H.E. Mafia, Game Over, Town Prevails. [archive plox]

[strike wolf]

Jak would be the easy vote being completely absent but I'm still trying to decide if i want to vote Ghostly again or not. It's funny how three of the main 4 people in this all seem at least a little scummy. More people are posting but I still feel like we need more fresh eyes on this day because at this point I feel I keep just flipping back and forth between two or more people. How is the replacement for PCM going?

Just a quick note: I posted this already (indirectly if nothing else) but Orr was not the tracker he was the Busdriver. Franklin Bluth was the tracker. Check the first page if you aren't sure.

[dazza2008]

I am leaving my vote on Ghostly for a few reasons.

1. He was going after the doc with no evidence at all he was not the doc.
2. Claimed at L-4. Why claim with not much pressure.
3. He seems to have a list from day 1 of who is scummy and it never seems to change whatever happens.
4. I do not believe he would get roleblocked on night 1.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

I never said ur cases were good
Just said ur good at finding cases not that there good
Please stop making my words seem what there not

And thanks dazza that helps

[safariguy5]

I am leaving my vote on Ghostly for a few reasons.

1. He was going after the doc with no evidence at all he was not the doc.
2. Claimed at L-4. Why claim with not much pressure.
3. He seems to have a list from day 1 of who is scummy and it never seems to change whatever happens.
4. I do not believe he would get roleblocked on night 1.

Yeah, y'know ghostly, you keep saying that you're going to drop the case on clever because you're not getting support, but then you keep bringing it up almost passive-aggressively.

unvote vote ghostly

[jak111]

Been a bit busy with other game and rl. But this game is getting such useless info that there's not much I CAN comment on.
Unvote (if needed), Vote Some7hing
His claim sounds like a bad role... Mr.Hyde... Not good. Dr.Jeckle and Mr.Hyde are the same person, so if he's one he's also the other, which makes me uncomfortable that he's a GOOD doctor. Or at very lest 3rd party.
But I guess it's time to claim since everyone seems to be doing so and if you kill me it's wasted space. :3
Claim Brittany Spears, Vanilla townie.
I don't got much to defend on since I'm useless at night anyhow, but if you wish to lynch me for 'inactivity' jonty, go ahead bud. Not gonna be worth the kill. And for anyone who cares I am active, I just don't post much in this one because I can't add anything to it yet. All I got is Some7thing's claim sounds odd to me and I wish to test it for real. Till the we actually advance a day I don't got a thing else for ya's unless there's a scum slip which to my eye there hasn't as of yet.

[MoB Deadly]

Claim Brittany Spears, Vanilla townie.

I am still lost as what theme this game is?

Isn't it "Britney Spears"??

Im thinking thats a lie, or Jak doesnt really care. vote jak

[dazza2008]

Why claim at all Jak? You have 1 vote on you. WTF is with everyone claiming with no pressure.

In fact Jak found clever's claim with no pressure suspicious(clever was at L-1).

Now Jak claims with no pressure and brings back up the doc case. I would switch my vote but I am still very suspicious of Ghost.

[spiesr]

Yeah, y'know ghostly, you keep saying that you're going to drop the case on clever because you're not getting support, but then you keep bringing it up almost passive-aggressively.

From what I gather, he didn't actually say he was going to forget about the case against SomethingClever, but rather simply not actively pursue it.

[safariguy5]

Yeah, y'know ghostly, you keep saying that you're going to drop the case on clever because you're not getting support, but then you keep bringing it up almost passive-aggressively.

From what I gather, he didn't actually say he was going to forget about the case against SomethingClever, but rather simply not actively pursue it.

Makes no difference to me, but ghostly keeps bringing up clever's posts, so I find his statement that he's not going to pursue the case currently very disingenuous.

[ghostly447]

Yeah, y'know ghostly, you keep saying that you're going to drop the case on clever because you're not getting support, but then you keep bringing it up almost passive-aggressively.

From what I gather, he didn't actually say he was going to forget about the case against SomethingClever, but rather simply not actively pursue it.

Thank you for that bit of defense but what people are tending not to notice are that:
clever made scumslips before and after his claim and yet almost no one notices.

The people who do notice continue to defend him on the fact that he is a claimed doc. Had he claimed anything else he would have been lynched regardless due to his immense amounts of slips. These people who defend him by going against me have already been listed along with an apparent few new recruits.

The few cases that have been made have been made by me and if no one has noticed the people I mentioned are trying to lynch me based on the evidence that my claim just happens to be watcher which normally comes paired with a tracker which normally comes from the same base movie or what not. Then I happened to get role blocked. And I happen to be arguing both days with the same people I suspect to be Mafia. In my opinion it is more of a terrible situation where the Mafia are very good and got lucky with everything they did night 1 and can now use it to their advantage.

It is now to the point I am going to request to get lynched so that I can help by allowing everyone to know I wasn't lying and the town can start getting somewhere. Just please put 2 and 2 together and seewhat you

[ghostly447]

Ebwop you can do to catch the scum

[safariguy5]

Yeah, y'know ghostly, you keep saying that you're going to drop the case on clever because you're not getting support, but then you keep bringing it up almost passive-aggressively.

From what I gather, he didn't actually say he was going to forget about the case against SomethingClever, but rather simply not actively pursue it.

Thank you for that bit of defense but what people are tending not to notice are that:
clever made scumslips before and after his claim and yet almost no one notices.

The people who do notice continue to defend him on the fact that he is a claimed doc. Had he claimed anything else he would have been lynched regardless due to his immense amounts of slips. These people who defend him by going against me have already been listed along with an apparent few new recruits.

The few cases that have been made have been made by me and if no one has noticed the people I mentioned are trying to lynch me based on the evidence that my claim just happens to be watcher which normally comes paired with a tracker which normally comes from the same base movie or what not. Then I happened to get role blocked. And I happen to be arguing both days with the same people I suspect to be Mafia. In my opinion it is more of a terrible situation where the Mafia are very good and got lucky with everything they did night 1 and can now use it to their advantage.

It is now to the point I am going to request to get lynched so that I can help by allowing everyone to know I wasn't lying and the town can start getting somewhere. Just please put 2 and 2 together and seewhat you

I just want to point out that you are generalizing.

First off, I wouldn't say doc is the only role that people think carefully before lynching. Cop would get that treatment, and I personally would think very carefully before lynching a JOAT claim.

Secondly, just because larger games have had both tracker and watchers in the past, does not mean that they ONLY appear together. I've had games where only one or the other was present. And Meta analysis regarding character origins doesn't do anything for you really.

I mean, it's not inconceivable to play doctor badly (see naxus in Firefly Mafia) and given the current situation and relative earliness of the game, I'm willing to give clever a bit of leeway and see where he goes with the claim.

[spiesr]

Thank you for that bit of defense but what people are tending not to notice are that:
clever made scumslips before and after his claim and yet almost no one notices.

Well, you see the sort of "scum-slips" that SomethingClever has made are the sort of things that can come from either being scum or simply being new. So if you believe his claim, it makes sense to conclude that these have simply come from him being new. In my opinion, the things that SomethingClever has done are not enough to justify thinking of him as scum given the context in which they happened. In fact, before his claim I couldn't say that I actually supported the case on him. The only thing that I have against him now is that I think his claim is either fake, or indicates that he is not a good thing to have around. Given that, I would say that anyone who actually believes his claim to be the truth and the whole truth would have no real reason to find even be suspicious of him. His actions tell us nothing. Any judgements rendered against him can only come from a binary decision based on your personal evaluation of his claim.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Yeah, y'know ghostly, you keep saying that you're going to drop the case on clever because you're not getting support, but then you keep bringing it up almost passive-aggressively.

From what I gather, he didn't actually say he was going to forget about the case against SomethingClever, but rather simply not actively pursue it.

Thank you for that bit of defense but what people are tending not to notice are that:
clever made scumslips before and after his claim and yet almost no one notices.

The people who do notice continue to defend him on the fact that he is a claimed doc. Had he claimed anything else he would have been lynched regardless due to his immense amounts of slips. These people who defend him by going against me have already been listed along with an apparent few new recruits.

The few cases that have been made have been made by me and if no one has noticed the people I mentioned are trying to lynch me based on the evidence that my claim just happens to be watcher which normally comes paired with a tracker which normally comes from the same base movie or what not. Then I happened to get role blocked. And I happen to be arguing both days with the same people I suspect to be Mafia. In my opinion it is more of a terrible situation where the Mafia are very good and got lucky with everything they did night 1 and can now use it to their advantage.

It is now to the point I am going to request to get lynched so that I can help by allowing everyone to know I wasn't lying and the town can start getting somewhere. Just please put 2 and 2 together and seewhat you

ok first I have not voted you vote at all so once again this statement is false

[Some7hingCLEVER]

EBWOP
Fastposted

[ghostly447]

Umm. That's because you haven't said a thing since you got cleared.

[DoomYoshi]

Jak, have you been hanging it with eagle recently? What you did bordered on psychosis.

[jak111]

Jak, have you been hanging it with eagle recently? What you did bordered on psychosis.

Nope, but I have been too close to the smoker's fence at school lately and that always gives my mind a headache.

Why claim at all Jak?

So I can say to "I told you so" to Jonty after the game. Mostly because if he wants to vote, might as well put it to use finding scum.

1.)In fact Jak found clever's claim with no pressure suspicious(clever was at L-1).

2.)Now Jak claims with no pressure and brings back up the doc case. I would switch my vote but I am still very suspicious of Ghost.

1.) That was before I checked over the entire thing, and I do believe it was L-2 Dazza, get it right boy.

2.) I bring it back up because I'm not posting much in here, but having read over everything for myself and seeing how Some7hing acted after and before the situation, I'm just willing to put my bet on he's either scum or 3rd party.

And as for the Ghost case have fun with that, STILL after reading it, I don't see that much against him, unless of course you're holding a grudge against him for the other mafia game most of us were in.

Claim Brittany Spears, Vanilla townie.

I am still lost as what theme this game is?

Isn't it "Britney Spears"??

Im thinking thats a lie, or Jak doesnt really care. vote jak

Well we both now know I suck at spelling her name and proof that I never quoted my pm since it's spelt wrong ;o XD :3

It seems to be just random famous characters to me. But I could be wrong of course. The second one would be more accurate than the first reason you gave. This day has been going on for over a week with not much progress. Either lynch me and see what I'm saying, lynch some7hing to see if I am correct, lynch ghost if you wish for a seemingly random bandwagon. Or lynch some other random no case as of yet I believe has really been worked on.

I'm working a case for each of you instead of the individuals you all seem to try and point out. Right now I only really have some7hing to go off of for now. Till I put the rest of your cases together in my head.

[chapcrap]

I don't know what to make of jak.

Who claims like that and spells the name wrong? Weird.

[DoomYoshi]

I don't know what to make of jak.

Who claims like that and spells the name wrong? Weird.

Clever also spelled the name wrong. This is surreal.

[jak111]

I checked my role days earlier, I didn't bother checking for spelling because I thought I knew how it was spelt. But obviously my memory of spelling Britney Spears isn't that great over a period of time.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Gotta say I know the feeling I thought I knew how to spell mine to I just didn't think it would have that big of a deal

[jonty125]

So Jak claims VT after one vote. I smell scum.

[jak111]

Bring it jonty. Bring it. I want you to put your vote somewhere where it counts. So why not?

[Victor Sullivan]

This is what happens when you f*ck a stranger in the ass...

-Sully