[Official] Choose Your Own Mafia - TOWN WINS

[*Pixar*]

so as its day 1 let me see if im getting this right. People are working off little to no info and people are already posting their thoughts on who is scum and town. Real smart

[ptlowe]

so as its day 1 let me see if im getting this right. People are working off little to no info and people are already posting their thoughts on who is scum and town. Real smart

You have the entirety of what has transpired to date.

[TimWoodbury]

okay so as far as eveyone is concerned im skum so jsut to get chat going and for shyts and giggles since someone in the previous pages have said that they would like a claim so how bout this i was draft spot #2 and got my draft choice as VIG and I AM TOWN. my questions earliear about vig revealing itself was to see if it would be helpfull people said no so i didnt at that point.

so now lets get over this i think that i think this and get to actuall conversion thats actually going to help get something done day1. i know with claiming this i will most likley get targeted night 1 by mafia so if i die night 1 just to get some actuall conversation going day 1 then great at least i was helpfull day 1.

im jsut getting home from work and scimmed the last few pages since i left for work.

1)still curious about virus still way to quiet, very few posts and his only recent post was saying nothing helpfull when asked about reads he never responded
2) dakky you changed your play style the alst game from being the 1 to get get conversation going and being lynched day 1 to being quiet so im assumeing your doing the same here
3)PT seems to ahve something stuck up his arse and or has a man crush for me i say worst case scernio we lynch a VT day 1 to get farther on and suddenly my whole goal is to kill town
4)wing odd he dont want to pressure virus whos said mroe or less nothing at all the entire game

[ptlowe]

okay so as far as eveyone is concerned im skum so jsut to get chat going and for shyts and giggles since someone in the previous pages have said that they would like a claim so how bout this i was draft spot #2 and got my draft choice as VIG and I AM TOWN. my questions earliear about vig revealing itself was to see if it would be helpfull people said no so i didnt at that point.

so now lets get over this i think that i think this and get to actuall conversion thats actually going to help get something done day1. i know with claiming this i will most likley get targeted night 1 by mafia so if i die night 1 just to get some actuall conversation going day 1 then great at least i was helpfull day 1.

im jsut getting home from work and scimmed the last few pages since i left for work.

1)still curious about virus still way to quiet, very few posts and his only recent post was saying nothing helpfull when asked about reads he never responded
2) dakky you changed your play style the alst game from being the 1 to get get conversation going and being lynched day 1 to being quiet so im assumeing your doing the same here
3)PT seems to ahve something stuck up his arse and or has a man crush for me i say worst case scernio we lynch a VT day 1 to get farther on and suddenly my whole goal is to kill town
4)wing odd he dont want to pressure virus whos said mroe or less nothing at all the entire game

You have a pretty mouth.

On a serious note..............not sure why you revealed this.....unless you arent it. If you are dont mod kill yourself again please. After we all agreed revealing it is a bad idea you go ahead anyways. Not sure what to do with this information.

You suggested we kill dakky or madmitch because they are VTs. You didnt mention as last resort.

[TimWoodbury]

okay so as far as eveyone is concerned im skum so jsut to get chat going and for shyts and giggles since someone in the previous pages have said that they would like a claim so how bout this i was draft spot #2 and got my draft choice as VIG and I AM TOWN. my questions earliear about vig revealing itself was to see if it would be helpfull people said no so i didnt at that point.

so now lets get over this i think that i think this and get to actuall conversion thats actually going to help get something done day1. i know with claiming this i will most likley get targeted night 1 by mafia so if i die night 1 just to get some actuall conversation going day 1 then great at least i was helpfull day 1.

im jsut getting home from work and scimmed the last few pages since i left for work.

1)still curious about virus still way to quiet, very few posts and his only recent post was saying nothing helpfull when asked about reads he never responded
2) dakky you changed your play style the alst game from being the 1 to get get conversation going and being lynched day 1 to being quiet so im assumeing your doing the same here
3)PT seems to ahve something stuck up his arse and or has a man crush for me i say worst case scernio we lynch a VT day 1 to get farther on and suddenly my whole goal is to kill town
4)wing odd he dont want to pressure virus whos said mroe or less nothing at all the entire game

You have a pretty mouth.

On a serious note..............not sure why you revealed this.....unless you arent it. If you are dont mod kill yourself again please. After we all agreed revealing it is a bad idea you go ahead anyways. Not sure what to do with this information.

You suggested we kill dakky or madmitch because they are VTs. You didnt mention as last resort.

not gonna get myself modkilled again its either yall bealive e and the doc protects me at night(heck cop can even investigate to make shure its true) or i get night killed either way it dont matter as long as it gets chat going.
i assumed it would be obvious i meant as a last resort but obviously not all saw it as what i meant, i sometimes think things but the way it comes out is differant then what im thinking.

[dakky21]

not gonna get myself modkilled again its either yall bealive e and the doc protects me at night(heck cop can even investigate to make shure its true) or i get night killed either way it dont matter as long as it gets chat going.
i assumed it would be obvious i meant as a last resort but obviously not all saw it as what i meant, i sometimes think things but the way it comes out is differant then what im thinking.

so you're a town vig. If you are not, I guess someone will not counter claim it because that will lead to their death, and you will probably survive. Is this what you wanted?

[dakky21]

If someone counter claims, they're dead unless there is a doctor and we can't know that.
If a real vig remain silent, Tim, you will be NK'ed and hope there is a doctor.
If there is a doctor and no one counter claims, you will be saved during the night while you can still be mafia vig.

So what now happens? I'm getting pretty much lost in all the possible options...

[TimWoodbury]

your over thinking it dakky because you was fooled in the c9 game.

though for the sake of it then if there is a doc then dont protect me tonight and i can almost gurentee im dead y skum.
if someone counter claims im going to push them as hard and as much as i can as i know for a fact im the vigilantee and there is only 1 remember dakky i had #2 metsfan can almsot posativly connfirm it by confirming that he is not vig(he dont have to claim to confirm that he is not it he jsut has to say hes not vig)i thinking mets took either cop or doc.

so again id like to har more usefull info from the ones i stated above especially virus as hes said absolutly nothing at all usefull and to show that i see him as suspecious UNVOTE VOTE VIRUS

[Endgame422]

If we lynch virus who will you shoot tim?

[TimWoodbury]

im not shure currently who i would shoot, right now if i had to say who i would say i prolly wouldnt shoot anyone especially after the mistake i made in foundation killing the cop

[*Pixar*]

makes sense that mets would choose doc or cop after picking first. Has virus claimed yet or did I miss it?

[TimWoodbury]

makes sense that mets would choose doc or cop after picking first. Has virus claimed yet or did I miss it?

virus has not claimed and virus has not said anything really at all will post what he said today

Page 4

oops been a while since last mafia game not a regular in the forum no more. i Confirm!

i can go with the end of list theory, but i would like to pick a target that wingcmdr isnt choosing then. i mean the idea has some merit in my opinion but could just be scum telling the idea. so rather not have wing in charge of the selection then

Page 9

Do you mean that you'd strongly object to a Virus lynch in general, or strongly object based on the currently available evidence? What if we pushed him and some useful information came out of it?

what are you looking to find here mets? i guess no one would be stupid enough to hard defend there scumbuddy if he were as inactive like me, atleast i value wing higher then doing that.

also i think you know me long enough that you know that i am not much of a big poster, ever.
i think some people mentioned that (about the activity) and you immediatly look in to that as hard evidence of scum pairs etc? bit far fetched it my opinion.

fped

so 2 posts in 10 pages something is super off with this dont yall think... and even after he knows were asking more of him he dose just the 1 post in response to mets??

[dakky21]

makes sense that mets would choose doc or cop after picking first. Has virus claimed yet or did I miss it?

He didnt claim anything yet, but what do you expect?

[Endgame422]

Virus is typically one of the quieter players.
I was really hoping he would post his reads today as i have zero clue about his alignment.
To me he seems like a backup lynch for just that reason.
Since tim has claimed i think town ought to lead his decision of who to shoot at night.
This will help prove tim to be town(or scum) as well as insulate us from off thewall kills.
We cant say exactly who to pick(too much info for scum) but if we give tim a couple options it can be a powerful play,especially if doc/empowerer are townies.
And tim has already painted a target on his back so its not like scum arent after him anyways.
I say lynch HS,tim shoots benga/AoG/virus to be decided by how the vote goes and what they bring to the table the next couple days.

[Metsfanmax]

Here's what I worry about. I think you're right that if he's going to shoot anyone, it had better be someone at the bottom of the list so that if we're wrong, we're probably not losing anyone crucial. This way, if he really is scum or SK and pretending to be town, we're forcing that faction to take a potshot for the night instead of killing the player they really want to kill. However, that might seem to be an acceptable trade-off in return for not being questioned on later days. But if he is town, then we're just throwing away a town player at 2:1 odds, solely to make us a little more confident that he's town. But he's going to get offed pretty soon by one of the anti-town factions unless the doc protects him, and the doc very well might not want to protect him until we have evidence that he really is town-aligned.

So, I think that Tim holding off tonight is a legitimate course of action, rather than shooting randomly into the crowd. Though maybe I'm just biased because I'm the one who got killed last time he got trigger happy...

[Metsfanmax]

Here's what I worry about. I think you're right that if he's going to shoot anyone, it had better be someone at the bottom of the list so that if we're wrong, we're probably not losing anyone crucial. This way, if he really is scum or SK and pretending to be town, we're forcing that faction to take a potshot for the night instead of killing the player they really want to kill. However, that might seem to be an acceptable trade-off in return for not being questioned on later days. But if he is town, then we're just throwing away a town player at 2:1 odds, solely to make us a little more confident that he's town. But he's going to get offed pretty soon by one of the anti-town factions unless the doc protects him, and the doc very well might not want to protect him until we have evidence that he really is town-aligned.

So, I think that Tim holding off tonight is a legitimate course of action, rather than shooting randomly into the crowd. Though maybe I'm just biased because I'm the one who got killed last time he got trigger happy...

Oh, forgot the most obvious point: Tim could entirely be telling the truth about his role and be lying about his alignment. If he's mafia/SK and also the vig, then it costs him essentially nothing to point his shot where we suggest that he does.

[TimWoodbury]

Here's what I worry about. I think you're right that if he's going to shoot anyone, it had better be someone at the bottom of the list so that if we're wrong, we're probably not losing anyone crucial. This way, if he really is scum or SK and pretending to be town, we're forcing that faction to take a potshot for the night instead of killing the player they really want to kill. However, that might seem to be an acceptable trade-off in return for not being questioned on later days. But if he is town, then we're just throwing away a town player at 2:1 odds, solely to make us a little more confident that he's town. But he's going to get offed pretty soon by one of the anti-town factions unless the doc protects him, and the doc very well might not want to protect him until we have evidence that he really is town-aligned.

So, I think that Tim holding off tonight is a legitimate course of action, rather than shooting randomly into the crowd. Though maybe I'm just biased because I'm the one who got killed last time he got trigger happy...

it is vry possable doc may not want to protect me till i can show town more and tottaly fine,and ur right id rather not spray and prey. im open to holding off and im also open to seleccting between 2 or 3 people determined by how votes fall. however im not gonna just shoot someone bottom of the list as they will most likley be Vanillia if it comes to shooting a bottom of list jsut for the heck of it or no shooting i would rather not shoot at all.

your correct mets thats a chance im hopeing yall are gonna be willing to take and accept that im being honest and doing a full compleate truthfull claim

[TimWoodbury]

and with that i think im off ffor the night gotta work again in the morning will check in again in the morning before work

[Army of GOD]

Only thing I worry about is that he might be in one of the mafia dactiinsnwith a tailor. They'd be able to hide his alignment and we'd fall too easily for his trap.


If no one counterclaims he's pretty obviously the vig (hell, Mets is the only one who could counter, unless Tim is boldly predicting no one got vig).


Then again, he could be toen and thr tailor woukd flip his alignment

[Army of GOD]

Only thing I worry about is that he might be in one of the mafia dactiinsnwith a tailor. They'd be able to hide his alignment and we'd fall too easily for his trap.


If no one counterclaims he's pretty obviously the vig (hell, Mets is the only one who could counter, unless Tim is boldly predicting no one got vig).


Then again, he could be town and the tailor could flip his alignment and he'd come up scum...not sure what the play is here.

EBWOP

[Army of GOD]

Also why would you claim?

[Endgame422]

Ok Mets logic is sound.
Tim doesn't shoot unless we decide someone is rather scummy by days end.
Altough if he is scum/SK and vig i would rather lead one of his kills,potentially to other anti-town factions,then let them run wild trying to kill the investigative roles.
I think hes town though so holding the kill and limiting us to 3 deaths may be best.
At this time id like to adress the SK
I think it would serve us all well for you to target scum.
By the time 4 scum are dead the town will be pretty damn small.
Play hard town the first couple days and do us all a favor.

[Streaker]

Hey Tim, good job! Not only did you just present mafia their single worst threat on a silver platter, you are also forcing our doc (if doc is even in town hands, or even in the game at all) to protect you.
Furthermore, you narrowed down the options for mafia even further. /end sarcasm.

Hi Pixar, glad to have you! Yeah it's a bitch isn't it, people posting their thoughts so others can read them and we can play the game. We should all just stay quiet day 1 because we have no information to go on and wait for night results. If town even has any night actions. And with at least 3 NK's out there. /end sarcasm.

Wing is very easy on the defense with AoG, for no reasons I saw. Though I didn't read AoG as hard scum, I also wondered why wing read him as town.

PTlowe keeps lying and twisting truths in almost every post he makes. Here's another example (for previous you should have read my previous posts about him):

Spoiler

okay so only ones left to actually give something anything at all would be i think virus hes said the least starting to get concerned with him

Is virus your scum read? What about the items brought forth this last page?

I'd strongly object to a Virus lynch. Nothing in his opening post suggests scum, and his inactivity isnt abnormal.

Activity isnt a clear indicator of alignment, it is a tool used by those who are active to deflect the focus onto others. Ptlowe and Tim are the major pushers of this logic.

Your analysis and interpretation is like that of a wandering goat. Since your reads and ideas arent sticking on me you start putting me in with Tim and dismissing actual analysis. The more I read of your words the more I think your scum. Trying every which way to find another target to harp on outside of yourself. Your slinging mud to get anything to stick. Your the user of the logic you are pushing saying I am using. Im actually trying to find scum thank you.

First off, they are reads and are not supposed to 'stick'. They are meant to bring out conversation. You react to it like the noose is already on your neck. Where is wing dismissing analysis? He's dismissing your eratic behaviour to his push. Just continues with more crap: wing is not shooting everyone, only Tim and PT. And ends with stating 'looking for scum', while all you are doing is going crazy on your defense.

Luckily PTlowe did promise to bring out the 'evidence' of wing dismissing analysis, so I'm very much looking forward to this. But 10 bucks says he is hoping nobody will follow up on his own statement.

Hotshot leaning scum, or even possible SK. He's not as comfortable as he usually is playing town.
Dazza going afk neutralizes my read, and I'll have to wait until D2 to get something out of Pixar

Benga reading scummy, mostly because of lack of anything.

[ptlowe]

How about this streaker. I'm vanilla town and tried to be the bomb and didn't get it. I'll pull wings posts about me together in the morning and shoot how they don't make sense to me. I'm not pointing at everyone just a few. He hasn't shown me one reason to show me as scum. I haven't forgotten just worked late you'll have it in the am. Again my point is he's reaching for air on me. But go ahead if you all think I'm scum Lynch me. Then when you see I wasn't lieing you will know either A people pointing at me are scum or B you couldn't get a read out of a paper bag.

[Streaker]

PT, I have shown reasons why you could be scum. You don't need to show me wing's posts, I read them just fine. I need you to follow up on your own post, and show us where wing dismissed analysis.
He could have been reaching about you, but your overreaction is saying more then you'd think.

Also, DON'T CLAIM JUST BECAUSE YOU ARE BEING PUSHED FFS.

Vote PTlowe