[SPECIAL] Surprise Mafia - Over - Mafia Wins - MVP Aladdin

[StorrZerg]

btw thanks for coming back to check in, and not doing anything!

(seriously, your gone for a while, you make no comment about anythign happening in the game, or about anyone. ) Other than to talk about insane stuff, to which you don't have an answer, just trying to drum up usless chatter imo.)

Things of note that are important to talk about
cop claims
mass claim
the weird thing regarding votes
cop checks
who people are voting on
seriously ANYTHING of value.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Why him over whatsausage, or benga?

I told falko that if he thought you were scum he should lynch PT first. No unvote do that will be interesting with the mucked up vote table.

Mtam is town as he is nailing his reads.

Storr, pt, ib are likely town in my books.

Aladdin, white rose, deg, benga, rish, falko are all anti town.

Mitch and dj need copchecking as i will never get a good read on em.

Have a good weekend everyone.

[DJPatrick]

wELL,
appears there has already been A mass Cop Claim...seriously, how many cops CAN there be in one game, even a large one like this so how is it possible to work out who's bullshitting at this stage? likewise with "claimed" cops' "claimed checks"???
Do we kill Mitch and what exactly is in these claimed suspicious packages? Where's mine? If I told you I had already received one would I be bullshytting? How would anyone know?
Yourself and Alladin have been pretty active, granted, but then Alladin was similarly active in our previous encounter ...I claimed Doc on Day two in that one and managed to make it through following night kills and Town won but it was bloody hard ...
In this one I may appear to be "under the radar" but my D2 vote on TWR is a gut feeling which I'm not changing just yet...
As to talking about insane stuff, I think this is the perfect game for that..

[StorrZerg]

Why do you put benga as anti town

[AladdinSane]

Maybe?
Games always slow down on weekends. ...

Their's uh...their's orlways Risk, y'know?

[AladdinSane]

As to talking about insane stuff, I think this is the perfect game for that..

ZINNNGGG!!! Noicely dun, DJP

[StorrZerg]

As to talking about insane stuff, I think this is the perfect game for that..

ZINNNGGG!!! Noicely dun, DJP

Eah... but to be gone and ignore any substance and only talk about that is poor. Doesn't help to further reads, or good discussion

[Iron Butterfly]

Why do you put benga as anti town

Conflicting cop checks?

Both of us can not be right. Does having a bad investigation make one scum?

I have a theory about the cops someone brought up and wing has posted that chart. Insane cop is dead. We have back up cop...Mitch? I am sure we have paranoid and Naive.How about a real one?

I think Wing was reading him scum before the cop thing.

ALSO Remeber when everyone lynched Strikewolf....BOOM?

From the way Mitch was talking I along with several others got packages. Mine was the 8 Ball. The others are Time Bombs??

[StorrZerg]

Why do you put benga as anti town

Conflicting cop checks?

Both of us can not be right. Does having a bad investigation make one scum?

I have a theory about the cops someone brought up and wing has posted that chart. Insane cop is dead. We have back up cop...Mitch? I am sure we have paranoid and Naive.How about a real one?

I think Wing was reading him scum before the cop thing.

ALSO Remeber when everyone lynched Strikewolf....BOOM?

From the way Mitch was talking I along with several others got packages. Mine was the 8 Ball. The others are Time Bombs??

He claimed his check before you.after another cop claim. Like why does he expos himself as anti town? Both checks in day time...

[StorrZerg]

Also mitch just claimed to hand out packages and isn't back up cop...

[Iron Butterfly]

Also mitch just claimed to hand out packages and isn't back up cop...

Why would he claim to hand out packages if they are bad for Town?

[StorrZerg]

Also mitch just claimed to hand out packages and isn't back up cop...

Why would he claim to hand out packages if they are bad for Town?

Because mitch enjoys fucking around. ...

[PLAYER57832]

Just a thort: does anyone else think that maybe Esylium is actually THE town and everyone who reads town is actually insane i.e. our roles are actually reversed to what they should be and we're acting ES REVERNI?

I'm new, but this does not seem to make sense with everything else. Possible for some of the folks, but not all.

[degaston]

... We have back up cop...Mitch? ...

From the way Mitch was talking I along with several others got packages. Mine was the 8 Ball. The others are Time Bombs??

First Mitch claimed to be a deputy, then he seemed crazy, then he was "NOBODY", then he was an evil mailman who had to be stopped for the good of the town. Having played with Mitch before, all of this could mean anything, but it seemed like he was just making up whatever lies he could think of so that he'd be lynched. It did not appear to me that he was trying to be helpful to town.

I received a gift last night. Doesn't say who it's from, and it doesn't even say that it was in the mail, but from the D2 mod message about a mailman in town, I assumed that it was. I can use it whenever I want, and I requested that Mitch be wounded. I don't really know what that means, but I'm guessing he may die by D3.

[/]

Ugh, finally caught up on a freaking horrifically long read.
Sorry, busy with school stuff, caught a cold too, bleh... Now I remember why I couldn't keep playing mafia last time. Dang y'all post fast.

Anyhow, thoughts so far.

Not sure what's going on with sanities, but I think it might be one of the following, from more likely to less likely.

1. Benga is a sane but limited cop, 8 ball is screwed up somehow (crazy, random, useless, whatever). The reason I think this is because I personally gave town screwed investigations on purpose at least twice in my games, one of those times, in Rolegift Mafia 2, I even used magic 8 balls as a flavor for it! As for WHY there would there be a role to give screwed investigations, it's more likely that you think. One, it's funny. Two it helps balance if town is OP. (Note to future mods, for bonus points let scum have this role, lets them make a townie of their choice look like a raving idiot when they mess up the result.) This also seems to click with this "beware the mailman" stuff.

2. Benga sane, 8 ball sane, certain people like IB naturally insane. With all this asylum stuff, it might be that some roles are naturally flawed in some way, like tainting the gifts they receive. This would click with why Hotshot, despite seemingly being a generic survivor has a role with "Delusional" in it. And why a guard needed to get a patient straight up killed. Because "Insane-asylum guard" is also "Insane, Asylum guard", because yay puns and cheesy jokes.

3. Benga insane, 8 ball sane.

4. Some sort of lying to save an ally/get brownie points situation. Not all that likely IMO

5. All the investigations are screwed, abandon ship!

Anyhow, Vote Whatsausage.
Also, WTF Falkomagno, why are you also voting the claimed cop out of nowhere? You didn't even attach a case to that.

[AladdinSane]

As to talking about insane stuff, I think this is the perfect game for that..

ZINNNGGG!!! Noicely dun, DJP

Eah... but to be gone and ignore any substance and only talk about that is poor. Doesn't help to further reads, or good discussion

Can you, like, switch to decaf or sumting?

But yeah, I tink I'm gonna reread the last ten pages or so, then I'll post thoughts about playas I find suspishus. I'm not reely on top of the whatsausage issue just yet, or wot shood be done about Mitch, and the votecount ting is doing my hed in.

[AladdinSane]

Also mitch just claimed to hand out packages and isn't back up cop...

Why would he claim to hand out packages if they are bad for Town?

Because mitch enjoys fucking around. ...

Five posibilities occur to me.

1. Mitch is jester and is trying to get linched. Seems a bit obvious, though.

2. Mitch wants us to tink he is jester so he don't get linched - dis strykes me as unlikely becorse he wozent under any particular presha. Still, maybe he is just been far-sited.

3. Mitch is Town and, as he said, has been told the rest of the packages are bad for Town, so he is sacrificng himself for the good of Town. If he gets linched today, the other packages don't get delivered.

4. Mitch is insane and, while he believes the packages are bad for Town, they are akshually good for Town.

5. Yeah, "Because mitch enjoys fucking around". I'm not shore wot Mitch's sex life has to do wit anyting but okay, it's a possibility.

I have no idea which of these I wood want to go wit. And I'm shore their are other posibilities two.

[AladdinSane]

Oh, and of corse

6. Mitch is lying about his roll again.

[AladdinSane]

Things of note that are important to talk about
cop claims
mass claim
the weird thing regarding votes
cop checks
who people are voting on
seriously ANYTHING of value.

Also

magic 8 ball / IB
Mitch / packages
strategy: how do we move foreward knowing that any given cop investigayshun is likely tainted (or at leest there is a good chance it is tainted?

[AladdinSane]

IB has claimed insane guard, so I think he might have known.

NO! Dis was clarified erlier wen I pointed out that IB's inishal deskripshun of his roll was ambi...ambig...ambigyoous. IB stated cleearly he is the gard of an insane esylum, NOT an insane gard of an esylum.

[AladdinSane]

Benga my magic 8 ball got Town on sausage.

For clarity I asked mod if magic 8 ball works like real life...hehe random results stuff. No magic 8 ball is right.

IB, you have a talent for stating tings ambi...ambig...ambigoously. First their was the "insane esylum gard" / "sane gard of the insane esylum' ting, and now dis.

I thort you were saying "No magic 8 ball is right" - i.e. "There are no magic 8 balls that are right", but on re-reading, and in teh lite of other posts, I see you ment "No, magic 8 ball is right" - i.e. "No, the magic 8 ball is not random, it gives accurate results".

So, if I remmebr correcly, the majik 8 borl, wich you claim gives accurate results, says whatsausage is Town, and Benga, who claims retired cop, says whatsausage is anti-Town. Who to believe?

Sum posibilites:

1. We don't have any evidence that there even is a magic 8 borl. Maybe it's just a story IB is making up. He seems to get speshal info each day, and has had a differnt story about how he got it each day. Maybe tomorro he will say a leprecorn appeard anf told him sumthing about sumbody.

2. There is a majik 8 borl and it is ackurate, so Benga is lying/insane/paranoid - implikashun is that sausage is Town

3. There is a majik 8 borl and is isn't ackurate, and we just don't know about Benga's sanity or even wether his cop claim is true - implikashun is that sausage is anti-Town.

I'm not shore wich of dese I want to go wit just yet. Wil give it moor thort.

[AladdinSane]

Posibility: IB is post-restricted to state sertin tings ambi...ambig...ambigoously.

[AladdinSane]

Shiiiiiiiiiiiit...

Or maybe IB really IS saying that there are no majik 8 borls that are accurate. WIFOM, I know, but in a game like dis, how to avoid it?

[Streaker]

Vote count:

-AladdinSane (3): Storrzerg*, Wing*, ptlowe*
-Storrzerg (3): madmitch*, Rishaed*, falkomagno*
-the white rose (4): Iron Butterfly*, DJPatrick*, Iron Butterfly, LSU Tiger Josh*
-benga (1): whatsausage*
-no vote (1): player57832*
-ptlowe (2): whatsausage, falkomagno
-whatsausage (5): benga*, ptlowe, Metsfanmax*, Metsfanmax, / (aka Slash)*
-Metsfanmax (1): Wing

Deadline is January 22nd, 09.00 CC Time. It takes 14 to have a majority. Reaching this deadline while your vote is not currently placed, will result in modkill.

[rishaed]

Vote count:

-AladdinSane (3): Storrzerg*, Wing*, ptlowe*
-Storrzerg (3): madmitch*, Rishaed*, falkomagno*
-the white rose (4): Iron Butterfly*, DJPatrick*, Iron Butterfly, LSU Tiger Josh*
-benga (1): whatsausage*
-no vote (1): player57832*
-ptlowe (2): whatsausage, falkomagno
-whatsausage (5): benga*, ptlowe, Metsfanmax*, Metsfanmax, / (aka Slash)*
-Metsfanmax (1): Wing

Deadline is January 22nd, 09.00 CC Time. It takes 14 to have a majority. Reaching this deadline while your vote is not currently placed, will result in modkill.

What are the stars for? If you'd be willing to tell me