Moderator: Community Team

You should block Neb. He's scum. And it's more than a hunch.SiriusCowKing wrote:Hey, do we have an anti-town count in storms end? because 3 of the people there are dead and they were all townies. The remaining ones alive are: nebuchadnezer, pancakemix, and me. I can prove that I am town by roleblocking the target that you want me to like I just said. Which means that 1 or both of the 2 others are mafia. FOS and I think we should look into that as soon as possible.
aage wrote:Never trust CYOC or pancake.
Now we're getting somewhere! I will put my KP on him! I can 100% be checked. Feel free to do it tonight if you'd like. YES! OMG SO HAPPYpancakemix wrote:You should block Neb. He's scum. And it's more than a hunch.SiriusCowKing wrote:Hey, do we have an anti-town count in storms end? because 3 of the people there are dead and they were all townies. The remaining ones alive are: nebuchadnezer, pancakemix, and me. I can prove that I am town by roleblocking the target that you want me to like I just said. Which means that 1 or both of the 2 others are mafia. FOS and I think we should look into that as soon as possible.
I am Tywin Lannister. I can use my wealth to learn someone's alignment, but there's a catch: Other Lannisters will return as town regardless of alignment. I investigated Neb N1 to see if there was someone I could trust in Storm's End. Turns out he's anti town. I checked Jak/Robik N2 and was roleblocked. With the roleblocks out now, I'm thouroughly confused. My guess is that Robik can't be checked, like Zivel. N3 I got a town result on Pretender (and I hinted at this during the day). I knew either he or Neb was Joffrey (in case you didn't piece it together the throne was in Storm's End) but I didn't know if Joffrey was a "Lannister" or not. Based on my result N3, I take it he was.
Why am I telling you this now? Frankly, I'm feeling a bit chicken.Plus we were having pretty good luck before yesterday and I was thinking about doing it then but I didn't.
So yeah. Block Neb.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
Votes pretender (uncool):pancakemix wrote:That actually makes perfect sense as for Arya. That, and I'd expect a counter by now regardless. I buy it.mtamburini wrote:Your claim is perfect as mafia, immune to checks? How convenient. You can only kill people you know the username and Character name of? You could be a mafia cop that gets back exact roles. I am not convinced.
Translation: You voted Zivel because it's convenient.You don't have a reason except it's the most available lynch.The whole thing of "Voting together" was brought up by someone else and somehow I got pinned as the one to suggest it. I have said point blank that the second I find out any of you are anti-town I'll push for your head but until then I'd rather us work a little bit together instead of fighting like all the other cities are doing. 6 heads are better than 1.
Though now I have suspicion on AoG, he has sort of sheeped with Zivel against me. Maybe because if we do effectively work together in the way I suggested we'd be eliminating mafia in every city that we confirm 3-4 of them town. Leaving the last 2-3 up for lynching.[/quote
1. How d you have any idea what the other cities are doing?
2. You're now "suspicious" of someone just because they confirmed what was going on in the topic? Clearly these two don't see eye to eye on the whole of things. Saying they're both after you is just bogus.
3. Voting NL will get us nowhere. I know you have an opinion, you may as well voice it, even if you have been caught with your pants down.
I voted Zivel because
a. WE are running out of time in this day
b. We spent all of the time this day on zivel-oriented business
c. If we find out what he is with his alignmenent, city etc we can use all of the other incidents of the day to see how they align or go against
So many options, only one vote... I'll ##Vote Jak since there seems to be some dishonesty and deflection going on here that I don't like. FOS on Pretender and Slight FOS on mtam.
Votes pershy (cool):pancakemix wrote:Mmm, yeah I'm going to ##Vote Pretender. I could point to any number of reasons over the past two reasons as a good one, but they just keep comin'. This new Zivel business is more than enough on its own...
Defends me on d3 when he got RB'd, and thinks that I'm 3p/scum (weird):pancakemix wrote:Well, it's certainly worth testing. ##Unvote ##Vote Pershy
What do we do if this ends up not being the truth? Or, perhaps a better question, what do we do if it ends up being true?
Same thing as above:pancakemix wrote:Don't care about Robik. He clearly hasn't read yet, we're just not in the mood for the jokes because we're well past that stage. If it keeps up tomorrow I'll worry about it.
Votes SCK (most likely uncool):pancakemix wrote:It's Robik. I say hold your fire. As much as I'd like to prove your claim, Robik shouldn't just get offed as soon as he comes in.Zivel wrote:So we doing this? I am willing to shoot poor ole pershy for a double lynch, who is next on the chopping block?
Finally votes Neb --> this is the first time he's mentioned Neb ALL GAME:pancakemix wrote:...that doesn't make any sense at all. Charm doesn't have to be a roleblocker. It's just theoretical and doesn't mean anything one way or the other. Also:SiriusCowKing wrote:Sounds like the best lead. Funny thing is, varys is charm, and I had my votes on her from day 2. I will go ahead and ##vote charm. I hope people listen to me more next time I have a theory.
For those who still doesn't get it, here is how I knew charm was anti-town from day 2:
-Night 1, charm and strike wolf get roleblocked, only 1 kill occurs. We now know that strike wolf is town so charm is the anti-town that was denied a kill.
-Night 2, the mafia roleblocker admits blocking bunnies, which we know was town. 2 kills occur. There was only 1 roleblock this night but there are many possibilities of why only 1 roleblock.
-Night 3, only 1 kill occurs but IAmRobik admits trying on legion and legion comes out saying his role had resilience. This proves that the normal amount of kills per night is 2, so a kill was indeed blocked in night 1. So far no one claims to have been roleblocked.
Legion's theory is that she would be the town roleblock, which actually makes me think he's trying to protect her and thus they are both mafia. If she was the town roleblocker, how could there be 2 roleblocks night 1. If it was the case, she would have been prevented from using her power and thus strike wolf would not have been roleblocked.
So no, no you're not reading, because that says that it's not charm who was tracked/potential RB.SiriusCowKing wrote:4-page 38:Do YOU even read the thread?legionnare wrote:@Betiko, the person I tracked was not charm. With that in mind I have to go with my first assumption of the powers of the person I tracked; that s/he has protective powers or roleblocking. As s/he visited crasp the first day and he still lived following day would suggest this, we have already taken out the mafia RB so the possibility remains that s/he is the Town Roleblocker.
S/he is of more use to town than I am so I will take his/her name with me to the grave regardless of what you do. Their identity must be protected at all costs considering the potential power of their role.
##Vote Sirius for some major skimmings.
@AoG: Have you forgotten that we can't lynch betiko even if we wanted to? My understanding is betiko is just the messenger anyway and this is something the Dread Fort is privvy to. (Am I wrong? Correct me if I am). If you're really that distrusting of Betiko, demand his name as collateral.
Knowing Jak, he probably tried (or learned his lesson from CYOC3...)Except for the fact that I said that I don't know if JAK targeted anyone n1/n2. Some people are scared to vigi shoot early in games because they don't have enough information. Maybe he did shoot someone and I shot someone else. I don't know.
If Neb Is mafia, I think this is bad for bunnies:pancakemix wrote:You realize I've posted at least once per (24 hr) day today right? And that I've been vocal about my reads and opinions both here and in the QT through those posts?@pancake – Hi. Nice to see you every once in a while.
I'm actually pretty surprised you were in favor of a charm lynch, especially since that's why you're voting Sirius, isn't it? Trying to start an easy wagon on her? Maybe that has little to do with her specifically, but if you thought she was scummy why not go along? While I'm at it, why not bring up the fact that you knew full well that charm was town and know how she plays, but your first reaction as soon as Crasp flipped was to out her as Varys? Charm had an eye on you and I don't think that was unfounded. Call it a hunch.
You wanted me, here I am.
##Unvote
##Vote Neb
1. I don't see that Legion posted his character name anywhere.boonetown wrote:Zivel, i had asked you about your shot twice and wanted you to talk to me about it before shooting. I hinted that i thought it should be discussed that the shot could be on legion instead... why did you not even bother to talk to me or discuss it...
2. You also said that he should go for Charm. So...
Conclusion: I'm not sure that it all adds up. I'm not sure why he would out this in the night instead of 1) yesterday 2) during the day tomorrow or right before the night ends. Having said that, I don't have too much of a reason to doubt him. In a setup of 24 people, I'd assume there are 6-7 scum and 2 are dead. It is unlikely that this claim will win the game for scum considering there was only 1KP last night. I think I'm willing to believe him and lynch neb tomorrow and reevaluate based off of the flip -- we do have his role name so Zivel can take care of him should neb flip town.pancakemix wrote:I gave my reasons. You probably should stop forgetting about this game.27ninjabunnies wrote:Also, why are there votes on Neb?
He's more likely town than not town.
His posting is actually been really good.
Fp by betiko
Hooray for double posts!
I did consider it, but I had other considerations. I was interested in SCK's case, for instance. I was just hinting at my results hoping someone would pick up, but I'm now reminded why I hate subtle hints.IAmRobik wrote:Why didn't you just come out yesterday and we could have lynched him!!!!!!
That, to me, seemed unwise. Better to quietly collect information rather than just announce it. Perhaps that will tell you why I've been keeping a lower-than-usual profile.strike wolf wrote:If youve had this information since N1, why didnt you mention it until now?
aage wrote:Never trust CYOC or pancake.
I repeated it for robik, not you, I should have clarified and I am not checked out, dont worry.Epitaph1 wrote:You should read the entire paragraph before jumping on a couple of sentences. You just reiterated what I had already said.boonetown wrote:but seeing as though everyone was assuming that the three left in kings landing were TOWN, why would anyone try to change my action at night at all? doesnt seem particularly towny.Epitaph1 wrote:
Re: boone's action. I don't think it's sound to assume that whoever used an action on boone last night is scum. The reason is because we've already knocked off a scum BD and RB, what other disruptive roles could they have and remain balanced? Again, it strikes me as overpowerful to give the mafia 3 roles that could majorly eff will town's results--admittedly, this is speculation on my part. The main reason last night's action on boone is scummy is that boone is one of the KL 3 who is mostly cleared. I don't think it was prudent to use a disruptive ability on one of the people from KL at this point.
FP'd by many
boone and bunnies seem to have checked out since they were cleared.
Anyway, no point in keeping my vote on charm. I think SCK has been the scummiest of the remaining players. Vote SCK
fp'd
Okay, I'll skip all the other stuff since my last post and jump right to this. That's a nice claim, pancake, but it doesn't add up at all. Why? I am Jaime Lannister, the kingslayer. Don't believe me? We can pull Cersei Lannister into this, if you like. My lover (both in the books and in this game as a lover mechanic). Cersei and I have been in a QT all game long sharing information and ideas. I will not out Cersie yet, but at this point, if you kill me, you kill Cersei. What is my power? Besides lover with Cersei, I have a .5 KP each night. I must apologize for being the cause of Hotshot's death. I hit him N1 because I thought he was off, and Cersei agreed that it wouldn't matter to bring him down to .5 life left. After the events of day 2, I thought he got off easy and flew under the radar. Cersei and I decided it would be okay if I hit him again. Thus his death N2. N3 I hit Jweidlin...that dude has been so far under the radar this game, and again doing a .5 KP doesn't kill anyone.pancakemix wrote:You should block Neb. He's scum. And it's more than a hunch.SiriusCowKing wrote:Hey, do we have an anti-town count in storms end? because 3 of the people there are dead and they were all townies. The remaining ones alive are: nebuchadnezer, pancakemix, and me. I can prove that I am town by roleblocking the target that you want me to like I just said. Which means that 1 or both of the 2 others are mafia. FOS and I think we should look into that as soon as possible.
I am Tywin Lannister. I can use my wealth to learn someone's alignment, but there's a catch: Other Lannisters will return as town regardless of alignment. I investigated Neb N1 to see if there was someone I could trust in Storm's End. Turns out he's anti town. I checked Jak/Robik N2 and was roleblocked. With the roleblocks out now, I'm thouroughly confused. My guess is that Robik can't be checked, like Zivel. N3 I got a town result on Pretender (and I hinted at this during the day). I knew either he or Neb was Joffrey (in case you didn't piece it together the throne was in Storm's End) but I didn't know if Joffrey was a "Lannister" or not. Based on my result N3, I take it he was.
Why am I telling you this now? Frankly, I'm feeling a bit chicken.Plus we were having pretty good luck before yesterday and I was thinking about doing it then but I didn't.
So yeah. Block Neb.
What is that bolded part? How would I know how Charm plays? I think I was in one maybe two games with her, and we both died N1 in one of them. So, if you want to bring up the Charm case, let's do it. Why did I think she was scum?pancakemix wrote:You realize I've posted at least once per (24 hr) day today right? And that I've been vocal about my reads and opinions both here and in the QT through those posts?@pancake – Hi. Nice to see you every once in a while.
I'm actually pretty surprised you were in favor of a charm lynch, especially since that's why you're voting Sirius, isn't it? Trying to start an easy wagon on her? Maybe that has little to do with her specifically, but if you thought she was scummy why not go along? While I'm at it, why not bring up the fact that you knew full well that charm was town and know how she plays, but your first reaction as soon as Crasp flipped was to out her as Varys? Charm had an eye on you and I don't think that was unfounded. Call it a hunch.
You wanted me, here I am.
##Unvote
##Vote Neb
How does proving yourself a roleblocker give us any info on your alignment???SiriusCowKing wrote:I can prove that I am town by roleblocking the target that you want me to like I just said. Which means that 1 or both of the 2 others are mafia. FOS and I think we should look into that as soon as possible.
I can understand you wanting to collect more info before revealing but you still haven't answered robik's question about why not wait 'til tomorrow??? Why out yourself tonight when you could have revealed another read tomorrow? Do you think you were are target tonight? You are now but I'm not sure you would have been before.pancakemix wrote:I did consider it, but I had other considerations. I was interested in SCK's case, for instance. I was just hinting at my results hoping someone would pick up, but I'm now reminded why I hate subtle hints.IAmRobik wrote:Why didn't you just come out yesterday and we could have lynched him!!!!!!
That, to me, seemed unwise. Better to quietly collect information rather than just announce it. Perhaps that will tell you why I've been keeping a lower-than-usual profile.strike wolf wrote:If youve had this information since N1, why didnt you mention it until now?
We already killed the mafia roleblocker and the bus driver. Do you really think there would be 2 mafia roleblocker and a bus driver? How much OP is that!MudPuppy wrote:How does proving yourself a roleblocker give us any info on your alignment???SiriusCowKing wrote:I can prove that I am town by roleblocking the target that you want me to like I just said. Which means that 1 or both of the 2 others are mafia. FOS and I think we should look into that as soon as possible.

The reason this stuck out to me was that unless there's a town bus driver, this wouldn't make sense because it would appear that Boone's actions were altered by Pretender (no way to verify this now).So, Pancake. It all comes back to your crap claim that you got a guilty on me. I am a Lannister. According to your claim, there is no way you got a guilty on me...unless the Bus driver or Pretender messed with your results. Care to rethink your claim?
StorrZerg wrote: i find no joy in this

I guess i was right (i made a mistake with kgb and removed him the post after) the throne was either pretender either neb... And they must ve taken the decision together.betiko wrote:timestamps:
storr posted the VC and changed it 3 times.
storr posts at (I'm giving the timestamps on my browser) 17:13, modifies 3 times, last modification at 17:54
pretender posts at 17:32
neb posts at 17:37
kgb posts at 17:53 and casts a vote on me when it was proven that votes on me don't work.
I think it is extremely likely to think that one of these 3 has the throne, and we don't know crap about this throne.... I think that any alignment can have it to double vote anonymously.
Is it something that gets passed on easily? no idea. Do people kill for the throne?
fp

Actually, if you and neb work together and if you are actually both town, you guys can perform a kill tonight. It could work fine to kill pcm, but i am not fully convinced about the pcm case, although i m really not a fan of everything we just learned...IAmRobik wrote:Betiko, who do you think I should drop the KP on? Should I still target legion or should i put it on neb/pcm?
I think I wanna put the .5 on neb as a precaution, but could also be convinced to completely ignore that situation and let it play out

We didn't really vote on scum there. We only voted on our special bonuses. Pretender made the THRONE votes all on his own it would appear. I thought Pancake was on the throne due to our first day vote, but I only inquired if Pancake made the vote, and didn't really push any further, as I thought the throne seemed town aligned. Otherwise, the conversation was who we leaned toward as scum, and most of that was repeated in the main thread here. PCM was fairly quiet in our QT.betiko wrote:I guess i was right (i made a mistake with kgb and removed him the post after) the throne was either pretender either neb... And they must ve taken the decision together.betiko wrote:timestamps:
storr posted the VC and changed it 3 times.
storr posts at (I'm giving the timestamps on my browser) 17:13, modifies 3 times, last modification at 17:54
pretender posts at 17:32
neb posts at 17:37
kgb posts at 17:53 and casts a vote on me when it was proven that votes on me don't work.
I think it is extremely likely to think that one of these 3 has the throne, and we don't know crap about this throne.... I think that any alignment can have it to double vote anonymously.
Is it something that gets passed on easily? no idea. Do people kill for the throne?
fp
Storm s end: how was the voting for scums in your qt, how did pcm react to them?
aage wrote:Never trust CYOC or pancake.
Again, I have to go with the devil I know. I don't know the nature of it and neither do you. Even if there were a redirect, you must admit it doesn't clear him. If he's a Lannister as he claims, my investigation means nothing. He could just as easily be scum.IAmRobik wrote:You really didn't think it was important to out the possible mod error? Man, PCM, I'm not thrilled at all.
Cersei, I think you need to out to confirm what neb is saying to be true.
aage wrote:Never trust CYOC or pancake.