Simpsons Mafia (8 of 13) Endgame, Town Win!

[pancakemix]

Breakdown of claims and clears:

3. safariguy5 Wiggum, Cop
5. Djfireside Homer, Vig
6. thechuck51 Lisa, Tracker
7. LSU Tiger Josh Character undisclosed, Weird Special Hider Thing
8. pmchugh Otto, Busdriver
9. strike wolf Unclaimed
10. TheForgivenOne Barney gumble, Roleblocker
12. pancakemix Hider confirmed

I've updated the list, but one thing confused me. Why pancake just snuck his claim in here, never name claimed, partially CC'd LSU and declared himself as "confirmed"? Maybe I am forgetting something, but I checked all of pancakes previous posts and saw nothing.

I never claimed, and it seems that me being confirmed's not the case anymore.

I am Bart Simpson, masoned with the above Milhouse.

Now I think we need a full claim from LSU. Once everything's on the table, we can work from there.

[pmchugh]

Why did you say you were confirmed?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I am Nick Riviera - Town Weak Doctor


I didn't want to claim my name or "special power" earlier for obvious reasons. My character will die if I go to any anti-town character which is why I voted Pershy since it would no longer be safe for me to go there and I didn't want to risk the cult expanding and increasing my odds of dying by going to an anti-town player. Being that I can protect Safari is why I was going there last night before the busdriver claim and is where I plan on going until I die which I would expect to be tonight since I fully revealed who I am.

He said he was confirmed because I lived when I thought I had went to him before finding out that I was role-blocked.

[thechuck51]

Breakdown of claims and clears:

3. safariguy5 Wiggum, Cop
5. Djfireside Homer, Vig
6. thechuck51 Lisa, Tracker
7. LSU Tiger Josh Dr. Nick, Weak Doctor
8. pmchugh Otto, Busdriver
9. strike wolf Milhouse, HIder/Mason
10. TheForgivenOne Barney gumble, Roleblocker
12. pancakemix Bart, Hider/Mason

LSU's claim is the weakest in my opinion. There was already a doctor in the game plus a JOAT. seems a little much to have a weak doctor too.

unvote vote LSU

[pershy]

MOD NOTE
I will give a slight extension to deadline (til tomorrow morning 8ish GMT) and then I will post scene.

[pershy]

Vote Count

Djfireside (1) - Safariguy,
thechuck51 (3) - pancakemix, pmchugh, safari
pmc (1) - DJ
LSU (1) - thechuck51

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline is tomorrow morning early GMT

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I disagree. I think Otto is weaker. I stayed on the faith healer claim as long as I did because I knew there wouldn't be a third town doc even as feable as mine is.

Vote pmc

[TheForgivenOne]

Hmmmm, I don't truly believe the Weak Doctor Claim, since I'd rather see him as a CPR Doc (For obvious reasons). But it could explain the lack of town night deaths.

But something is nagging at me. chuck said N2 that BK visited Saf. He should have died, because I didn't roleblock BK, pmchugh didn't busdrive Saf that night, and LSU didn't doc him that night. How did he survive?

strike wolf brought it up, but nobody followed it, and chuck didn't really acknowledge it.

[thechuck51]

Hmmmm, I don't truly believe the Weak Doctor Claim, since I'd rather see him as a CPR Doc (For obvious reasons). But it could explain the lack of town night deaths.

But something is nagging at me. chuck said N2 that BK visited Saf. He should have died, because I didn't roleblock BK, pmchugh didn't busdrive Saf that night, and LSU didn't doc him that night. How did he survive?

strike wolf brought it up, but nobody followed it, and chuck didn't really acknowledge it.

I don'r know why saf didnt die I just know BK visited him. the only other role that could protect saf would be the mafia doctor but that wouldn't make sense.

[strike wolf]

Disregarding some kind of convoluted mafia ploy. either Chuck is lying about bk's action.
TFO is lying about his action or a mod error. the third option can't be proven and I tend to trust mods not to make those kind of errors.

[safariguy5]

I think there are way too many investigative roles. Mason Hiders work as an extra investigative role if played correctly, because one mason can hide behind someone and tell the other mason and if the hider turns up dead, we've ID'd an anti town role. I'm sticking with my vote on chuck because of the BK visit claim, and considering we already had a marge fakeclaim.

[thechuck51]

Disregarding some kind of convoluted mafia ploy. either Chuck is lying about bk's action.
TFO is lying about his action or a mod error. the third option can't be proven and I tend to trust mods not to make those kind of errors.

Normally I would agree regarding mod errors but considering how he abandoned the game I wouldn't be surprised if Dazza made a mistake.

[pmchugh]

Its possible that pershy had something to do with it but I think it would most likely be a block and not a doc which would make the tracker claim a lie.

LSU's claim is very weak, especially the fact he was so half arsed in going after our faith healer.

Invite vote cky for now I'll believe bk but I'm not convinced at all. Ck definitely has been all over the place with his votes so I'll move there

yea that does hurt. so who were you on last night faith healer? also mod can you prod pretender seeing how he seems to be awol from other games at this time as well and might need replacing

I am torn between chuck and LSU. unvote vote chuck We have at least two lynches anyway.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Very Selective quoting. If you read further on day 2 I had one of the last two votes on bk and switched off only after pancake pointed out that leader was probable cult. My vote stays on pmchugh.

[strike wolf]

I forgot the possibility of a mafia BD messing up results. I'm sticking with my vote on Chuck.

[strike wolf]

I forgot the possibility of a mafia BD messing up results. I'm sticking with my vote on Chuck.

Actually scratch that. wouldn't explain the no visiting say thing.

[TheForgivenOne]

I'm just having a hard time believing chuck's claim. One of his reports just doesn't add up.

Vote: Chuck

[pershy]

Vote Count

thechuck51 (4) - pancakemix, safari, pmchugh, Forgiven L-1
pmc (2) - DJ, LSU
LSU (1) - thechuck51,

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline is now

[pershy]

Scene

The citizens of Springfield sat around in Mo's Tavern drinking beer and chatting about who was the most suspicious among them, but 5 of them couldn't agree on who to lynch and by the time day ended they had had too much beer by then anyway.



Please get your night actions in asap.
Thanks

[pmchugh]

Very Selective quoting. If you read further on day 2 I had one of the last two votes on bk and switched off only after pancake pointed out that leader was probable cult. My vote stays on pmchugh.

I'll respond to this later.

Scene

The citizens of Springfield sat around in Mo's Tavern drinking beer and chatting about who was the most suspicious among them, but 5 of them couldn't agree on who to lynch and by the time day ended they had had too much beer by then anyway.



Please get your night actions in asap.
Thanks

Didn't even realise there was a deadline.

[pershy]

wow - thanks for getting in your actions so fast

Scene N4 - Retribution


Fat Tony had had enough! The town was blocking his actions and killing his men. "If you wanna do something properly you gotta do it yourself!" He waited til night and snuck out, gun loaded and headed for Barney's house. He would kill him and plant the gun at the weak doc's house - yeah! He stealthily smashed down the front door, went to the bedroom and fired into the mass that was in the bed several times. "That'll teach you!" - wait - no blood. He pulled back the covers just to find a mound of pillows riddled with holes! Damn! Roleblocked!!! Or Mo's having a lock in! OK - he'd have to kill someone else!

But as he left the house he saw Homer standing in the middle of the street with a gun and other angry townies behind him including Bart, Millhouse, Otto, Nick Riviera and Cheif Wiggum.

"Very well, I'll have to kill 'em all", thought Tony as he raised his gun.

"Oh no you don't!" yelled Homer....

.....and let him have it.

show

Homer Simpson - overeager town vigilante has shot thechuck51 and killed Fat Tony - mafia framer. All threats are eliminated. TOWN WINS

Mafia and Cult lose.

Well done guys! Good game. Unfortunately mafia got a rough deal. Town seemed very powerful in this game but I guess things could have been very different if the cult recruiter had stayed alive and converted more people and with so many power roles DJ could have killed off townies and townies blocking each other etc.

On N1 and N2 I don't know all of the actions but I know that I was blocked anyway and chose not to use a JOAT power, then 77 converted me. On N2 I investigated Shaggy and he came up guilty. I also had gun investigate, protect and kill I think but got lynched. Below are the remaining roles and actions that I know.

Mafia
thechuck51 - Fat Tony - Mafia Framer
ShaggyDan - Legs - Mafia Doctor

Town
safariguy5 - Cheif Wiggum - Town Cop
Djfireside - Homer Simpson - Overeager Vigilante
pancakemix - Bart Simpson - Town Mason
Some7hingCLEVER Strike wolf - Millhouse - Town Mason (was inactive, I was going to replace him(speak to strike wolf, he said he would play))
LSU Tiger Josh - Nick Riviera - Weak Doc(dies if he protects scum)
TheForgivenOne - Barney Gumble - Town Roleblocker
pmchugh - Otto Mann - Town Busdriver

N3

Pmchugh (busdriver) swaps Safari and Some7thing clever
Forgiven (town rollblocker) rollblocks ShaggyDan
LSU (town weak doctor) (weakly) protects Safari
Chuck (mafia framer) frames LSU
ShaggyDan (mafia doctor) tries to kill Safari but has been roleblocked. He protects Chuck
DJ (townovereager vigilante) shoots ShaggyDan


N4

chuck - kill TFO frame LSU
LSU protect safari
TFO - roleblock chuck
pmchuhj - swaps saf and himself
saf - investigate chuck
DJ - kill chuck


Cheers - gg played by all. Special thanks to Strike Wolf for taking over as Millhouse Town Mason from Some7thingClever. Thanks for that. I told you there probably wouldn't be long to go. Cheers for setting it up Dazza - shame you couldn't finish it.

Well done town

[strike wolf]

Great shooting DJ. an overeager vig is often a burden on the town but you turned it into an advantage.

[pmchugh]

Yaaaaaaaaaay.

[pancakemix]

Whoo hoo! DJ for MVP.

Kudos for taking over, pershy. Well done.

[strike wolf]

DJ for MVP. Saf managed to collect a good series of investigations so he'd be second.