[Official] Choose Your Own Mafia - TOWN WINS

[Epitaph1]

Thank you.

Epi - mitch, HS, AoG
ptolwe - AOG, Wing, Sausage, Virus, hotshot


Keep it coming.

[Metsfanmax]

Thank you.

Epi - mitch, HS, AoG
ptolwe - AOG, Wing, Sausage, Virus, hotshot


Keep it coming.

The hell is this? Talk about the lamest, most convenient way to appear townie while also muddling things up severely. We have a list of people we want to lynch. It's compiled by the mod and you get on to it by voting for people. What you're doing is compiling a list of any complaint any player might have against anyone, which doesn't help narrow down the lynch, it helps widen it. The day ends in like 48 hours. What we don't need right now, when it is acknowledged that we don't have much activity left remaining, is to start thinking about acting. We need to actually act.

unvote

vote Epi

[madmitch]

well that settles that, pretty scummy Epic VOTE EPIC

[dakky21]

well that settles that, pretty scummy Epic VOTE EPIC

And another EPIC fail. Keep bandwagoning like that and you will be the next.
I will keep my vote on you, I'm not voting epi for writing a sarcastic post.

[Epitaph1]

Thank you.

Epi - mitch, HS, AoG
ptolwe - AOG, Wing, Sausage, Virus, hotshot


Keep it coming.

The hell is this? Talk about the lamest, most convenient way to appear townie while also muddling things up severely. We have a list of people we want to lynch. It's compiled by the mod and you get on to it by voting for people. What you're doing is compiling a list of any complaint any player might have against anyone, which doesn't help narrow down the lynch, it helps widen it. The day ends in like 48 hours. What we don't need right now, when it is acknowledged that we don't have much activity left remaining, is to start thinking about acting. We need to actually act.

unvote

vote Epi

You clearly do not understand what I'm doing here, Mets.

We are nowhere near a consensus about the lynch. The VC shows that we are all over the place.

So, what I've started doing is gathering a list of everyone's suspects. If a bunch of us keep listing a certain player or players, then we know who we should focus our attention in what little time we have.

For example, so far AoG and HS have appeared on the lists for me and ptolwe. If a few more people come on and they list HS or AoG, then we start to go after them. If people want to start coordinating and putting their votes on a few people, then we don't need my exercise. But as of the last VC, 6 people have votes. 6! We've got to narrow it down pronto and that's what I'm trying to do here. Since you can't vote for two people at once, I'm getting a list of everyone you're willing to vote for.

Want to help out by giving us those you'd be willing to lynch? Or are you going to throw your vote away on me when there are so many other suspects that would be a better D1 lynch than me?

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Why have you ignored my list which clearly has yourself in it?

Lynching someone who is perceived by most mildly scummy but not strongly scummy by anyone is what this will achieve. There are also five people who you should be ignoring. The identity of these five is hidden, but having no conviction to push your strong reads through doesnt help.

That said, this list will be a useful piece of information come D2.

[Army of GOD]

what's the current vote count at?

I think the people who are splintering the vote need to defend themselves. They're hurting a possible D1 lynch more than anyone (as well as virus)

[Epitaph1]

well that settles that, pretty scummy Epic VOTE EPIC

And another EPIC fail. Keep bandwagoning like that and you will be the next.
I will keep my vote on you, I'm not voting epi for writing a sarcastic post.

Seriously. How mitch only has two votes right now is beyond me.


**UNOFFICIAL VC**

Hotshot: Endgame
ptlowe: AoG, Streaker, Pixar, benga
virus: Tim
Wing: HotShot
Epi: Wing, Mets, mitch
madmitch: dakky, Epi
AoG: sausage, ptolwe

Tim, virus will likely get replaced if he doesn't show up soon. So, your vote will have a bigger impact elsewhere.

I'd be surprised if anyone with 1 vote gets lynched at this point even though virus, HS, and Wing are tripping so many scumdars. There would have to be a major tide of votes to accomplish lynching anyone with 1 vote or less at this point.

---

fpd

Epi - mitch, HS, AoG
ptolwe - AOG, Wing, Sausage, Virus, hotshot
Wing - Epi, ??

Wing, state it clearly on the record whom you would like to lynch right now.

fpd again

see above

[madmitch]

well that settles that, pretty scummy Epic VOTE EPIC

And another EPIC fail. Keep bandwagoning like that and you will be the next.
I will keep my vote on you, I'm not voting epi for writing a sarcastic post.

WHAT IS YOUR PROBLEM? I am not bandwagoning and you know it , I made two votes in this game and they were both reasonable so quit trying to stir the pot,if you can;t vote for me in the first post you find someway to do it,so back off

[madmitch]

@ Dakky, I looked up your home town on google earth, looks nice,do live in the main city or the outskirts. what;s the deal about the tree and the rock? looks neat.

[Epitaph1]

Mitch, who are you willing to lynch right now.

Me and who else?

[Epitaph1]

@ Dakky, I looked up your home town on google earth, looks nice,do live in the main city or the outskirts. what;s the deal about the tree and the rock? looks neat.

Not sure where you're going with this. . .

[madmitch]

@ Dakky, I looked up your home town on google earth, looks nice,do live in the main city or the outskirts. what;s the deal about the tree and the rock? looks neat.

Not sure where you're going with this. . .

just wanted to get to know my adversary,no big deal,oh by the way I see on your profile one of your interests is fake claiming

[Metsfanmax]

So, what I've started doing is gathering a list of everyone's suspects. If a bunch of us keep listing a certain player or players, then we know who we should focus our attention in what little time we have.

This is not going to do anything. Has it gotten us anywhere so far? Do you think it will save us in the next 48 hours? The problem is one you've already acknowledged: we all have suspicions of a number of players. There isn't going to be one single player who everyone is mostly suspicious of, to a significantly greater extent than everyone else. If that were true then that person would already be leading the vote count.

More importantly, this list is ripe for bias. You've only started collecting this information on the last page when there's plenty of information on who suspects who buried in the last 15 pages. Why are you ignoring all that? Does my suspicion of a player only count if it is on the Epitaph1-approved list? I mean, I voted for you and you didn't even add me to the list of people who are suspicious of you. So I have no idea what you're trying to do except spread confusion.

Seriously. How mitch only has two votes right now is beyond me.

Yes I know, we're all idiots for not instantly agreeing with this analysis. Please forgive us for being so slow.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Page 14

Who is everyone willing to lynch?

Page 15

I would lynch any of, Epi, PT, Pix, Hotshot, or Benga.

Page 16

Wing, state it clearly on the record whom you would like to lynch right now.

[Metsfanmax]

Page 14

Who is everyone willing to lynch?

Page 15

I would lynch any of, Epi, PT, Pix, Hotshot, or Benga.

Page 16

Wing, state it clearly on the record whom you would like to lynch right now.

Don't get too upset about it. It seems to have been established that a suspicion is not formal until you directly say it to Epi and Epi alone. That's why there is no list for Sausage and virus despite ptlowe clearly saying on page 15 that he would vote for them.

[Epitaph1]

Mets, if you don't like my exercise, that's fine. All I'm trying to do is get people to focus and narrow down the list of suspects. People have started posting their reads, which is helpful imo. However, it's one thing for someone to say that think someone is slightly scummy or whatever, but it's another thing to be willing to vote for someone. I want to know who everyone is willing to vote for since people are probably willing to vote for more than one person, but only have one official vote.

This is not going to do anything. Has it gotten us anywhere so far?

I just proposed my idea 3.5 hours ago. . .

There isn't going to be one single player who everyone is mostly suspicious of, to a significantly greater extent than everyone else. If that were true then that person would already be leading the vote count.

That's what I'm trying to figure out. I'd bet there are two or three people that a lot of us are willing to vote but we just need to get organized.

More importantly, this list is ripe for bias. You've only started collecting this information on the last page when there's plenty of information on who suspects who buried in the last 15 pages. Why are you ignoring all that? Does my suspicion of a player only count if it is on the Epitaph1-approved list? I mean, I voted for you and you didn't even add me to the list of people who are suspicious of you. So I have no idea what you're trying to do except spread confusion.

I'm just asking people to simply and clearly list who they are willing to vote for. This isn't bias, this is a straightforward question that will hopefully lead to a clear list. I'm not ignoring everyone's comments from the past 15 pages. I'm not asking for reads. I'm asking: who would you vote for. For example, I think Wing is scummy but I'm not willing to lynch him on D1. I've explained why multiple times.

My list isn't just going to reiterate everyone's votes. You can check the VC for that. I'm trying to go beyond the VC here.

Yes I know, we're all idiots for not instantly agreeing with this analysis. Please forgive us for being so slow.

Didn't call you guys idiots. I'm just surprised that mitch has so few votes based on how he's played.

---

So Mets, I'll ask you again: who would you lynch right now? Me and who else?

fpd

Thank you, Wing.

Epi - mitch, HS, AoG
ptolwe - AOG, Wing, Sausage, Virus, hotshot
Wing - Epi, PT, Pix, Hotshot, Benga

**UNOFFICIAL VC***
Hotshot: Endgame
ptlowe: AoG, Streaker, Pixar, benga
virus: Tim
Wing: HotShot
Epi: Wing, Mets, mitch
madmitch: dakky, Epi
AoG: sausage, ptolwe

fpd again

ptolwe's list has been counted

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

I bet there are 8 people willing to vote Epi.

[Epitaph1]

Wing, do you really think I'm the scummiest person?

I suppose all you need is 3 townies to join the 5 scumbags, so you wouldn't have to do that much convincing.

[Metsfanmax]

Wing, do you really think I'm the scummiest person?

You've already established that this isn't about who is the scummiest, it is about who we can get 8 votes for. So you can't really complain.

[madmitch]

Wing, do you really think I'm the scummiest person?

You've already established that this isn't about who is the scummiest, it is about who we can get 8 votes for. So you can't really complain.

well said

[Epitaph1]

Wing, do you really think I'm the scummiest person?

You've already established that this isn't about who is the scummiest, it is about who we can get 8 votes for. So you can't really complain.

I'd like to hear him answer that.

He has his vote on me, which I take as he thinks that I'm the scummiest. I find that hard to believe.

---

Mets, you clearly don't like my approach. So, what's yours? Lynch me? Because I'm really the scummiest person here?

fpd

Lol mitch.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

I use my vote on the towniest player i can find.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Thats sarcasm before Mitch votes me

[Marashu]

9.virus90 (8,9) Should be kicked for inactivity

He has not yet replied to my prod. I am giving him until tomorrow morning - if there is no reply, I will be replacing him, and giving an extension.