Actually, I've gone back through everything again (particularly day 1 and 2) and I am firmly of the opinion that it is scummy to lynch avowed townies without a good reason. And I believe that there's no good reason to lynch Vodean or Clever.
But I've gone back and re-looked at the case on Jak. Just because he's masoned with Doom doesn't make that a bad case. Plenty of mafia masons out there. And even if he's third party at leasst that's more expendable than town. So, if there is a value on retesting this on someone other tan Everywhere then let's retest on Jak.
Jak says hunt the inactives day 1 page 8
Edoc points out Jak is scummy for his attempted mislynch day 1 page 12
Neb claims day 1 page 20 I am Tank. Vanilla Townie. I have nothing special to do during the night, so I'm trying to keep myself interested by stirring the pot. And if I get lynched, who cares? Fortunately, my ploy worked, and we actually have some activity to go off of now. My two high suspects are edocsil and MoB Deadly for trying to vote for me with some "reasons" as to why I deserved the vote. However, their reasons are flimsy at best...and just plain stupid at worst. But, they felt they had to give reasons, so that they didn't just look like blatant bandwagoners...right?
Jak votes Neb day 1 page 21
Jak and IB go back to Neb day 1 page 24
Neb and Leehar bicker and Jak gets philosophical and doesn't want Leehar, IB, Jak or Eldario lynched but makes comment about them anyway day 1 page 26
Dazza and IB attack Jak day 1 page 26
Neb goes for Jak day 1 page 27
I and Everywhere vote jak day 1 page 27
Cowboyz also doesn't like the case on Jak but likes the one on IB but doesn't vote day 1 page 28
DJ & SG7 vote for Jak day 1 page 29
Chuck votes jak day 1 page 30
Doom claims mason with Jak day 1 page 30
Lot's of unvoting day 1 page 31
We are back to inactives and Jak and Mob go for Eldario day 1 page 37
Doom and Jak vote for Eldario day 1 page 40
Vote count at that point is eldario(8)- neb, shield, hippo, everywhere, djfireside, betiko, doomyoshi, jak111 day 1 page 41
Eldario claims day 1 page 41 I am Commander Locke, Vanilla Townie
At this point voting are eldario(10)- shield, hippo, everywhere, DJ, betiko, doom, IB, Mob, clever, jonty day 1 page 44
Eldario falls on his sword day 1 page 47
Neb votes for Eldario day 1 page 48
Everywhere votes for Eldario day 1 page 48
pmc votes Eldario day 1 page 49
Betico, jonty and Neb vote Eldario day 1 page 49
eldario, Commander Locke, Vanilla Townie has been lynched! day 1 page 50!!!
DAY TWO
jonty unvotes and Fos' s7c and Jak day 2 page 55
s7c slaps jonty and jonty apologises day 2 page 55
Jak Fos' s7c day 2 page 55
at this point the count is skill(9)- sound, betiko, jonty, everywhere, hippo, edoc, chuck, cowboyz, dj day 2 page 59
sound and dj want skill prodded (but don't take off their votes) day 2 page 61
Jak votes skill day 2 page 61
Leehar Fos' Jak for not waiting day 2 page 61
Betico unvotes day 2 page 61
Skill is prodded and the vote count is skill(10)- sound, jonty, everywhere, hippo, edoc, chuck, cowboyz, dj, IB, jak day 2 page 62
Jonty Fos' Jak for putting skill at L1 but doesn't unvote day 2 page 62
skill asks to be replaced day 2 page 62
Jak protests at the delay day 2 page 63
Doom agrees and hammers skill day 2 page 63
Betico bemoans the lack of claim (a bit late now!) day 2 page 63
jakslaps betico day 2 page 63
cowboyz, Captain Mifune, Town Vigilante, has been killed! night 2 page 64
)
So now you want to die? Also, your little one liners are really starting to get to me. Especially when you just parrot someone else.
