Batman Mafia~~~GOTHAM WINS!!!!!!!!

gethine · Post by **gethine** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 1:29 pm

kalishnikov wrote:
Serbia wrote:btw, nice to have you Kalish
I'm glad we got to play again, Serbia. This game I probably won't spend every night trying to kill you

just probably?

kalishnikov · Post by **kalishnikov** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 1:56 pm

gethine wrote:
kalishnikov wrote:
Serbia wrote:btw, nice to have you Kalish
I'm glad we got to play again, Serbia. This game I probably won't spend every night trying to kill you
just probably?

lol, yea just probably. You never know...

MountainLion · Post by **MountainLion** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 2:09 pm

nagerous wrote:
gimpyThewonder wrote:
nagerous wrote:I think the random vote concept introduced in this game is dangerous as no-one knows who it is that is lynched and it might be a very important power role.
and that's different from what usually happens how? i've only seen scum caught out on the first day once (i might not have huge experience, but i've seen plenty of games), and he was a complete noob. i thought rather than wadding through 10 pages of people claiming to random vote, but really voting for whoever they don't like from previous games, i'd take the more fun way and try out a new feature. ah well, as always anything anyone says or does on day 1 looks scummy and gets you the finger

the people who get lynched on day 1 are normally idiots that screw the game up anyway and pro-town or not it is often good to see the back of them. With this random vote concept anyone could go including the most experienced players and instead we would get left with noob deadbeaters plus no proper information to go on as it would just be a lottery.

gimpyThewonder, do you have a reply to this?

MountainLion · Post by **MountainLion** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 2:10 pm

derfderf34 wrote:
Skittles! wrote:
pancakemix wrote:
Skittles! wrote:But fool is an actual role, and how would a jester know that?
Because he is told. In a PM. With his role.
Fool and Jester are different. Jester wins by getting lynched, right?
Fool(s) need to lynch someone as their first post every day.
no fool means i can only vote for completely random reasons

If derfderf is a Fool and can only vote for completely random reasons than he's of no use to us. His role, if he didn't roleclaim and played it well, would have disrupted the game. Why he roleclaimed is strange, and I'd like to hear his answer. Either way, thanks for roleclaiming derf. Now we know we can ignore you and not waste a lynch.

cmckinney · Post by **cmckinney** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 2:14 pm

what is a fool?

Serbia · Post by **Serbia** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 2:20 pm

kalishnikov wrote:
gethine wrote:
kalishnikov wrote:
Serbia wrote:btw, nice to have you Kalish
I'm glad we got to play again, Serbia. This game I probably won't spend every night trying to kill you
just probably?
lol, yea just probably. You never know...

FOS Kalish, starting trouble with me already!

Talapus · Post by **Talapus** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 3:06 pm

Vote Count:

(2)gethine – anarkistsdream, Iliad,
(1)Fircoal - willis
(2)cmckinney – LSU Tiger Josh, freezie
(2)random – gimpyThewonder, derfder34
(2)pancakemix – Fircoal, I Got Served
(1)Iliad – pancakemix
(1)MountainLion - jnd94
(1)Kernal_Kronic - nagerous

With 26 players it takes 14 to lynch. Day 1 will end 4am(PST) on June 12th . That’s 39 hours from now, make them count!

Chad22342 has been replaced by spinwizard, and kwanton took Iliad's place(and no, I still have no idea why Iliad was forum banned.)

Serbia · Post by **Serbia** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 3:44 pm

In this case, allow me to be the first. VOTE: Spinwizard

spinwizard · Post by **spinwizard** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 3:55 pm

Serbia wrote:In this case, allow me to be the first. VOTE: Spinwizard

wh

Serbia · Post by **Serbia** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 4:00 pm

No good reason, just felt it was necessary. If I didn't, wouldn't Fircoal?

gimpyThewonder · Post by **gimpyThewonder** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 4:04 pm

MountainLion wrote:
nagerous wrote:
gimpyThewonder wrote:
nagerous wrote:I think the random vote concept introduced in this game is dangerous as no-one knows who it is that is lynched and it might be a very important power role.
and that's different from what usually happens how? i've only seen scum caught out on the first day once (i might not have huge experience, but i've seen plenty of games), and he was a complete noob. i thought rather than wadding through 10 pages of people claiming to random vote, but really voting for whoever they don't like from previous games, i'd take the more fun way and try out a new feature. ah well, as always anything anyone says or does on day 1 looks scummy and gets you the finger

the people who get lynched on day 1 are normally idiots that screw the game up anyway and pro-town or not it is often good to see the back of them. With this random vote concept anyone could go including the most experienced players and instead we would get left with noob deadbeaters plus no proper information to go on as it would just be a lottery.
gimpyThewonder, do you have a reply to this?

didn't know i was supposed to...

but i stand by what i said. I just reallllly don't enjoy day one, its rare that a useful clue is dropped and it really only seems to serve people's personal grudges and enmity towards certain other players (waranted or not) in getting them out of the game. I think sometimes people forget that its all just a game, and that really we are all just kids at heart (regardless of age), why else would we be playing a game but to have fun? sure some players are annoying as heck, but perhaps one day they will grow up a little and be as stuffy as some of the other players. is that what you wanted as a reply? I like the idea of random gamewide rather than random among the less experienced or annoying. I'm an equal-opportunity lyncher. end-mild-rant

derfderf34 · Post by **derfderf34** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 4:04 pm

cmckinney wrote:what is a fool?

a player who can only vote for completely random reasons

Serbia · Post by **Serbia** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 4:12 pm

gimpyThewonder wrote:
MountainLion wrote:
nagerous wrote:
gimpyThewonder wrote:
nagerous wrote:I think the random vote concept introduced in this game is dangerous as no-one knows who it is that is lynched and it might be a very important power role.
and that's different from what usually happens how? i've only seen scum caught out on the first day once (i might not have huge experience, but i've seen plenty of games), and he was a complete noob. i thought rather than wadding through 10 pages of people claiming to random vote, but really voting for whoever they don't like from previous games, i'd take the more fun way and try out a new feature. ah well, as always anything anyone says or does on day 1 looks scummy and gets you the finger

the people who get lynched on day 1 are normally idiots that screw the game up anyway and pro-town or not it is often good to see the back of them. With this random vote concept anyone could go including the most experienced players and instead we would get left with noob deadbeaters plus no proper information to go on as it would just be a lottery.
gimpyThewonder, do you have a reply to this?
didn't know i was supposed to...

but i stand by what i said. I just reallllly don't enjoy day one, its rare that a useful clue is dropped and it really only seems to serve people's personal grudges and enmity towards certain other players (waranted or not) in getting them out of the game. I think sometimes people forget that its all just a game, and that really we are all just kids at heart (regardless of age), why else would we be playing a game but to have fun? sure some players are annoying as heck, but perhaps one day they will grow up a little and be as stuffy as some of the other players. is that what you wanted as a reply? I like the idea of random gamewide rather than random among the less experienced or annoying. I'm an equal-opportunity lyncher. end-mild-rant

Let me add my two cents...

The random vote is an interesting feature. I'm personally not going to use it. Say we all get together and just vote 'random'. When we get a lynch, whether pro- or ant- Gotham, what will we have learned? We all voted, but no-one VOTED for the guy who's been lynched. And why not just vote 'random' the whole game? The mafia will continue to kill who they want during the night, and all of us choosing the 'random' option will learn nothing. When we force a vote on day one, we have a record of who voted for who. This record becomes valuable the longer the game goes on. Voting 'random' therefore makes you look scummy, in my opinion. If you want to vote that way, fine, go ahead. As for me, I won't. (now were I scum, I might feel differently

)

cmckinney · Post by **cmckinney** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 4:26 pm

I agree with Serbia's statement that using the random vote seems like a tool the mafia would use in order to have an easy lynch. Since they are the far minority, the odds of it getting voted for one of them is smaller than the odds one of them will slip up.

MountainLion · Post by **MountainLion** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 4:29 pm

gimpy, I agree with your reasoning, but Serbia said exactly why I wouldn't vote random either.

IGMEOY gimpy

Vote Skoffin. you posted once...do you have any more to add?

cmckinney · Post by **cmckinney** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 4:33 pm

is IGMEOY= i got my eye on you?

MountainLion · Post by **MountainLion** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 4:37 pm

cmckinney wrote:is IGMEOY= i got my eye on you?

yup

derfderf34 · Post by **derfderf34** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 5:44 pm

unvote

vote cmckinney because that cat is obiously very evil

pancakemix · Post by **pancakemix** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 5:47 pm

First, I think you made up that fool crap. Second, you're not fooling anyone. Third, STFU.

cmckinney · Post by **cmckinney** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 6:36 pm

derfderf34 wrote:unvote

vote cmckinney because that cat is obiously very evil

???????????

Oh yes, I am obviously evil, simply because, as fircoal can vouch for, i tend to push for a quick vote for people who will do nothing to help or even harm our mission to weed out the mafia. WTH!

cmckinney · Post by **cmckinney** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 6:37 pm

pancakemix wrote:First, I think you made up that fool crap. Second, you're not fooling anyone. Third, STFU.

Who are you saying that to?

pancakemix · Post by **pancakemix** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 6:37 pm

cmckinney wrote:
pancakemix wrote:First, I think you made up that fool crap. Second, you're not fooling anyone. Third, STFU.
Who are you saying that to?

Derfderf.

Skittles! · Post by **Skittles!** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 7:13 pm

Is DerfDerf meant to be in an Insane Ayslum or does he just want to be lynched?

Skoffin · Post by **Skoffin** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 7:20 pm

MountainLion wrote:gimpy, I agree with your reasoning, but Serbia said exactly why I wouldn't vote random either.

IGMEOY gimpy

Vote Skoffin. you posted once...do you have any more to add?

I haven't slept in two days, give me a break =P I don't really have much to add at this point, lack of sleep and lack of evidence to go on.

Skittles! wrote:Is DerfDerf meant to be in an Insane Ayslum or does he just want to be lynched?

Or it could just be a very strange but clever way to keep from being lynched for most the game? Afterall, he already has half the players decided to ignore him.

Talapus · Post by **Talapus** » Sun Jun 10, 2007 8:04 pm

Vote Count:

(1)gethine – anarkistsdream
(1)Fircoal - willis
(3)cmckinney – LSU Tiger Josh, freezie, derfderf34
(1)random – gimpyThewonder
(2)pancakemix – Fircoal, I Got Served
(1)MountainLion - jnd94
(1)Kernal_Kronic - nagerous
(1)Spinwizard – Serbia
(1)Skoffin – MountainLion

With 26 players it takes 14 to lynch. Day 1 will end 4am(PST) on June 12th . That’s 34 hours from now, make them count!

Chad22342 has been replaced by spinwizard, and kwanton took Iliad's place(and no, I still have no idea why Iliad was forum banned.)