Stool Pigeon Mafia - Game Over! Mafia Win!!! MVP- Zimmah

[thehippo8]

vote fox

should have never removed my vote.

Again with no explanation. And considering I'm the one that called attention to your actions (or lack thereof, I should say), this doesn't really help. As for your claim that you want to be lynched, if you did, why are you still voting? Why vote for someone else? Why not vote for youself? Is this a claim stated only because you wish to look less scummy than you do? If you claim that you want out and want to be lynched, do you expect us all to immediately think you're VT?

You've said you're frustrated (and I relate, I am too) but I don't think non-participation and unexplained votes will make the game easier for you. Or us, for that matter. I don't want to screw up the next lynch but bloody hell, man, you're looking awfully scummy the past 10 or 20 pages!

At the very least, an explanation will help.

Hey fox, this is a good question, but what of Zimmah's suggestion to take out Mob first on the basis that Mab is the SK? Something Mob hasn't denied. But then WW doesn't deny being scum either. I am happy whichever way we are to go but a decision needs to be made on a rational basis.

[VioIet]

Vote Count

zimmah (1)- MoB

MoB (3)- zimmah, Eldario, hippo

wildwilliam (2)- foxxie, chapcrap

foxxie (1)- william

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

[FoxMists]

vote fox

should have never removed my vote.

Again with no explanation. And considering I'm the one that called attention to your actions (or lack thereof, I should say), this doesn't really help. As for your claim that you want to be lynched, if you did, why are you still voting? Why vote for someone else? Why not vote for youself? Is this a claim stated only because you wish to look less scummy than you do? If you claim that you want out and want to be lynched, do you expect us all to immediately think you're VT?

You've said you're frustrated (and I relate, I am too) but I don't think non-participation and unexplained votes will make the game easier for you. Or us, for that matter. I don't want to screw up the next lynch but bloody hell, man, you're looking awfully scummy the past 10 or 20 pages!

At the very least, an explanation will help.

Hey fox, this is a good question, but what of Zimmah's suggestion to take out Mob first on the basis that Mab is the SK? Something Mob hasn't denied. But then WW doesn't deny being scum either. I am happy whichever way we are to go but a decision needs to be made on a rational basis.

I understand what you're saying. I agree that both look scummy. I'm not sure there is a rational way to decide who is SK and who isn't. I'm not even sure we CAN win this one. There's no bloody way to tell anything since we don't know any roles of those killed. If y'all feel like MoB is a stronger suspect, I'm willing to entertain that, but thus far I've not seen anything that makes him any more likely. Ugh, this feels like a dice toss. Apprpriate considering the website I suppose, ha!

If we screw up and MoB isn't scum... have we f'd our last chance? That's my fear. If y'all are determined, I don't think a stalemate will help us, so I'll join you on that basis alone, but I won't say I agree completely. I just don't have any better info to give and my suspect is uncooperative in the extreme.

[chapcrap]

Foxxie, I agree with you. It appears the consensus is MoB, so unvote vote MoB.

[wildwilliam]

unvote vote MoB

That's a hammer.

[wildwilliam]

I would like to point something out about players being replaced.

If player A gets killed and is allowed to come back, 2 out of 3 times they will be mafia. please look below:

if Player A is town: they could come back as Town or Mafia.
if Player A is Mafia: they could only come back as Mafia. If they came back as town, they would know all the mafia, and that would be dumb.

So Mafia twice and Town once, or something along those lines.

[MoB Deadly]

I did all I could.

[thehippo8]

I would like to point something out about players being replaced.

If player A gets killed and is allowed to come back, 2 out of 3 times they will be mafia. please look below:

if Player A is town: they could come back as Town or Mafia.
if Player A is Mafia: they could only come back as Mafia. If they came back as town, they would know all the mafia, and that would be dumb.

So Mafia twice and Town once, or something along those lines.

A couple of problems with that. Firstly we don't have any info of that kind. Secondly, Davidbates was replaced because he was non-responsive and mob has been there since the beginning.

[thehippo8]

I did all I could.

Really? Maybe a review would help? I'm not clear on what you think you did.

[wildwilliam]

A couple of problems with that. Firstly we don't have any info of that kind.

What does this even mean?

Secondly, Davidbates was replaced because he was non-responsive and mob has been there since the beginning.

Davidbates was not killed and allowed back in, so argument is invalid to the point I am making. I never said anything about MoB, MoB was also not killed and let back into the game, so once again, argument is invalid. please deposit $0.25 to continue playing.

Also, we should lynch anyone who is giving riddles. they are either Mafia or pigeon and since we will never know until the end of the game, and we have no idea who is who, it makes no sense to keep any of them alive.

Can the Mafia or serial killer please kill me tonight? Thanks. This game has 0 chance at being successful for the town especially since we have nothing to go on except riddles that may or may not be from town and the number of kills each night.

I am sure this game is fun in real life because there are many more tells you can get from reading peoples faces, but this is brutal to play online.

[thehippo8]

A couple of problems with that. Firstly we don't have any info of that kind.

What does this even mean?

No claims other than VT.

Secondly, Davidbates was replaced because he was non-responsive and mob has been there since the beginning.

Davidbates was not killed and allowed back in, so argument is invalid to the point I am making. I never said anything about MoB, MoB was also not killed and let back into the game, so once again, argument is invalid. please deposit $0.25 to continue playing.

Herewith a quarter. Shame the first page doesn't reflect all the ins and outs or the hokie-tokie!

Also, we should lynch anyone who is giving riddles. they are either Mafia or pigeon and since we will never know until the end of the game, and we have no idea who is who, it makes no sense to keep any of them alive.

Are you meaning Mob or something else?

Can the Mafia or serial killer please kill me tonight? Thanks. This game has 0 chance at being successful for the town especially since we have nothing to go on except riddles that may or may not be from town and the number of kills each night.

I am sure this game is fun in real life because there are many more tells you can get from reading peoples faces, but this is brutal to play online.

I agree, it is too weird. Maybe the game would work better with very strict time-lines?

[zimmah]

A couple of problems with that. Firstly we don't have any info of that kind.

What does this even mean?

Secondly, Davidbates was replaced because he was non-responsive and mob has been there since the beginning.

Davidbates was not killed and allowed back in, so argument is invalid to the point I am making. I never said anything about MoB, MoB was also not killed and let back into the game, so once again, argument is invalid. please deposit $0.25 to continue playing.

Also, we should lynch anyone who is giving riddles. they are either Mafia or pigeon and since we will never know until the end of the game, and we have no idea who is who, it makes no sense to keep any of them alive.

Can the Mafia or serial killer please kill me tonight? Thanks. This game has 0 chance at being successful for the town especially since we have nothing to go on except riddles that may or may not be from town and the number of kills each night.

I am sure this game is fun in real life because there are many more tells you can get from reading peoples faces, but this is brutal to play online.

lol so you're actualy suggesting that the only ones who can actually confirm a role of someone be killed just because they potentialy are mafia? are you even serious?

[wildwilliam]

A couple of problems with that. Firstly we don't have any info of that kind.

What does this even mean?

Secondly, Davidbates was replaced because he was non-responsive and mob has been there since the beginning.

Davidbates was not killed and allowed back in, so argument is invalid to the point I am making. I never said anything about MoB, MoB was also not killed and let back into the game, so once again, argument is invalid. please deposit $0.25 to continue playing.

Also, we should lynch anyone who is giving riddles. they are either Mafia or pigeon and since we will never know until the end of the game, and we have no idea who is who, it makes no sense to keep any of them alive.

Can the Mafia or serial killer please kill me tonight? Thanks. This game has 0 chance at being successful for the town especially since we have nothing to go on except riddles that may or may not be from town and the number of kills each night.

I am sure this game is fun in real life because there are many more tells you can get from reading peoples faces, but this is brutal to play online.

lol so you're actualy suggesting that the only ones who can actually confirm a role of someone be killed just because they potentialy are mafia? are you even serious?

and how do we know that these people are not mafia making up fake riddles to kill townies? If I remember you had a solid lynch yesterday. how did that work out again?

[zimmah]

never claimed it was a solid lynch, besides, without any info nothing will happen. do you suggest we just randomly lynch people blindly instead?

ye 'm sticking my neck out to get some people lynched that have an increased probability of being scum because they are not on my white-list, but that does't mean i should be lynched over any small mistake. especially because i'm one of the few that actually does seem to have a remote clue about what's going on and trying to lead the town out of the dark.

and any mistakes at this points are costly, that's why i try to make the least amount of mistakes possible, but unfortunately i'm not almighty nor all knowing.

and besides, you're one to speak. exactly how many people do NOT suspect you? in fact, if it wasn't for me, you'd probably be lynched by now, is this your way of showing your gratitude? or are you actually saying i'm wrong for not lynching you, and thereby declaring you're no good?

[wildwilliam]

a) you never answered my question.

never claimed it was a solid lynch, besides, without any info nothing will happen. do you suggest we just randomly lynch people blindly instead?

b) nope, I told you who we should lynch if you would read my posts instead of skimming them.

and besides, you're one to speak. exactly how many people do NOT suspect you? in fact, if it wasn't for me, you'd probably be lynched by now, is this your way of showing your gratitude? or are you actually saying i'm wrong for not lynching you, and thereby declaring you're no good?

c) you obviously have not been reading any of my posts. I have requested to be lynched and killed at night. So what you are saying is a complete lie.

****fixed.

[wildwilliam]

I think I edited my post. That was not my intention. I thought I hit quote. This was my previous post.

a) you never answered my question.

never claimed it was a solid lynch, besides, without any info nothing will happen. do you suggest we just randomly lynch people blindly instead?

b) nope, I told you who we should lynch if you would read my posts instead of skimming them.

and besides, you're one to speak. exactly how many people do NOT suspect you? in fact, if it wasn't for me, you'd probably be lynched by now, is this your way of showing your gratitude? or are you actually saying i'm wrong for not lynching you, and thereby declaring you're no good?

c) you obviously have not been reading any of my posts. I have requested to be lynched and killed at night. So what you are saying is a complete lie.

[VioIet]

Vote Count

zimmah (1)- MoB

MoB (5)- zimmah, Eldario, hippo, chap, william

wildwilliam (1)- foxxie,



MOB Deadly has been lynched.


It is now Night 5. Please send in your actions.

Night 5 Begin

[VioIet]

Eldario has been killed.

theHippo has been killed.


Day 6 Begin

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

[wildwilliam]

vote fox

this is all I am posting feel free to lynch.

[MoB Deadly]

Town fails so hard, SK is STILL alive

[Eldario]

a black day indeed

[thehippo8]

Seeing tripple!

Click image to enlarge.

[chapcrap]

vote fox

this is all I am posting feel free to lynch.

You and foxxie keep going at each other!! Back and forth.

I, for one, think it is you who are scummy. The only reason you weren't lynched yesterday is because zimmah thought that MoB was the SK. Which, he obviously wasn't. So, I will vote you today. unvote vote WW

[wildwilliam]

vote fox

this is all I am posting feel free to lynch.

You and foxxie keep going at each other!! Back and forth.

I, for one, think it is you who are scummy. The only reason you weren't lynched yesterday is because zimmah thought that MoB was the SK. Which, he obviously wasn't. So, I will vote you today. unvote vote WW

thank-you.

[VioIet]

Vote Count

wildwilliam (1)- chapcrap

foxxie (1)- william