[Beginner] Straight Mafia - TOWN WINS

[rizky_biznezz]

i agree... i have cases on them both.. but i feel stronger about mitch i can at least make some sense out of tims outting you where as mitch just put it out there for the sake of doing it... everyone seems to find tim scummier so to avoid a possible no lynch i will vote tim if i have to

[Streaker]

and if very well may get him killed tonight even if hes not cop so if he is he should should say who hes investigated thus far least town will know who not to lynch tomarrow

This again sounds like you are trying to get cop to claim/confirm

Right now i want to vote for you, but by my reckoning you are already at l-1, there is still 2 days to go, so i will refrain for the moment from hammering you, but unless i hear a convincing argument to spare you, i will hammer tomorrow.

just lynch me i almsot gurentee that the guy will get NK'd especially after i put the focus on him

You just keep going on and on about the cop, and this statement looks like you trying to point out to your buddy on who to nk.
What do you hope to achieve with this post, if you are town?

[TimWoodbury]

I think both Tim and Mitch are looking very scummy for trying to finger me as Cop, but I'm not sure which I want to vote for. Mitch seems to be backing down a bit, but Tim has gone ahead and admitted he has practically got me NKed, so I am still leaning toward him.

Mitch and Tim were at each others' throats early on, but maybe that was their strategy from the start, just a bit of theater to throw us off the track.

Tim, I am prepared to unvote you, but only if you can come up with a good explanation for why you are trying to finger me as Cop. You know it isn't good for Town to do that. Even if you think I am Cop, surely the best thing would be to keep it to yourself?

Again, I am Town but I am not saying more than that. I have done no snailmailing or softclaiming.

thnk of it this way i say ur cop with no real reason or ryme other then just how your posts was skum is gonna NK you with any luck im reading wrong they do NK yah ur not cop then the cop has another night to investigate someone. he will have been able to narrow it down to 3 people after the night

[AladdinSane]

Streaker did actually say in the chat room that he was going to be crazy busy and was missing from live chat for several days so seeing as he lives in there dont read too much in to his absence.

Ah, okay then. I guess the absence seems less scummy now. Tim and Mitch seem to have leapt into the spotlight as suspects, and I don't see a way to go forward with the Streaker = Scum theory at the moment, so I'll let it go for now and hope that the Cop might investigate Streaker on N2, on account of being very "Grey" at the moment imo.

[AladdinSane]

thnk of it this way i say ur cop with no real reason or ryme other then just how your posts was skum is gonna NK you with any luck im reading wrong they do NK yah ur not cop then the cop has another night to investigate someone. he will have been able to narrow it down to 3 people after the night

If I am reading you right (and I am not sure I am, because your writing style is virtually incomprehensible), you are claiming that my posts make me look like the Cop and you felt the need to shout this out to everyone. Thinking that I am the Cop and drawing attention to this, you acknowledge that it might get me NKed, but you hope you are wrong and I am not the Cop, meaning my death will buy the Cop another night of investigation.

That makes no sense to me. You think I am the Cop. Drawing attention to this is bad for Town, if it is true. But you think that there is a benefit to Town if you are wrong. But since you don't think you are wrong, it doesn't make sense to try to finger me as Cop.

I'm still inclined to keep my vote on you, because even if you are innocent, that kind of logic is of no use to Town.

[AladdinSane]

i starting to get a feeling aladain knows more about me then he is saying with how hes defending me. there is only 3 MAYBE 4 people who would know my allignment
1)skum #1
2)skum #2
3)me
4)possable cop investigated me

i cant imagine that if aladin was skum that he would e defending me he would be jumping like crazy throwing a lynch to make me L-1 and he obviously aint me so i think hes more or less soft claiming snail mailing that hes cop and investigated me and came up town.

Just revisiting this post. Both Mitch and Tim have tried to finger me as the Cop. I think one thing that is making Tim seem the scummier of the two to me at the moment is that not only is he doing that but he is also trying to use his snailmailing theory to suggest that the Cop has investigated him and found him to be Town. That just seems like a sneaky way of trying to make himself look good.

Once more, I am Town, but that is all I have said, and all I will say, as to my role.

[AladdinSane]

Also, it's weird how TIm sometimes writes in a perfectly lucid style, and at the other times is virtually incomprehensible. Care to explain, TIm?

[rizky_biznezz]

Looks as though it's gonna be a Tim lynch anyway... It's all too confusing so either way it will be good to know.. So vote tim

[bosaardbeitje]

Here! Before anyone thinks that me being sick is a Doc softclaim Have to read first...

[AladdinSane]

Here! Before anyone thinks that me being sick is a Doc softclaim

Maybe not a doc softclaim but fishing for a doc reply

[the white rose]

I think both Tim and Mitch are looking very scummy for trying to finger me as Cop, but I'm not sure which I want to vote for. Mitch seems to be backing down a bit, but Tim has gone ahead and admitted he has practically got me NKed, so I am still leaning toward him.

Mitch and Tim were at each others' throats early on, but maybe that was their strategy from the start, just a bit of theater to throw us off the track.

Tim, I am prepared to unvote you, but only if you can come up with a good explanation for why you are trying to finger me as Cop. You know it isn't good for Town to do that. Even if you think I am Cop, surely the best thing would be to keep it to yourself?

Again, I am Town but I am not saying more than that. I have done no snailmailing or softclaiming.

thnk of it this way i say ur cop with no real reason or ryme other then just how your posts was skum is gonna NK you with any luck im reading wrong they do NK yah ur not cop then the cop has another night to investigate someone. he will have been able to narrow it down to 3 people after the night

The point is well made. Tim for whatever reason has a cop read on Aladin, any townie would keep that quiet, tim is shouting it from the rooftops. I do not know if tim is right or wrong, but the point is that he thinks he is right, so he has basically indicating to his buddies who to nk should he die, yes, he may be wrong, but no townie would even try to identify the cop

so as promised yesterday.

unvote vote tim

[bosaardbeitje]

First of all, I believe DJ's claim, so no reason to go after him. Although I do find it strange that he says it exactly when most of us have backed off. This is no indication of him being scum, because scum wouldn't draw attention to himself again. So, he must be Town.

and if very well may get him killed tonight even if hes not cop so if he is he should should say who hes investigated thus far least town will know who not to lynch tomarrow

Not true. If he investigated someone and that person turned out to be Town, he can let us know through his reads. No need to say it and then get killed by mafia.


Fpd and still reading

[bosaardbeitje]

Was that the hammer?

[TimWoodbury]

rizky was the lynch and like i said when i thought i was lynched last time i am vt.

[bosaardbeitje]

No, rizky revoted and TWR hammered. We will find out soon enough if you are speaking the truth. You shouldn't have gone on and on about the Cop if you are VT. I would probably have hammered you myself. More thoughts after the Night.

[rizky_biznezz]

Didnt hammer but I wasn't sure if I was going to be back in time so I put my vote back on.. If Tim is town we better get if right D3 but no pressure guys lol

[the white rose]

he must be scum surely? no townie would ever try and out the cop under any circumstances.

[Epitaph1]

VOTE COUNT

Streaker - Patrick
mitch - Tim
Tim - Streaker, mitch, Aladdin, risky, whiterose (LYNCH)

[Epitaph1]

Another day, another call to action. The town was not going to sit idly by while the mafia had their way.

This time they turned their sights on Tim. They put the noose around his neck and gave it a swift tug. Before anyone knew it, his body hung limply over the town square.

Spoiler

Tim - Vanilla Townie - has been lynched.

It is now Night 2. Deadline in 48 hours.

[Iron Butterfly]

Sorry for lack of participation but I have been very sick.

[Epitaph1]

Sorry to hear that, IB. I hope you feel better soon.

Scene:

Whiterose went to bed that night feeling a little uneasy. It wasn't just the fact that he had seen another vanilla townie get the noose, but he couldn't shake the feeling that he had been followed home. As he laid in bed and pulled the covers up to his chin, he saw the door to his bedroom slowly open. The darkness masked the face of the intruder, but it didn't hide the barrel of the gun that was inches from whiterose's face.

Spoiler

Whiterose - Vanilla townie - has been killed.

It is now D3.

With the US holiday, I'll extend the deadline a bit. Deadline is December 3 at 10:00 CCT.

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

[bosaardbeitje]

Okay, so we lost 4 players, out of which 3 were acting incredibly scummy. We need to get it right today, so I suggest to end end that right now The only person left on my current suspect list is Mitch, but I can't really connect him to a scum partner, so I am now looking at everyone again, cause there must be 2. It's difficult to come up with new reads, because I was convinced that Streak vs DJ was a Town fight and Aladdin and rizky haven't done anything particularly scummy. It's D3 and it's 4-2, if we don't lynch scum, it will be 3-2 and it will be game over N3.

[madmitch]

unless they know more than they let on? A classic WIFOM

Maybe I was right when I said this ? It seems the newbies are still alive, I think D.J. IS LYING ABOUT HIS Role and we let him get away with it ,not this time VOTE D.J.

[bosaardbeitje]

I am leaning in the same direction. It's really really weird that DJ has been able to survive 2 nights. After D1 it may not have been clear to mafia that he was the Doc, but surely they must have known after D2. Maybe Aladdin was right all along.

[rizky_biznezz]

I'm at work so i don't have much time so I will post my thoughts later today