Moderator: Community Team
But if Two Face is mafia, the Cult Leader would die if he tried to recruit a mafia member, right?kalishnikov wrote:Also true, I hadn't considered that.derfderf34 wrote:there might be a cult and two face was joining itkalishnikov wrote:True, but the night log said 2 figures were reported talking by the bushes where the coin was found. I'm not sure the SK would be colluding with someone else. Thats why I suggested he was part of a 2 man team as seems to be the tendencies so far with the mafia groups unless I'm misreading the night scenes, which is a possibility.
First, every version of the insane cop I've played with gets the opposite results on the investigation. Random results would be a bitch....kwanton wrote:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harvey_Bullock_%28comics%29
Bullock is definitely good. But if mandy is a cop, he is not sane. Here are the options as far as I see it:
Mandy is lying. Koesen is town.
Mandy is telling the truth but is paranoid. Koesen is either town or mafia. No way of knowing.
Mandy is telling the truth but is insane. Now I've heard of two different versions of the insane cop. One is that the cop gets opposite roles. If that is the case then Koesen is town. The other is that the investigation turns out random. If that is the case there is no way of knowing.
So the evidence automatically tells me not to vote for Koesen without anything else to go by. Am I right?
That is true. When I was writing that last post I wasn't really thinking about the fact that Gordon would be the sane cop, almost for sure.kwanton wrote:You overlooked one thing kalish:
1)XenCobra - A.K.A. “Commissioner Gordon/Chief Of Police” – Pro-Gotham/Cop
We already had a cop die. And I would bet my ass that gordon was the sane one. If everyone chooses to go after koesen however, I won't go against the town.
Mandy would not be naive. He got a guilty off two people. My bet would be paranoid or insane.jnd94 wrote:Dont vote kosen. Its gonna be another progotham if you do. its simple, comissioner gordon should be the sane one, so, if there is another cop then it would have to be paranoid, insane, or naive, which could all mislead us into a lynch. I wouldnt go for this lynch just yet.
All in all the good guys are getting a load of Cack herekalishnikov wrote:The cop doesn't know if he's insane or sane. When he gets the pm from the mod, it just says "Cop". Its up to the mod what results he gets.Huckleberryhound wrote:So, what's the point of an insane cop investigating anyone ?
It just adds another layer to the game.
I've actually stated some very good points on why to not lynch Koesen. Not many people seem to listen to me so at this point it's turning into a case of "If ya can't beat em, speed up the proccess then laugh at them for not listening to you."MountainLion wrote:We should hear from koesen before we lynch him....you never know.
How many votes is that on him? Does anyone else want to get more discussion before we lynch koesen so fast?
Well, if you already suspect this is a wrong vote, then why don't you take it back? It's not like we're anywhere near the deadline.kwanton wrote:I've stated repeatedly that mandy's sanity is suspect and I gave the possibility that he is lying. I gave into voting for you after many people DID NOT LISTEN TO ME!!!![]()
![]()
Consider the above. First Mandalorian goes around fossing people for no reason at all, and only when he's prodded, he suddenly comes with his cop claim and accusation.mandalorian2298 wrote:You want me to add something? Fine, since this game is big and not very productive, so far. I am Detective Bullock. On first night I investigated Gimpy and he showed Anti-Gotham. On this Night I investigated koesen and he too showed Anti-Gotham. But, give the character of Detective Bullock, I am really not so sure of my sanity (plus the fact that I usually suck in power using).MountainLion wrote:Mandy, is this all you have to contribute? Usually you have 3 or 4 paragraphs in your posts.mandalorian2298 wrote:FOS multiple people wearing the same avatar and a minor Fosito on people with similar avatarspancakemix wrote:That's derfderf.
BTW derfderf has a Green Bay Packers avy.
Well, there's only one way to find out: vote koesen
