-Madmitch
Mitch, you are showing signs of improving. However, you need to work on a few things, most of all: PATIENCE. Waiting a couple days longer instead of hammering in the end, could have won the game for town. You were so eager to vote and completely spoil any chance town might have. Epi said he was going to analyze everyone again, and deadline was ages away. No reason to end the game on a coinflip. To end on a positive note, you had a few posts with very good analysis in them. Keep it up!
-bosaardbeitje
First game in mafia, though you wouldn't say that actually. Being the 'bulldog' this game, you were very active and driving in the conversation. Made a few errors in logic, all in all very very good for a first game. Try to look at everyone when analyzing.
-subtleknifewield
Mafia 1, played a good game though town enabled you guys to have a LOT of room. Do not attempt to lynch a claimed cop with the same eagerness in a more experienced game, you WILL get lynched for it. Still, you pulled off a very nice win here.
-ptlowe
Mafia 2, played a solid game as well. There is no reason to let a claimed power role live, especially if you know there is no doc. It worked out very well in your favour, but it's a risk you should not take in another game.
-wcwnww, replaced by Razorvich
Inactive, failed to reply to any prod, replaced by Raz who was thanked for replacing by getting insta killed
Thanks for the effort, Raz!
-Epitaph1
As one of the most experienced players this game, it was so fun seeing him struggle with the fact that a claimed cop managed to survive the night
It's not easy reading 'new' players, and mafia did play quite well. I think he would have figured out the correct lynch if mitch allowed him. Kinda strange that Epi was so strongly believing in a scum Tim.
-Aage
Got taken out quite early, I'm still figuring out why. I don't understand the case on him, and neither does he
A casualty of a newbie game, let's call it.
-rizky_biznezz
Took a few days to get the hang of it, but it's not easy getting in there and playing for the first time. Managed to really play very well and put out a few solid reads later in the game. You need to have a bit more confidence, and experience.
-TimWoodbury
Tim. Tim Tim Tim Tim Tim. I am going to be honest with you: town probably lost because of your claim. In games like these, there is no point in claiming where you did. If you have the information to share then go ahead. But I noticed you do this in other games as well. It's really really really bad for you and your team in 99% of the case. The 1% is you being a jester. Please try and learn from this, having such a strong power doesn't mean you have to spear the assault, it means you disclose the information at the right time. You allowed mafia to be able and afford
not killing you at night. You saw what happened when you claimed bos as town. Credibility is very important. As pointed out in this thread, deception is the name of the game. That said, I hope you learned from this game and carry on in the other games. I enjoyed watching you squirm
In general, this game is about more then reading other players as scum. You need to be able and read town play as well, and manage to convince others of your opinion.
This was a very, very good 'noob' game, and an incredible level of activity. I enjoyed hosting it very much, and I hope you guys all stick around and play the other games.
If anyone of you has any questions, pm any of us.
If anyone wants to give a better analysis of play of everyone, please do so. I'd be eager to see what everyone thought.
[/quote]