[INTERMEDIATE]Enemy of My Enemy - Archive please

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

If Mtam wasn't modkilled, it would most probably be the same situation as it is now... it would just be 2v1v1 and you and Rage would no lynch today and end in a tie anyway.

Nope, me and Epi wrote a long case against Rage which we would have used to convince town to lynch Rage over Epi, then it would be 3v2, lynch Epi, 2v1...

[dakky21]

If Mtam wasn't modkilled, it would most probably be the same situation as it is now... it would just be 2v1v1 and you and Rage would no lynch today and end in a tie anyway.

Nope, me and Epi wrote a long case against Rage which we would have used to convince town to lynch Rage over Epi, then it would be 3v2, lynch Epi, 2v1...

Ok, even if that happened like you said, Rage would be lynched instead of Epi, that would end 3v2 and then Storr would say you are the other mafia and it would be a town win. So I don't believe you would go that route...

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Ah right, yeah true. Town would have won a 2v1v1 though due to killing each other

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Why did you investigate me Rage?

[Marashu]

And with that, town loses. The game is a draw between anti-town.

Dead chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/51/H/LbSj8NSvFYfS
Mafia chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/51/H/UJ4mCnHdG3nn
Werewolf chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/51/H/LwB3qWaNEQeVb

Maybe it's just because it was a difficult time of year, but not being able to find a replacement for mtamburini ended up skewing the endgame, in my opinion.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Town should have won due to the excellent and equal strength of investigation by both anti town factions. Oddly town had very little control in this game type.

[StorrZerg]

if the game allows a tie like it, then mtambs death did nothing. Mafia can still team up with the wolves.


i disagree wing, 2 mafia/wolf to start was great, but with out killing 2 in a row you can't decrease kp. Not to mention, wolf/mafia never hit each other with kp. This setup kind of needs that to happen for town to have a chance.

Rage knew i had a result on wing. He likely would have killed me, then it was final 3 for you guys. Probably woulda been for the best cause its a chance town can win. I didn't think anti town factions could be allowed to "tie"

, i could have given the information, then worked with town to lynch the last wolf over epi.

[Ragian]

Why did you investigate me Rage?

Because it was down between you and belly, I felt. Why didn't you investigate/kill me?

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Why did you investigate me Rage?

Because it was down between you and belly, I felt. Why didn't you investigate/kill me?

It was not beneficial to kill you, it would have ended up with me in a 4v1. Likewise you should have been trying to kill town and not Mitch as mafia suspect!

We didnt need to investigate you, we knew it was between you and Hotshot. Epi and I both independantly came to this same conclusion. At that point in the game knowing who you were for certain would only help us avoid Epi being lynched, it wasnt helpful to take away your additional nightkill yet.

[Ragian]

Well, tactics are not universal.