Re: (GON 3rd game)Town wins. Day 5

[joak]

Ok happy to go with vote on bantam as a vet I would have thought he would have defended himself better and as a noob I am trying to pick up hints and tips from everyone and don't want to messs up anything for us townies sovote bantam

[crasp]

Just a note from me:

I hate the "leader gets lynched" part of this in mafia. I had never played it that way before, and hate it. It just seems wrong, and it should be that if there is no consensus, then it is a "no lynch" for the day. I think the rules need to change, as the way we play now caters to the lazy people and makes them lazier.

Think this would be okay with really experienced players. Remember that while people may not be posting they might still be playing e-mail tennis with me.Its not really my place to tell people when to post or what to say although i will help if I can. Not that I would call my self experienced but i think participation has been quite high considering the number of noobs we have. Well looking forward to the next one.

Need to stop this or move to a seperate thread. Confusing people. Sorry people. Apart from joaks post ignore all after the vote up date.

[crasp]

Bantam now L-2

[charm]

Bantam now L-2

What does L-2 mean?

[crasp]

Bantam now L-2

What does L-2 mean?

2 short of a lynch charm. Lynch is 8 bantam now 6. At this point you would normally claim.

[TheCrown]

Bantam, I guess go ahead and claim... then we can stop the lynch and see who we believe of the 3 claims.

[H8 AFK]

A Bantam is a type of chicken isn't it?

Says it all really

unvote joak, vote bantam.

h8afk

[Bantam]

Hi
I am town - so as I've said - that doesn't help you at all - there are now 3 of us claiming.

Sirius I have received your PM and I've read your post

Why I think bantam is suspicious:

-Veteran yet not talk for a good amount of days. The only way to gather info is to make people talk, and to make them talk is by talking. You should know that.
-When he does talk, he says that the evidence is flimsy at most and will not vote. This is mafia on day 1, of course the evidence is flimsy. But if you don't start suspecting anyone just because they might not be the bad guys, how are you gonna find the bad guys. Using that reasoning I could say that I will not ever vote anyone until a cop found them out and let the mafia win.
-People started voting for you and you didn't react. Trying to fall under the radar again? My bet is that you are waiting for someone to make a mistake in a post and let the town jump on him instead. It could have worked since some other player got a lot of attention too.

In terms of replying - I've played 1 game so that's hardly veteran - there are a number of ways to play this game - I didn't realise that we all had to play the game the same way - because I don't use your methodology - maybe I decide to use my eyes and my ears rather than my fingers.
As for betting - where's KE 3rd when you need him because I'd like to lay my house against you being wrong.

As for Kill - think - "less is more" - obvious isn't it - quality is better than quantity.

Anyways I'm done - there it is - make your mind-up - the more astute amongst you will work it out.

FP'd by joak - here comes another bandwagon jumper....

[TheCrown]

Bantam, are you saying that you are a "regular townie" or "vanilla townie" with no role?

[Bantam]

Bantam, are you saying that you are a "regular townie" or "vanilla townie" with no role?

I am a regular townie - if you want the role I can do so.

[TheCrown]

That is the role, so I don't know what you mean...

[Bantam]

That is the role, so I don't know what you mean...

So I am a townie with a night role.

[crasp]

Hi


Sirius I have received your PM and I've read your post

Why I think bantam is suspicious:

It is my understanding that this is a mod kill. i was quite specific about this at the start of the game. now waiting on clarification.

[TheCrown]

A night role? How is that a mod-killable thing? How is having a night action not a "power" role, I don't get it. What is your night action Bantam?

[TheCrown]

Everyone unvote Bantam quick, I think this claim of his is the truth!

[joak]

What the fek is goin oan ok invite bantam

[joak]

un vote bantam fekin phones didn't mean to invite you lol an PS av never jumped oan a band waggon in ma life mate

[SiriusCowKing]

Sirius I have received your PM and I've read your post

It is my understanding that this is a mod kill. i was quite specific about this at the start of the game. now waiting on clarification.

My PM was just telling him that I posted something about him and I wanted to be sure he had the chance to read it and reply since the last day of day 1 was about to end. Then I added that I couldn't say anything more because that would be specifics. Would you rather have me PM you and you PM him next time?

[Killuminati19]

I will unvote Bantam, but this ears and eyes nonsense is lame. Don't wait for six people to vote you before you finally feel compelled to talk. Going against my own policy here, but I would love to know what Justplay wants to try to pass himself off as.Vote justplay for a claim. Running out of time tho.

[Killuminati19]

I would add that a lot of precious time was wasted waiting for Bantam to chime in.

[SiriusCowKing]

Everyone unvote Bantam quick, I think this claim of his is the truth!

I don't know if bantam is telling the truth, but I would rather not lynch him for now, his last post did put doubt in my mind. We could always vote for someone else in my list. If you guys have a target with enough votes that I find suspect, I will vote that target. Unvote.

[crasp]

My understanding is that any pm's during daytime should come to me. Even at night the only people who should be talking via pm are those who have roles that allow it.it is also my understanding that it is a serious offence. like i say i am awaiting instruction from epitaph and will update accordingly.
For the record i had already pm'd bantam to tell him he was at L-2 the same as i would do with anyone, this was also the case with H8.

[TheCrown]

Then I must confess that a few days ago I PM'ed DB4 to check back into mafia. I wanted him to see a response in the thread before he disappeared for another day. Nothing was said but to "check mafia thread".

[TheCrown]

How much time do we have until the end of the day?

[crasp]

How much time do we have until the end of the day?

Just under 4 hours. 20.00 cc time