CSI Mafia Game Thread **MAFIA IS TEH WINNER**

[misterman10]

Also, cena, what happened to posting in all green?

[unriggable]

Okay. Lotsa debating going on. Mostly just noob arguing.

I'm still a bit suspicious of LSU Tiger Josh since he took my questioning of the rules as a sign if scummery (word?) which is evidently not the case. Anybody who is scum will try to make themselves as transparent and innocent-looking as possible, and I'm doing exactly the opposite. Evidently LSU thinks that a mafia will use reverse psychology of what I just presented to make themselves appear as town. Not really - haven't seen it happen in any game. BTW sam_levi - roleclaim not a good idea. You'll be hunted tonight.

But they do. If exposing yourself made someone automatically look like town, ALL the mafia are going to start doing it. Also, if Sam gets killed tonight, then that's not too bad, that's a lesser chance that the mafia will hit the doc. The point is not to survive at all costs but to help your faction [unless you are a survivor].

Not really. By that logic it would be profitable to re-reverse the psychology, and then you end up with the default tips. You can do this an endless amount of times, over and over and over again, to appear or conceal you scumminess. You have to understand that I didn't ask for clarification of rules because I want to appear innocent, I did it because I wanted to have the rules clarified.

[duday53]

we dont

need

a lynch

exactly, only a mafia needs lynch

vote sam

Oh, also by "role list", I meant what are the roles in the game, and not who are those roles. I should vote whoever was dumb enough not to realize that, but I will keep this vote...

you still cant get that. You can only assume how mant mafia there are, if there is an sk, vigliante, or another killing role/investiagtive/protective power roles

He means for ALL mafia games. He's a newbie.

That makes more sense. I apologize Crab

[XGSuperstar]

Okay. Lotsa debating going on. Mostly just noob arguing.

I'm still a bit suspicious of LSU Tiger Josh since he took my questioning of the rules as a sign if scummery (word?) which is evidently not the case. Anybody who is scum will try to make themselves as transparent and innocent-looking as possible, and I'm doing exactly the opposite. Evidently LSU thinks that a mafia will use reverse psychology of what I just presented to make themselves appear as town. Not really - haven't seen it happen in any game. BTW sam_levi - roleclaim not a good idea. You'll be hunted tonight.

But they do. If exposing yourself made someone automatically look like town, ALL the mafia are going to start doing it. Also, if Sam gets killed tonight, then that's not too bad, that's a lesser chance that the mafia will hit the doc. The point is not to survive at all costs but to help your faction [unless you are a survivor].

Not really. By that logic it would be profitable to re-reverse the psychology, and then you end up with the default tips. You can do this an endless amount of times, over and over and over again, to appear or conceal you scumminess. You have to understand that I didn't ask for clarification of rules because I want to appear innocent, I did it because I wanted to have the rules clarified.

The mafia will do whatever it takes to win. And why would the scum re-reverse it? If its DEAD ON that anyone active is town, the scum will be active as well, so the town will re-reverse it instead of the mafia. In mafia, NOTHING is set in stone. Nes has over 9000 scum tells and he's often town.

[unriggable]

Okay. Lotsa debating going on. Mostly just noob arguing.

I'm still a bit suspicious of LSU Tiger Josh since he took my questioning of the rules as a sign if scummery (word?) which is evidently not the case. Anybody who is scum will try to make themselves as transparent and innocent-looking as possible, and I'm doing exactly the opposite. Evidently LSU thinks that a mafia will use reverse psychology of what I just presented to make themselves appear as town. Not really - haven't seen it happen in any game. BTW sam_levi - roleclaim not a good idea. You'll be hunted tonight.

But they do. If exposing yourself made someone automatically look like town, ALL the mafia are going to start doing it. Also, if Sam gets killed tonight, then that's not too bad, that's a lesser chance that the mafia will hit the doc. The point is not to survive at all costs but to help your faction [unless you are a survivor].

Not really. By that logic it would be profitable to re-reverse the psychology, and then you end up with the default tips. You can do this an endless amount of times, over and over and over again, to appear or conceal you scumminess. You have to understand that I didn't ask for clarification of rules because I want to appear innocent, I did it because I wanted to have the rules clarified.

The mafia will do whatever it takes to win. And why would the scum re-reverse it? If its DEAD ON that anyone active is town, the scum will be active as well, so the town will re-reverse it instead of the mafia. In mafia, NOTHING is set in stone. Nes has over 9000 scum tells and he's often town.

The point is that since the issue has been argued into the ground, I can't do my hints that will confirm my roleclaim on day 4 / 5.

[misterman10]

IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT:

life-saver has informed me that she will not have internet access for the next few days or so, and she was only now informed of this. dustn64 will be replacing life-saver.

All votes to life-saver are now on dust64

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Okay. Lotsa debating going on. Mostly just noob arguing.

I'm still a bit suspicious of LSU Tiger Josh since he took my questioning of the rules as a sign if scummery (word?) which is evidently not the case. Anybody who is scum will try to make themselves as transparent and innocent-looking as possible, and I'm doing exactly the opposite. Evidently LSU thinks that a mafia will use reverse psychology of what I just presented to make themselves appear as town. Not really - haven't seen it happen in any game. BTW sam_levi - roleclaim not a good idea. You'll be hunted tonight.

But they do. If exposing yourself made someone automatically look like town, ALL the mafia are going to start doing it. Also, if Sam gets killed tonight, then that's not too bad, that's a lesser chance that the mafia will hit the doc. The point is not to survive at all costs but to help your faction [unless you are a survivor].

Not really. By that logic it would be profitable to re-reverse the psychology, and then you end up with the default tips. You can do this an endless amount of times, over and over and over again, to appear or conceal you scumminess. You have to understand that I didn't ask for clarification of rules because I want to appear innocent, I did it because I wanted to have the rules clarified.

The mafia will do whatever it takes to win. And why would the scum re-reverse it? If its DEAD ON that anyone active is town, the scum will be active as well, so the town will re-reverse it instead of the mafia. In mafia, NOTHING is set in stone. Nes has over 9000 scum tells and he's often town.

The point is that since the issue has been argued into the ground, I can't do my hints that will confirm my roleclaim on day 4 / 5.

No the point is you acted dumb to do this on day 1 instead of waiting to appraoch it at the proper time.

[dustn64]

conworm and VOTE NES why does he not have any votes. I guess I need to read up.

[dustn64]

IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT:
All votes to life-saver are now on dust64

WTF? she has the most votes, thanks alot LS

[Hitman079]

vote NES. let's push him for another mafia retirement; maybe this time it will even last a week

[misterman10]

VOTE COUNT

sam_levi_11
KiwiTaker
LSU Tiger Josh (1): Minister Masket
Syzygy
XenCobra
CrabNebula
cena-rules
Strider24
unriggable (2): LSU Tiger, Syzygy
Minister Masket
NESconqueror (2): dustn, Hitman
pancakemix
Fircoal
duday53 (1): XenCobra
Hitman079
XGSuperstar
dustn64 (5): Fircoal, NESconq, KiwiTaker, XGSuperstar, sam

With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch.

[life-saver]

IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT:
All votes to life-saver are now on dust64

WTF? she has the most votes, thanks alot LS

God, sorry everyone OMGUS bandwagoned on me.

[Syzygy]

IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT:
All votes to life-saver are now on dust64

WTF? she has the most votes, thanks alot LS

God, sorry everyone OMGUS bandwagoned on me.

[Fircoal]

IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT:
All votes to life-saver are now on dust64

WTF? she has the most votes, thanks alot LS

God, sorry everyone OMGUS bandwagoned on me.

you deserved it.

[cena-rules]

green went home

vote NES

re-ti-re

[NESconqueror]

green went home

vote NES

re-ti-re

I am not going to retire as easily as last time...
Quit bandwagoning upon me and let us get a lynch on whoever has the most votes. (Anyone who says me simply is prokaryotic in the counting department)

[Iliad]

green went home

vote NES

re-ti-re

I am not going to retire as easily as last time...
Quit bandwagoning upon me and let us get a lynch on whoever has the most votes. (Anyone who says me simply is prokaryotic in the counting department)

Ehh what?

[dustn64]

green went home

vote NES

re-ti-re

I am not going to retire as easily as last time...
Quit bandwagoning upon me and let us get a lynch on whoever has the most votes. (Anyone who says me simply is prokaryotic in the counting department)

Ehh what?

*shakes head* NES please go kill yourself now.

[Minister Masket]

Vote sam-levi for lying out of his butt.
An early role-claim like that is either too noobish for words or a poor scum defense.

[sam_levi_11]

i wish it was a poor scum defence but...

[Strider24]

Unvote Vote dustn64

[unriggable]

Okay. Lotsa debating going on. Mostly just noob arguing.

I'm still a bit suspicious of LSU Tiger Josh since he took my questioning of the rules as a sign if scummery (word?) which is evidently not the case. Anybody who is scum will try to make themselves as transparent and innocent-looking as possible, and I'm doing exactly the opposite. Evidently LSU thinks that a mafia will use reverse psychology of what I just presented to make themselves appear as town. Not really - haven't seen it happen in any game. BTW sam_levi - roleclaim not a good idea. You'll be hunted tonight.

But they do. If exposing yourself made someone automatically look like town, ALL the mafia are going to start doing it. Also, if Sam gets killed tonight, then that's not too bad, that's a lesser chance that the mafia will hit the doc. The point is not to survive at all costs but to help your faction [unless you are a survivor].

Not really. By that logic it would be profitable to re-reverse the psychology, and then you end up with the default tips. You can do this an endless amount of times, over and over and over again, to appear or conceal you scumminess. You have to understand that I didn't ask for clarification of rules because I want to appear innocent, I did it because I wanted to have the rules clarified.

The mafia will do whatever it takes to win. And why would the scum re-reverse it? If its DEAD ON that anyone active is town, the scum will be active as well, so the town will re-reverse it instead of the mafia. In mafia, NOTHING is set in stone. Nes has over 9000 scum tells and he's often town.

The point is that since the issue has been argued into the ground, I can't do my hints that will confirm my roleclaim on day 4 / 5.

No the point is you acted dumb to do this on day 1 instead of waiting to appraoch it at the proper time.

VOTE LSU Tiger Josh

Ignoring my intentions which I have stated multiple times - looking for excuses to lynch me.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

But they do. If exposing yourself made someone automatically look like town, ALL the mafia are going to start doing it. Also, if Sam gets killed tonight, then that's not too bad, that's a lesser chance that the mafia will hit the doc. The point is not to survive at all costs but to help your faction [unless you are a survivor].

Not really. By that logic it would be profitable to re-reverse the psychology, and then you end up with the default tips. You can do this an endless amount of times, over and over and over again, to appear or conceal you scumminess. You have to understand that I didn't ask for clarification of rules because I want to appear innocent, I did it because I wanted to have the rules clarified.

The mafia will do whatever it takes to win. And why would the scum re-reverse it? If its DEAD ON that anyone active is town, the scum will be active as well, so the town will re-reverse it instead of the mafia. In mafia, NOTHING is set in stone. Nes has over 9000 scum tells and he's often town.

The point is that since the issue has been argued into the ground, I can't do my hints that will confirm my roleclaim on day 4 / 5.

No the point is you acted dumb to do this on day 1 instead of waiting to appraoch it at the proper time.

VOTE LSU Tiger Josh

Ignoring my intentions which I have stated multiple times - looking for excuses to lynch me.

Nice OMGUS revenge vote. I repeat you acted like a dumbass doing this on day 1. You have played in a few games and should know that by now you don't go around acting stupid trying to "hint" at a power role on day 1 when it should be quite apparent that you don't. If you do have a power role then you would be considered an idiot for getting a target on yourself this early by acting stupid.

[CrabNebula]

lol this is the first game that I am playing that doesn't have a role-list.

Will comment on others comments later.

[Hitman079]

Quit bandwagoning upon me and let us get a lynch on whoever has the most votes.

let us lynch teh n00b