Modern Warfare Mafia Day 6(Town Win!)

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I am trying to ignore Vodean's comment and just get on with the game but that's a lot easier said than done. As far as that's concerned, Vodean please do not join any games with me ever again I'll be trying to avoid any with you. IF you do join one I'm going to be involved in, I will drop out and I will make if very public why I don't want you in that game.

Same here.

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

UTAlan-3 (LSU Tiger Josh, spiesr, gregwolf)

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

[spiesr]

So, we still need to here from cena-rules, ga7, & wercool.

As far as that's concerned, Vodean please do not join any games with me ever again I'll be trying to avoid any with you. IF you do join one I'm going to be involved in, I will drop out and I will make if very public why I don't want you in that game.

Same here.

I will sign that petition...

[wercool]

ouch, that's a bit harse. can we get a defence from UTA?

[UTAlan]

I guess at L-2 it's claim time. I'm a vig that got one kill for the entirety of the game. I chose to take out taco-man because I suspected him of being cult recruiter. I thought about waiting another day for more evidence, but didn't want to take the chance that more people would be recruited.

As far as vodean is concerned, when I voted him I was kind of meta-gaming. I was frustrated at him for blatantly breaking rules, regardless of whether he was scum or not. Once it was revealed that he was cult, I went back through the entire thread to see who looked most like cult recruiter and decided to use my kill on taco_man.

I didn't realize I would come up guilty on investigation, since I'm not mafia or cult, but I was trying to serve the town's best interests.

[spiesr]

Hmm, one shot vig claim. To me it seems like if that is the entirety of your ability that there would not have been any reason for you not to claim sooner. I mean, it is not like you have any powers you needed to keep secret, why wait until -2L, especially when it was obvious that you would get there if you didn't post any defense.

I don't see how the claim that you have made explains how LSU could have gotten a guilty reading on you. I mean, you should show innocent if you really are a town vig. The busdriver could have screwed up the investigation,but there in no way to know at this point...

[UTAlan]

I didn't claim sooner because in the few mafia games I've played, I've gotten the impression that you should almost never claim if you aren't close to being lynched. I guess in this case I could have claimed right away b/c of the investigation or whatever, but I was just trying to play it safe.

As I said before, I don't know why I came up guilty, but I've never played an investigative role so I'm not really sure how the mechanics of that works.

[strike wolf]

Heading back up to Atlanta tonight and will be less active over the weekend. As far as UTA's claim it is interesting to say the least, I hope to make a more detailed comment on it tonight though can't promise I'll be on for any length of time.

[ga7]

The role claim sounds credible, but it could as easily be a cult role. I find it quite hard to not take in account Vodean's dead talk and fully agree on a "blacklisting" for now. I kinda doubt he was bluffing as he doesn't seem to have the wits for it...
Anyway that leaves us with an interesting theory of a cult that can't recruit lol. Basically a weak mafia, sounded like 3 members, which would make sense if the night kills were done by a SK. One kill this night that UTA claims to have done against all logic (taco was quite supportive of town so far), and somehow another killer for the night before. I don't buy it. There is a chance UTA was busdrived but it's far more likely LSU's result is accurate and he's scum IMO.

Vote UTAlan

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

UTAlan-4 (LSU Tiger Josh, spiesr, gregwolf, ga7)

UTAlan is at L-1
With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

[UTAlan]

The role claim sounds credible, but it could as easily be a cult role. I find it quite hard to not take in account Vodean's dead talk and fully agree on a "blacklisting" for now. I kinda doubt he was bluffing as he doesn't seem to have the wits for it...
Anyway that leaves us with an interesting theory of a cult that can't recruit lol. Basically a weak mafia, sounded like 3 members, which would make sense if the night kills were done by a SK. One kill this night that UTA claims to have done against all logic (taco was quite supportive of town so far), and somehow another killer for the night before. I don't buy it. There is a chance UTA was busdrived but it's far more likely LSU's result is accurate and he's scum IMO.

Vote UTAlan

I think we have to refuse to take Vodean's dead talk into account (if for no other reason than to keep him from getting the satisfaction of ruining this game).

That aside, taco_man didn't seem to be all that pro-town to me. He brought very little content to the game, usually only posting to say "I know I haven't been posting much." His lurking is what made me suspect him to be either scum or cult.

[spiesr]

At this point in time my money is on LSU's investigation being correct. Therefor, I support the decapitation of UTAlan.
I would however, still like it if cena were to make an appearance, and find wercool's one line contribution to the day to be incredibly lame...

[safariguy5]

Cena-rules has been prodded. Any other prod requests?

[Army of GOD]

So LSU investigated UTA, who vig-killed taco_man, which means the mafia (assuming there is mafia) either chose a non-existent person or got blocked?

I would've believed you UTA if you didn't say you killed taco_man.

Vote UTAlan

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Cena-rules has been prodded. Any other prod requests?

This is why I investigated him night 1 since he tries to fly under the radar sometimes and gets busy with real life instead of posting here.

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

UTAlan-5 (LSU Tiger Josh, spiesr, gregwolf, ga7, Army of GOD)

UTAlan has been lynched.
With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

[safariguy5]

Scene

During Day 3, the citizens took shelter in a convenient warehouse as Pave Low's flew overhead. An immediate accusation by LSU Tiger Josh put suspicion on UTAlan. Despite his best efforts, Alan was forced outside in the middle of a bombing run, ending his life instantly.

UTAlan (Mafia Poisoner) has been killed!

It is now Night 3, 48 hours to send in actions.

[Army of GOD]

[talkinginsleep]Just wondering, but what do the "Town Busdriver" and "Mafia Poisoner" do? Are they any different then regular townies and mafia? (Just in case they occur in future games)[/talkinginsleep]

[strike wolf]

Guess I missed the action, good lynch. the busdriver picks two people during the night and any ability used on one of them during the night will happen to the other. Say if Taco had switched UTA and PMC and LSU investigated PMC, PMC would come out guilty because that's how UTA would show up, opposite way around LSU investigates UTA and he would come out innocent because of PMC's alignment. It's been a while since I read over the roles in mafia but I believe the poisoner picks one person per night to poison and they would die the following night.

[Army of GOD]

Ah, kk, thanks.

[cena-rules]

Sorry about missing so much, I was rushed to hospital. Ill try and catch up now

[LSU Tiger Josh]

bump night should be over.

[safariguy5]

bump night should be over.

I prodded people who haven't sent in actions, thanks for the patience guys.

[safariguy5]

Scene

spiesr advanced through a trench. He could see a large underground bunker up ahead. He made sure to flashbang into the room before entering. He did not see, however, the claymore planted right next to the door. He was killed instantly as the claymore blew both of his legs off.

spiesr Cult Framer was killed!

It is now Day 4, with 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

[strike wolf]

So that makes 2 cult and 1 mafia down. A framer isn't exactly a town role to begin with so I have to assume that he was cult from the beginning supporting the evidence that cult may not have a recruiter. Find anything new LSU?