Yo Ho, A Pirate's Life! [2/16] Endgame: Pirates Win!

[Nebuchadnezer]

"Cabin boy" Sounds like everybody's bitch <.< x3. But seriously, you're claiming 'Cabin boy' with no real role. Damn I might as well call myself one eyed timmy, or peg leg sam for that matter. Unless someone can clear ya today. I'm keeping this lynch vote on you isaiah. For anyone who wants to still know why?

1.) Spam
2.) 1st person on the no vote wagon
3.) Unprecise claim of 'Cabin Boy' with no known linked role to it.

I do believe those are the main points I have with him so far, anything else I should add to the list of reasons?

On #3 - because there is no linked role associated with it. Just because you have a role, does not mean you will have some sort of power with that role.

ARE YOU TOWN?

[isaiah40]

"Cabin boy" Sounds like everybody's bitch <.< x3. But seriously, you're claiming 'Cabin boy' with no real role. Damn I might as well call myself one eyed timmy, or peg leg sam for that matter. Unless someone can clear ya today. I'm keeping this lynch vote on you isaiah. For anyone who wants to still know why?

1.) Spam
2.) 1st person on the no vote wagon
3.) Unprecise claim of 'Cabin Boy' with no known linked role to it.

I do believe those are the main points I have with him so far, anything else I should add to the list of reasons?

On #3 - because there is no linked role associated with it. Just because you have a role, does not mean you will have some sort of power with that role.

ARE YOU TOWN?

yes

[jak111]

Well, you'd be 'vanilla townie'. Since you did not know that I seriously doubt you are.

[jonty125]

So Isaiah is claiming VT???

BOOM!!! [color=ff0000]unvote vote Isaiah[/color] for 1) claiming a VT 2) the reasons for voting him aren't half bad when you stack them up next to each other and not see them as a lot of one-offs

[jonty125]

So Isaiah is claiming VT???

BOOM!!! unvote vote Isaiah for 1) claiming a VT 2) the reasons for voting him aren't half bad when you stack them up next to each other and not see them as a lot of one-offs

EBWOP

[soundman]

Opps, hit edit instead of quote.

[SPARTACUS1974]

ok not going to vote just yet but i would like to know why Isaiah claimed so early and with such a weak claim ? seems real scummy to me .
so why did you claim with no real presure?

[crazymilkshake5]

Ok, in light of current events, Unvote Vote isaiah40 For acting scummy and Having a sketchy claim.

EBYOP

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Woah I just read up and Isaiah is seeming very scummy
But what I see is that he is becoming more panicky and panicky
In my experience (which is not much at all) I see that happen more when people have either a really good town role or are mafia
And he claims just plain ole townie
Nahhh I dont like the sound of it
I hope this isn't a hammer
unvote vote isaiah40

[jonty125]

Woah I just read up and Isaiah is seeming very scummy
But what I see is that he is becoming more panicky and panicky
In my experience (which is not much at all) I see that happen more when people have either a really good town role or are mafia
And he claims just plain ole townie
Nahhh I dont like the sound of it
I hope this isn't a hammer
unvote vote isaiah40

That's L-1

[crazymilkshake5]

Woah I just read up and Isaiah is seeming very scummy
But what I see is that he is becoming more panicky and panicky
In my experience (which is not much at all) I see that happen more when people have either a really good town role or are mafia
And he claims just plain ole townie
Nahhh I dont like the sound of it
I hope this isn't a hammer
unvote vote isaiah40

That's L-1

That it is, Wach ya got isaiah40?

[jak111]

Hmm, with L-1 left, who wants to bring down the hammer on him? Just to sorta update the votes.

SPARTACUS1974
crazymilkshake5
isaiah40 - Gilligan, ghostly, jak111, Leehar, thehippo, jonty, Crazymilkshake, Some7hing - (L1)
thehippo8
Victor Sullivan
Some7hingCLEVER
TeeGee
new guy1
ghostly447 - newguy - (L8)
NoSurvivors
Gilligan
kiwi3
Leehar - isaiah - (L8)
jak111
jonty125 - (L9)
Nebuchadnezer - TeeGee, - (L8)

Not voting: Spartacus, Sully, NoSurvivors, kiwi3, Nebuch

With 16 alive it takes 9 to make someone walk the plank.

Deadline: None yet.

(Colors are my edits to what it looks like now)

[SPARTACUS1974]

ok isaiah you got 8hrs to reply or i gonna bring down the hammer im off to bed now so talk or ya gonna walk my plank

[Victor Sullivan]

Guys, guys, you make it too easy for someone to just come in and hammer; not to mention there's the possibility of Hated Townies and MC Hammers. Someone should unvote, because I am really tempted to lynch isaiah

-Sully

[Leehar]

I'm surprised to see I'm in the middle of the Isaiah votes? Did I only fos first?
And heck, cabin boy seems scummy itself as well, I never imagine them to really be happy with their jobs. Maybe a menial power role is possible as well in the vein of investigative watcher or similar I guess? But I don't understand why he seemed so sketchy with his responses?

And what are you talking about, no pressure Spartacus? l-4/3 should be too close enough for comfort?

[isaiah40]

I'm surprised to see I'm in the middle of the Isaiah votes? Did I only fos first?
And heck, cabin boy seems scummy itself as well, I never imagine them to really be happy with their jobs. Maybe a menial power role is possible as well in the vein of investigative watcher or similar I guess? But I don't understand why he seemed so sketchy with his responses?

And what are you talking about, no pressure Spartacus? l-4/3 should be too close enough for comfort?

Yes I am Town, and I fibbed when I said I didn't have a role. I am a tracker, so if those who are town, decide to go ahead and make me walk the plank then you will be fighting blind. I was hoping to try and protect my role from mafia as long as possible. Technically Gilligan unvoted but forgot to place his "unvote" in color. So Doc, I will need protection tonight!

Sully shame on you for being razzed at possibly lynching me!!

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Well I have never seen someone do that
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT
Ok so if ur tracker town wouldnt vote for you considering town outnumbers mafia there is no need to lie so for this reason my vote stands

[ghostly447]

I'm surprised to see I'm in the middle of the Isaiah votes? Did I only fos first?
And heck, cabin boy seems scummy itself as well, I never imagine them to really be happy with their jobs. Maybe a menial power role is possible as well in the vein of investigative watcher or similar I guess? But I don't understand why he seemed so sketchy with his responses?

And what are you talking about, no pressure Spartacus? l-4/3 should be too close enough for comfort?

Yes I am Town, and I fibbed when I said I didn't have a role. I am a tracker, so if those who are town, decide to go ahead and make me walk the plank then you will be fighting blind. I was hoping to try and protect my role from mafia as long as possible. Technically Gilligan unvoted but forgot to place his "unvote" in color. So Doc, I will need protection tonight!

Sully shame on you for being razzed at possibly lynching me!!

Unvote

time to investigate a little I suppose. I wont be able to do anything until tomorrow after my second day of paintball. Another early morning tomorrow.

[isaiah40]

Well I have never seen someone do that
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT
Ok so if ur tracker town wouldnt vote for you considering town outnumbers mafia there is no need to lie so for this reason my vote stands

So if you are town, you would be willing to lose a tracker who could find out who the mafia are? If you aren't town then you must be mafia, which now I believe you are, or else you would have unvoted. Something interesting to think about. I think we have uncovered one mafia!! So I will now unvote vote Some7hingCLEVER!

[TeeGee]

Well I have never seen someone do that
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT
Ok so if ur tracker town wouldnt vote for you considering town outnumbers mafia there is no need to lie so for this reason my vote stands

So if you are town, you would be willing to lose a tracker who could find out who the mafia are? If you aren't town then you must be mafia, which now I believe you are, or else you would have unvoted. Something interesting to think about. I think we have uncovered one mafia!! So I will now unvote vote Some7hingCLEVER!

Interesting

and I forgot to unvote my joke vote, although no dire consequence came from it.. so for now

unvote

FOS Some7hingCLEVER as I think isaiah may have a point, I need to go back and read

[soundman]

Vote count:

SPARTACUS1974
crazymilkshake5
isaiah40 - Gilligan, jak111, Leehar, thehippo, jonty, CMS, some7 - (L2)
thehippo8
Victor Sullivan
Some7hingCLEVER - isaiah - (L8)
TeeGee
new guy1
ghostly447 - newguy - (L8)
NoSurvivors
Gilligan
kiwi3
Leehar
jak111
jonty125
Nebuchadnezer

With 16 alive it takes 9 to make someone walk the plank.

Deadline: None yet. We'll see how this day goes.

[jonty125]

I'm surprised to see I'm in the middle of the Isaiah votes? Did I only fos first?
And heck, cabin boy seems scummy itself as well, I never imagine them to really be happy with their jobs. Maybe a menial power role is possible as well in the vein of investigative watcher or similar I guess? But I don't understand why he seemed so sketchy with his responses?

And what are you talking about, no pressure Spartacus? l-4/3 should be too close enough for comfort?

Yes I am Town, and I fibbed when I said I didn't have a role. I am a tracker, so if those who are town, decide to go ahead and make me walk the plank then you will be fighting blind. I was hoping to try and protect my role from mafia as long as possible. Technically Gilligan unvoted but forgot to place his "unvote" in color. So Doc, I will need protection tonight!

Sully shame on you for being razzed at possibly lynching me!!

unvote we can test his claim if needs be.

[quote="Some7hingCLEVER]Well I have never seen someone do that
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT
Ok so if ur tracker town wouldnt vote for you considering town outnumbers mafia there is no need to lie so for this reason my vote stands[/quote]

Do you have any reason to believe he is not a tracker?

[Some7hingCLEVER]

No its just very sketchy thats all

[crazymilkshake5]

I'm surprised to see I'm in the middle of the Isaiah votes? Did I only fos first?
And heck, cabin boy seems scummy itself as well, I never imagine them to really be happy with their jobs. Maybe a menial power role is possible as well in the vein of investigative watcher or similar I guess? But I don't understand why he seemed so sketchy with his responses?

And what are you talking about, no pressure Spartacus? l-4/3 should be too close enough for comfort?

Yes I am Town, and I fibbed when I said I didn't have a role. I am a tracker, so if those who are town, decide to go ahead and make me walk the plank then you will be fighting blind. I was hoping to try and protect my role from mafia as long as possible. Technically Gilligan unvoted but forgot to place his "unvote" in color. So Doc, I will need protection tonight!

Sully shame on you for being razzed at possibly lynching me!!

unvote we can test his claim if needs be.

Well I have never seen someone do that
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT
Ok so if ur tracker town wouldnt vote for you considering town outnumbers mafia there is no need to lie so for this reason my vote stands

Do you have any reason to believe he is not a tracker?

Do you have any reason to believe that hes not mafia?

[jak111]

We were close to a hammer to test his claim but now you guys are jumping toward someone who is just against isaiah's claim like I am.

Let me point out a few things I saw for the 'bout past page and a half.

Well I have never seen someone do that
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT
Ok so if ur tracker town wouldnt vote for you considering town outnumbers mafia there is no need to lie so for this reason my vote stands

So if you are town, you would be willing to lose a tracker who could find out who the mafia are? If you aren't town then you must be mafia, which now I believe you are, or else you would have unvoted. Something interesting to think about. I think we have uncovered one mafia!! So I will now unvote vote Some7hingCLEVER!

Some7hing's post is yet still unclear to me, but I do believe he just means if you were a tracker why would you try to hide it at L-2/L-1. As for your voting isaiah it's all over the place, you have no case against anybody and your willing to just randomly vote against anyone who votes you.

I'm surprised to see I'm in the middle of the Isaiah votes? Did I only fos first?
And heck, cabin boy seems scummy itself as well, I never imagine them to really be happy with their jobs. Maybe a menial power role is possible as well in the vein of investigative watcher or similar I guess? But I don't understand why he seemed so sketchy with his responses?

And what are you talking about, no pressure Spartacus? l-4/3 should be too close enough for comfort?

Yes I am Town, and I fibbed when I said I didn't have a role. I am a tracker, so if those who are town, decide to go ahead and make me walk the plank then you will be fighting blind. I was hoping to try and protect my role from mafia as long as possible. Technically Gilligan unvoted but forgot to place his "unvote" in color. So Doc, I will need protection tonight!

Sully shame on you for being razzed at possibly lynching me!!

unvote we can test his claim if needs be.

Well I have never seen someone do that
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT
Ok so if ur tracker town wouldnt vote for you considering town outnumbers mafia there is no need to lie so for this reason my vote stands

Do you have any reason to believe he is not a tracker?

Do you believe isaiah's claim this quickly? Do you have any reason to believe his claim?

As for the testing the claim, I do not wish to let him off today with a feeling he might try to strike me in the night for leading the case against him. But if he does make it through the night I say he tracks me and tells everyone what I am, if he's wrong he's dead...

Like I said, I'd rather not even give him that chance because I might not make it through the night if he's mafia.