One night ultimate werewolf - Game over - Werewolves win

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Hey its hard to win as Tanner. Was going for it.

Alright I'll let you off, your play did make sense then.

[BuJaber]

If he was tanner and mitch switched him he would not tell us to shoot LSU.

one thing is for sure.. pt is NOT tanner.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

If he was tanner and mitch switched him he would not tell us to shoot LSU.

one thing is for sure.. pt is NOT tanner.

Longer game than that. PT was banking on Mitch lying, in which case PT had a good shot at getting himself lynched by claiming that he was the Werewolf. As Mitch would then claim that he was lying and PT was still the werewolf.

[DoomYoshi]

I'm the robber. I hit madmitch so now he is the robber.

[DoomYoshi]

Incidentally, unvote vote falko. He knows the story was made up since he is a werewolf I think. I don't think we've heard from LSU all game...

[madmitch]

@ Doom so you switched with me, well I think my actions went through or did they ? I know you didn't get them, one good thing we are both town aligned and we need to kill a werewolf but who? IT is either LSU or PT or falko. just wondering why LSU hasn't deny the claim.

[BuJaber]

I'm the robber. I hit madmitch so now he is the robber.

So he was the troublemaker?

[Falkomagno]

Incidentally, unvote vote falko. He knows the story was made up since he is a werewolf I think. I don't think we've heard from LSU all game...

but if is made up, then also wing is lying, as he was confirming mitch lie.

Now im confused, as it seems ptlowe was playing risky fro no reason....My scenario is that mich and wing are the werewolves and ptlowe is the minion. It is pretty obvius if you think about it. Dont join the bandgwagon against me, you fool.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Incidentally, unvote vote falko. He knows the story was made up since he is a werewolf I think. I don't think we've heard from LSU all game...

but if is made up, then also wing is lying, as he was confirming mitch lie.

Now im confused, as it seems ptlowe was playing risky fro no reason....My scenario is that mich and wing are the werewolves and ptlowe is the minion. It is pretty obvius if you think about it. Dont join the bandgwagon against me, you fool.

What the actual.....

No counterclaim on seer, troublemaker or tanner (though unlikely to get a counterclaim on the last)

So what, those three cards just happen to be the spares and we claimed them without knowing that?

Doom -why would a werewolf get involved in the discussion when they could just let LSU be lynched?

[ptlowe]

vote falk your scumming

[ptlowe]

Why in the hell would I claim tanner after Mitch was confirmed troublemaker. If I was werewolf game is over with wing confirm

[Falkomagno]

Why in the hell would I claim tanner after Mitch was confirmed troublemaker. If I was werewolf game is over with wing confirm

Ahh but instead you are playing orchestrated with Wing. Like two buddies. Both of you are the werewolves. Good luck with the town buying your non-case.

[madmitch]

@ FALKO you seem to want to kill us town people, I think you are a minion and LSU is your werewolf buddy , I would vote for you but it would do me no good so VOTE LSU

[DoomYoshi]

@ Doom so you switched with me, well I think my actions went through or did they ? I know you didn't get them, one good thing we are both town aligned and we need to kill a werewolf but who? IT is either LSU or PT or falko. just wondering why LSU hasn't deny the claim.

Your actions do go through, I only steal your alignment.

[DoomYoshi]

@wing: I'm not sure, it just stood out to me. I think you are probably right although right now I am having trouble understanding falko.

[ptlowe]

Why in the hell would I claim tanner after Mitch was confirmed troublemaker. If I was werewolf game is over with wing confirm

Ahh but instead you are playing orchestrated with Wing. Like two buddies. Both of you are the werewolves. Good luck with the town buying your non-case.

Naw your logic is idiotic at best. Your the wolf

[ptlowe]

If LSU is lynched he will win. If you switched us Mitch he is the tanner

[Falkomagno]

wing keeps trying to support ptlowe action, where he claim werewolf, then back off saying that he was tanner instead. The protection pt is getting from mitch and wing and his reckless actions indicates that pt is the minion, and wing and mitch the werewolves. The he only thing not matching here is yoshi joining the bandwagon against me that doesn't make any sense. I told you that they were lying and pt already acknowledge it, so i was right...

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Falko claim please

[HotShot53]

I just sent a reminder to LSU since although he confirmed via PM, he hasn't posted in the thread yet.

As a FYI, I will not be posting vote counts since all votes in the thread are not official. Only the votes via PM after the day ends will be official.

The day will end at 22:00 CCT on Thursday, May 5. If LSU has to be replaced I will extend the day if requested.

[BuJaber]

I am so lost at this point.

Maybe if I break it down into steps.

I'm sorry pt, there are too many bad roles you could be before or after the switch, and you have no idea of knowing yourself, so I can't trust your nomination
BUT wing and Yoshi are agreeing with you so maybe voting Falko is a good choice. I'm just gonna wait and see what LSU says.


Thanks Hotshot for trying this. I never imagined that the game could work on a forum, but not having the ability to read faces/body language is actually making this a lot more challenging.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

YOU ALL NEED TO CLAIM

This IS LYLO

[madmitch]

you are right wcg. we need claims before we can go any futher, we really need to find out what or who LSU was before I changed him.

[Falkomagno]

This is confusing, but I think i got the idea now.
I am the witch, and I pick up troublemaker from the center…so I knew mitch was lying. The reaction of pt lowe confused me, as it looked impossible to be so naïve and claim right away werewolf, and then wing supporting mitch claim.
What I think now is that the wolves are mitch, wing and Yoshi instead, while pt is for real the tanner. Now the thing is to see who is the minor of those 3.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I got vanilla townie. I hate vt roles in games in general and tend to just ride them out when i get them early on. Whether I was switched or not, I don't know. I just know that this would be easier reading expressions in general instead of just what is posted