To recap on kgb's activity so far this game.
First post: Joke vote, does not count as contribution.
kgb007 wrote:X-Stor-X wrote:id like to skip the joke phase....
Why? Something to hide?
vote xstor bc I can
Second post: March 23rd, adds a little to what was going on at the time. But no reads given really, just a bit of talk on what the opening scene could mean.
kgb007 wrote:Lol for the record my vote against xstor was a joke vote although that doesn't seem to be in question at the moment.
@xstor yes I have a question for you - are you scum? (Note the sarcasm) congrats on moving beyond the joke vote stage rather quickly
@jak where was the overreaction? He responded to a post regarding him/his play, maybe he's town maybes he's not but didn't xstor have the chance to respond to posts regarding himself?
As for the multiple factions I didn't read it as more than two but I could have interpreted it wrong I'm playing on my phone so quoting is a pain but the last line of the opening scene naming the new party read to me as the same people that the mod opened the paragraph with
Anyways... unvote and carry on
Third post: March 24th, Restates he does not think there are more than one multi-player factions against town.
kgb007 wrote:Correct mud, I doubt there are 2 (multiple players-non town) factions against town, I've usually played with a SK, only 15 players and I didn't interpret opening scene as had been previously stated
Fourth post: March 27th, mentions he's been on vacation, mentions he has not read up to the point of his post.
kgb007 wrote:Been on vacation in the Dominica republic since Sunday, back home tmw night, the novels of posts since Monday made it unappealing to keep up on my phone, seems like you guys are doing just fine without me for now
Fifth post: March 29th, first real good post he's made in the game about his reads and what not.
kgb007 wrote:relax xstor, i was on vacation sunday to friday, flew back late friday night and active in another mafia, all from my phone, you can understand (i hope) if i don't want to read through D1 posts with a full complement of players posting especially when i don't have anything important to say only to have to re-read in a sober state to remember once i return home anyway
personally i don't care for nark's play style, too emotional for me. i think some know nark to play this way and troll him for these types of responses. i've never been big on forums before bc it can devolve into these types of arguments.
i can't remember who said of nark's premature claim that "it was probably going that way" with the voting behavior, we cannot assume this and i didn't like the unsolicited claim although the role and nark's meta fit his behavior
as for the group of people doubting jonty's vig claim bc of this supposed multi non town killing factions, i have 2 questions:
1) unless you know something town doesn't, why would you default to believing multi non-town killing factions based on the opening scene? obviously some of us didn't interpret it that way, so isn't there a chance the game will have the usual 1 scum faction?
2) would jonty still claim town vig if it's being widely considered that there are multi non town killing factions knowing that the vig claim may not relieve some of the pressure on him?
we'll know a lot more beginning on D2 based on the kill(s). jonty has already stated he won't be killing and i believe him. his role claim is worth revisiting assuming there was a second kill tonight
vote no lynch were we really going to find scum to lynch on D1 short of getting lucky?
Sixth post: April 1st, literally adds NOTHING to what's going on atm.
kgb007 wrote:ah come on xstor, you've never been lacking for epic novels words so far this game...LOL
With the tally of six posts after he confirmed, I personally find only find posts 2 and 5 to be "real" posts. The rest is one sentences or fillers.
Add onto that the days between each post and the only reads and thoughts he's given are on Anark case, Jonty case and how many factions there MIGHT be against town. (The anark case was a very brief two question part directed at me in his second post and the Jonty's case was on his 5th post).
Out of posts 2 and 5, I personally find 5th to be the only useful post (useful is different from real).
Right now he is presenting the very definition of scummarining. Few posts (days apart), little to no insight on his/her thoughts and opinions on the game and current cases/new cases. (In fact 0 new cases are brought up by him/her).
So, if it wasn't for RD's odd claim that I think people want to see what it really flips (I think new player with a bad claim as mafia), I'd be voting you kgb. At least RD is trying to post as a new player, you're not.
FOS kgb.
FP'd by MudPuppy
