appropriate negative feedback

[lord voldemort]

this is the feedback i left for ronc8649:
ignore list for any speed gamers. stupid idiot suicided on me for no reason. has no concept of speed freestyle tactics. just a stupid person really.

it was deemed inapropriate. which i think is bull. it was a freestyle speed esc game. which if u play you should know that every troop is important. in this game he continued to auto my troops everywhere. i was by means the strongest player in the game at the time and didnt deserve it. he later said that because i didnt give him a pswd to the battle royal he did it because of that.

i have filled in an e-tickey bout this and all that gear

i want to know if the feedback is appropriate

[owenshooter]

inappropriate-0

[lord voldemort]

why though

[wicked]

Did you pick the correct game to leave him that feedback for? It was deemed non-factual, and as he won the game, I'd have to agree he didn't suicide on you and does understand how to play that type of game.

[owenshooter]

what she said.-0

[billy07]

i would say it`s appropriate, but seeing as you lost the game and he won maybe the mod`s only looked at it that way!

He was on my ignore list before this anyway.

[-ShadySoul-]

If you were the strongest...didnt he do a right thing? YOu were the biggest threat so he had to slow you down a bit, maybe his tactics werent perfect...but they worked.

[State409c]

I get a lot of negative feedback because

1) I am chatty during games, and I don't mince words
2) Some people on this site have terribly thin skin or are horribly retarded

I have had a few negative feedbacks I left removed for really bogus reasons. I'd get a similar sort of feedback, ask for it to be removed, and get the most obtuse and vague explanations from the mods on why they allowed it. I also think they are taking into consideration how many negatives you already have and someone like me, that has about 30% negative feedbacks, they are just like, f*ck this guy he sucks, he can use another one.

[ParadiceCity9]

seems appropriate to me.

[bob the pirate]

I think the fact that half the feedback is you calling the other person stupid had something to do with it, and didn't give much of an explanation behind it. If you had used the explanation you give here explaining the neg feedback AS the negative feedback, maybe the mods would have cared less.
Eg:

ignore list for any speed gamers. stupid idiot suicided on me for no reason. has no concept of speed freestyle tactics. just a stupid person really.

gets replaced by

it was a freestyle speed esc game. which if u play you should know that every troop is important. in this game he continued to auto my troops everywhere. i was by means the strongest player in the game at the time and didnt deserve it

And then, yeah, the fact that you lost and their tactics apparently won them the game kinda makes it look like you don't know what you're talking about.

Edit: Heh. I don't know how quotes work.

[wrestler1ump]

this is the feedback i left for ronc8649:
ignore list for any speed gamers. stupid idiot suicided on me for no reason. has no concept of speed freestyle tactics. just a stupid person really.

it was deemed inapropriate. which i think is bull. it was a freestyle speed esc game. which if u play you should know that every troop is important. in this game he continued to auto my troops everywhere. i was by means the strongest player in the game at the time and didnt deserve it. he later said that because i didnt give him a pswd to the battle royal he did it because of that.

i have filled in an e-tickey bout this and all that gear

i want to know if the feedback is appropriate

The feedback is most certainly inappropriate. You insulted him. Probably retaliatory as well. With all the trivial reasons I have had my feedback deleted for, it is a relief to know that I am not the only person having my feedback deleted.

By the way, I would recommend a moderator look at the feedback that Lord Voldemort left for other people. Some of the neutrals and negatives need to be deleted.