Moderator: Community Team

I'll remove my vote when you give me a good reason why you never voted for H8 when you had the chance on Day 1?charm wrote:Vote legion
I'll remove my vote for you if
You remove your vote from me first
@Charm as I asked for on page 40 (the previous page)legionnare wrote: @Mookie @charm @joak any explanation as to why you didn't vote for H8?
@Sirius, not everyone agrees who is scummy here, otherwise would have already had a lynch.SiriusCowKing wrote: rather than lynch someone else who everyone agrees that they are scummy?

I'm not going to change my vote and jump on a bandwagon just because a bunch of you were voting out of your arse! I didn't see a good enough reason to vote for H8 at the time. Veterans were trying to stir up trouble and stated that Day 1 tells us nothing and that knowledge would be gained no matter who is lynched.legionnare wrote:I'll remove my vote when you give me a good reason why you never voted for H8 when you had the chance on Day 1?charm wrote:Vote legion
I'll remove my vote for you if
You remove your vote from me first
Fair enough, thanks for the response, @Moookie @Joak, still waiting.charm wrote:I'm not going to change my vote and jump on a bandwagon just because a bunch of you were voting out of your arse! I didn't see a good enough reason to vote for H8 at the time. Veterans were trying to stir up trouble and stated that Day 1 tells us nothing and that knowledge would be gained no matter who is lynched.legionnare wrote:I'll remove my vote when you give me a good reason why you never voted for H8 when you had the chance on Day 1?charm wrote:Vote legion
I'll remove my vote for you if
You remove your vote from me first
Bantam, on the other hand, initiating a boys club and being a bit quiet, ave me reason to vote for him and no reason that I could see to rescind my vote!
@Mookie @charm @joak any explanation as to why you didn't vote for H8?
Fair enough thanks for the response, I'm not making accusations, I'm just trying to see where everyone stands compared to known quantities.mookiemcgee wrote:@Mookie @charm @joak any explanation as to why you didn't vote for H8?
I think i explained clearly why I voted for Bantam... Because otherwise I had the next most votes and I would be dead.
As far as why not vote for H8, it was the first day and the only reason anyone else gave for voting for him was to get him to talk because he was quiet.
The initial vote for H8 came from crown, then several other vets voted for him just to get him to talk, you yourself didn't give a reason for voting for H8 other than "I'll follow the consensus"... Crown made a post a little later specifying that the votes for H8 were not intended to lynch him but rather just to get him to claim. if the rest of us had hopped on the bandwagon and lynched him before he did claim and he turned out to be town those of us voting last would have been accused of being suspicious also.
This is why I didn't vote for him, there was no reason to believe he was mafia, he just wasn't talking much. Once he did claim townie everyone unvoted him, as there was no reason to believe he was anything but town. Unless I missed more "coded language" there was no reason to vote for H8 over anyone else that early.
I'm telling all the townies I know 100% for sure joak is a townie & if Sirius is going to prove he's the reviver I'll unvotemookiemcgee wrote:I would like to Vote Joak . He has been on many people suspicious lists, and my gut tells me hes scum. He did vote H8 but thats about the only thing he's done that doesnt look scummy to me.
I'm rather confused about everyone else...
I'm still somewhat suspicious of DB4 and jusplay and killum. Although killum I do believe is town for now
I'm not ready to vote for Sirius, I think he is cornered and either he revives someone overnight or he gets lynched tomorrow.
Charm has claimed town over and over. Since I have seen no evidence towards her just suspicion she will stay on my list.
I'm still concerned that Crown is a "pide piper" leading all the newb townies down the wrong path. But everything he says seems legit to this new guy
King ed, I'm super confused as if hes truthful or not...
Legion I'm still uncertain about, he seems legit also but i just dont have a good enough read on this game yet.
I guess almost everyone is on my list, although I think tuffy is townie, and probably crown and sirius also(even though they are at odds)... Gabs also seems Town, plus if TC is truthful we have Gabs at 100% town...
fp'd legion

Thanks Sirius, it helps that I'm paranoid IRL!SiriusCowKing wrote:King Ed's claim that joak is townie with no evidence to back it up can only mean 3 things. He is the inventor or skitzo and discovered that he was a good guy, they are both mason brothers, or they are both mafias. Since I think that joak is connected to AFK, that would mean they are mafia. More than that, joak is the one who was pushing for me to get lynched before I had the chance to revive anyone, yet did not vote for me. I believe he would rather not take any blame once the reviver is lost.
If I have to put a priority order in my suspects list, it would go like this:
Joak
King Edward 3rd
Charm
jusplay4fun
legionnare
side note: I am impressed at your skills legionnare since this is your first game. It shows that you read a lot about the mafia game and that you are trying hard. You get an auto invite to any future games for sure
So from this I gather that KE3 and Joak are 66% townie 33% Mafia. I'm not sure if that is good enough odds for me to vote either way.SiriusCowKing wrote:King Ed's claim that joak is townie with no evidence to back it up can only mean 3 things. He is the inventor or skitzo and discovered that he was a good guy, they are both mason brothers, or they are both mafias. Since I think that joak is connected to AFK, that would mean they are mafia. More than that, joak is the one who was pushing for me to get lynched before I had the chance to revive anyone, yet did not vote for me. I believe he would rather not take any blame once the reviver is lost.
charm wrote:Correction...
VOTE JUSPLAY4FUN
If I get it wrong this time, you all know exactly who I mean.
There's a 4th thing it could mean & if I come right out & say it I would need you the reviver???? the next day. At 1st I believed you but when you keep targeting townies & townies with a role that makes me believe TC was right about you with that being said I Vote SiriusSiriusCowKing wrote:King Ed's claim that joak is townie with no evidence to back it up can only mean 3 things. He is the inventor or skitzo and discovered that he was a good guy, they are both mason brothers, or they are both mafias. Since I think that joak is connected to AFK, that would mean they are mafia. More than that, joak is the one who was pushing for me to get lynched before I had the chance to revive anyone, yet did not vote for me. I believe he would rather not take any blame once the reviver is lost.
If I have to put a priority order in my suspects list, it would go like this:
Joak
King Edward 3rd
Charm
jusplay4fun
legionnare
side note: I am impressed at your skills legionnare since this is your first game. It shows that you read a lot about the mafia game and that you are trying hard. You get an auto invite to any future games for sure
Odds of each possibility are not that simple, some of them are more probable.legionnare wrote:So from this I gather that KE3 and Joak are 66% townie 33% Mafia. I'm not sure if that is good enough odds for me to vote either way.
Although joak has yet to fully come out and say why he didn't vote H8 so he's 50/50 at the moment.
Don't pretend that you're the cop, we all know it's someone else. If you haven't figured it out, I'm not gonna say it out loud because then the other mafias might not have figured it out either.King Edward 3rd wrote:There's a 4th thing it could mean & if I come right out & say it I would need you the reviver

legionnare wrote:Nothing posted for 10 hours? Hmmm... I'm going to trust Sirius for the now, it's entirely possible that he mis-read and got mixed up when he was ill and posting (how are you feeling by the way? better I hope?)
Charm has given a good enough reason for me to back down
Joak I'm still undecided about, he has yet to straight-up say why he never voted H8 like the other 3 on my list.
Jusplay has been rather silent since our little spat on the first day so my suspicion is again groing
KE3 although posting regularly is seeming suspicious and now tops my list
So unvote vote KE3