[Official] Holiday Mafia - Game Over!

[superkeener]

Hmmmmmmmmm. I guess the matter is solved. Can we move on?

[Metsfanmax]

4) This means you agree this could be a game mechanic that I would know (although rishaed brought it up). Therefore you are doing the exact same thing as I just did. Speculate. But you are being arbitrary between what I said and what rishaed said, so not only you are speculating, you are taking sides, not just FOSing but voting in a quite serious way. You just cleared my doubt, you were half serious.

well here is a half serious vote:

unvote, vote mets

It's not arbitrary; rishaed wasn't actually speculating on game mechanics, but you were.

That being said, this is how D1 goes. No one should take it personally, and we can indeed move on.

[anamainiacks]

4) This means you agree this could be a game mechanic that I would know (although rishaed brought it up). Therefore you are doing the exact same thing as I just did. Speculate. But you are being arbitrary between what I said and what rishaed said, so not only you are speculating, you are taking sides, not just FOSing but voting in a quite serious way. You just cleared my doubt, you were half serious.

well here is a half serious vote:

unvote, vote mets

It's not arbitrary; rishaed wasn't actually speculating on game mechanics, but you were.

That being said, this is how D1 goes. No one should take it personally, and we can indeed move on.

I honestly thought the matter was resolved/forgotten a while back in the thread; I've no idea why betiko insists on harping on it and bringing it up again. Your obsession with the issue is getting suspicious to me, but since it's still Day 1, I'd still prefer to abstain and thus say unvote for now.

[Nendreel]

I honestly thought the matter was resolved/forgotten a while back in the thread; I've no idea why betiko insists on harping on it and bringing it up again. Your obsession with the issue is getting suspicious to me, but since it's still Day 1, I'd still prefer to abstain and thus say unvote for now.

From what I've seen, Betiko never lets these things go. It'll keep coming up as long as there's a way to tie it into a case.
Not really suspicious, just par for the course.

I just went through the Rankin/Bass filmography, I'm kinda surprised how many of their holiday specials I've never even heard of. I was expecting a more well known library.

[thechuck51]

care to explain how your slip is not bigger than mine mets?

It was already explained by others. You called out what was obviously a joke vote with something related to game mechanics, hinting that you know about the possibility of stealing gifts. Obviously stealing gifts is most likely a mafia/third party ability if it does exist.

That being said, I also admit that this mechanism is quite reasonable to conjecture about given what we have been told about the gifts, so it's possible you know nothing about it and were just speculating. So my vote is only half serious. But it was definitely something to keep in mind.

I'm looking but I don't see where metsfanmax actually slipped? (aside from openly rooting for the mets)
I'm also wondering if by not denying any slip, mets is actually conceding that he did slip (that sentence makes more sense in my head)

[Metsfanmax]

care to explain how your slip is not bigger than mine mets?

It was already explained by others. You called out what was obviously a joke vote with something related to game mechanics, hinting that you know about the possibility of stealing gifts. Obviously stealing gifts is most likely a mafia/third party ability if it does exist.

That being said, I also admit that this mechanism is quite reasonable to conjecture about given what we have been told about the gifts, so it's possible you know nothing about it and were just speculating. So my vote is only half serious. But it was definitely something to keep in mind.

I'm looking but I don't see where metsfanmax actually slipped? (aside from openly rooting for the mets)
I'm also wondering if by not denying any slip, mets is actually conceding that he did slip (that sentence makes more sense in my head)

No. Someone accused me of a slip in response to my vote on betiko, in what I assume was a joke vote. Didn't think it worth responding to.

[NoSurvivors]

Don't worry about what betiko says D1.. He's one to overthink everything :p lol

[edocsil]

care to explain how your slip is not bigger than mine mets?

Are you saying you have a tiny "slip"?

[Iron Butterfly]

vote Scrooge town instawin.

I will vote Jonty

Scrooge was a Townie.

[betiko]

care to explain how your slip is not bigger than mine mets?

Are you saying you have a tiny "slip"?

I was just saying that if my question was seen as a slip according to met's logic, viewing my question as a slip was one too, or at the vey least at the same extent.

Anyway, concerning scrooge or whatever I have no idea of this show. Is there a grinch?

[Nendreel]

Anyway, concerning scrooge or whatever I have no idea of this show. Is there a grinch?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rankin/bass#Christmas

Here's the Filmography of the Rankin/Bass studio.
The ones you'd most likely recognize are Rudolph and Frosty. They also did an adaptation of A Chrismas Carol, so it's possible to see Scrooge here. They didn't adapt Dr. Seuss though, so no Grinch.

[Kanin Usagi]

Anyway, concerning scrooge or whatever I have no idea of this show. Is there a grinch?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rankin/bass#Christmas

Here's the Filmography of the Rankin/Bass studio.
The ones you'd most likely recognize are Rudolph and Frosty. They also did an adaptation of A Chrismas Carol, so it's possible to see Scrooge here. They didn't adapt Dr. Seuss though, so no Grinch.

Don't forget Santa Claus is Coming to Town and that other Santa one.. Uhhh, the one with Heat Miser and Cold Miser?

[pancakemix]

Spiesr replaces babagonosh.

[Nendreel]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rankin/bass#Christmas

Here's the Filmography of the Rankin/Bass studio.
The ones you'd most likely recognize are Rudolph and Frosty. They also did an adaptation of A Chrismas Carol, so it's possible to see Scrooge here. They didn't adapt Dr. Seuss though, so no Grinch.

Don't forget Santa Claus is Coming to Town and that other Santa one.. Uhhh, the one with Heat Miser and Cold Miser?

I'd be lying if I said I did remember those two.

[spiesr]

Confirm or something, you know.
The Betiko/rishead/mets thing looks mildly interesting. Of course it is pretty insubstantial, but not bad for this early on Day 1. We'll have to keep it in mind and possibly go back to it if nothing else comes up in the next couple days.
Meanwhile, it seems that Little Witt and soundman are the only ones left on Mob's list of people who haven't contributed anything at all. May as well just go down that list now. Vote Little Witt. Please post and give me a reason why you should not be our Day 1 lynch.

[soundman]

Vote Betiko! For admitting to a tiny slip!

[betiko]

Vote Betiko! For admitting to a tiny slip!

I didn't admit any kind of slip. I said that if mets considers it a slip, I was wondering how his reaction would not be a slip.

Another guy who is not bringing any substance at all is superkeener. you can hardly make posts as dull as those:

One sentence recap. Go.

too lazy to read 1 page.

Hmmmmmmmmm. I guess the matter is solved. Can we move on?

to what? bring in substance instead of posting to say nothing at all! I'll go back to my previous vote. I hate when players think they can be safe by posting once in a while a line that says nothing.

unvote vote superkeener

[superkeener]

Vote betiko thats all. I have got to keep to my short meaningless posts.

[rishaed]

Vote betiko thats all. I have got to keep to my short meaningless posts.

ah, someone does not know that Mafia is a game where short meaningless posts get you lynched rather quickly. unvote vote superkeener in other words, why should we not lynch you, who is contributing nothing but confusion to the game with one-liners that is generally viewed as very scummy. And being lazy is not equivalent to a good excuse. By all means if you are learning here is something to learn, Once in a while 1 liners are okay, when you post nothing but one liners, it becomes scummy. As they say the only ones who do not slip up are those who do not say anything.

[Nendreel]

Vote betiko thats all. I have got to keep to my short meaningless posts.

Is this a joke vote, or are you serious?

Either way, it's not reducing suspicion against you.

[edocsil]

Vote betiko thats all. I have got to keep to my short meaningless posts.

ah, someone does not know that Mafia is a game where short meaningless posts get you lynched rather quickly. unvote vote superkeener in other words, why should we not lynch you, who is contributing nothing but confusion to the game with one-liners that is generally viewed as very scummy. And being lazy is not equivalent to a good excuse. By all means if you are learning here is something to learn, Once in a while 1 liners are okay, when you post nothing but one liners, it becomes scummy. As they say the only ones who do not slip up are those who do not say anything.

Lol.

Vote rishaed Over-reacting

In other news I like the new guy.

[MoB Deadly]

Vote betiko thats all. I have got to keep to my short meaningless posts.

Thats enough to earn my vote. Posting lots of thoughts, instincts, suspicions is how people are made accountable throughout the entire game. Scum want to float in between cases as much as possible by not posting large posts or substantial contributing posts.
unvote vote superkeener


fastposted by edoc.... you think superkeener was just playing around? I dont know his personality its my first game with him.

welcome to the game spiesr

[MoB Deadly]

Im happy to vote for little witt too, who hasnt done anything right?

[rishaed]

Vote betiko thats all. I have got to keep to my short meaningless posts.

ah, someone does not know that Mafia is a game where short meaningless posts get you lynched rather quickly. unvote vote superkeener in other words, why should we not lynch you, who is contributing nothing but confusion to the game with one-liners that is generally viewed as very scummy. And being lazy is not equivalent to a good excuse. By all means if you are learning here is something to learn, Once in a while 1 liners are okay, when you post nothing but one liners, it becomes scummy. As they say the only ones who do not slip up are those who do not say anything.

Lol.

Vote rishaed Over-reacting

In other news I like the new guy.

I don't consider myself to be overreacting. Just trying to give him some helpful hints for forum mafia. Since I play differently on forums than RL. And as MoB, he's a new face to me so i don't know how experienced he is.

[edocsil]

Vote betiko thats all. I have got to keep to my short meaningless posts.

Thats enough to earn my vote. Posting lots of thoughts, instincts, suspicions is how people are made accountable throughout the entire game. Scum want to float in between cases as much as possible by not posting large posts or substantial contributing posts.
unvote vote superkeener


fastposted by edoc.... you think superkeener was just playing around? I dont know his personality its my first game with him.

welcome to the game spiesr

Keener was poking fun at the walls ppl have been posting that say nothing at all, and more or less giving people the bird for calling him out for meaningless posting posting on D1, when other are not here, and that those who are posting aren't posting much more informative stuff.