[Official] HP Mafia - MVP: Aage - Archive

[mtamburini]

[

I could get behind a senpai lynch if mine doesnt go through``

You basically are cool with chilling on the bandwagon that Storr and Streaker create. You then checked out of the thread. So if you want to hide behind saying that you never voted him cool.
But in reality if you go back to those pages where that whole thing starts up, you are involved in it.

Why is it that you can't explain the Raigan case or the soft claim? Why does it have to be an alignment question? If you can't answer the questions maybe you fake claimed like i think you did and we lynch all liars?

Already posted the case i started on Raigan,

[mtamburini]

I never said the 1st one wasnt an allignment question, I said 2 because it leads into 3 which is not an allignment question.

[mtamburini]

Did you think senpai was towny before he claimed some role that I have not read about yet

[got tonkaed]

Yeah the problem was that whole post you had was full of crap. Streaker immediately called you out.

Long story short - 1) what was the other detail that caused you to think raigan was weird? They had not interacted in a way that came out
2) You buddied up to Streaker who had notably town reads in a super passive way so that you could hop a bandwagon later and be able to say you claimed no part of it.
3) By explaining more about your ability we have a shot at being able to track it if things happen or don't happen night 1 with a bus driver. You can also cement it isnt a false claim.
4)you are the one trying to turn this into me claim hunting you which i am not doing, but if you dont say anything and just make a bunch of posts that eat up a ton of pages, it makes it hard town to follow and a make a fair call on if you live or die.

I did. I defended Sempai the whole time, because unlike you i have read the thread.

[mtamburini]

I KNOW YOURE READING THIS AT WORK BETCH YOU DIE TODAY OR TONIGHT CHOOSE STORR

You are so dumb. I've claimed 3rd party survivor, yet that's not obvious I guess. I'm under no post Restriction other than having fun and being sad I'm not with anyone.
I labeled you as scum (death eater ) because you are so late to jump on me being weird. You called it out, but didn't hound me till others jumped on me.


Can I please go back to my character? ??
I'm willing to town side, and give reads which I have been.
student = town read. Some people all ready figured me out.

I'd like to point out sempai since I'm out of character . Pushed me for being 3rd party possibly turning mafia latter. He was pushing an easy lynch. That obviously wouldn't show who is scum or not upon the flip. He jumps very quickly on mtamburini when he thinks I could be cop.
He isn't reading people.

As a group we have no idea if character indicates alignment. If it does, filch is obviously 3rd party. Doesn't give a shit about the students. Has been at hogwarts in bad times and good, his loyalties lie in the school because it accepted him as a Squib. Which also means I can't turn into a death eater because I lack magic. based on what I am I think it does indicate, and it means imo mafia have good fake claims. Like Voldemort fake claim could be hairy potter. Hence we need to be lynching people based on their scummy play.

I believe mafia to be death Eaters with fake claims as students. Or it could be no fake claims and alignment isn't indicative by flavor.

If this is true then you shall survive in the night good luck

My reasoning for targeting storr tonight simply stated here, well find out if hes lying or not

[got tonkaed]

Which is great if we don't know that there is a busdriver. So who cares if you say openly you will target him to find out if he is lying. All that your claim did was ensure a 3rd party survivor doesnt get lynched day one.

If there is a third party cult, and you and storr are members, it is a great way to ensure you get a free shot at someone night 1. If the whole thing about a kill wasn't real, which it would make sense as with a fake claim.

If it was a gambit for something else, you could have explained that earlier and didn't, so either you were really holding out, or it was never a gambit at all. Couple that with the non-case on Raigan and the willingness to buddy up to Streaker but not hop on the vote until later, I think you lied. I feel we should lynch you because you are a liar and thats what we do to liars.

[mtamburini]

Yeah the problem was that whole post you had was full of crap. Streaker immediately called you out.

Long story short - 1) what was the other detail that caused you to think raigan was weird? They had not interacted in a way that came out
2) You buddied up to Streaker who had notably town reads in a super passive way so that you could hop a bandwagon later and be able to say you claimed no part of it.
3) By explaining more about your ability we have a shot at being able to track it if things happen or don't happen night 1 with a bus driver. You can also cement it isnt a false claim.
4)you are the one trying to turn this into me claim hunting you which i am not doing, but if you dont say anything and just make a bunch of posts that eat up a ton of pages, it makes it hard town to follow and a make a fair call on if you live or die.

I did. I defended Sempai the whole time, because unlike you i have read the thread.

Post anything that I was around for that made him look town and I will post the things that make him look scummy.

And show me the buddying after I attacked him for not having my biggest scum read in his list.

[mtamburini]

Which is great if we don't know that there is a busdriver. So who cares if you say openly you will target him to find out if he is lying. All that your claim did was ensure a 3rd party survivor doesnt get lynched day one.

If there is a third party cult, and you and storr are members, it is a great way to ensure you get a free shot at someone night 1. If the whole thing about a kill wasn't real, which it would make sense as with a fake claim.

If it was a gambit for something else, you could have explained that earlier and didn't, so either you were really holding out, or it was never a gambit at all. Couple that with the non-case on Raigan and the willingness to buddy up to Streaker but not hop on the vote until later, I think you lied. I feel we should lynch you because you are a liar and thats what we do to liars.

So what does my claim have to do with the possibility of there being a busdriver? Why do you insist on talking about roles? Do you enjoy helping out the scum team ?

[degaston]

I didnt ask you how many games youve played, I asked you do you even know how to play the game?

Someone can play 100 games and still not know how to play.

Yet you think that after one beginner's game, I should know something about whether questions are related to agenda or alignment? I didn't vote for you because of tonka's questions, but because of your evasion of them. I think number 2 seems like a reasonable place to start - why did you soft claim? Was that supposed to help the town, and if so, how?

[Epitaph1]

VOTE COUNT

StorrZerg - dazza
mtamburini - sempai, sempai, virus, charm, skillful, madmitch, tonkaed, Pixar, BG, degaston (L-3)
Ragian - mtamburini, dd
charm - HotShot, Endgame, Ragian
pershy - floyd
dd- Talapus

With 24 alive, it takes 13 to lynch.

Deadline Friday, noon Eastern Time.

[got tonkaed]

So get this...Storr posts one thing in Filtch talk...and this is how raigan responds

Hell no! Are you insane!?

This is the only post that connected the two of them before you said one of the two of them was getting lynched. Yet as you posted, their interactions had been weird. Well this is the one interaction they had, must be super scummy for you to get that gem of a read.

Also you posted shortly after Streaker made the Sempai vote that you would be on board, Streaker had already been declared townie leaning before then, thus the buddy buddying.

I talk about the role because its a motivation for why you would make such a dumb claim. instead of not understanding it at all, you make a fake claim under teh set up to buy a fellow 3rd party person time.

[mtamburini]

Theres 2 ways of going about this tok, you can either make me claim or lynch me, both are going to make the scum team win. Im confident that you do not have a role similar to mine or you wouldve backed the f*ck off by now which leads me to believe you are not town. There are other people who have similar role pms like mine (I really do not have to soft it and I hope I accidentally have not) but if I have then the people who are defending me know about it and are trying to keep me alive without outting that part of our PM.

If you dont know what im talking about, I cannot help you further explain it. Does the entire role pm flip with me or just the character name?

[strike wolf]

I feel like this is turning into a circle jerk. Eventually someone is going to have to compromise so we can actually get discussion that doesnt exist only on a merry go round.


Fped. Well maybe we are starting to get somewhere...still feels rather slow...

[got tonkaed]

I'll leave that up to Epitaph. I feel like Mtam's next go round is going to be a bunch of PM playing, which I don't really have the ability to do.

I am certainly confident that a day 1 lynch doesn't end the game for town if he dies, but I have no way to counter a play the mod defense. He has basically tried to drag out a conversation where i go back to post things and he replies 3 or 4 times without reading. I still think he is the scummiest person for the reasons laid out, I leave to you guys to choose to lynch or not.

[mtamburini]

I'll leave that up to Epitaph. I feel like Mtam's next go round is going to be a bunch of PM playing, which I don't really have the ability to do.

I am certainly confident that a day 1 lynch doesn't end the game for town if he dies, but I have no way to counter a play the mod defense. He has basically tried to drag out a conversation where i go back to post things and he replies 3 or 4 times without reading. I still think he is the scummiest person for the reasons laid out, I leave to you guys to choose to lynch or not.

Why are you dodging easy questions to answer fi your town.

[mtamburini]

Thats the only part I Read which made me want to vote for you so how do you feel knowing that is my reasoning for you to die?

Honestly I could not give a f*ck. If you mean die in real life I am slightly concerned but I reckon I will sleep ok. If you mean in the game then f*ck it.

What the f*ck was this ever talked about?

[mtamburini]

I'll leave that up to Epitaph. I feel like Mtam's next go round is going to be a bunch of PM playing, which I don't really have the ability to do.

I am certainly confident that a day 1 lynch doesn't end the game for town if he dies, but I have no way to counter a play the mod defense. He has basically tried to drag out a conversation where i go back to post things and he replies 3 or 4 times without reading. I still think he is the scummiest person for the reasons laid out, I leave to you guys to choose to lynch or not.

Playing pontius pilot now? Washing your hands clean when incase I get lynched and flip town you can be the one that said I left it to you guys.

[mtamburini]

Still havent quoted my buddying of streaker

[got tonkaed]

I unfortunately have no clue what the PM angle you are shooting for here is and I leave it to the Mod to determine if he is cool with that. Either way, its just another distraction defense instead of explaining your early page play. All of this is just making it harder on someone to re-read to try and figure out what you are on about anyway.

I guess we can ask Semp if he feels whatever you are driving it is something he understands because as of now he is the only person to claim officially and it would not make sense for Storr to have a similar unique PM if that is what you are driving at.

It is obvious my hands are dirty if you flip town.

[mtamburini]

I didnt ask you how many games youve played, I asked you do you even know how to play the game?

Someone can play 100 games and still not know how to play.

Yet you think that after one beginner's game, I should know something about whether questions are related to agenda or alignment? I didn't vote for you because of tonka's questions, but because of your evasion of them. I think number 2 seems like a reasonable place to start - why did you soft claim? Was that supposed to help the town, and if so, how?

So storr could stop playing like a fucking idiot, yes storr stopped using his fake bs PR and started to given competent reads I could understand.

[mtamburini]

I unfortunately have no clue what the PM angle you are shooting for here is and I leave it to the Mod to determine if he is cool with that. Either way, its just another distraction defense instead of explaining your early page play. All of this is just making it harder on someone to re-read to try and figure out what you are on about anyway.

I guess we can ask Semp if he feels whatever you are driving it is something he understands because as of now he is the only person to claim officially and it would not make sense for Storr to have a similar unique PM if that is what you are driving at.

It is obvious my hands are dirty if you flip town.

I would strongly believe storr does not have a similar PM as the one I got. Can you quote Senpais full cliaim or at least the page

[got tonkaed]

Read it yourself. I probably would have been cool with it before the whole circle jerk, but if you want to basically defend yourself by getting in a word fight, I dont feel super compelled to help you. Especially when i have had to reread only to have you keep shooting out 1 liners and not read yourself.

It would actually amuse me in a dark humor type of way if my whole going out on a shield to pressure you is all because you never bothered to read from the start of the game. That would be worth a chuckle or two.

[mtamburini]

Read it yourself. I probably would have been cool with it before the whole circle jerk, but if you want to basically defend yourself by getting in a word fight, I dont feel super compelled to help you. Especially when i have had to reread only to have you keep shooting out 1 liners and not read yourself.

It would actually amuse me in a dark humor type of way if my whole going out on a shield to pressure you is all because you never bothered to read from the start of the game. That would be worth a chuckle or two.

I did read the start, then RL happens and the pages added up, already been explained twice, now your just being a dick and not letting me try to read you because you have some Higher class person of which im not allowed to question

[degaston]

So storr could stop playing like a fucking idiot, yes storr stopped using his fake bs PR and started to given competent reads I could understand.

Maybe I missed it. How did it become your job to get Storr to stop playing like an idiot?

[got tonkaed]

Now that we have gotten to like 3 pages, can i declare your entire defense one long OMGUS or do we need to keep posting about it for a bit longer.

You should probably keep reading.