WoT:Mem of Light An Ending

[TimWoodbury]

im skum lynch im here ill help vote tim

[StorrZerg]

doom i think you are confusing 2 people...

[aage]

Hey! I just got here I would be happy to go after anyone who killed the past me especially Doom who never backed me up or Mandy who has the worst story ever.

According to your own logic, your past self was scum.

You said: I am town, you will know this because Doom was roleblocked.

If you follow that to its logical conclusion, then if Doom wasn't roleblocked, you are lying and you are therefore scum, right? Isn't that how proof works?

Since I wasn't roleblocked you were therefore scum. You literally should have voted yourself if you would only apply the rules of logic to your own reasoning.

vote mandy

Mitch still hasn't seemed to realise his action was apparently redirected. I state again: there's why you never let dead players sub.

[madmitch]

@ Aage I finally understand thanks.

[BuJaber]

Let's wait for results and see who's even alive first
And in case I'm dead: I want my last word to be cheese.

So you think someone is dead?

Rish said he would start the day then "may" post the results few hours after.

That's what I was talking about... Everyone seems to assume that there were no deaths.

If that's the case... Gregwolf's input is vital to figure out the whole mitch/new guy/mandy busdrive claims. If he has some sort of lightning rod role that could explain some things. Otherwise there are apparently 3 busdrivers.. which would be weird.

If the people who didn't post during D2 don't post again, then I will vote for one of them.

Mitch replaced William so there's that. Let's not forget that he could be scum this time.

My case against Doom would be much stronger if mitch had flipped light, so now I am assuming he is dark. Also I think he'd be a lot more nervous in his posting if he was light.

[StorrZerg]

cept that would be for "other actions" not death. that kinda has to happen at day start.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

cept that would be for "other actions" not death. that kinda has to happen at day start.

And seeing as "Luc" dodged death its quite explanatory.

Bujaber is scum.

Ask a simple question, get an essay in defence. Scum

[BuJaber]

cept that would be for "other actions" not death. that kinda has to happen at day start.

Alright fair enough


Wing.. the game is harder when you're actually playing it, isn't it?.. your brilliant deductions have been just as wrong as all of ours so far. The simplest explanation is usually the correct one.. I acted confused because I was confused because I expected 2 posts from Rish. I didn't give an essay in response... I responded to you and made my opening post for D3. 2 small posts in one. Actually, if you lynch me that'd be 3 for 3 dark players... perhaps that is your intention all along?

aage - remember your case on rish in the pokemon game? Any chance it could apply to mets here?

I want to vote for tim just for his last post. Who votes for themselves like that for being "scum"? It's like some bad reverse psychology.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

your brilliant deductions have been just as wrong as all of ours so far.

Which of my deductions have been wrong?

[BuJaber]

your brilliant deductions have been just as wrong as all of ours so far.

Which of my deductions have been wrong?

I thought dakky and mitch.. Sorry I thought you voted for mitch too. And dakky everybody thought was scum when we thought dark = scum, so that one isn't really wrong. Verdict still out on Mandy. But anyway I've more or less agreed with your choices in this game so I thought you were on the mitch wagon too. Though I don't recall you saying that he isn't scum just that mandy is the better target. (Didn't check this, don't care, not important right now).

Turns out it's just me that's wrong.

[DoomYoshi]

doom i think you are confusing 2 people...

Nope. Just carrying on with my life.

[mandalorian2298]

Hey! I just got here I would be happy to go after anyone who killed the past me especially Doom who never backed me up or Mandy who has the worst story ever.

aaaaaand there's why you never let dead players sub.

Amen.

Anyway, I have absolutely no new ideas to contribute.

[Ragian]

Nothing has swayed my opinion. With no added information, I'm voting mandy. No death is nice.

[BuJaber]

Mandy how about you give us all the information you have gained this game. We either believe you or we don't but either way that information could come in handy regardless of how the lynch goes. If you're town don't die in vain. You claimed to have switched yourself with new guy N1, what about N2?

[aage]

aage - remember your case on rish in the pokemon game? Any chance it could apply to mets here?

Could I? Probably. Should I? Probably not. He disagreed with me - that's fine. I didn't go after Rish in the pokemon game because he was being sceptical, I did it because I believed he was using his stance to gain leverage without providing a reasonable alternative. Mets doesn't need leverage, the case already exists and he is using sound logic. I especially enjoyed this post, thought it was excellent.. the only off point was that Mitch soft claimed and then hard claimed immediately after with no pressure. Besides, Mets went after a reasonable target D2 while Rish did not in the other game, and if Mets is scum, he was definitely not afraid to get his hands dirty on Dakky.


I'll need a bit to reread some stuff though. A week of downtime kills the momentum.

[aage]

Storr, do you believe Greg is a lightning rod type role, and if so do you think he's town?

[StorrZerg]

Storr, do you believe Greg is a lightning rod type role, and if so do you think he's town?

I don't think this question leads in a good direction. We should be looking at contributions. I don't think trying to just out roles helps. I don't think it matters if he is, or if something else is doing it. This game setup is confusing. We are fighting miss information regarding setup and flavor. Better to push actions. I don't think Greg has been stellar, I'd lynch off of that. But others have done worse

[mandalorian2298]

Mandy how about you give us all the information you have gained this game. We either believe you or we don't but either way that information could come in handy regardless of how the lynch goes. If you're town don't die in vain. You claimed to have switched yourself with new guy N1, what about N2?

Sure.

As long as you give me a reasonable (to me) explanation how publicaly sharing information whom I switched with whom is going to help the Dark. I switched X with Y. Having find out who X and Y are, what would be your next move?

[sam_levi_11]

Okay so no death is probably the best result we could hope for. Makes me wonder what happened to stop a dark being night killed, presumably we have a role blocker who hit their target or probably a bulletproof dark player who was hit. With little new information to go on, I'm thinking we will probably end up starting where we finished D2, looking at Mandy. That said, I'm going to hold off voting for Mandy for now.

im skum lynch im here ill help vote tim

I want to vote for you just for this. It comes off as some weak GCSE (I'm a brit, think 15 year olds) psychology shit. You didn't post anything of use. You didn't give a point of view, you didn't give us information and you didn't analyse everything else. This comes across as just wanting to appear active.

If Marashu & Tokle don't post more than once or twice when we get further into today, I'll be voting for them.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Guys get some balls.

Vote Mandy

Also ignore Tim, if we have a vig kill him.

[StorrZerg]

Vote Mandy



@sam doesn't really matter what caused no death. Either you know or you don't. and killers know. So they are going to be looking for people softing shit. 0 point talking about it. literally only helps mafia. If it pertains to the lynch, that is different.


Wing, im pretty sure we have a vig. It wont be a normal "vig" but im sure we have something.

[madmitch]

@ Mandy are you still sticking to your story of who you are? After rereading about Graendal in this part of the story she was killed and resurrected as an old hag Hessalam not the pretty girl you are claiming.

[BuJaber]

Mandy - It is possible that you telling us your night action might be collaborated by someone else because of his/her role & night actions. Then we either find two scum, or we don't mislynch you. I only see positives for town.

Wing - With all the claims of busdriving going on, vig becomes less powerful with a setup like this. Seem like lynch is the best way to kill who we want. I'm not saying tim is necessarily the better target, but since right now both are probably light, we should lynch the person who is most likely to be light.

Voting for mandy this early makes little sense.. he already claimed. Just from the people who have posted already, we have like 5/8 guaranteed voters on him if we need. Let's put pressure on tokle/marashu/greg.

Vote Tokle

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Mandy - It is possible that you telling us your night action might be collaborated by someone else because of his/her role & night actions. Then we either find two scum, or we don't mislynch you. I only see positives for town.

Wing - With all the claims of busdriving going on, vig becomes less powerful with a setup like this. Seem like lynch is the best way to kill who we want. I'm not saying tim is necessarily the better target, but since right now both are probably light, we should lynch the person who is most likely to be light.

Voting for mandy this early makes little sense.. he already claimed. Just from the people who have posted already, we have like 5/8 guaranteed voters on him if we need. Let's put pressure on tokle/marashu/greg.

Vote Tokle

I am such a fool, cant believe I didnt see it before.

Mandys partner everybody.

Yeah sure, lets ignore that Mandy has claimed a character not in the same sequence as Mitch previous role.... lets instead go after someone for not posting.

Game over.

Lynch Mandy, then lynch Bujaber.

[DoomYoshi]

Is the Bujaber/aage interaction scum asking for help or scum looking for an easy lynch? I know mandy is brilliant so he may have told Bujaber to do that to lead to WIFOM trying to clear or frame aage.