[OFFICIAL] Stack the Deck mafia (4/12)Endgame: MAFIA WIN

[Endgame422]

My vote on TWR was just to get some action from him originally but im starting to think hes mafia.
His bandwagon on wings case on mars is suspect,also im not very trusting of players who assure me of anything,even more so when they are assuring me that he will start contributing more to the hunt for scum.
Actions speak louder then words and TWR seems to be stalling,with time running out.
The maniacs case on rizky looks like another one id like to look into.
Rizky what are your thoughts on wings case on mars and my points against TWR?
Also agreed its strange that PT has been gone for so long but we cant read into streaker not prodding him.
Playing the mod is a recipe for disaster.
PT whatcha think of IBvsBoss on the "list" arguement?

[madmitch]

I JUST REALIZE THAT PT WAS MIA LIKE DAKKY,

[dakky21]

who wants to join my bw?

It is true that i have not been as active on this game as yet, but that is really because i have not really anything useful to post. I guess I am being a little distracted with my other games, and perhaps should not play so many games at once.

Having said that, it is only D1 and as yet I have no real reads on anyone, what would you have me do? keep switching my vote with lots of joke votes?

suffice to say I am reading all posts carefully and when i find something scummy i will pounce on it.

mitch, that is mad, even for you...which statement of dakky's do you believe? and now you vote him......me thinks you are playing too many mafia games at once

yep, sympathise with you dakky, i have posted way more than you but still found my way onto some players scumlists, i am in both the games you mention too....but don't really want to D1 lynch you again

I stand by my vote on TWR - these 4 posts were made by TWR and nothing new was included, no scum hunting and not even pushing on someone.

Except the bandwagon thing, and I believe that first post says it all.

[Marashu]

My vote on TWR was just to get some action from him originally but im starting to think hes mafia.
His bandwagon on wings case on mars is suspect,also im not very trusting of players who assure me of anything,even more so when they are assuring me that he will start contributing more to the hunt for scum.
Actions speak louder then words and TWR seems to be stalling,with time running out.
The maniacs case on rizky looks like another one id like to look into.
Rizky what are your thoughts on wings case on mars and my points against TWR?
Also agreed its strange that PT has been gone for so long but we cant read into streaker not prodding him.
Playing the mod is a recipe for disaster.
PT whatcha think of IBvsBoss on the "list" arguement?

I agree on wanting to hear rizky's thoughts - ana did a good job at pointing that out. While I'm not a fan of rose's stalling, we do still have three days, which is enough time to build cases, so I'm not entirely sure I like how you're trying to rush things, either. PTLowe hasn't really done anything to change my read on him, but it was a vague and early read.

If I may speculate, I'm wondering if scum took daychat. Might explain why some normally chatty people aren't as talkative - it would be eating at their time, while also giving them a chance to coordinate stalling.

Wing is seeing what sticks, but I always have a hard time reading him D1. I'd say I'm leaning town with him? On the subject of bosaa bandwagoning on mitch's case on dakky, well, just say "bandwagoning on mitch's case" and I think you'll agree that it's a tough pill to swallow. Coupled with the fact that she is aware of mitch's playstyle, and I doubt she would expect anything to come of it if she were scum.

we have 3 days to decide on a lynch and agree i see the concensis thus far is dakky buthe claims to have not realized game started or something so im gonna let him read and after he posts ill throw a ote out

This quote bothers me. If you read the thread and think that dakky is the consensus for the lynch, then I think you are skimming. Do you have any thoughts on any of the other cases?

Waiting on dakky's "later" post, but I do believe him when he says he's spread too thin.

Unvote since I still have my joke vote.

Right now, I would say my 3 would be rizky, rose, and tim (yes, I am aware that I just unvoted him). Right now all three are either stalling, skimming, or not committing. I would like to hear more from all of them. It's possible that pt is scum, but I am not sure who his scumbuddies would be, unless he's an unrecruited traitor. I'm not sure who I would swap out of my 3 for him, though.

fp'd by dakky

[TimWoodbury]

alot of the recent posts has mentioned dakky thus why i said concesis was dakky. as yah i kinda as skimming with being in 4 active games thats my bad.

[ptlowe]

My vote on TWR was just to get some action from him originally but im starting to think hes mafia.
His bandwagon on wings case on mars is suspect,also im not very trusting of players who assure me of anything,even more so when they are assuring me that he will start contributing more to the hunt for scum.
Actions speak louder then words and TWR seems to be stalling,with time running out.
The maniacs case on rizky looks like another one id like to look into.
Rizky what are your thoughts on wings case on mars and my points against TWR?
Also agreed its strange that PT has been gone for so long but we cant read into streaker not prodding him.
Playing the mod is a recipe for disaster.
PT whatcha think of IBvsBoss on the "list" arguement?

Sorry guys sick over the weekend. Was absent from all of my games.

I dont read much into either of them. I think Bos reaction was overkill but she is still new. I do side with IB on the reaction. I dont see how Bos gets a scum read from him based upon that.

Also, meant nothing bout the joke vote stage. Just joking around.

[ptlowe]

Also unvote since we are beyound the joke vote stage. I agree with Marusha on that course of action.

My only read on scum so far is slight and its towards TWR as I am used to him posting more. However, the same can be true for me but things have been busy with being sick.

-pt

[TimWoodbury]

i think posting in general is down this game because a few of the more ctive psters are in multiple games and were trying to not mix games up. its unfortunate side effect

[madmitch]

@ Mars good call on that day chat, makes sense ,now we have to see who is posting regularly and whose not, lets see who comes out of the shadows now

[Streaker]

Mod note: I missed pt's absense, if he didn't post he would have been prodded now as well.

[rizky_biznezz]

sorry guys with quite a few players not adding anything it hasnt been easy making cases...

anam i didnt agree with all sides, i actually agreed with bos on it being a strange question... asking for specific details as to what she finds scummy is different to just asking why mitch wasnt scummy to her... however upon reading your post you actually did side with both of them so not sure how you find me scummy for it?

and im really not sure the timing is much to go on BUT im willing to look at any kind of detail so not really sure thats a bad thing either?

havent played with dakky before so not sure whether this is usual for him or not but there are quite a few players in more than one game who are posting so i would expect some more from him..

endgame i think the points against white rose are stronger at this stage.. mars has made some good points and had reasonable explanations so far

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Wing is seeing what sticks, but I always have a hard time reading him D1.

You say that every game. That exact line.

Right now, I would say my 3 would be rizky, rose, and tim (yes, I am aware that I just unvoted him). Right now all three are either stalling, skimming, or not committing. I would like to hear more from all of them. It's possible that pt is scum, but I am not sure who his scumbuddies would be, unless he's an unrecruited traitor. I'm not sure who I would swap out of my 3 for him, though.

So your three picks are three players who are known to make a multitude of errors, regardless of alignment and will tell us nothing from their flips?

[rizky_biznezz]

when you put it like that wing it does make me rethink....

not sure how rose, tim and i are the 3 most suspicious people when there are so many not posting much at all.. it seems scum would be more interested in us killing players who are in here writing than those who dont come here at all... especially after it was mars that made the point about the daytalk and the scum being busy.. but yet the 3 suspects are the ones that have been in here posting

[the white rose]

Mars explanation as to why he was first to post is still a little bit iffy. I know, if it were me getting up at 5am i would not be looking at a forum game that had not even started. would have left it till i got home.....having said that some are more keen than others so for now i will unvote.

unvote

[the white rose]

Sorry guys sick over the weekend. Was absent from all of my games.

well that is not exactly true is it? you were posting in adventure game sunday, in fact you made 2 seperate posts, but did not post at all here, until late on monday evening. Did you read this on Sunday? why did you not post?

[the white rose]

Sorry guys sick over the weekend. Was absent from all of my games.

well that is not exactly true is it? you were posting in adventure game sunday, in fact you made 2 seperate posts, but did not post at all here, until late on monday evening. Did you read this on Sunday? why did you not post?

in fact, just checked his cc games, and he was actively playing all weekend.....see game 16088656.

Doesn't make him definite scum, but his reasons for not playing are untrue....therefore......

vote ptlowe

[rizky_biznezz]

pt-- lack of posts, trying to get bos on his side

mars-- did point out the fact that daytalk could be keeping people busy... but then put 3 people on suspect list that had been here

white rose-- making cases now... after being named a suspect by several players... a little suspicious

iron butterfly-- asked bos exactly what she looks for when putting someone on her suspect list, got a little defensive then disappeared

anam-- tried to make a case so seems to be hunting.. but only returned after a prod and tried to make my posts in to things that they werent.. a little suspicious maybe busy with daytalk

mitch-- making a lot of jokes, not many reads switching up votes.. similar to last game.. town at this stage

bos-- seems to be hunting and trying to make cases.. sticking with town for now

going to wait and see what others have to say before i vote.. simply because last game ppl hammered early when we still had heaps of time and with everyone changing votes so much i dont want that to happen here, plus i would like to hear more from the ppl who havent been around much before i decide

[the white rose]

white rose-- making cases now... after being named a suspect by several players... a little suspicious

really? and how is one supposed to make a case on days 1 and 2 of D1 before anyone has posted anything other than joke votes?

i have been reading this forum throughout, generally ignoring joke votes, until i see something a little suspicious, such as ptlowe lieing about his lack of posting.

Its true, I have been named by a few players, but their reasons for mentioning me have been a) making a joke vote on the mod....and b) not posting much at the start of the game, when lets face it there is not much to post. Now we have finally got some proper posts to work on I can start making cases on them.

If that makes one suspicious, you must have a pretty big sus list.

[Marashu]

Wing is seeing what sticks, but I always have a hard time reading him D1.

You say that every game. That exact line.

And I likely will continue to until I can figure out your D1 play.

Right now, I would say my 3 would be rizky, rose, and tim (yes, I am aware that I just unvoted him). Right now all three are either stalling, skimming, or not committing. I would like to hear more from all of them. It's possible that pt is scum, but I am not sure who his scumbuddies would be, unless he's an unrecruited traitor. I'm not sure who I would swap out of my 3 for him, though.

So your three picks are three players who are known to make a multitude of errors, regardless of alignment and will tell us nothing from their flips?

Not very familiar with rizky or rose's plays. Be tough to learn from Tim, but I'd be willing to risk that because I think he could be mafia, yes.

On my point on daytalk, I was looking for people who were posting less than expected norm (other people's accounts on rose's lack of posts is what got rose on that list), and as for rizky being around, most of those posts contribute little more than showing that he is still present.

fp'd by rose

[rizky_biznezz]

I do have a big list rose i suspect everyone at the moment because we haven't got anything to prove otherwise so just making some notes from the little info we have so far... I understand u defending urself but I haven't voted for u I can't even put much together because of the lack of posts from some ppl but deadline is getting closer so if my post gets some reactions and activity from people then good

[Endgame422]

Mars,3 days is not alot of time,im "rushing" because,if we dont get a serious case today we will be hard pressed to get 7 votes for anyone,much less 7 votes on a decent case.
You said you dont like roses stalling but then proceed to stall. Whats up with that?

[ptlowe]

Sorry guys sick over the weekend. Was absent from all of my games.

well that is not exactly true is it? you were posting in adventure game sunday, in fact you made 2 seperate posts, but did not post at all here, until late on monday evening. Did you read this on Sunday? why did you not post?

in fact, just checked his cc games, and he was actively playing all weekend.....see game 16088656.

Doesn't make him definite scum, but his reasons for not playing are untrue....therefore......

vote ptlowe

Played my games and had a sitter as well. You can have clan mates sit you...dah..also the two posts were real quick non researched. Doesnt mean ik not sick or that i have been hiding from the game. Your just upset because you got called out.

[dakky21]

white rose-- making cases now... after being named a suspect by several players... a little suspicious

really? and how is one supposed to make a case on days 1 and 2 of D1 before anyone has posted anything other than joke votes?

And how is one supposed to make a case on YOU if you just read and don't post? If you're mafia and just waiting to bandwagon onto someones lynch, not posting is great strategy. You're still my no.1 suspect.

[bosaardbeitje]

@ Dakky, you are calling out TWR for a lack of substance during the first days of the game. I fail to see how that is different from your own play. Your posts don't include much new information either. You voted TWR at the beginning of the game, then you come back 4 days later and simply stick with your vote. You don't address any other things that have been going on. To me that makes you either scummy or uninterested. It also surprises me that it took a prod from Streaker to get you back in here, since I know how often you are online. Combining that with the speculation from Maras about day chat, I think that could mean you were busy making sneaky plans.

I'm the Ace of Spades

King of Hearts here...

you know what... i'm back to my original game, screw this

vote madmitch

that's the Dakky we know and love

you know what, you just jumped in my thoughts in that other game... but just a small jump because of that msg...

Don't we even get a little story leading into day 1.. I feel a bit ripped off lol

good point

vote streaker for not telling us a story

from what I learned so far, (joke)voting the mod or any non playing character means you want to lynch anyone, thus making you mafia...

vote white rose

Is that Haiku?

I'm silent because didn't expect both games to start the same day.
Need to read this game again, will post something later today.

Ptlowe, TWR and Anam (I missed that earlier) have also been quiet for a while. Out of those Anam looks most Town to me because of the last post with lots of content. Ptlowe and TWR haven't convinced me of their innocence so far. And now we seem to have lost IB...

Fpd

[madmitch]

@ Rizky you gave us your list but Dakky was not on it why? Can you not make a read on him or are you trying to protect him?