Alright, I'm willing to go on board with the Sempai case. Mainly because, in all the posts I've read, he defends himself by saying people misinterpret his posts. The misinterpretation argument is bad because Sempai uses it to change his own posts from 'taking a stance' to 'not relevant to the game'.
Examples:
I'm just saying...
Storr could 'potentially maybe' be useful 'later on', for no reason in particular. Sempai clearly says he doesn't want to lynch Storr, but on the other hand he claims he never 'defended' Storr and that he still has an FoS on Storr.
I never said....
Storr is distracting, yet he wastes posts on discussing and arguing with him. If he doesn't find him scummy, and only finds him distracting, then why does he let himself be distracted?
Also note he'd rather get rid of the guy who claimed town vig than the guy who claimed powerless 3rd party because "he could be potentially more helpful". There's a load of bullshit if I ever saw one.
Then there's this post:
sempaispellcheck wrote:Also, has anyone noticed how Storr is accusing BG of getting distracted and not looking for scum, and did the same to me when I voted for him?
Smells to me like he's intentionally distracting people just so he can call them out for getting distracted - laying traps just to see who falls into them?
I fell into his trap because I'm new, and BG fell in just because of his dislike for Storr's playstyle.
As far as I can tell, the only possible scum Storr's pointed out is mtam - and mtam drew enough attention to himself.
I still think mtam needs to go, but I'm not so sure I trust Storr anymore.
sempai
Laying traps just to see who falls into them is normal mafia play, especially for Storr since he believes you don't find mafia by hanging around. And he's right, you don't.
I haven't seen a lot of merit in the case on Degaston, maybe Sempais alignment will help to get a read on him but I doubt it. I've seen people (eg. Strike) suggest there's a connection between the two but I don't see it.
Pixar is a potential lynch because of the no-lynch suggestion, followed by "let's lynch either Storr or Mtam".
Ragian is slightly scummy in my opinion, his posts don't contain information relevant to the game other than boohoo I don't know the flavour. I expect he steps up his game a notch, because you don't have to know the flavour to find scummy players. If he doesn't, I'm very interested in pressuring him.
There's still this weird-ass post from Ton:
got tonkaed wrote:Dakky - want to let us all know why you think the mafia should be able to talk via pm during the daylight?
I really don't know what to do with this.
For now I'll
vote Sempai to see what he has to say in defense.
). Work is finally calming down. I was hoping to catch up today but it likely won't be 'til tomorrow. I've read all the posts but wanna spend some time analyzing... though it's mostly junk based on my first pass. While I wish I've had time to post more, I feel little sense of urgency to vote just yet. I just don't have a good feel of who is scum/town... not sure that will change much on D1 but my vote would be largely a guess at this point and I'd rather have time to convince myself there has actually been some scummy behavior.
