair

this vote usair

[soundman]

Vote Count:

Rodion -
Zimmah -
Mob Deadly -
Mr. Squirrel -
Codierose -
Chapcrap -
Crazymilkshake5 -
usAir - codierose, Mob, General, Zimmah - (L2)
thehippo8 -
TheGeneral2112 -

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline: Monday, Jan. 9th

If activity really picks up then I'm willing to extend the deadline.

[MoB Deadly]

Can you prod USair so we can at least get a claim before the deadline?

[soundman]

Can you prod USair so we can at least get a claim before the deadline?

I sent him a prod on Wednesday. He was off the site for a few days and got back on this weekend multiple times per day and still hasn't opened it... He was on earlier and I was hoping he'd look at it but no luck. I think I'll have to replace him if you guys don't lynch him. Should I see if I can get a replacement and extend the deadline (again)?

[MoB Deadly]

I think so... we are struggling for activity as it is, inactives can only hurt us.

[thehippo8]

unvote, consider this an opportunity to have carbs with teeth .... happy holidays .... vote usair

[crazymilkshake5]

well he's screwed, haha right, back to the thread, this is mainly because my last post was on page 3 of my post thing so i needed a quick reference... and go ahead and take it out of my 3 posts.... fun stuff this thread is...

[soundman]

Vote Count:

Rodion -
Zimmah -
Mob Deadly -
Mr. Squirrel -
Codierose -
Chapcrap -
Crazymilkshake5 -
usAir - codierose, Mob, General, Zimmah, thehippo - (L1)
thehippo8 -
TheGeneral2112 -

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline: Friday, Jan. 13th

I'm looking for a replacement for usAir. I've pushed the deadline to Friday. Unless you guys just decide to lynch him anyway.

[codierose]

well he's screwed, haha right, back to the thread, this is mainly because my last post was on page 3 of my post thing so i needed a quick reference... and go ahead and take it out of my 3 posts.... fun stuff this thread is...

so you voting or not

[Rodion]

He said he can't vote because his vote was stolen, just like Squirrel's vote was stolen the previous day.

[Rodion]

Also, obviously I'm against lynching before I hear a claim.

[MoB Deadly]

Im just gonna unvote... I dont want scum to get an easy hammer (or a dumb/impatient townie)

[soundman]

Vote Count:

Rodion -
Zimmah -
Mob Deadly -
Mr. Squirrel -
Codierose -
Chapcrap -
Crazymilkshake5 -
usAir - codierose, General, Zimmah, thehippo - (L2)
thehippo8 -
TheGeneral2112 -

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline: Friday, Jan. 13th

[edocsil]

/in for replace

[codierose]

[soundman]

/in for replace

Awesome! Edocsil now replaces usAir.

[thehippo8]

Brilliant, thanks edoc ...unvote

[TheGeneral2112]

/in for replace

Sweet. You should probably begin by claiming, since we are kinda' about to lynch you.

[MoB Deadly]

/in for replace

Sweet. You should probably begin by claiming, since we are kinda' about to lynch you.

either that, or give us a better case to vote :-/

[edocsil]

either that, or give us a better case to vote :-/

Ok
Vote Mob

My thoughts:
Town group

thehippo8 ~ Townie
Zimmah ~ Townie
TheGeneral2112 ~ Townie

They know each other, I don't know how they managed to identify each other but they have. If it wasn't for that I would suggest a pursuit of them due to the doc lynch.

Rodion ~ I can never get a read on him, he has fooled me often enough for me to not pass judgment at this time. Has been helping town in my eyes.
Mr. Squirrel ~ He is absent ATM, not going to make a case, it would be ignored.
Codierose ~ New to the site and the game, no thoughts as of yet.
Crazymilkshake ~ Scummy target of mine, he hasn't helped out a lot but he is a noob. I don't believe wholeheartedly he is scum, but I wouldn't condemn anyone who vigged him.
Chapcrap ~ Second most likely to be scum in my opinion. He helped lynch a Doc. Shame on you.
Mob Deadly ~ You helped lynch a doc. You also have no excuse. I would be hard after one of those in the town group if they hadn't gotten that little ...whatever it is... going on.

I won't quote it all, but my reasons for voting him all come from page 24. Everyone's reasons for Lynching the town doc sucked, but some of the others were at least making their own cases. You just played follow the leader and helped hang the doc. He claimed, and you all had no reason to disbelieve him. TG was a noob and protected the wrong guy, oh well, he was a noob. Lets face it what are the odds of there NOT being a doc in a 14 man game? MoB saw an opportunity to get the doc hung with minimal apparent risk to himself and took it.

Now it is day 3 and you went with a wagon on the inactive. Surely you could have found a better case for a lynch? (this goes for all of you, The Gaze of Shame has been extended, now forever know as TGoS) Yes you unvoted to avoid a lynch, but this way you are able to develop a wagon and then walk a way from it leaving the blame for others.

So in short, I vote for MoB for being an overcautious scum who tried to hard to avoid all suspicion, and therefore has triggered my suspicions (God this sounds like WIFOM)

also @ General. USair left the site, I am not USair and I am not responsible for his absence. I will not claim because of this current case upon me.

[MoB Deadly]

either that, or give us a better case to vote :-/

Ok
Vote Mob

lol touché sir

That doc thing was reckless and I will definitely admit it... Let me tell you my train of thought because in my eyes SOMETHING clearly didn't add up. Working on a post now..

[MoB Deadly]

Argh I have less time than I thought, this is most of my defense, not as nice and clear cut as I wanted it, but at least it's something.

Okay first off... (I am going to go chronologically.)

I was the first vote on Victor. Yes it was a jokevote, but I always check the forums to see if I need to make a drastic unvote. I'm not always here to fully contribute and participate, but I continually skim the threads to see if anything groundbreaking occurs. If I was scum, would I let my Godfather bury himself? Would I also fuel his bandwagon? I understand this is all WIFOM, and I am not making it as the basis of my defense, but I feel it is notable.
This was December 6th, when VS was at L-4. I think that is a crucial moment where I have to pick a side, and I picked with the town.

EBWOP

Sorry I have been wrongfully neglecting this mafia. I will improve my game.

My vote on Sully is a joke vote, but I am not going to move it. After reading this argument between Victor and 2112, I feel like VS was picking on the new guy to get him claimed. I am not going to lie and say General did nothing scummy, but he's new to the mafia forum, and if anyone has read his posts outside of this forum, they seem to match this post-style. 2112 did ask victor for quoted evidence to what he said and VS hasn't provided it.

Again I am getting the vibes that VS was just "taking it for granted" that we were going to bandwagon pressure/lynch 2112 for his erratic posting style. This is just a hunch obviously, as we don't have much to go on Day 1.

NEXT: You say:

My thoughts:
Town group

thehippo8 ~ Townie
Zimmah ~ Townie
TheGeneral2112 ~ Townie

They know each other, I don't know how they managed to identify each other but they have. If it wasn't for that I would suggest a pursuit of them due to the doc lynch.

And I agree completely. As I said before Hippo was acting extremely scummy and I would be encouraging everyone to vote for him if it wasn't for zimmah. I am pretty sure I have 4-5+ posts attacking Hippo.

Vote Count:

Rodion -
Zimmah -
Mob Deadly -
Mr. Squirrel -
Shieldgenerator7 -
Chapcrap -
Crazymilkshake5 -
usAir -
TeeGee - maximum, General, Zimmah, Mob, CMS, Chapcrap, hippo - (Lynch)
thehippo8 -
maximumbandit - TeeGee - (L6)
TheGeneral2112 -

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

Instead I debated with everyone and followed max (which I will explain), General (on your townie list) and Zimmah (also on your townie list)

Who else am I supposed to follow, than the 1 confirmed townie and another whos partially confirmed? There wasn't even any other case brought to the table, except for TeeGees OMGUS on Max, and Hippo's practically random voting???

Max's case to start Day 2:
He brought up very valid points on VS defending TeeGee about that whole editing debacle. Why would VS need to defend him?

I voted for TeeGee for:
Getting defended by VS
For failing as a doc, and not even defending why he chose to heal hippo. If he came back and explained why he thought he should save hippo, or apologized for missing the watcher or SOMETHING he may not of been lynched. But he did NOTHING to defend himself.
I had the same thoughts as General and we both were convinced hippo and/or teegee had to be scum
Zimmah and Hippo who are on your townie list, also voted for him, so obviously they were convinced he was scum too.