Re: (GON 3rd game)Town wins. Day 5

[jusplay4fun]

I agree with Kill.

I haven't had much to add, just waitin on King Ed's claim.

[jusplay4fun]

I have to say this: unlike my first Mafia game GoN Mafia #2), that dragged on before Christmas with an intermission for the Holidays, this game has moved so much more quickly and is "funner" because the pace is getting good now.
Good work all.

I think DB4 said it already, everyone doing well, even the noobs. We have not had to spend time trying to get several to participate. I read and try to understand; I jus try to limit my posts to something useful and relevant.

Mike

[jusplay4fun]

Here it is.....

I TOTALLY agree with DB4 on this one.....well said DB4.

Mike

Code: Select all

I for one would like to take a moment to say that I think this group of players is the best yet! Even a couple of the newbs are holding their own. Well done so far guys/includes you in context Charm (1 of the guys )!
That said, here are my top three suspect scum at the moment:

1. Joak - Just plain slippery and a lot of dancing going on
2. King Ed - Come to think he's evasive and over defensive...maybe
3. Moo - Very confusing at times...maybe just his no feeling well

[jusplay4fun]

I agree on the "this group of players is the best yet!"

I am still thinking about suspects, but I am NOT sure about his list, entirely.....JUS TO clarify any confusion as to what I meant on previous post......

Mike

[King Edward 3rd]

12 players it takes 7 to lynch.Next deadline. Wed 2nd April. 23.59 Central Alba time.

Vote Count
Sirius- King.ed, 1
Charm- jusplay 1
King Ed- Kill, sirius, Gabseni, 3
jusplay- charm 1
Just over 3 days to go.

well with legionarres vote added to this vote count it looks like you can hang my uniform & badge on the tree that you all hang me from. I liked being the survivor in my 1st game nobody wanted to kill me because it didn't help either group. I had fun in my 2nd. game & will be talking to you from the spirit world. FP,ed by Sirius

If this isn't a full claim then this is (I'm the regular town cop It was nice playing with you idiots that either can't or won't read between the lines. I've dropped hints like my reg. job didn't pay enough for what I do for the town. Also I said that I had to go during the day to do my side remodeling job on the shops because I was going on night turn on my reg. town job. then the post above. I also vouched for joak & said I was 100 % sure he was a townie!!!!!!!! So go ahead & hang me you bunch of stupid townies the mafia will like you guys because they won't have to waste a kill on me. Well Tuffy now I know how you felt last game trying to let people know what you found out at night without giving away your role. @ Bantam is it cold in the spirit world because it looks like I'll be coming to join you. Good job townies hang another one of your own

[SiriusCowKing]

I have already given my inputs several times already, nothing changed since I posted my list of suspects. I can still add 1 more thought, my list of who I am absolutely sure of being townie:
Gabsensei
TheCrown

And sorry that I have been confusing. The posts while I have been sick, yes I agree that I contradict myself a lot. The other posts, some small miss wording mistakes, but if you take my corrections in consideration, I don't see why it would be confusing.

FP'ed by King Edward 3rd

[King Edward 3rd]

King Ed, I've mentioned it before, and I've said that I had something to do with H8 dying... you don't need to throw out other ideas about it. No one will be coming out and saying that I am wrong, of that I can guarantee.

King Ed, your under-reaction to people voting you and saying you are not cop is uncharacteristic of you.

Vote King Ed for not being convincing. I have had my suspicions about you earlier in the game, now you seem to not be putting up much arguments. I want your FULL claim before we lynch you. No "hinting" at what you are, just tell us exactly what you are and what you found out on night 1.

This is the 2nd game for me & why do I have to claim my power role & you don't your starting to piss me off like the last game I guess I have to have a melt down before you believe me

[SiriusCowKing]

Do we believe that claim and unvote?

[Gabsensei]

unvote vote charm

well in case he is the cop i will unvote and i go on charm even if she did called she was regular townie but she is still a big mystery to me :S

[SiriusCowKing]

unvote vote charm

well in case he is the cop i will unvote and i go on charm even if she did called she was regular townie but she is still a big mystery to me :S

Yeah, I don't think Ed is lying there, and I would like to test him too. Ed, I will unvote but I need you to check on TC. If you can confirm that he is town, without saying if he got a power role, then it will also confirm that you are a townie and that gab is one too. More than that, it would build up a trust bound that every townie will be able to follow up to, something that will lead the town to victory in the end.

As for charm, well she's on my list too. So I will follow gab's example and vote charm, nothing personal.

[charm]

Oh geez, of course I'm a mystery! I'm a sexy dingy chick with a geeky intelligent side. Oh, and for your info Crown, you did recruit my husband and me independently! And he loves BigMacs!! So, if I get killed, you guys will still have a deep dark mystery to solve. Who is CHARM married to in GoN?


I promise I'm just a town girl, I'll even get sparkle nail polish tomorrow if that will help prove my innocents.
Honestly, I wish I were mafia or a crazy town person - you all know I would have had so much fun with those roles (not rolls)!


Sirius will you please resurrect me if I'm killed?

[TheCrown]

So, do we have a counter-claim to cop?

What happened to this Sirius, when you were talking to King Ed?

Don't pretend that you're the cop, we all know it's someone else. If you haven't figured it out, I'm not gonna say it out loud because then the other mafias might not have figured it out either.

You seemed so sure that there was a cop and it wasn't king Ed...now you're off voting somewhere else.... So, let me get this straight... Sirius, by his words or lack of, has pretty much revealed who the town cop and doc are? Are you kidding me? I want answers and I want them now Sirius. I thought you knew of another cop...

THIS IS WHY WE SHOULD HAVE HUNG SIRIUS BACK THEN, EXACTLY THIS! HE IS CAUSING MORE PROBLEMS!

[legionnare]

For now I'm willing to believe KE3 so unvote
He is behaving the same way he did in the last game when he was being voted on as Survivor and got lynched (I didn't participate but I did read through it - yes all 80 odd pages)

[legionnare]

@Legionnare: I already explained why I was silent on day 2.

Fair enough, all you said was that you were still feeling new to this, as per others who are posting rarely I get that it is hard to have input when the players are playing so well and it's a hard choice. But as far as I have counted you have posted the least on Day 2 (I'm probably wrong, and if so I apologise).

[legionnare]

Right we are getting close to Lynchday (41ish hours and counting) so we need to make a choice.

Charm - Consistently claiming Regular Townie, posts are less quirky and random - a sign that she is trying to blend in to avoid attention? (surely against her nature! )

DB4 - Staying off the radar, posts are mainly conforming to others ideas - rarely (if at all, feel free to correct me) contributing fresh ideas as to other players identities

Gabsensei - Mostly following TC's lead, Mason Brothers or Mafia Brothers? Changed vote to charm (a target of charm's)

Jusplay - Been quiet but claims still feeling his way in the game, again acted aggressively to my post earlier (didn't even vote that time) once I pointed this out he posts 4 calm posts agreeing with Kill's POV (nothing to add until KE3 claims) and DB4's appraisal of the game so far.

Kill - Had a tiff (look it up) with Tuffy early in Day 2, silent since other than to say he is waiting on KE3 claim

KE3 - forced to claim Townie Cop I've already posted that I am willing to believe him for the time being

Mookie - Still feeling out the game, I believe that he is town, he adequately explained his lack of vote on H8 to me

Joak - Vouched for by KE3, if true then townie, if KE3 is lying then scum ( I doubt scum would bring this sort of attention on 2 of their number when 1 is already dead so again willing to believe he town for the time being)

Tuffy - absolutely no read on him, other than his tiff (look it up) with Kill at the start of Day 2 little input

Sirius - Cornered, either he revives during the night or he is lynched next day (based on posts by TC et al)

TC - Pushing Sirius and others for a full claim (none of this 'read between the lines' claim nonsense) but not claiming himself, says it would be detrimental if he did but as far as I can tell the strongest Townie power roles have been claimed so what is left for him to claim? I'm aware from last game this is standard play from him, but all the same, every game is different and as others have said (including TC) previous games have no impact on this one.

Vote TC - what's your role? Enough with the avoiding, out with it.

[legionnare]

Right we are getting close to Lynchday (41ish hours and counting) so we need to make a choice.

Charm - Consistently claiming Regular Townie, posts are less quirky and random - a sign that she is trying to blend in to avoid attention? (surely against her nature! )

DB4 - Staying off the radar, posts are mainly conforming to others ideas - rarely (if at all, feel free to correct me) contributing fresh ideas as to other players identities

Gabsensei - Mostly following TC's lead, Mason Brothers or Mafia Brothers? Changed vote to charm (a target of charm's)

Jusplay - Been quiet but claims still feeling his way in the game, again acted aggressively to my post earlier (didn't even vote that time) once I pointed this out he posts 4 calm posts agreeing with Kill's POV (nothing to add until KE3 claims) and DB4's appraisal of the game so far.

Kill - Had a tiff (look it up) with Tuffy early in Day 2, silent since other than to say he is waiting on KE3 claim

KE3 - forced to claim Townie Cop I've already posted that I am willing to believe him for the time being

Mookie - Still feeling out the game, I believe that he is town, he adequately explained his lack of vote on H8 to me

Joak - Vouched for by KE3, if true then townie, if KE3 is lying then scum ( I doubt scum would bring this sort of attention on 2 of their number when 1 is already dead so again willing to believe he town for the time being)

Tuffy - absolutely no read on him, other than his tiff (look it up) with Kill at the start of Day 2 little input

Sirius - Cornered, either he revives during the night or he is lynched next day (based on posts by TC et al)

TC - Pushing Sirius and others for a full claim (none of this 'read between the lines' claim nonsense) but not claiming himself, says it would be detrimental if he did but as far as I can tell the strongest Townie power roles have been claimed so what is left for him to claim? I'm aware from last game this is standard play from him, but all the same, every game is different and as others have said (including TC) previous games have no impact on this one.

Vote TC - what's your role? Enough with the avoiding, out with it.

[legionnare]

P.S. I don't know why but it keeps double posting for me (no lag at my end), only push the 'Submit' button once...

[legionnare]

Gabsensei - Mostly following TC's lead, Mason Brothers or Mafia Brothers? Changed vote to charm (a target of charm's) - should read - a target of TC's

[joak]

Av never met such a bunch o liars in ma life you lot could sell snow tae the Eskimos ....lol.. Anyhow Sirius hasn't resurrected anyone tc isn't claiming charms wandering about flaunting herself ledionaire thinks we are all shite im sticking with Sirius he needs to resurrect for me

[SiriusCowKing]

Oh geez, of course I'm a mystery! I'm a sexy dingy chick with a geeky intelligent side. Oh, and for your info Crown, you did recruit my husband and me independently! And he loves BigMacs!! So, if I get killed, you guys will still have a deep dark mystery to solve. Who is CHARM married to in GoN?
:-$ :-$ :-$

I promise I'm just a town girl, I'll even get sparkle nail polish tomorrow if that will help prove my innocents.
Honestly, I wish I were mafia or a crazy town person - you all know I would have had so much fun with those roles (not rolls)!


Sirius will you please resurrect me if I'm killed?

If you prove to be a townie, probably.

You seemed so sure that there was a cop and it wasn't king Ed...now you're off voting somewhere else.... So, let me get this straight... Sirius, by his words or lack of, has pretty much revealed who the town cop and doc are? Are you kidding me? I want answers and I want them now Sirius. I thought you knew of another cop...

THIS IS WHY WE SHOULD HAVE HUNG SIRIUS BACK THEN, EXACTLY THIS! HE IS CAUSING MORE PROBLEMS!

Why so eager for me to reveal who I thought the cop was? By the way, I thought it was you. Either the cop or something else which I will not name, in case no one got it.

[SiriusCowKing]

Joak, I can only resurrect at night. Voting for me now would be killing the chance that I have of resurrecting.

[joak]

Bloody hell im uber confused now ok but I still don't know why you want me out

[Killuminati19]

Wow, this day is getting more and more confused. unvote

I don't think we have a good handle on anyone being mafia. Mafia is sure getting a lot of good information on us. I don't feel compelled to vote anyone at the moment. I'm starting to believe Charm is a regular townie.
If Moo doesn't use his supposed reviving powers tonight, he is an immediate lynch. But why on earth did you make that comment to King Ed about him not being the cop, only to believe him when he claimed cop?
I believe TC and Gab are town. I also believe King Ed, and by association, Joak.
Perhaps Tuffy and DB4 should be revisited. A lot of blending in. Justplay continues to be on my list of suspects as well.

[SiriusCowKing]

I wasnt sure about king ed because I thought that TC was the cop. Gab believes that ed is telling the truth and I trust gab. Anyway I know what TC is now because of a later post that he wrote, and so it would make sense that ed is the cop. I think we can rule that joak is something town as long as ed is town. I still hope you check on TC for us ed, will you?

[SiriusCowKing]

I wasnt sure about king ed because I thought that TC was the cop. Gab believes that ed is telling the truth and I trust gab. Anyway I know what TC is now because of a later post that he wrote, and so it would make sense that ed is the cop. I think we can rule that joak is something town as long as ed is town. I still hope you check on TC for us ed, will you?