D5 of The Reid technique Mafia Game

[SoN!c]

Official vote count:

Kingm (4) Extreme Ways, Loose Canon, Devante, Charle




With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch!

[halrob64]

Vote Kingm

[SoN!c]

Official vote count:

Kingm: (5) Extreme Ways, Loose Canon, Devante, Charle, Halrob


KINGM IS AT L-1 *

*L-[X] – Refers to the number of additional votes required to LYNCH a player!

Because: With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch!

[Darin44]

I would vote Kingm but I would like to see what he from him first

he is on my list after rereading. I skipped over the poems the first time around

my list
Kongming - something just doesn't set right with me
Kingm - something just doesn't set right with me
Hjelp - something just doesn't set right with me

town
Loose Canon - has me hanging on ever word. could be me down fall
Ragian - trying to give him fresh start

not sure
Halrob more town than not
Charle more town than not
Strike Wolf
Devante - 3rd party maybe
EW hard to figure out more town than not

[halrob64]

well I think everyone wants to hear from Kingm Darin, hopefully won't take too

[halrob64]

Loose is a wizard regardless of allegiance

[halrob64]

I think Charle is more likely the Elevator Killer

[halrob64]

https://www.bing.com/videos/riverview/r ... ORM=VAMGZC
if you see this guy at night its Charle...runnnnn

[Extreme Ways]

Unvote
Kingm, claim please.

[Extreme Ways]

Loose is completely correct here btw. Mafia have more information by virtue of being the informed majority. They know what roles exist on their side, which also means they can fill in what other roles may exist more easily.

EW, surely they won't know the roles of their scum partners on day 1 until the night when they talk to each other. They know who their partners are at this stage but not their roles? Unless scum has day talk as well which is not impossible with Sonic Setup

Depends on the host I guess but I would give team + role regardless.

[hjelp]

@ halrob64

An idea, if you vote Kingman then I will vote too, we vote for leverage and then see what will happen ?
What do you think?

Ok, I will too.

Vote Kingman

[Kingm]

Wow, I had not checked in the last like 48h, and have went from 0 votes to almost lynched.

I have been extremely busy (check my game count, if you think I'm talking shit), just all of a sudden got spammed with 50 new games in one day, its insane.

And I'm town, I'm a PR, I do not want to be more specific, since I probably already am in deep shit, any doc please protect me tonight.

Will try my best to read up and contribute later, just have to get my head above water first.

FP by hjelp

[Devante]

UNVOTE KINGM

for now to ensure there is no speed lynch. Will expect more from you king but will see what others have to say first

[hjelp]

Wow, I had not checked in the last like 48h, and have went from 0 votes to almost lynched.

I have been extremely busy (check my game count, if you think I'm talking shit), just all of a sudden got spammed with 50 new games in one day, its insane.

And I'm town, I'm a PR, I do not want to be more specific, since I probably already am in deep shit, any doc please protect me tonight.

Will try my best to read up and contribute later, just have to get my head above water first.

FP by hjelp

Anyone at L-1 would have said the same (almost). What if there is no doctor ? You are at L-1 and still claim contribute later. It has been 48 hrs according to you.

[hjelp]

well, L-2 now

[hjelp]

Unvote Kingman

[kongming3]

Don't think a doctor should protect/default to protecting kingm here, and I don't think anyone should plan around that being the case.

[halrob64]

Maybe he doesn't need protecting, maybe he is playing the bluff and hoping to get to nightfall without getting lynched?

[hjelp]

Maybe he doesn't need protecting, maybe he is playing the bluff and hoping to get to nightfall without getting lynched?

good point

Vote Kingman

[Kingm]

Full claim then: 50% Vanilla Town, 50% Cop, I will not give away if its odd or even day I can investigate, since that will make it really easy to block if scum has a roleblocker.
I also hope that we town have more investigation power than this, but I have a feeling that maybe nobody is 100% vanilla, and everyone at least have some kind of power, that's at least my guess.

And to any other cops, if you have the ability to check me N1, then do so and then have me lynched D2 if I'm lying.

[Loose Canon]

I'm just going to say I have flipped re Extreme now, as I've thought about what was going on in my mind some more.

I think I found it unusual that Extreme had taken the lead on 2 lynch pressure votes.
Bearing in mind that Extreme often subs in, that Sonic often plays, I've often thrown around D1 lynch votes myself, and there was precious little lynch pressure in this game till Extreme subbed in, that Extreme's play is usually active; whats left is actually a small sample size of games and so my impression of Extreme playing anomalously in this game was probably a false impression. At least thats what I'm telling myself and/or you guys.
Extreme has played a bit helpfully this game, but I'm a bit bored with the helpful Extreme = Mafia Extreme stereotype, and I'm sure Extreme would have got bored with or have adjusted his mafia Extreme play in light of this stereotype by now.
More to the point I can't as of yet see any cracks in a theory that Extreme has played D1 as a town player would or should.

So i've got no choice other than to put Extreme as edging town for me - at least for now.

[Devante]

I'm just going to say I have flipped re Extreme now, as I've thought about what was going on in my mind some more.

I think I found it unusual that Extreme had taken the lead on 2 lynch pressure votes.
Bearing in mind that Extreme often subs in, that Sonic often plays, I've often thrown around D1 lynch votes myself, and there was precious little lynch pressure in this game till Extreme subbed in, that Extreme's play is usually active; whats left is actually a small sample size of games and so my impression of Extreme playing anomalously in this game was probably a false impression. At least thats what I'm telling myself and/or you guys.
Extreme has played a bit helpfully this game, but I'm a bit bored with the helpful Extreme = Mafia Extreme stereotype, and I'm sure Extreme would have got bored with or have adjusted his mafia Extreme play in light of this stereotype by now.
More to the point I can't as of yet see any cracks in a theory that Extreme has played D1 as a town player would or should.

So i've got no choice other than to put Extreme as edging town for me - at least for now.

Would almost agree with everything other then he doesn't usually provide as much dissection as he did on D1 with a lot of it not necessarily much more then fluff. I took it as trying to help out given all the new players and since it's a sonic game but i'd say slight lean town at this point or 3p trying to stir the direction of the game. On the fence at this point

As for kingm, for now I don't see the need to pursue further and going to go back and reread a bit last couple pages. One comment I will make is that I did not like the constant unvoting then voting going on with hal and hjelp as it got too close to a point where scum could of just hopped in and lynched when we weren't there yet

[halrob64]

Factually incorrect as far as I'm concerned, I did not respond to jhelp he took his own decision, I did not vote unvote, as far as I know my vote is still in place.
just saying

As for kingm, for now I don't see the need to pursue further and going to go back and reread a bit last couple pages. One comment I will make is that I did not like the constant unvoting then voting going on with hal and hjelp as it got too close to a point where scum could of just hopped in and lynched when we weren't there yet

[hjelp]

...

As for kingm, for now I don't see the need to pursue further and going to go back and reread a bit last couple pages. One comment I will make is that I did not like the constant unvoting then voting going on with hal and hjelp as it got too close to a point where scum could of just hopped in and lynched when we weren't there yet

And so, why didn't scum just hopped in and lynched ?

[hjelp]

Maybe he doesn't need protecting, maybe he is playing the bluff and hoping to get to nightfall without getting lynched?

good point

Vote Kingman

Unvote Kingman
Vote Kingm

I meant Kingm .. sorry