Civil War Day 7. UNION WINS!!!!! Thanks 2 ALL 4 PLAYING

magneticgoop · Post by **magneticgoop** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 4:59 pm

i still say kill nark for reasons i stated before and the stonewall jackson caim i dont believe. anyone who knows anything about the civil war knows about jackson. that proves nothing about his alignment. also if he was confed or union (not sure which because his claims state both) he would not bother sending in a roleblock.

spurgistan · Post by **spurgistan** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 5:18 pm

Well, OK, but seeing as how "anybody who knows anything about the Civil War" definitely applies to Josh, don't you think he would have put Stonewall in this game? Nobody's counterclaimed AD yet, and I feel like Jackson would be a roleblocker, fits in with the theme so far.

nagerous · Post by **nagerous** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 5:20 pm

unkill kill goop for voting to kill someone whos roleclaim fits with the game theme.

magneticgoop · Post by **magneticgoop** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 5:25 pm

spurgistan wrote:Well, OK, but seeing as how "anybody who knows anything about the Civil War" definitely applies to Josh, don't you think he would have put Stonewall in this game? Nobody's counterclaimed AD yet, and I feel like Jackson would be a role blocker, fits in with the theme so far.

i mean that it would be like in batman mafia claiming robin. it just is too common and unoriginal. plus just because no one counter claimed doesn't mean nobody else is jackson just they may have felt they shouldn't role claim

nagerous · Post by **nagerous** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 5:30 pm

in my history of mafia games I've never seen someone claim such a big role and lie about it. It would only work in an endgame situation for scum to claim that when they know that the major role hasn't been killed yet. Your argument hence is illogical unless you are claiming that you yourself are Jackson goop.

gimpyThewonder · Post by **gimpyThewonder** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 5:34 pm

Anarkistsdream wrote:
Huckleberryhound wrote:
Anarkistsdream wrote:If you told me you are Davis and you weren't countered, I'd unvote and struggle to keep you.
But do you see my dilema....with people like ga7 on the prowl, naming a side would kill me for sure.
We still outnumber them... And I am a roleblocker... I blocked ga7 last night. I will continue to. And anybody else on our side may be able to help. *shrug*

Basically, would you rather be lynched or NKed?

This is exactly why AD can't be trusted. There is no way he could have performed a night action last night unless he was 3rd party. I think its a major slip to say he took a night action (he says roleblock but i think it was a kill). i'm not buying it. People are saying they kill all liars but AD has gotten through several days so far as a liar. Bah, i don't trust it

magneticgoop · Post by **magneticgoop** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 5:34 pm

nagerous wrote:in my history of mafia games I've never seen someone claim such a big role and lie about it. It would only work in an endgame situation for scum to claim that when they know that the major role hasn't been killed yet. Your argument hence is illogical unless you are claiming that you yourself are Jackson goop.

i am just saying of it was on obscure person in the war it would be more believable because he probably couldn't have just made that up (without some effort)

nagerous · Post by **nagerous** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 5:38 pm

obscure claims are less believable because it is less likely to be involved in the game and be counterclaim. I doubt someone could go in to a game and just claim a famous character like robin for instance in batman without expecting some rammifications as that would be a crazy strategy for mafia to undertake. Claiming obscure characters less likely to be countered is much more regular for scum.

Russianfire8371 · Post by **Russianfire8371** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 5:40 pm

nagerous wrote:unkill kill goop for voting to kill someone whos roleclaim fits with the game theme.

Anyone can look up the civil war and roleclaim a person. Why do yo ugo for a kill because someone's questioning a roleclaim that most everyone has debated at one point or another?

FOS Nagerous

Russianfire8371 · Post by **Russianfire8371** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 5:41 pm

ok you fastposted me so let me respond to that.

magneticgoop · Post by **magneticgoop** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 5:47 pm

gimpyThewonder wrote:
Anarkistsdream wrote:
Huckleberryhound wrote:
Anarkistsdream wrote:If you told me you are Davis and you weren't countered, I'd unvote and struggle to keep you.
But do you see my dilema....with people like ga7 on the prowl, naming a side would kill me for sure.
We still outnumber them... And I am a roleblocker... I blocked ga7 last night. I will continue to. And anybody else on our side may be able to help. *shrug*

Basically, would you rather be lynched or NKed?
This is exactly why AD can't be trusted. There is no way he could have performed a night action last night unless he was 3rd party. I think its a major slip to say he took a night action (he says roleblock but i think it was a kill). i'm not buying it. People are saying they kill all liars but AD has gotten through several days so far as a liar. Bah, i don't trust it

QFT

Russianfire8371 · Post by **Russianfire8371** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 5:48 pm

nagerous wrote:obscure claims are less believable because it is less likely to be involved in the game and be counterclaim. I doubt someone could go in to a game and just claim a famous character like robin for instance in batman without expecting some rammifications as that would be a crazy strategy for mafia to undertake. Claiming obscure characters less likely to be countered is much more regular for scum.

Just one question. How come you NOW start defending AD after all this time?

nagerous · Post by **nagerous** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 5:54 pm

skim central, I've supported/defended him since he roleclaimed a confederate roleblocker stonewall jackson back on page 58 I believe. This I see as an Important role that shouldn't be lynched.

Russianfire8371 · Post by **Russianfire8371** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 6:04 pm

nagerous wrote:skim central, I've supported/defended him since he roleclaimed a confederate roleblocker stonewall jackson back on page 58 I believe. This I see as an Important role that shouldn't be lynched.

Ok i believe you there. I dont remember everything thats gone through the game and ive already gone through 30+ pages today so im sorry i didnt check about you defending him earlier.

my other FOS is towards ga7

LSU Tiger Josh · Post by **LSU Tiger Josh** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 6:56 pm

Huck Hound seemed to think it was a good idea to stay general in his discussion on which side he was. Somehow this idea didn't work as it confused all members in the game and resulted in several of them voting to kill him. President Jefferson Davis Confederate President has been killed off. All who voted for Huck have had their votes reset.
AD and Russian watch your bullets as yall each only have 3 left.

Vote Count 9 to lynch
33. Huck Hound/cena-rules 9 (Serbia, Syzygy, GA7, Nag, Kwanton, Neutrino, Sheep of Dumb, DN, MOD)
3. AnarkistsDream 2 (MagneticGoop, Gimpy)
24. GA7 2.0/JND/Vudure 1 (AD)
19. Skoffin
1. Jake 2.0/Xen Cobra
2. Serbia
6. Kwanton
7. Russianfire8371/Dwight
11. Nagerous
13. Hitman079
18.Magneticgoop 2.0/The Weird One
20. Neutrino
21. Spurgistan
22. GimpyThewonder
23. SheepofDumb
26. Syzygy
32. dominationnation

Spent bullets (Limit of 6)
1. Jake 2.0/Xen Cobra
2. Serbia 1 (Huck Hound)
3. AnarkistsDream 3 (Spurgistan, AD, Huck Hound, GA7)
6. Kwanton 1 (Huck)
7. Russianfire8371/Dwight 3 (Spurgistan, Huck Hound, Spurgistan)
11. Nagerous 1 (Huck)
13. Hitman079
14. Dustn/Duday53
18.Magneticgoop 2.0/The Weird One 1 (AD)
19. Skoffin
20. Neutrino 1 (Huck Hound)
21. Spurgistan
22. GimpyThewonder 1 (AD)
23. SheepofDumb 1 (Huck Hound)
24. GA7 2.0/JND/Vudure 2 (AD, Huck Hound)
26. Syzygy 1 (Huck Hound)
32. dominationnation 2 (AD, Huck Hound)
33. Huck Hound/cena-rules 2 (Spurgistan, GA7)
MOD 1 (Huck Hound)

LSU Tiger Josh · Post by **LSU Tiger Josh** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 6:58 pm

Vote Count 9 to lynch
3. AnarkistsDream 2 (MagneticGoop, Gimpy)
24. GA7 2.0/JND/Vudure 1 (AD)
19. Skoffin
1. Jake 2.0/Xen Cobra
2. Serbia
6. Kwanton
7. Russianfire8371/Dwight
11. Nagerous
13. Hitman079
18.Magneticgoop 2.0/The Weird One 1 (Nag)
20. Neutrino
21. Spurgistan
22. GimpyThewonder
23. SheepofDumb
26. Syzygy
32. dominationnation

Spent bullets (Limit of 6)
1. Jake 2.0/Xen Cobra
2. Serbia 1 (Huck Hound)
3. AnarkistsDream 3 (Spurgistan, AD, Huck Hound, GA7)
6. Kwanton 1 (Huck)
7. Russianfire8371/Dwight 3 (Spurgistan, Huck Hound, Spurgistan)
11. Nagerous 2 (Huck, Mangeticgoop)
13. Hitman079
14. Dustn/Duday53
18.Magneticgoop 2.0/The Weird One 1 (AD)
19. Skoffin
20. Neutrino 1 (Huck Hound)
21. Spurgistan
22. GimpyThewonder 1 (AD)
23. SheepofDumb 1 (Huck Hound)
24. GA7 2.0/JND/Vudure 2 (AD, Huck Hound)
26. Syzygy 1 (Huck Hound)
32. dominationnation 2 (AD, Huck Hound)
MOD 1 (Huck Hound)

LSU Tiger Josh · Post by **LSU Tiger Josh** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 7:02 pm

You have 10 and a half hours left to lynch a second person.

sheepofdumb · Post by **sheepofdumb** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 7:11 pm

Kill AD2

dustn64 · Post by **dustn64** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 7:12 pm

GO NORTH!!!

Anarkistsdream · Post by **Anarkistsdream** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 7:41 pm

Several things to say here:

One... Why am I AD 2??? I haven't been killed yet...

Second, Wow, look at the three who have voted me... SheepofDumb is revenge voting due to me telling him he is a fucking idiot... Well, sorry Sheep, but you are, and Josh was nice enough to let you in this game and you aren't even playing, you little shit.

Gimpy.... You have done nothing but repeat in different words what others have said... You are pathetic, and unless you get your shit together and actually start trying to decipher this game yourself, you are a fly on my shit.

Goop, you've had it out for me all game...

I think that it is quite obvious that these three are the Natives, or at the very least Union soldiers who really DO believe me and are getting my own side to betray me.

Regardless, it isn't working.

Lastly, as I have already explained... If my roleblock didn't go through, then GA7 didn't get an action either, so I don't see why ANYONE would not believe me.

Go back a few pages and see how confused I was at what LSU was asking for... Numbers, what? Do we still get actions, what?

I was confused, and so still sent one in. If it didn't count, well and good, but that certainly doesn't make me a killer...

I am Jackson, no one has countered, and if no one can counter what is the reason for believing I am not him? There isn't one... You three are pathetically attempting to redirect blame.

I already have people on my side who trust me, and you three newbs don't much matter.

Although, Goop, I expected better from you.

Russianfire8371 · Post by **Russianfire8371** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 7:41 pm

if only Huck had stopped being so mysterious...

FOS GA7, Sheep, and Skoffin.

Where the hell has Skoffin been?

Skoffin · Post by **Skoffin** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 7:46 pm

Personally, I'm inclined to believe Nark's claim. As I mentioned before, I myself was thinking of the same idea he used, he just beat me to it. I'd like to keep him around just for having to guts to try it

Although I am curious to know for sure. He has claimed a prominent person, and no one has countered it, so it would probably be best to believe him, atleast for now.

Russianfire8371 · Post by **Russianfire8371** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 8:04 pm

Skoffin wrote: Personally, I'm inclined to believe Nark's claim. As I mentioned before, I myself was thinking of the same idea he used, he just beat me to it. I'd like to keep him around just for having to guts to try it Although I am curious to know for sure. He has claimed a prominent person, and no one has countered it, so it would probably be best to believe him, atleast for now.

glad for you to have posted after 5 days (real days)

sheepofdumb · Post by **sheepofdumb** » Wed Sep 19, 2007 9:08 pm

Anarkistsdream wrote:Wow, look at the three who have voted me... SheepofDumb is revenge voting due to me telling him he is a fucking idiot... Well, sorry Sheep, but you are, and Josh was nice enough to let you in this game and you aren't even playing, you little shit.

First, you seem a bit pissy today AD.

Second, I randomly picked you, If you are claiming confed, then Unkill It's not a revenge vote because I never saw you call me an idiot, oh, control you PMSing.

Calm down. I'm starting all over again and I thought that I could take a few big games. I joined in these way before the started in the first place. I'm sure a lot has happened, I'm just not ready to follow it yet.

ga7 · Post by **ga7** » Thu Sep 20, 2007 1:19 am

Hmm ok. First of all: Bwahahaha. I foresee my second incarnation will also be shortlived, but this soldier did his part

I don't really get the FOS I'm getting though

About AD, well I guess it's true it was confusing, and I forgot the fact your claim was pretty much the one and only thing going for you that makes you not third party. I'll leave it at that. Feel free to NK him though

At this point, things are evening out a bit, and there's not that many players remaining. So this:

spurgistan wrote:Now that Huck's dead, I feel like it's time to concentrate on the fact that we still have unaligned killing roles run amok here.

Seems a good idea for next day. I'll wait to see if I survive to reread about this though, but regardless of your (main) side, don't let them go unnoticed.