Army of GOD wrote:I don't understand what you're getting at Storr. I visited him because I had my vote on him day 2. I thought he was scum. Since my result didn't return anything of interest, that either means he's not the moon shaman or he was bussed. Since I know he's not the moon shaman and there's likely one other scum out there, the odds that he is mafia have been decreased.
AoG What result did you get from wing when you "checked" him?
Found nothing if interest, similarly to you
I chose to visit Wing and rish because each of those days ended with my vote on them. I thought they were both scum at the time.
Army of GOD wrote:I don't understand what you're getting at Storr. I visited him because I had my vote on him day 2. I thought he was scum. Since my result didn't return anything of interest, that either means he's not the moon shaman or he was bussed. Since I know he's not the moon shaman and there's likely one other scum out there, the odds that he is mafia have been decreased.
AoG What result did you get from wing when you "checked" him?
Found nothing if interest, similarly to you
I chose to visit Wing and rish because each of those days ended with my vote on them. I thought they were both scum at the time.
And thats what bothers me. If your negative result is the same as the result of visiting me than something doesn't seem right.
The two should be intrinsically different, and thats what makes me not believe your claim.
aage wrote: Maybe you're right, but since we receive no handlebars from the mod I think we should get some ourselves.
Army of GOD wrote:I don't understand what you're getting at Storr. I visited him because I had my vote on him day 2. I thought he was scum. Since my result didn't return anything of interest, that either means he's not the moon shaman or he was bussed. Since I know he's not the moon shaman and there's likely one other scum out there, the odds that he is mafia have been decreased.
AoG What result did you get from wing when you "checked" him?
Found nothing if interest, similarly to you
I chose to visit Wing and rish because each of those days ended with my vote on them. I thought they were both scum at the time.
And thats what bothers me. If your negative result is the same as the result of visiting me than something doesn't seem right.
The two should be intrinsically different, and thats what makes me not believe your claim.
rishaed wrote:
See this is where your statement gets illogical....At the very end DY specifies what the "Blood Moon" was (red Waterballoon) which makes me read it as flavor.
It also says that "all evidence was washed away" which sounds like the type of role effect that scum would have. While I agree that trying to read too much into flavor is a fool's errand, that whole thing seems like it wasn't just placed into the day scene at random. Notice how the D2 scene didn't have any language like that.
And as a Mod, you never give out clear statements on a role name or something along those lines inside of a scene, unless they died.
Well, that's true. But he also didn't say that the "Blood Moon Shaman" came out and performed a ritual that made a waterballoon fly up in the air. He just said that there was a blood moon, which seems like the type of power mafia might have.
2.This has really messed with me: Why is the claimed doc still alive? (Better said: Why hasn't he been NK'd by the mafia yet...)
This is messing with me too. I've wanted to believe NoS the whole time, but it is fairly suspicious that scum did not kill him.
As for Storr/Aog, if Storr is telling the truth I have the suspicion that AoG/Storr are trying to lynch each other (but somehow i don't thing AoG is being truthful, b/c I've never heard of a lyncher who loses when his target gets lynched (like srsly wut?).
This is DY. You really have to ignore your beliefs on what is plausible in a DY game. (Not that AoG is necessarily telling the truth, but "I've never heard of this role" is really unconvincing in a DY setup.)
The problem here is that we have two different roles with the same name. As a mod that is confusing and otherwise pointless.
Also LOL at mets. There is a basis for that belief. I cause actions to fail not come back negative.
aage wrote: Maybe you're right, but since we receive no handlebars from the mod I think we should get some ourselves.
rishaed wrote:
The problem here is that we have two different roles with the same name. As a mod that is confusing and otherwise pointless.
See above re: DY.
Also LOL at mets. There is a basis for that belief. I cause actions to fail not come back negative.
AoG said he found "nothing of interest." Does that sound like a successful action to you?
The problem here is one of semantics. If a cop were to try and investigate Rishaed would the result come back "you find nothing of interest" or would there be no reply.
I think that question is moot as AOG says he has to kill the Moon Mafia by picking someone each night. Why would you need a result if that action makes the answer evident? You either have dead mafia or you do not. Case closed. Why the hell would you get a reply?
Iron Butterfly wrote:Wait....I am assuming you kill the Shaman or are you a cop that can only detect the mafia boss?
Either way the fact that his results from both wing and me were the same does not add up. Plus the entire "Lyncher" Claim. What mod would have two different variations on a role and call them the same thing in one game? (And pardon if it seems like i'm playing the mod here, but from the standpoint of someone who has modded it makes no sense.)
aage wrote: Maybe you're right, but since we receive no handlebars from the mod I think we should get some ourselves.
is it just me or is there no need to look for the moon shaman anymore since night 1 anywayt?
DoomYoshi wrote:The Night was eerie. Shortly after dinner, the large red moon rose. Something wasn't right, you could feel it in the rain. Suspecting foul play, the rain, specifically TailGunner, the 9 of Rain, Town Moon Shaman went out to prepare a ritual. As he got out there, a quick papercut from a sharp card caused him to explode in a gushing fountain of blood. There was no doubt now, the Blood Moon was upon us!
Iron Butterfly wrote:Wait....I am assuming you kill the Shaman or are you a cop that can only detect the mafia boss?
Either way the fact that his results from both wing and me were the same does not add up. Plus the entire "Lyncher" Claim. What mod would have two different variations on a role and call them the same thing in one game? (And pardon if it seems like i'm playing the mod here, but from the standpoint of someone who has modded it makes no sense.)
Well it's very likely that there's a liar between Storr and AoG. I lean slightly towards Storr but wouldn't be opposed to an AoG lynch either.
virus90 wrote:vote Rishead Cause jokevote and before being accused of not being here in the jokevote phase.
Also i want to play a game you host Tailgunner would be a oK second pick for a jokevote, since he is nr 13 and thats unlucky.
now look for capital letters and shuffle a bit.
N1: streaker.
N2: AoG
but AOG got bussed with storr so i ended up visiting storr.
and storr visited rishaed.
so i have a problem with storr having no night action? while i see him visiting people
virus90 wrote:well im the town tracker.
seem y first message;
virus90 wrote:vote Rishead Cause jokevote and before being accused of not being here in the jokevote phase.
Also i want to play a game you host Tailgunner would be a oK second pick for a jokevote, since he is nr 13 and thats unlucky.
now look for capital letters and shuffle a bit.
N1: streaker.
N2: AoG
but AOG got bussed with storr so i ended up visiting storr.
and storr visited rishaed.
so i have a problem with storr having no night action? while i see him visiting people
How do you know he got bussed? Because this changes things.
aage wrote: Maybe you're right, but since we receive no handlebars from the mod I think we should get some ourselves.
because i targetted AoG and got as result; not gonna quote literaly:
but it was litteraly said that aog was busdrived so i got a result from storr. who visited rishaed.
it didnt leave much room for doubt on the busdrive (read: it was exactly stated)
Tailgunner would be a oK second pick for a jokevote, since he is nr 13 and thats unlucky.